요약으로 복습하기
STEL5E 과목의 강의 31편을 요약만으로 훑어봅니다. 시험 전날에 쓰세요.
제 0 장 Introduction: Ethics Is About People
- The ethical questions about AI are about people: who has the task, who is hurt, who is not seen.
- The course teaches a way of judging, practised on invented cases; it does not teach how the technology works.
- Technical detail, the theology of the image of God, and church AI policy are left to other courses.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox thinking are each described in their own terms and not ranked.
- Where Christians disagree, the course gives each side fairly and asks only that you not blur responsibility and keep the weak in sight.
- Every Practice Lab has three ways in and four privacy promises.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The central claim | The ethical questions about AI are about people; ask them from the dignity of every person, with humility. |
| What the course teaches | A way of judging, practised on invented cases. |
| The one thing asked on contested points | Do not blur responsibility, and keep the weak in sight. |
| Three ways into a lab | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
One sentence to remember Behind every question about a machine there is a question about a person.
This week's action Write down one question about technology that someone near you faces, and list the people it touches.
제 1 장 Week 1: The Eyes of Ethics
- The ethics of AI is a question about people: who has the task, who is hurt, who is not seen.
- A tool extends what we can do; an agent answers for it. A program remains a tool in people's hands.
- "The system did it" is a way for a decision to disappear while its effects remain.
- Readers will not agree on whether technology is neutral; the course asks you to keep both questions open.
- The six topics are old questions in a new place: responsibility, fairness, watching, work and truth.
- Cases are invented, because news goes stale and invites judgement of real people.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Tool and agent | A tool is used for a purpose; an agent acts and answers. People answer, not programs. |
| Is technology neutral? | Disputed: one side stresses the user's choice, the other the shape of the design. Keep both questions. |
| The danger named here | "The system did it": the decision vanishes, the effect remains. |
| Genesis 2:15 and Proverbs 14:15 | Work is a task of care (cultivate and keep); prudence weighs where a thing leads. |
One sentence to remember Behind every question about a machine there is a question about a person.
This week's action Choose one tool you meet this week and write down who made it, who chose it, who relies on it, and who receives its results.
- Genesis 1:26-27 says every human being bears God's image; this course calls the resulting worth dignity.
- Dignity does not depend on usefulness, wealth, age or skill.
- Exodus 22:21-24 shows dignity tested at the stranger, the widow and the orphan, who are easily wronged.
- Keep apart what the text says, a principle drawn from it, and our judgement today.
- Scripture forms a judging person through wisdom, the prophets and grace; it is not a rule-list for tools.
- "Dignity" is a direction to look, not by itself an argument.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Dignity | The worth every person has as one made in God's image, not dependent on usefulness. |
| Where dignity is tested | At the stranger, the widow and the orphan: the people who are easily wronged and seldom heard. |
| The three layers | What the text says; a principle drawn from it; our judgement today. |
| Micah 6:8 | Act justly, love mercy, walk humbly with God. |
One sentence to remember Dignity is the first question to ask of any case: does this treat the person as a person?
This week's action Take one Bible passage you know and write its three layers on a single page: the text, the principle, a judgement.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox thought each form habits of eye; none is ranked above another here.
- Protestant streams often stress vocation, the neighbour, conscience and community.
- Catholic social teaching uses dignity, the common good, subsidiarity and solidarity, with the option for the poor and the universal destination of goods.
- Orthodox thought stresses the person in communion, synergy and life as sharing in God.
- The three overlap in keeping the weak in sight and refusing to treat a person as a unit.
- They also part, for example on structure, authority and trust in institutions; we say so when it matters.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Subsidiarity | Decisions should be made at the lowest level that can make them well; larger bodies help and do not swallow. |
| The common good | Conditions of life in which persons and groups can flourish; not just the sum of private interests. |
| Orthodox emphasis | The person in communion, synergy, life as sharing in God. |
| Protestant emphasis | Vocation, the neighbour, conscience and community; the streams differ. |
One sentence to remember Three traditions look with different words, but each asks about the person who is easily overlooked.
This week's action Ask someone from a different Christian tradition what question they would ask first about a new tool in the church, and listen without answering.
- The five questions: who has been given this task; who might be hurt; who is not seen; what do I not know; with whom shall I judge.
- They protect responsibility, the weak, the unheard, humility and the judge from his own blind spots.
- The order matters: start with the task and the people, then turn to yourself.
- The method does not give the answer; reasonable people who ask the five may still differ in how much risk they accept.
- Hold a judgement with humility: say what it rests on, what would change it, and when you will look again.
- Humility is not an escape: if someone may be hurt now, caution goes to the side of the person at risk.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The five questions | Task; hurt; unseen; unknown; with whom. |
| What question 3 protects | The unheard: those absent from the case as first told. |
| Holding a judgement humbly | Say what it rests on, what would change it, and when to review. |
| Why judge with others | Proverbs 11:14 and Acts 15: wisdom grows in company and corrects our blind spots. |
One sentence to remember Ask about the task and the people before the tool, then judge with others and hold the judgement humbly.
This week's action Pick one decision you face and write the five questions with one honest line under each.
- The lab applies the five questions to one case and ends in a short judgement.
- The aim is a considered judgement that states what it rests on and what would change it, not a correct answer.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, and the partner's way.
- Never write a real employer, church, person or confidential detail on the form.
- A leader asks which question changed the mind, never what was decided.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Applying the five questions to one case and judging humbly. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| The leader's question | Not "what did you decide?" but "which question changed your mind?" |
One sentence to remember Slow the decision down once, so you can feel what each question changes.
This week's action Fill in the five-questions form on paper for one case and keep it where only you will find it.
제 2 장 Week 2: Responsibility
- A tool cannot answer, be forgiven or repair anything; only people can, so ethics looks for the people.
- Four roles matter: maker (design), deployer (choice to use here), user (operation), decider (the decision about a person).
- The responsibility gap is made between people, each pointing to the next, even when every statement is true.
- Genesis 3 and 4 show that pointing away from oneself is an old habit, not a new one.
- When responsibility is blurred, the weak suffer first, because they have no other door.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four roles | Maker, deployer, user, decider. |
| The responsibility gap | Harm that every person near it can say was not theirs to own. |
| Who suffers first when it is blurred | The weak, who have no other door to knock on. |
| Why the old excuses matter | Genesis 3 and 4 show the habit of pointing away; the machine did not invent it. |
One sentence to remember When a tool does the work, the responsibility does not vanish; it only becomes harder to find.
This week's action Next time you hear "the system did it", ask quietly, "Who chose to use it, and who decided?"
- Deuteronomy 22:8 places responsibility on the builder, before the accident, for dangers that can be foreseen.
- Exodus 21:33-34 holds the one who made or controls a hazard to repair, whether or not harm was intended.
- In Luke 10, the Samaritan saw, could act, and thought of the days that followed; duty grows with sight and means.
- Luke 12:47-48 gives degrees: ignorance is not cleared but weighed less, and more entrusted means more asked.
- Keep three things apart: what the text says, the principle drawn, and our judgement today.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Responsibility of design | The builder answers for foreseeable danger before anyone falls (the roof railing). |
| Responsibility of knowing neglect | The one who controls a hazard and knows of it must make good what falls in (the pit). |
| Responsibility of ignorance | Not cleared, but weighed less than for the one who knew (Luke 12:47-48). |
| Why Scripture is not a rule-list | Its passages are law, story and parable given in settings; we judge, and say that we judge. |
One sentence to remember Responsibility has kinds and degrees, and it follows knowledge, means and what has been entrusted.
This week's action Pick one decision you share in at work or church, and write which of the three kinds of responsibility you hold in it.
- A serious decision is one that is weighty for the person, hard to undo, costly to another, and made without their being heard.
- Exodus 18 shows both sharing the load and keeping the great matters; Proverbs 18:13 asks us to hear before answering.
- Three safeguards for a serious decision: an explanation, a human review and a way to object.
- Church discipline and restoration are decisions a body of persons must keep, with listening and a human face.
- On how much may be handed over, readers disagree; the course requires only a named owner and the weak kept in sight.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four questions | How serious; can it be undone; who bears the cost; can they be heard. |
| The three safeguards | An explanation; a human review; a way to object. |
| Exodus 18:22 | Small matters are shared out; every great matter comes up to a person who answers. |
| The minimum both positions share | A named person owns the decision and is reachable by the person it touches. |
One sentence to remember A tool may prepare, sort or remind, but a serious decision about a person needs a named person who can explain it, review it and hear an objection.
This week's action Choose one process in your church or work that uses a list or score about people, and write down who owns the decision it feeds.
- After an error with a tool, the honest steps are: say what happened, own your part, repair, and change what let it happen.
- Zacchaeus’ repair was specific, costly and the fruit of a changed heart, not its price.
- Psalm 51 shows confession that blames no one else and does not hurry past the wrong.
- Matthew 5:23-24 places reconciliation with a neighbour before the gift at the altar.
- A community is safe to report in when the first question is who is hurt, and the reporter is thanked.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four steps | Say what happened; own your part; repair; change what let it happen. |
| Luke 19:8 | Zacchaeus gives half to the poor and restores four times what he wrongly took. |
| Matthew 5:23-24 | Be reconciled to your brother first, then offer the gift. |
| Safe to report | First question "who is hurt?"; reporters thanked; leaders confess their own errors. |
One sentence to remember A tool cannot say "I am sorry; what do you need?" Only a person can, so a person must be found.
This week's action Write one sentence for a recent small error of your own that begins "I did" or "I did not", and has no word that moves blame.
- A responsibility map lists the steps of a case in order and names, for each, a role and an office.
- An empty cell, marked "nobody" or "?", is the responsibility gap made visible.
- The aim is to see clearly and to say who should hold each step, not to find someone to blame.
- Use titles, never real names; nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, anyone may pass, the leader writes too.
- If the lab brings out a real harm, stop, and speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the map shows | For each step: the role, the office, who could be hurt, who could object. |
| The most important entry | "Nobody": the empty cell where the gap is. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| If a real harm comes out | Stop; speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person; call the local emergency number if danger is now. |
One sentence to remember A gap shows up as an empty cell, and the work is to put a named office there.
This week's action Draw the map for one real process you know, using titles only, and keep it where only you will find it.
제 3 장 Week 3: Bias and Fairness
- Unfairness in automated systems is old prejudice made to look like arithmetic. It enters through the recorded past, the design choices, and the way results are used.
- A record shows who was given a chance. People who were never lent to, hired or invited are silent in it, and silence is easily read as lack of evidence.
- A record can be accurate and unjust at once, because it may faithfully show who was favoured.
- A score becomes a decision when no one reads the doubtful cases, even if the tool never said "refuse."
- Leviticus 19:15 and Proverbs 24:23 forbid partiality in judgment, and they speak to people who hold a verdict in their hands.
- Finding bias is not a reason to judge the builders. The right question is who is responsible for correcting it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three sources of bias | The recorded past; the design choices; the way the result is used. |
| Why a number hides unfairness | It looks exact, impersonal and finished, so people stop asking who chose what. |
| Leviticus 19:15 | No injustice in judgment: no partiality to the poor, none to the great. Judge your neighbour in righteousness. |
| Three questions to carry | What past, and who is missing? What was chosen, and whom does it favour? How is it used, and who reads the doubtful cases? |
One sentence to remember A score looks like arithmetic, but behind it are a recorded past, human choices and human use, and each can carry an old partiality.
This week's action Pick one list or ranking in your own community and write down who was missing from the past it relies on.
- Four common measures of fairness are the same rule for all, equal opportunity, fair results, and priority for the weak.
- The four measures can give different answers to the same choice, and no arithmetic removes the need to decide.
- The measure of fairness is a moral choice and must not be hidden inside a tool.
- Scripture joins justice and righteousness, forbids partiality and bribes, and guards both the poor in court and the court from partiality.
- Readers differ on which measure to use. This course requires only that responsibility not be blurred and that the weak be kept in sight.
- Text, principle and judgement must be kept apart: the verses do not mention systems or choose a measure.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four measures of fairness | Same rule for all; equal opportunity; fair results; priority for the weak. |
| Justice and righteousness | Often paired in the prophets: right ordering of a case or society, and right relation among people (Amos 5:24). |
| What James 2:1-4 shows | Partiality can lie in a small act, such as who gets the good seat, and a church is not exempt. |
| What the course requires | Do not blur responsibility, and keep the weak in sight, whichever measure is preferred. |
One sentence to remember No tool chooses what "fair" means; a person must choose, say so plainly, and answer to those who are affected.
This week's action Find one decision in your community that sorts people, and write one sentence saying which measure of fairness it uses, even if no one ever said so.
- A structure is a lasting arrangement of rules, habits, money and tools that shapes what people can do and outlasts any one person.
- A pattern can hurt people although every step was reasonable and no one intended the harm.
- Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox writers all say that persons are answerable and that arrangements shape persons. They differ in the weight and meaning of "structure."
- Isaiah 10:1-2 and Luke 11:46 see both the written arrangement and the people who make it.
- Ezekiel 18 refuses to let a person hide in the story of the past, while Nehemiah confesses with his people.
- To see only persons leaves the pattern, and to see only structure leaves no one answerable.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A structure | A lasting arrangement of rules, habits, money and tools that shapes what people can do and outlasts any one person. |
| Isaiah 10:1-2 and Luke 11:46 | Woe falls on those who write oppressive decrees and load heavy burdens: the arrangement and the persons are both named. |
| Ezekiel 18:2-4 | The proverb of sour grapes is rejected: each soul is answerable to God and cannot hide behind the past. |
| Two ways to fail | Seeing only persons, so the pattern stays; seeing only structure, so no one is answerable. |
One sentence to remember Look at the arrangement that hurts, and look at the persons who keep it; neither look cancels the other.
This week's action Write one sentence naming a repeated pattern in your community that hurts someone, and one small step a named role (not a person) could take.
- People go unseen for ordinary reasons: the notice did not reach them, they cannot come, they are afraid, or the numbers do not include them.
- Luke 14:12-14 asks a host to open the table to those who cannot repay, and Acts 6:1-6 shows a neglected group's complaint heard by the whole community.
- Listening means going to people on their ground, making it safe to speak, asking open questions, sharing the work, reporting back and looking again.
- The decision still belongs to those entrusted with it, but listening should change it.
- Listening fails when one person is made to speak for all, when it is a show, or when a person's story is used without consent.
- Where someone reveals danger or abuse, help them reach a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and the local emergency number if danger is present.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why people are missing | The notice missed them, they cannot come, they are afraid, or the numbers leave them out. |
| Luke 14:12-14 | Invite those who cannot repay you; the table is opened beyond the circle of exchange. |
| Acts 6:1-6 | A neglected group complains, the whole body hears it, and people are chosen to oversee the work. |
| Ways listening goes wrong | Tokenism; a show of consultation; using someone's story; waiting for total agreement; losing humility. |
One sentence to remember Before deciding for people a plan will touch, go to them, in their place, and listen to the ones least likely to speak.
This week's action Name one decision your community will soon make and one group it will touch that has not yet been asked.
- The lab applies the week's tools to one invented selection process: three sources of bias, four measures of fairness, structures and persons, and listening.
- The aim is to see more than you first saw, and to hold your judgement humbly, not to deliver a verdict.
- Each of the three ways in is complete. The form never carries a real person, church, employer or confidential detail.
- Four promises govern the lab: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, anyone may pass, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
- A leader asks what was seen, never about anyone's own situation, and does not let the room settle on one villain.
- If a real harm comes to light, the lab stops and the student speaks to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Purpose of the lab | To find who is missing from an invented selection process and to hold the judgement with humility. |
| The three ways in | In your own place; the observer's way with the printed case; the partner's way. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| If real harm surfaces | Stop, speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and call the local emergency number if danger is present. |
One sentence to remember Seeing who is missing is a practice, and it begins with a printed case, a quiet half hour and one honest line about what you do not know.
This week's action Fill in the form once more on a different invented process, and ask one trusted person to tell you who they think is missing.
제 4 장 Week 4: Surveillance and Privacy
- Scripture speaks of being seen in several ways: Psalm 139 as comfort and weight, Genesis 3 as exposure and a question, Genesis 16 as rescue from being unseen.
- The difference between care and threat is not the act of looking but who looks, whether the watched know, and whether they can answer.
- A human watcher sees the act and not the heart, has mixed motives, and often gives the watched no place to answer.
- The psalm is not an argument that nothing is private; it speaks of God alone.
- The panopticon is a picture of the one-way look: the watcher sees and is not seen, and the watched change themselves.
- The three questions of the watcher: who is watching, for whom, and with what right? "We can see it" is not "we may see it."
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Psalm 139 | God knows the whole person and does not leave; comfort that is also a weight. |
| Genesis 3:9 | God's first words to the hiding man are a question: "Where are you?" |
| Genesis 16:13 | Hagar names God as the one who sees; the unseen is seen. |
| The three questions | Who is watching? For whom? With what right? |
One sentence to remember To see a person is a power, so before we judge any watching we ask who is watching, for whom, and with what right.
This week's action Choose one place where you are watched or you watch (a workplace, a home, a church) and write the answers to the three questions in three short lines.
- Matthew 6 warns against showing off devotion; it gives a picture of an inner room but is not a rule about data.
- Proverbs 11:13 and 25:9-10 teach that a confidence is given for one purpose and must not be spread.
- Real consent is knowing, specific, free, able to be taken back, and from someone who can give it.
- The more power the asker holds, the more care the asking needs; a church holds much of this power.
- A church holds administrative, sensitive and entrusted information, and each deserves its own care.
- Four habits: collect less, keep less, share less, tell people. Follow local law and written rules.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Matthew 6:1-6 | Devotion done to be seen is empty; it is about motive, not data rights. |
| Proverbs 11:13 | The trustworthy keep a secret; a confidence is not for spreading. |
| Five conditions | Knowing, specific, free, able to be taken back, from someone who can give it. |
| Four habits | Collect less, keep less, share less, tell people. |
One sentence to remember A confidence is given for one purpose, and a church that holds it is a steward, not an owner.
This week's action Write down one kind of information your church or group holds, and answer the four habits for it in four short lines.
- Watching has good reasons in home, work and public safety, and each has a danger that grows with time.
- Four marks test watching: a stated purpose, proportion, openness, and a limit with a way to object.
- Christians differ on safety against liberty. The course requires only that responsibility not be blurred and the weak be kept in sight.
- Romans 13 has been read as respect for authority, as a normal case limited by Acts 5:29, and as authority judged by its purpose.
- Revelation 13 has several readings; this course names no present tool or group as its beast.
- A community that has been watched asks: if this list were read by someone who meant us harm, who would be hurt?
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four marks | A stated purpose; proportion; openness; a limit and a way to object. |
| What the course requires on safety and liberty | Name who answers for the watching, and keep the weak in sight both ways. |
| Romans 13 and Acts 5:29 | The normal case of respect for authority, and its limit when obedience would mean disobeying God. |
| Revelation 13 | Read in several ways; no present tool or group is named as its beast. |
One sentence to remember Watching for safety can be right, and the way to keep it right is a stated purpose, proportion, openness, and a way for the watched to object.
This week's action Choose one kind of watching you meet (a camera, a measure at work, a rule at home) and test it against the four marks, writing one line for each.
- Galatians 6:1, Matthew 18:15 and 1 Peter 5:2-3 speak of the manner of looking after one another: gentle, private first, aimed at restoring, willing, not lording it over.
- Care and control may use the same act; five signs show which way a case leans: invited, mutual, private first, aimed at restoring, free to refuse.
- Accountability among believers stays accountability when it is chosen, mutual, held by a person rather than a file, and able to end.
- The people watched most are often the ones who can least refuse: children, hourly workers, people who receive help, migrants, the old and the sick.
- Those who help hold power and should ask only what the help needs.
- Watching with love asks before it looks, looks with the person, keeps little, lets it end, and looks to itself.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Galatians 6:1 | Restore with gentleness, looking to yourself. |
| Matthew 18:15 | Go to him privately first; the aim is to regain a brother. |
| The five signs | Invited, mutual, private first, aimed at restoring, free to say no. |
| Who is watched most | Those who can least refuse: children, hourly workers, those who need help, migrants, the old and sick. |
One sentence to remember Care asks, looks with the person, keeps little and lets the person say no; control imposes, looks one way, keeps the record and charges for refusal.
This week's action Choose one way your church or group keeps watch on its members and test it against the five signs, writing one line for each.
- The lab applies the week's tools to one invented case: the three questions, the five conditions of consent, the four marks, and the five signs of care or control.
- The aim is to see more than you first saw, and to hold your judgement humbly, not to deliver a verdict.
- Each of the three ways in is complete. The form never carries a real person, church, employer or confidential detail.
- Four promises govern the lab: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, anyone may pass, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
- A leader asks what was seen, never about anyone's own situation, and does not let the room settle on one villain.
- If a real harm comes to light, the lab stops and the student speaks to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Purpose of the lab | To see what is seen, what is hidden and who is weak in an invented case, and to hold the judgement with humility. |
| The three ways in | In your own place; the observer's way with the printed case; the partner's way. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| If real harm surfaces | Stop, speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and call the local emergency number if danger is present. |
One sentence to remember Before a church begins to watch, a printed case, a quiet half hour and one honest line about what you do not know are a good place to start.
This week's action Fill in the form again on a different invented arrangement, and ask one trusted person who they think is weak in it.
제 5 장 Week 5: Work and Livelihood
- Work comes before the fall in Genesis 2:15, and becomes toil after it in Genesis 3:17-19; it is a good gift that has been hurt.
- Work gives livelihood, dignity, service and community; a payment can replace only the first of these.
- Second Thessalonians 3:10 speaks of people who will not work, not of people who cannot find work.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox traditions speak of work as calling, as dignity and as offering, and all say it is for persons.
- We keep apart what the text says, a principle drawn from it, and our judgement today.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four gifts of work | Livelihood, dignity, service and community. |
| Work in Genesis | Given before the fall to cultivate and keep; made hard by the fall. |
| 2 Thessalonians 3:10 | Concerns people who will not work; not a rule for those who have lost work. |
| Three traditions | Vocation (Protestant); dignity of labour (Catholic); work as offering (Orthodox). |
One sentence to remember Work is more than income, so a change in work must be judged by what people lose and gain beyond their wages.
This week's action Write down, without names, one person whose work has changed, and list which of the four gifts they gained or lost.
- The question of changing work is old: printing, the mechanised loom and the age of industry each brought pain to people in the middle of change.
- Forecasts about work are weak ground for moral judgement, because outcomes depend on future choices and a forecaster may have an interest.
- Optimists and pessimists each have a strong case; this is a point where readers will not agree.
- The course requires two things only: do not blur responsibility, and keep the weak in sight.
- Ecclesiastes teaches us neither to praise the past nor to wait for certainty before sowing.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why distrust forecasts? | Outcomes depend on choices not yet made, the past proves nothing, and forecasters may have an interest. |
| Optimistic reading | Change ends some work and begins other work; prepare people to move. |
| Pessimistic reading | This tool reaches mind work; the average may hide the person left behind. |
| What the course requires | Do not blur responsibility; keep the weak in sight. |
One sentence to remember We do not know the future of work, but we know who is hurt now and who is able to help.
This week's action Do one small thing for a person whose work is uncertain: listen, offer a skill, or ask a question on their behalf.
- Jubilee, sabbath and gleaning are three Old Testament pictures of a community that keeps need from becoming permanent.
- Gleaning gives food and a task, and so teaches help that preserves dignity.
- Catholic teaching on the universal destination of goods, Protestant stewardship and Orthodox gift all say that what is mine is not only mine.
- Retraining, shorter hours and a basic income each have strong supporters and strong critics; this is a point where readers will not agree.
- Any proposal is tested by two questions: does it blur responsibility, and does it keep the weak in sight?
- A church can listen, help privately, keep a person's dignity, and stay beside the person long after the first week.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What does gleaning teach? | Help can give both food and a task, so that the person keeps dignity. |
| Universal destination of goods | Catholic teaching that God gave the earth's goods for all people; property serves a larger purpose. |
| Two tests for any proposal | Does it blur responsibility? Does it keep the weak in sight? |
| How a church helps | Listen first, help privately, preserve dignity, stay for the long months. |
One sentence to remember Good help keeps a neighbour's dignity as well as feeding them, and stays when the first concern has faded.
This week's action Think of one person whose work is uncertain and decide one way to be present for them, without advice and without publicity.
- The sabbath command gives rest to everyone in the household, including servants and the stranger, and teaches that a person is not their output.
- Matthew 6:26 argues from the Father's care to human value; it is not an argument for idleness or a scolding of the anxious.
- In 1 Corinthians 12 the weaker parts of the body are necessary and receive more honour.
- Usefulness becomes an idol when it decides who has worth; it harms the busy, the idle and the community.
- Work remains a gift; the error is to believe that work is what makes us worth anything.
- Anyone who feels worthless should speak to a pastor or priest and to local crisis help.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What does the sabbath teach? | A person is not only their output; rest is commanded for all, including the least powerful. |
| Matthew 6:26 | An argument from the Father's care to human value; neither idleness nor a scolding. |
| 1 Corinthians 12:22-25 | The weaker parts are necessary and receive more honour; the members care for one another. |
| Idol of usefulness | Making worth equal to production; it harms the busy, the idle and the community. |
One sentence to remember Worth is given by the Father and not earned by use; pity looks down, but honour looks across.
This week's action Visit or call someone who can no longer do much, ask what they would like, and listen to the answer.
- The lab places one changing workplace under the week's questions: who is carried, who is left, and who answers for it.
- The form asks for the four gifts of work, the decision chain, the two tests, what I do not know, a fair statement of a different view, my judgement and whom I would ask.
- The aim is a considered judgement held humbly, not a correct answer.
- Four promises govern the lab: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
- No real employer, church or person is ever written on the form.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Aim of the lab | A considered judgement on a changing workplace, held with humility; there is no correct answer. |
| Four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| Two tests | Does it blur responsibility? Does it keep the weak in sight? |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way with the printed case; the partner's way. |
One sentence to remember Judge a change in work by who is carried, who is left, and who answers for it.
This week's action Tell one trusted person the best form of a view that differs from yours about a change in work.
제 6 장 Week 6: Truth, Care and the Church Together
- The ninth commandment forbids false testimony against a neighbour. Applying it to pictures, voices and text is our judgement, not the text's own words.
- A counterfeit harms three kinds of people: the person imitated, the person deceived, and the community whose trust in real evidence is weakened.
- The weak, the lonely and the hurried are deceived first. A plain agreement made beforehand protects them better than any test.
- A church that uses synthetic material should say so where the hearer will see it, so that no false impression is given.
- Habits of checking are pausing, asking the source, using a second trusted route, and asking who gains. None is certain.
- Truthfulness includes saying "I do not know" and correcting what we shared. We can be sincere and wrong.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three harms of a counterfeit | The person imitated; the person deceived; the community that loses trust in real evidence. |
| Rule for a church using synthetic material | Say so, where the hearer will see it, so that nobody receives a false impression. |
| Four habits of checking | Pause; ask the source; use a second trusted route; ask who gains and who is hurt. |
| Truthfulness and humility | We can be sincere and wrong, so we say "I do not know" and correct what we shared. |
One sentence to remember A false picture or voice is wrong because a person is led to believe what is untrue, and the weak are deceived first.
This week's action Write down one agreement your community could make beforehand about requests for money or secrecy, and tell the person who is most alone in your community about it.
- Care is more than the transfer of comfortable words. In John 1:14 and John 11 God comes in presence, and Jesus weeps with those who weep.
- A tool may assist in preparing and supporting care. A person must give the acts in which presence is the point.
- Readers will not agree where the line falls. The course requires only that a tool not stand where a person's presence was promised, and that its nature never be hidden.
- We do not judge a lonely person who leans on a tool. We ask what the community has done.
- We do not know the long-term effects of such tools on loneliness. Honest leaders say so.
- A person in danger must not be left with a program as the only listener. Contact a pastor or priest and local crisis help, and the emergency number if danger is now.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Incarnational care | A principle drawn from John 1:14 and John 11: love is shown by being present in the body, at a cost of time. |
| A tool may assist | Rotas, reminders, a first draft the sender reads, changes and signs, and routine administration. |
| Three positions on the line | Care is personal and a simulation is a counterfeit; a tool may be a mercy where no person is available; a tool may supplement under a responsible person. |
| What the course requires | Do not let a tool stand where a person's presence was promised; never hide that it is a tool; keep the lonely in sight. |
One sentence to remember Care is something a person gives at a cost, so a tool may help the carer reach the door but may not stand in the doorway in place of the carer.
This week's action Write the name of one person in your community who is alone, and plan one visit or call in the next seven days that a person, not a tool, will make.
- Acts 15 reports a long discussion, first-hand witnesses heard, and a decision given as the work of the Spirit and of the people. We draw a principle from it, not a procedure.
- Readers will not agree on who the deciding community is and how far its decision binds. The course requires that those affected are heard first and that the decision is written plainly.
- Romans 14 asks a community to receive a member whose conscience differs. Its limit is that the community acts to protect persons from harm.
- To seek out the child, the old, the poor and the afraid is more than to invite them.
- Twelve questions help a community judge: need, task, persons, decisions, truth, presence, information, work, unknowns, conscience, stopping and review.
- A decision can honestly be "for now", with a record of what is not known.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Acts 15 as a pattern | Long discussion; those who saw the facts heard; a decision owned by the Spirit and the people. A principle, not a procedure. |
| Romans 14 | Receive a member whose conscience differs; its limit is harm to others, which the community must prevent. |
| Invite or seek out | To invite is to send a notice; to seek out is to go to the person and ask. |
| A decision "for now" | A trial of stated length, a named person, a way to stop, a review date, and a record of what is not known. |
One sentence to remember A community judges well when those who will be affected are sought out before the decision and a conscience that differs is respected.
This week's action Choose one practice in your community that arrived without being decided, and ask three people who are not usually consulted what they think of it.
- The six weeks asked one question from six sides: how is this person, made in God's image, being treated, and who has the task of seeing that they are treated well?
- Psalm 8 holds smallness and glory together. We draw from it, and from Genesis 1:27, that dignity is given by God and not earned.
- Dignity makes us ask who the person is, look first at the least powerful, and accept that some things may be done to no one.
- Humility means saying what we are sure of, what we are not, and what would change our mind. It is not refusing to judge.
- Colossians 3:12-14 teaches that the way a community disagrees is part of its ethics.
- Christian hope rests on God and not on a forecast. We can act without panic and without boasting.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The thread of the six weeks | The dignity of persons: each week asked how a person is treated and who answers for it. |
| Psalm 8 and dignity | Smallness and glory together; dignity is given by God, not earned by usefulness or cleverness. |
| Humility | Say what you are sure of, what you are not, and what would change your mind; still judge and act. |
| Hope | Rests on God, not on a forecast; allows us to act without panic and without boasting. |
One sentence to remember Every question about AI is a question about a person made in God's image, and the least powerful person is the one most easily forgotten.
This week's action Explain the course in your own plain words to one person who has not studied it, and listen to what they ask back.
- The ethics page puts a case, the persons, the five questions, the weeks it touches, a humble judgement, who to ask and one step on a single sheet.
- The aim is a judgement that has asked the right questions and knows its limits, not a correct answer.
- Box E says what I am sure of, what I am not sure of, and what would change my mind.
- Box F names roles, not people, and includes someone who may disagree and someone not usually asked.
- Four promises of privacy: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- A leader asks which box was hardest, never what the person decided, and praises questions and not conclusions.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The ethics page | Case; persons; five questions; weeks touched; humble judgement; who I will ask; one step. |
| Box E, a judgement held humbly | My best judgement; what I am sure of; what I am not sure of; what would change my mind. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| The question to ask in a group | Not "what did you decide?" but "which box was hardest?" |
One sentence to remember A good judgement is one that has asked about the persons, says what it does not know, and has named who else to ask.
This week's action Fill in the ethics page on paper, keep it where only you will find it, and take the one step you wrote in box G.
← Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence: Responsibility, Bias, Surveillance, Work