Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
Every reading of the image in the last two lectures had a weak point at the same place: the person who cannot do what the reading seems to count. A very young child, a person with dementia and a person with severe disability are the test of any account of human worth. If worth hangs on ability, they are in danger. If it does not, we need to say what it hangs on.
This lecture asks that question directly. It does so with respect for those who are named in it, and it never treats them as mere test cases for an argument. They are persons, and some of them may be in your own family.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why a measure of worth based on ability puts some persons at risk.
- Describe how each of the four readings of the image answers the question of worth without ability.
- State what it means to say that dignity is given and not proven, and state one criticism of this view fairly.
- Explain what Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 add to the argument.
- Explain how Philippians 2:5-8 speaks to the idea that worth does not depend on status or power.
Whoever sheds man’s blood, his blood will be shed by man, for God made man in his own image." — Genesis 9:6
World English Bible
With it we bless our God and Father, and with it we curse men, who are made in the image of God." — James 3:9
WEB
Have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus, who, existing in the form of God, didn’t consider equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men. And being found in human form, he humbled himself, becoming obedient to death, yes, the death of the cross." — Philippians 2:5-8
WEB
Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 are far from Genesis 1 in time, yet both still speak of human beings as made in God's image. The first comes after the flood, in a world already broken by violence. The second comes from a letter to churches, and speaks of the tongue that blesses God and curses people. Philippians 2:5-8 does not use the word image, but it speaks of Christ who held no claim to status, and it is often read beside the image passages.
1. The test we do not choose
Most of the time we do not ask what a person is worth. We live among people we love, and we do not make a list. But there are moments when a society, or a family, or our own heart makes a list without saying so. We ask: Is she still herself? Can he still contribute? Is this life still useful? When we ask these questions we are using a measure of worth, whether we say so or not.
A measure of worth based on ability is easy to fall into, because ability is easy to see. A person who can work, speak, learn, decide and give is plainly there. A person who cannot may seem to recede. Many modern habits quietly support the measure: we ask a stranger what she does; we praise achievement; we feel pity or embarrassment before dependence. Machines that do many tasks well may sharpen the habit, since they make the measure of usefulness seem more precise.
The Christian conviction that this course presses is that worth is not found by the measure. Let us see how this works out when it is hardest.
2. An invented case, told with respect
Here is a case (an invented example). In a parish there lives a woman called Mrs. Okafor, aged eighty-four. For fifty years she taught children to read. She sang in the choir. Now she has dementia, a condition in which memory and thinking slowly fail. She no longer knows the name of the street where she has lived since her marriage. Often she does not know her daughter's name, though she smiles when the daughter comes in, and she holds her hand.
Her grandson is nineteen and studies computing. One Sunday he visits and tells his priest that he is troubled. He has been reading about programs that write and answer questions. "My grandmother used to be the cleverest person I knew," he says. "Now the program can do more than she can. I know it is wrong to think so, but I find myself asking what she is, now." He stops. "I do not want to ask it."
The priest does not answer at once. He says that the question is honest and that the boy is right to be troubled by his own thought. Then he asks, "Does your grandmother still know when you come in?" The grandson says she lights up. "She does not know my name. But she knows that someone who is hers has come."
Notice what the case does. It does not say that Mrs. Okafor is like a machine or unlike one. It shows the habit of measuring turning in a young man's mind, and he is honest enough to see it. The question "what is she, now?" is the question this lecture is about. The answer cannot be given by measuring her. If we measure, we lose her. What then can we say?
3. How each reading answers
Each of the four readings of lectures 1-2 and 1-3 has an answer. We give them as a holder of each might.
The substantial reading says that the image rests in the kind of being a person is, and not in the present use of any power. Mrs. Okafor is a human being, with a human soul, and the image is hers as it was when she taught. A power can be hidden by illness and still be the person's, as a sleeping person is still a thinking being. A newborn child, who has not yet used reason, is a human being by kind and so bears the image already. The weak point we named is the slide to "more ability, more image". Here the reading must hold firm against its own danger: the image is of the kind, not of the degree.
The relational reading says that the image is the being addressed and loved, and Mrs. Okafor is addressed and loved. Her daughter holds her hand. God knows her by name, though she cannot give her own. The image does not depend on her answering, because the relation begins from the side of the one who loves. A child is the first example: she is called by name long before she answers. The weak point we named is the person with no partner. Here the reading says that God is always a partner, and that the community of the church is called to be one too.
The functional reading says that the image is a to care and rule, and the community must carry those who cannot take up the calling alone. The task is given to the human race and to each person as a place in it. Mrs. Okafor's life of teaching is part of that calling, and the care she now receives is part of it too, for those who give the care. Her dependence also calls forth service in others. The weak point is the danger of counting only those who perform. The reading must therefore insist that the calling is not a test.
The Christ-centred reading says that Christ is the true image, and the worth of each person lies in being one for whom Christ lived and died. The worth is not assessed; it is paid for. Mrs. Okafor, in her forgetting, remains one whom the Son of God knows. Her forgetfulness cannot sever her from the one who "foreknew" and calls. The weak point is the risk of ranking those outside the faith. The reading must therefore state that the image in creation is common to all, and the conformity to Christ is a gift that no measure can grant or take away.
Look at what the four answers share. Each puts the foundation of worth outside the person's performance: in the kind of being, in the love that addresses, in the calling given, in the Son who gave himself. That is not a coincidence of vocabulary. It follows from the same biblical conviction.
4. Dignity as given, not proven
The word often used for this conviction is dignity: a worth that belongs to a person as such, and not by reason of what she does. Christians say that this dignity is given. It is not earned, and it cannot be proven to a doubter by a test, since it was never based on a test. God has given it, and it is to be recognised and not conferred.
Notice how the two texts we added show this. Genesis 9:6 comes after the flood. Humanity has fallen, and violence is everywhere. Yet the text says that to shed human blood is a grave wrong, "for God made man in his own image". The image is still said of human beings after their failure. It has not been forfeited by sin. This lecture does not take up what Genesis 9:6 says about punishment, which Christians have read in different ways; we take only what it says about the reason given, the image.
James 3:9 makes a similar point from the New Testament. It speaks of the tongue: "With it we bless our God and Father, and with it we curse men, who are made in the ." The text does not say that we curse only those who are admirable. It says people, who are made in the image of God. To curse a person is therefore to wrong one who bears God's image, and that holds whoever the person is. James writes to churches in which some were despised, and he does not allow that a person's standing be set by what the community thinks of him.
Taken together, the two verses suggest that the image is not lost by nor withdrawn when a person is weak or wicked or unattractive. That is what is meant by calling it a given. It is the ground on which one stands, not the prize at the end of a race.
5. Christ's self-emptying
Philippians 2:5-8 adds a different note. Paul asks the church to "have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus", and then describes the one who "existing in the form of God" did not consider equality with God "a thing to be grasped", but "emptied himself, taking the form of a servant". He was found in human form, humbled himself, and became obedient "to death, yes, the death of the cross".
The passage is about how Christians should treat one another, and it is also one of the deepest statements of what God is like. This is the point for our question. If the God whom Christians worship did not hold on to status, then status cannot be the measure of what is worth honouring. The one who was most able, in the Christian account, became weak. He was carried, as an infant is carried; he was handled, bound and killed. This does not make weakness good in itself, and we should not romanticise suffering. It means that God's way of showing what a human being is worth passes through weakness and not around it.
For those who care for a person like Mrs. Okafor, this can be a quiet strength. The care is not a lesser thing. It is a kind of sharing in the way the Son came among us. It is also a call to the community: a church that honours only the strong has not understood the one whom it follows.
6. Criticisms of dignity as given
The view of dignity we have described has critics, and fairness requires that we hear them. We state their arguments in a form they would accept.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some thoughtful people, including some Christians, doubt that "dignity" can do the work it is asked to do. They say that the word is vague: that appeals to it are often used to stop discussion rather than to guide it, and that people who say "dignity" mean very different things. A second criticism, made by some philosophers, is that if worth is the same for every human being whatever their abilities, it seems to rest only on belonging to a biological species, and they ask why species membership should carry such weight. They ask what makes a human being with no capacities differ in worth from another animal. Some in this line hold that worth should follow capacities such as the ability to feel or to plan. Others, who value the same people, prefer to speak of care and love as the ground and not of dignity as a possession.
The defenders of dignity reply that the Christian conviction does not rest on species alone. It rests on what God has done: made, called and redeemed each human being. The reply to "why species?" is "because God has set his image upon this kind and his love upon each one". Defenders add that the alternative is dangerous. If worth follows capacity, then it can be lowered by illness and age, and history shows how readily that line has been used against the weak. They also say that to recognise a limit on what we can prove is not the same as having no ground: a conviction that rests on God's act cannot be proven by argument alone, and does not need to be. The critics' weak point is therefore the question what will protect the weak if capacity is the measure; the defenders' weak point is that those who do not share their faith may not find the ground persuasive. The course requires that you can state both positions fairly. It does not require that you share a view about who has won.
7. What this asks of us
Nothing in this lecture says that ability is bad. Skill is a gift, and the good it does is real. What it denies is that skill is the ground of worth. Where that is clear, a few practical consequences follow.
First, watch the language. We say a person "contributes", is "productive" or is "a burden". Each word, used carelessly, carries a measure. We need not stop using them, but we should notice when they are doing the work of a verdict on a person.
Second, notice what a machine's ability does to the measure. If a machine can do a task better than a person, a person who measures by task will feel smaller. The Christian reply is not to claim the task for ourselves out of pride. It is to see that the measure was wrong from the start.
Third, remember who is in the room. When a church speaks about these questions, someone in the pew may be caring for a parent who no longer knows her, or may be a person who lives with a disability. They should hear nothing that suggests their worth, or the worth of the one they love, depends on keeping up.
If this lecture touches a loss of your own, you may stop and speak to a pastor, a priest or a person you trust. If you are in despair or in danger, call your local emergency number.
Diagram 1. Two ways of resting worth
핵심 요약
- A measure of worth by ability puts the very young, the ill, the old and the disabled at risk.
- All four readings of the image rest worth outside performance: in kind, in love, in calling, in Christ.
- Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 speak of the image after the fall, so it is not forfeited by failure or weakness.
- Dignity is given by God and recognised, not earned or proven; critics call it vague or ask why species matters.
- Philippians 2:5-8 shows the Son not grasping status, so status cannot be the measure of worth.
- Ability is a gift; it is not the ground of worth.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why ability is a risky measure | It puts at risk those who cannot yet, or can no longer, do what is measured. |
| Dignity (as Christians use it) | A worth that belongs to a person as such, given by God and recognised, not earned. |
| Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 | Both speak of the image after the fall: it is not lost by sin or weakness. |
| Philippians 2:5-8 | The Son did not grasp status but emptied himself; status is not the measure of worth. |
One sentence to remember Worth is not found by measuring a person; it is given, and the care of the weak is a share in how the Son came among us.
This week's action Notice one word you use for people ("productive", "burden", "contribute") and ask what measure it carries.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In the invented case, what did the priest's question ("Does your grandmother still know when you come in?") do for the grandson?
- Where do you notice a measure of worth by ability in your own speech, your community or your habits?
- Choose one of the four readings of the image and say how it answers the question of worth without ability. Where must it be careful?
- What do Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 add to the argument that Genesis 1 alone does not?
- State the criticism of "dignity as given" in a form its holder would accept. How would a defender reply?