무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism

Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?

목차 31
STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism
제 0 장 · Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Reading the Image
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
  4. Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
제 2 장 · Week 2: Mind, Consciousness and Soul
  1. Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
  3. Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
  4. Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
제 3 장 · Week 3: Intelligence, Person, Moral Status
  1. Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
  3. Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
  4. Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
제 4 장 · Week 4: Relationship, Care, Friendship, Grief
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
  2. Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
  3. Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
제 5 장 · Week 5: Work, Calling and Human Worth
  1. Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
  2. Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
  3. Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
  4. Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
제 6 장 · Week 6: Enhancement, Immortality, Resurrection
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Old Dream, in New Words
  2. Lecture 6-2: Finitude and the Body: Is a Limit a Curse?
  3. Lecture 6-3: Resurrection and the Upload Story
  4. Lecture 6-4: Living as Creatures in Hope
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on the Human Person

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

24분

Christians use the word soul often, in prayer, at funerals, in hymns and in arguments. People mean different things by it without noticing. One person means a non-material part that leaves at death. Another means the whole inner life of a person. Another means simply "the person, seen as loved by God". Before anyone asks "could a machine have a soul?", we need to ask what the word is being asked to do.

This lecture sets out several ideas of the soul that have a long history in Christian thought, shows what each is trying to protect, and asks what happens to the question about machines when it is put in each form. Our aim is modest. We use the question about AI as a mirror: it shows us what we already assumed about ourselves. We do not use it as a verdict on any machine.

이 24분으로 얻는 것

  • Describe three ideas of the soul: a non-material substance, a life principle, and the continuity of a person.
  • Say what each idea is trying to protect.
  • Explain why the question "could a machine have a soul?" changes meaning with each idea.
  • State fairly the disagreement over the make-up of a person, and what this course requires.
  • Explain why a person's standing before God does not depend on proving the soul.

Yahweh God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul." — Genesis 2:7

World English Bible

and the dust returns to the earth as it was, and the spirit returns to God who gave it." — Ecclesiastes 12:7

WEB

Jesus, crying with a loud voice, said, “Father, into your hands I commit my spirit!” Having said this, he breathed his last." — Luke 23:46

WEB

The first passage describes the beginning of a human life. The second describes an ending in the language of a poem about old age. The third gives the last words of Jesus on the cross. Together they speak of dust, breath, spirit and the hands of God. They do not give a definition of the soul, and we should not ask them to.

1. A word with many jobs

When Christians say "soul" they may be doing one of several jobs. They may be naming what survives death. They may be naming what makes a living thing alive. They may be naming the real self, the one who loves, remembers and answers to God. They may be naming the part of us that God cares most about. These jobs overlap, and the word is good at sliding between them. That slide is not always a fault. But when we bring a machine into the picture, the jobs pull apart, and we need to know which one we mean.

We look at three ideas, each with a long history. They are not the only ones.

2. Idea one: the soul as a non-material substance

On this idea the soul is a real thing, though not a material thing. It is the part of a human being that thinks, chooses and loves, and it can exist apart from the body. It is the idea we met in lecture 2-1 as dualism. Plato's teaching in ancient Greece was influential here, and many early Christian writers used something like it, though they changed it where it did not fit their faith. Plato held that the soul exists before the body and is imprisoned in it. Christian writers generally denied both points: they held that God creates each soul, and that the body is good and is made to be raised.

What it protects. It protects the conviction that a person is more than what can be weighed and measured, that what matters most about us is not simply a pattern of matter, and that something of the person remains in God's hands when the body dies. For many believers at a deathbed, this is a great comfort.

What strains it. The questions of lecture 2-1: how does a non-material thing act on a body? And what, exactly, does it do, if the brain seems to do the thinking? A further strain is that Scripture seldom speaks of the soul in this way. The Old Testament usually means by nephesh the whole living being. Where the New Testament speaks of a person's state between death and the resurrection, as Paul does in Philippians 1:23, readers disagree about what he means.

The question about machines in this form. If the soul is a non-material substance that God creates and joins to a body, then whether a machine has a soul is a question about God's action, not about the machine's design. A believer on this view might say that no one can say what God would do, and that a machine's structure cannot settle it. Or she might say that the Church has taught that souls are given to human beings, and that she sees no ground for supposing otherwise. Both are possible within this idea, and the course does not choose between them.

3. Idea two: the soul as the life principle

A second idea comes mainly from Aristotle and was taken up in the Christian West by Thomas Aquinas. Aristotle asked what the difference is between a living thing and a dead one. His answer was that a living thing has a soul, which he understood as the organising principle that makes a body a living body: able to take food, to grow, to sense, and in human beings to reason. A plant has a soul of one kind, an animal of another, a human being of a third. On this idea the soul is not a ghost in the body; it is what makes the body alive and makes it this kind of body.

Aquinas used this idea, in the summary of his teaching, to say that the human soul is the form of the body, and also that the human soul is of such a kind that it can exist after death, though in an incomplete state, waiting for the body to be raised. He held that the soul alone is not the whole person; the person is soul and body together. So this idea tries to keep two things: the unity of the person, and a belief that something continues.

What it protects. It protects the goodness and importance of the body, and the thought that a human being is one thing, not two things bolted together. It fits the Bible's own way of speaking of a person as a living being.

What strains it. It can seem hard to understand without learning a technical vocabulary, and critics ask whether "form" says more than we can check. Those who think a soul must be an immaterial thing may feel that it gives the soul too little reality.

The question about machines in this form. If the soul is the life principle of a living body, then the question about a machine is: is it a living body? A machine, as we know machines, does not grow, feed or reproduce as a living thing does. A careful holder of this idea would say that on its terms a machine of the usual kind would not have a soul, since it is not alive in this sense. But she would also say that we do not know what the future of making may hold, and that the idea gives a question to ask, not an answer to read off. She would ask: what is it about life that does the work?

4. Idea three: the soul as the continuity of a person

A third idea asks a different question. Instead of "what is the soul made of?" it asks "what makes someone the same person over time?" You are not made of the same matter you were made of when you were a child; most of what your body is made of has been replaced. Yet you are the same person. What makes it so?

Some answer: the body, as a continuous living thing. Some answer: memory and character, the chain of remembering and caring that links you to your earlier self. The philosopher John Locke, in 1690, suggested that a person is the same by the continuity of consciousness and memory. Some Christian writers answer: the person is held in being by God, who knows each by name, and so the soul is, in a sense, the person's being known and kept by God. This is sometimes expressed by saying that the soul is the person as God holds the person in mind.

What it protects. It protects the thought that the one who dies and the one who is raised are the same person, and not a copy. This matters greatly to the Christian hope, as we see in lecture 6-3.

What strains it. If sameness is memory and character, then loss of memory in illness would be a loss of the self, and this conflicts with the Christian conviction that the person with dementia is wholly a person. If sameness is the body, then it is hard to say what happens between death and resurrection. If sameness is God's holding, then it is true but gives us little to say about how. Each answer pays a price.

The question about machines in this form. If the person is the continuity of memory and character, then someone may ask whether a machine that kept a record of a person's words and style could be that person. This is the question behind several stories we meet later. Under this idea we note only the shape of the question and the main difficulty: a record of what a person said is not the same as the person, and a being known by God is not a pattern that can be copied. Whether continuity of pattern is enough is exactly the point at which the ideas differ. We return to it in lecture 6-3.

5. The make-up of a person: where readers differ

This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians have long divided over how many parts a person has. Some hold that a person has two: body and soul, where spirit and soul are two names for the same inner side (this is sometimes called dichotomy). Some hold that a person has three: body, soul and spirit, where spirit is the part that meets God (trichotomy). Some hold that a person is one thing with many aspects, and that body-soul language names the aspects and not parts (a holistic view). Each reading appeals to Scripture. The three-part view points to a verse such as 1 Thessalonians 5:23, which lists spirit, soul and body together. The two-part view points to places where "soul" and "spirit" appear to be used for the same thing. The holistic view points to the way the Old Testament speaks of a person as one living being.

The strongest case for the three-part view is that it gives a clear place for a person's meeting with God, and respects the verses that distinguish spirit from soul. Its weak point is that the same verses can be read as a figure of speech for the whole person, and that the Bible elsewhere uses the words loosely. The strongest case for the two-part view is that it accounts for most of the language of Scripture and the church's long teaching with the fewest assumptions. Its weak point is that it can appear to cut the person in two. The strongest case for the holistic view is that it follows the Old Testament's own picture and the hope of resurrection. Its weak point is the question of what is said of the dead before the raising. Most Protestant traditions have tolerated more than one of these views. Catholic and Orthodox teaching generally speak of body and soul with spirit as an aspect of the soul, and most Orthodox writers avoid a rigid count.

What this course requires is less than any of the three requires: that you can state each fairly, and that you do not make a person's belonging to Christ depend on the count.

6. The question about AI as a mirror

Here is the point of the lecture. When someone asks "could a machine have a soul?", the question does not have one meaning. It depends on what the asker has taken the soul to be. If the soul is a non-material substance, the question is about what God does. If it is the life principle, the question is about whether the thing is alive. If it is the continuity of a person, the question is about what makes anyone the same one over time.

This is why the question works as a mirror. It sends us back to ask: what did I think a soul was? A person who says "obviously not" and a person who says "perhaps so" may be using the word in quite different senses, and so may be agreeing about more than they think, or disagreeing about something other than they think. The mirror also shows us something humbling: most of us have held an idea of the soul without ever having had to say what it was.

A Christian who finds this unsettling can take comfort in two facts. First, the church has never required one theory of the soul as the condition of faith. It has required the confession that God made the human being, body and soul, that Christ took our nature, and that the dead will be raised. Second, the weight of these confessions does not rest on our ability to explain the soul. We do not have to complete the account.

7. Standing before God does not depend on proof

One more thing needs saying plainly, because this topic can hurt. Nobody has to prove that they have a soul in order to be a person before God. The person in a coma, the newborn child, the person whose mind is clouded by illness: none of them must show a test of the soul. In the language of Luke 23:46, the one who commits his spirit to the Father is held by the Father whether or not he can say it. A Christian view of the soul, whatever form it takes, should leave every human being safely inside the circle of those whom God has made and keeps. If an idea of the soul could be used to put a living human being outside that circle, the idea has been misused.

8. Three layers

  • What the text says. Genesis 2:7: dust and breath, and a living being. Ecclesiastes 12:7: at death the dust returns to the earth and the spirit to God who gave it. Luke 23:46: Jesus commits his spirit to the Father as he dies.
  • A tradition's reading. Many readers see in Ecclesiastes 12:7 and Luke 23:46 a sign that something of the person is held by God at death. Others note that Ecclesiastes is a book of questions, and that the same book says elsewhere that no one knows what comes after. Some read these as pictures of breath leaving a body, in a book that does not set out a doctrine.
  • Our judgement. A prudent judgement is that the Bible gives us confidence that God keeps those who die, and does not give us a full account of what the soul is. We use the question about AI to test our own ideas, and we hold the answer lightly.

Diagram 1. Three ideas of the soul, and what each protects

One word, three jobs "Could a machine have a soul?" changes meaning with each A non-material substance Protects I am more than what can be weighed The machine question becomes What does God do? The design cannot settle it. Strain How it moves a body; Scripture seldom says it this way The life principle Protects The body is good; a person is one, not two bolted together The machine question becomes Is it alive? What about life does the work? Strain Technical words; is "form" more than a label? The continuity of a person Protects The one raised is the same one who died, not a copy The machine question becomes Is a record of a person's pattern that person? Strain If sameness is memory, what of the person who has lost memory? The question about AI is a mirror: it asks what we meant by "soul". No one has to prove a soul to stand before God.

핵심 요약

  • "Soul" does several jobs: what survives death, what makes a body alive, the real self, the person as God holds the person.
  • Three ideas: a non-material substance, a life principle (Aristotle, Aquinas), and the continuity of a person. Each protects something and strains at something.
  • Whether a machine could have a soul changes meaning with each idea; the question works as a mirror, not a verdict.
  • Christians differ on the count of parts (two, three, or one living whole); the church has not made one theory a condition of faith.
  • A record of a person's words and pattern is not obviously the same as the person.
  • No one must prove a soul to stand before God; an idea of the soul that puts a living person outside that circle is misused.
Front Back
Soul as substance A real non-material thing that can exist apart from the body. Protects: I am more than what is weighed.
Soul as life principle What makes a body a living body of its kind (Aristotle, Aquinas). Protects: the unity of the person and the goodness of the body.
Soul as continuity What makes a person the same one over time. Protects: the one raised is the same one who died.
Dichotomy, trichotomy, holism A person has two parts, three parts, or is one living whole with many aspects. Readers do not agree.

One sentence to remember "Could a machine have a soul?" is first a question about what we meant by the word.

This week's action Write in two sentences what you mean when you say "soul", then ask one trusted person what they mean and compare.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • When you last used the word "soul" (in a prayer, a hymn, a conversation), which of the three jobs was it doing?
  • Plato held that the soul is imprisoned in the body; early Christian writers denied this. Why might the goodness of the body matter so much to Christian teaching?
  • If a person is the same over time by memory, what follows for a person who has lost memory? How does each idea of the soul answer?
  • State the two-part, the three-part and the holistic views each in a form their holders would accept. Which weak point seems to you the most serious, and why might a holder of that view disagree?
  • "Could a machine have a soul?" Choose one idea of the soul and answer the question as a careful holder of that idea would. Then say what it would add that the answer cannot decide.
  • Why does the lecture say that a person need not prove a soul to stand before God? Who might hear that sentence as good news?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.