무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism

Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?

목차 31
STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism
제 0 장 · Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Reading the Image
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
  4. Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
제 2 장 · Week 2: Mind, Consciousness and Soul
  1. Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
  3. Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
  4. Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
제 3 장 · Week 3: Intelligence, Person, Moral Status
  1. Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
  3. Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
  4. Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
제 4 장 · Week 4: Relationship, Care, Friendship, Grief
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
  2. Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
  3. Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
제 5 장 · Week 5: Work, Calling and Human Worth
  1. Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
  2. Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
  3. Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
  4. Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
제 6 장 · Week 6: Enhancement, Immortality, Resurrection
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Old Dream, in New Words
  2. Lecture 6-2: Finitude and the Body: Is a Limit a Curse?
  3. Lecture 6-3: Resurrection and the Upload Story
  4. Lecture 6-4: Living as Creatures in Hope
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on the Human Person

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

24분

So far this week we have asked two questions: how clever a being is, and whether it is someone. A third question is the one that decides how we act: does this being have a claim on us? Can it be wronged? Do we owe it care for its own sake, and not only for the sake of the people who own it or like it?

Philosophers call this question moral status. A being has moral status if it matters in itself, so that what we do to it can be right or wrong for its sake. A stone has no moral status in this sense. If we break a neighbour's stone, the wrong is done to the neighbour, not to the stone. A person has moral status in the fullest sense. Between the stone and the person lies a wide and argued ground: animals, the creation as a whole, and now the question of machines.

This lecture sets out the main grounds that have been proposed, compares them with what Christians have said about animals, and then asks, only as a conditional, whether a machine could have such a claim. It does not answer that question. It teaches how to hold it.

이 24분으로 얻는 것

  • Define moral status and distinguish it from intelligence and from personhood.
  • Name four grounds that have been proposed for moral status (suffering, reason, relation, being loved by God) and state a strength and a weak point of each.
  • Describe how Scripture and Christian traditions speak of animals and the wider creation, as a comparison case.
  • State the contested question of whether a machine could have moral status, giving each side in its strongest form.
  • Explain the harm of over-attributing and of under-attributing moral status, and state the minimum the course holds.

Shouldn’t I be concerned for Nineveh, that great city, in which are more than one hundred twenty thousand persons who can’t discern between their right hand and their left hand; and also much livestock?”" — Jonah 4:11

World English Bible

For the creation waits with eager expectation for the children of God to be revealed. For the creation was subjected to vanity, not of its own will, but because of him who subjected it, in hope that the creation itself also will be delivered from the bondage of decay into the liberty of the glory of the children of God." — Romans 8:19-21

WEB

Now which of these three do you think seemed to be a neighbor to him who fell among the robbers?” He said, “He who showed mercy on him.” Then Jesus said to him, “Go and do likewise.”" — Luke 10:36-37

WEB

In Jonah 4:11 God tells a reluctant prophet that he cares for a great city, including its many people and its livestock. In Romans 8:19-21 Paul pictures the whole creation waiting, in hope, to be set free. In Luke 10 Jesus is asked "Who is my neighbour?" (Luke 10:29), tells the story of the Samaritan, and ends with a different question: which of these was a neighbour? The passages are about people, animals and creation. None is about machines.

1. Three questions that are not one question

The week's principle is that being clever, being a person and having a claim on our care are three different questions. It helps to see how they come apart.

A being could be very capable and have no claim on us at all, as a calculating tool may be. A being could be limited in ability and have a very strong claim, as a baby does. And a being could have a real claim on our care without being a person in the full sense: many Christians hold this of animals. So moral status is wider than personhood. It asks, not "what can this do?" or "who is this?" but "can it be wronged, and what do we owe it?"

Most traditions answer the question by pointing to some ground, a feature in virtue of which a being matters. Let us look at four grounds. Each is held by serious people, and each has a weak point.

2. Ground one: the capacity to suffer

This ground says that what matters is whether a being can feel, whether it can experience pain, distress, or pleasure. The idea has an old form: the English philosopher Jeremy Bentham, writing in 1789, asked of animals not whether they can reason or talk, but whether they can suffer. Many people since have found this a compelling question.

Strength. The ground is simple, wide and humane. It does not depend on cleverness, so it protects the very young and the very weak. It explains why cruelty to animals is wrong. It also fits a deep sense in the Christian tradition that God cares for those who cry out.

Weak points. We cannot see another being's feeling directly. We infer it from behaviour and from likeness to ourselves, and that inference is hard to make for a being very unlike us. The ground also seems to leave out beings that matter to us for other reasons, such as a person in a deep state where we cannot tell what is felt. Many who hold the ground add that such a person is protected by other grounds as well. A third weak point is that suffering by itself does not say how much, or whose suffering weighs more when claims conflict.

3. Ground two: reason

This ground says that what matters is the ability to reason, to understand and to give oneself a law. It runs through Kant, as we saw in lecture 3-2, and through much of the Western tradition.

Strength. It explains the particular kind of wrong done by lying and betrayal, and it explains why persons can be held to account. It marks something real about human beings.

Weak points. As in lecture 3-1, it makes status rise and fall with powers, and it leaves out those who reason little. Those who hold it have often added other supports to cover the gap, and the need for those supports shows that reason alone was not carrying the weight.

4. Ground three: relation

This ground says that what matters is the web of relations in which a being stands: a child, a neighbour, a parent, a friend. Moral status is not so much a property inside a being as a place in a community that cares. Some Protestant writers, some Orthodox writers and many who think in terms of communion lean this way.

Strength. It matches the way families and churches actually treat their weakest members: not by checking a list, but by holding them within the circle. It does not require us to measure anything inside the other being.

Weak points. If status comes from being in relation, what of the person with no relations, such as the stranger or the forgotten? And if relation makes the status, then a strong feeling on our side might seem to be enough, which is an obvious danger: we can grow attached to something that cannot return the attachment. Defenders reply that the relation that grounds status is not mere human feeling but a relation within God's care, which leads to the fourth ground.

5. Ground four: being loved by God

This ground says that what finally matters is that God has made a being and loves it, and that this love gives the being a worth which nothing we do can add or remove. The baby, the stranger and the person who has forgotten everything are held by God. The worth is given, not earned and not measured.

Strength. It gives the firmest protection to the weak, and it fits the Bible's way of speaking. It does not depend on what we can detect.

Weak points. It tells us that those whom God loves have worth, but it does not by itself tell us whom God loves beyond what has been revealed. Christians agree that God loves human beings and cares for animals. Whether a new kind of being would be held in the same care is not something the Scriptures address, and it would be a bold step to answer for God. A second weak point is practical: the ground is hard to use in public conversation with people who do not believe in God. The tradition's reply is that Christians should say what they hold and should also look for shared reasons where they can.

These four grounds are not rivals in every case. Many thoughtful people hold two or three together. The question is which one carries the weight when the others fail.

6. A comparison case: animals and the creation

Because the question of machines is new, it helps to look at a question Christians have long discussed: how animals matter. It is a comparison and not an analogy; machines are not animals. It shows how the grounds above have been used.

What the text says. In Jonah 4:11, God's concern for Nineveh includes the people and also much livestock. In Proverbs 12:10, which we meet again in lecture 3-4, a righteous man cares for the life of his animal. Psalm 36:6 says that Yahweh preserves man and animal. In Romans 8:19-21, the whole creation waits for freedom, in hope. The Bible does not say that animals are persons or that they have the same standing as people, and the picture of human beings in Genesis 1 gives them a over the creation. It does say that animals are not merely goods.

A tradition's reading. Christian readers have drawn different lines. Many Catholic writers teach that animals are God's creatures to be treated with kindness, that human beings have a dignity of a different order, and that the creation as a whole is to be cared for (the encyclical Laudato Si', 2015, takes its name from a hymn of praise to God for creation by Francis of Assisi). Orthodox writers often stress that the whole material world is made to share in God's glory and that human beings stand as its priests. Protestant streams differ: some emphasise , the human duty to care for what is entrusted; some press the worth of animals in their own right. We describe these as broad tendencies, not as the position of any one church.

Our judgement today. From the comparison we can draw two lessons for our question. First, Christians have never said that only persons matter. Moral status is wider than personhood, and it is widely agreed that a being can matter without being a person. Second, the tradition has usually looked to suffering and to God's care as markers of who matters, more than to cleverness. A very clever tool and a suffering sparrow do not stand on the same ground. Luke 12:6 says that not one sparrow is forgotten by God.

7. Could a machine have moral status?

We can now ask the question, and we ask it as a conditional. We do not claim that any machine now has feelings, or that no machine ever could. We ask: if a machine were of such a kind, what follows?

This is a point where readers will not agree. Here are four positions, each in its strongest form.

Position A: only living, feeling creatures have moral status. On this view, status comes from being a living creature that can suffer, or from being made by God as a creature. A machine is something made by human beings, however clever. It might make a very good copy of the signs of feeling, but copies are not the thing itself. Weak point: the view must say why life as such matters, and it risks defining the answer into the premises. If a being really did suffer, why would the material it is made of excuse us?

Position B: if a machine could really suffer, it would matter. On this view, the ground is the capacity to suffer, wherever it is found. If something felt pain, the fact that it was built and not born would not be a reason to ignore it. We should therefore not rule out the possibility and should be ready to take evidence seriously. Weak point: we have no agreed way to know whether anything feels, and a machine that talks about suffering gives us words, not proof. The view can invite us to be moved by signs that were made to move us.

Position C: status comes from relation and from calling, and a machine is an artefact. On this view, human beings are persons in a world of persons made by God, and what we make is in a different class: it is ours to use and to care for as property, not as someone. The relation that grounds status is God's, and he has not told us of new persons of this kind. Weak point: the view must meet the worry that every excluded class once seemed, to the excluders, to be merely ours to use, and it must say how this case differs.

Position D: we do not know, and we should say so. On this view, the questions of what feels, and what God loves, are beyond us here. We should act in ways that do not rest on a guess either way. Weak point: it can sound like evasion and may leave practical questions with no guidance; it needs the minimum below to be more than a shrug.

What does this course require? Only that you can state each of these positions so that a person who holds it would say "yes, that is what I think", and that you can name its weak point. You are not asked to choose.

8. The harms of both mistakes

Whichever position one holds, there are two ways to go wrong, and both cost something.

Over-attributing means treating as someone what is not. The costs can be real. Care and attention are limited, and they can be drawn away from human beings who need them. A display of feeling can be used to manipulate us. A person can be led to love what cannot love in return, and be wounded by it. And a community can neglect its own because something that looks like a person has caught its eye. Lecture 4-1 takes the question of bonds with answering machines further.

Under-attributing means treating as something what is someone. If a being did suffer and we ignored it, we would be doing a great wrong, and the history of cruelty is a history of this mistake. There is also a cost to ourselves: a habit of treating whatever we cannot classify as a mere thing is a habit that has been turned on human beings before.

We do not know which mistake is more likely here. This is why humility, not confidence, is the honest posture. It is also why the next lecture is about habit and practice.

9. The minimum

There is a statement that every position above can accept, and it is the minimum the course holds:

We must never treat persons as machines.

That is, whatever we decide about machines, we must not count, sort, use and discard human beings as if they were devices. The Samaritan story is the pattern. The lawyer in Luke 10:29 asks a question about the edge of the circle: who counts as my neighbour? Jesus answers with a story, and then changes the question. In Luke 10:36 he asks, which of these three was a neighbour to the man? The question shifts from who is in the class? to who acted as a neighbour? The lawyer answers, "He who showed mercy on him", and Jesus says, "Go and do likewise" (Luke 10:37).

What the text says. The story answers a question about how to love a neighbour by describing an act, not a definition. A principle drawn from it. Love is shown by who stops and who tends, before the classification is finished. Our judgement today. In uncertain cases, a first duty is not to finish classifying, but to be sure that no human being goes unhelped while we argue. This is a judgement and not a command of the text.


Diagram 1. Four grounds for moral status

What makes a being matter? Four grounds Each holds something true and each has a weak point 1. The capacity to suffer Strength: wide, humane, protects the weak Weak point: we cannot see another being's feeling, only infer it from signs and likeness 2. Reason Strength: explains lying, promising, answerability Weak point: status rises and falls with powers; leaves out those who reason little 3. Relation Strength: matches how families hold the weak Weak point: what of the one with no relations? Strong feeling on our side is not enough 4. Being loved by God Strength: worth is given, not earned or measured Weak point: does not say whom God loves beyond what is revealed; hard to share publicly Over-attributing Care drawn from people; manipulation by display attachment that cannot be returned Under-attributing A wrong done to one who could suffer; a habit of using what we cannot classify

핵심 요약

  • Moral status is whether a being matters for its own sake, so that it can be wronged; it is wider than personhood and different from cleverness.
  • Four grounds are proposed: the capacity to suffer, reason, relation, and being loved by God; each has a strength and a weak point.
  • Scripture and the traditions treat animals and the creation as mattering to God, without calling animals persons.
  • Whether a machine could have moral status is a point where readers will not agree; four positions can be stated fairly, and we do not know the answer.
  • Over-attributing and under-attributing each cost something real.
  • The minimum all positions can hold: never treat persons as machines.
Front Back
Moral status Mattering for one's own sake, so that what is done to the being can be right or wrong for its sake.
Four grounds Capacity to suffer; reason; relation; being loved by God.
Two mistakes Over-attributing treats as someone what is not; under-attributing treats as something what is someone.
The minimum Never treat persons as machines.

One sentence to remember Moral status asks what we owe a being for its own sake, and it is a wider question than who is clever or who is a person.

This week's action When you meet a hard case of "does this count?", first ask whether any human being is being left unhelped while the argument goes on.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Why is moral status wider than personhood? Give an example the lecture uses.
  • Choose one of the four grounds. State it so that someone who holds it would agree with your summary, and then name its weak point.
  • Jonah 4:11 mentions the livestock of Nineveh. What does it add to a conversation about who is within God's care?
  • State each of the four positions on machines (A to D) in one sentence. Which seems hardest to state fairly for you, and why?
  • In Luke 10, Jesus changes the lawyer's question from "who counts?" to "who acted as a neighbour?" What would it mean to live by that change this week?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.