Lecture 6-3: Resurrection and the Upload Story
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
This is the centre of the week. Lecture 6-1 heard the old dream of escaping death in its modern words. Lecture 6-2 looked at the body and its limits. Now we set two stories side by side: the story of an uploaded mind, in which a person's pattern might be kept in another medium, and the Christian hope of the resurrection of the body, in which God raises the dead.
The two are sometimes spoken of as if they were the same hope in different clothes. They are not. They rest on different pictures of what a person is, they look to different sources of life, and they promise different things. To see the difference is not to win an argument against anyone. It is to be able to say clearly what Christians hope for when they say the creed.
The lecture follows the principle of the week: the oldest dream of escaping death has new words; the Christian answer is not escape from the body but the hope of its raising. It makes no claim about whether any upload could ever be done. We write in conditionals throughout: "if a pattern of a mind could be kept ..." The lecture also tries to show where thoughtful Christians differ, within the hope of resurrection and about the story of the upload. Medicine is not covered.
이 30분으로 얻는 것
- State what the Christian hope of the resurrection of the body claims, using 1 Corinthians 15 and the creeds.
- Distinguish the immortality of the soul from the resurrection of the body.
- Set out, as a structure of arguments, the question of what makes someone the same person over time, and give the main answers.
- Name at least three things an "uploaded mind" story assumes about persons, and say why they are assumptions.
- Explain in what sense resurrection is not a technology, and describe how Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox emphases differ within the hope.
But now Christ has been raised from the dead. He became the first fruits of those who are asleep." — 1 Corinthians 15:20
World English Bible
For since death came by man, the resurrection of the dead also came by man." — 1 Corinthians 15:21
WEB
For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ all will be made alive." — 1 Corinthians 15:22
WEB
But each in his own order: Christ the first fruits, then those who are Christ’s, at his coming." — 1 Corinthians 15:23
WEB
Then the end comes, when he will deliver up the Kingdom to God, even the Father; when he will have abolished all rule and all authority and power." — 1 Corinthians 15:24
WEB
For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet." — 1 Corinthians 15:25
WEB
The last enemy that will be abolished is death." — 1 Corinthians 15:26
WEB
So also is the resurrection of the dead. The body is sown perishable; it is raised imperishable." — 1 Corinthians 15:42
WEB
It is sown in dishonor; it is raised in glory. It is sown in weakness; it is raised in power." — 1 Corinthians 15:43
WEB
It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body. There is a natural body and there is also a spiritual body." — 1 Corinthians 15:44
WEB
See my hands and my feet, that it is truly me. Touch me and see, for a spirit doesn’t have flesh and bones, as you see that I have.”" — Luke 24:39
WEB
In 1 Corinthians 15 Paul argues that Christ’s resurrection is the beginning of a harvest in which the dead will be raised, and that the last enemy to be abolished is death. The same chapter contrasts what is sown and what is raised. In Luke 24:39 the risen Jesus tells his frightened disciples that he is not a ghost. The passages say nothing about machines. They tell what Christians hope for, and that is what we need in order to compare it fairly with another hope.
1. What the hope says
The Christian hope of resurrection is not one idea among many in the faith. In 1 Corinthians 15, Paul treats it as a centre on which much else turns. The argument of the chapter runs in a line. Christ has been raised (verse 20). Death came by a man, and the raising of the dead comes by a man (verse 21). In Adam all die, in Christ all will be made alive (verse 22). There is an order: Christ first, then those who belong to him at his coming (verse 23). Then the end, when every power set against God has been put down, and the last enemy to be abolished is death (verses 24-26).
Notice several features of this hope.
It is the hope of a person, not of a part. The chapter says that the body is sown and the body is raised. The pairs in verses 42-44 describe one thing changed: perishable and imperishable, dishonour and glory, weakness and power, natural and spiritual. The thing that is sown is the thing that is raised, and it is changed.
It is a gift of God, in Christ. The raising is done by God, and it follows from what has been done to Christ. The dead do not raise themselves. This is why the New Testament speaks of Christ as the first fruits: the first part of a harvest, which promises the rest.
It is a hope for the world, not only for each person. Paul’s picture is of an end in which death is abolished and, as 1 Corinthians 15:28 puts it, God is all in all. It is not only a picture of individuals leaving death one by one.
It does not make death small. Death is called an enemy. Christians who hold this hope are not asked to say that death is nothing. The hope is strongest where the loss is most honestly named.
The creeds carry this hope into worship. The Apostles’ Creed says that the church believes in the resurrection of the body, and the says that the church looks for the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come. Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant churches say these creeds, each in its own way, and so they share this hope at the centre.
2. Two old ideas: immortality of the soul, and resurrection
Many students will have met the word immortality, and think it means the same as resurrection. Historically they are different ideas.
The immortality of the soul is the idea that a person has a soul which does not die, and which continues when the body ends. Versions of this idea are found in ancient Greek thought; Plato’s dialogue the Phaedo argues for it. On such a view, the body is often seen as a limit, or as a burden, and death may be a release.
The resurrection of the dead is the idea that the whole person dies, and that God raises the whole person. The Bible speaks of the person as a unity (a point we met in week 2), and the hope of the New Testament is not mainly that a soul will leave the body, but that the dead will be raised.
Christian thought has not kept these two entirely apart. Many Christians have held that the soul, or the person, continues in the presence of God after death, in a time of waiting before the raising of the body. Catholic teaching speaks of the soul's life with God after death, and holds that at the end the body is raised and joined to it again. Orthodox teaching also speaks of the soul after death, and of prayer for the departed, in hope of the general resurrection. Protestant traditions differ here: many speak of the believer being with Christ at death and awaiting the resurrection of the body; some have held that the dead are in a kind of sleep until the raising. These are real differences, and this course does not decide among them.
What these traditions share is the thing that matters for our comparison: the final hope is not only a soul that survives, but a person raised. The soul’s continuing, where it is held, is a stage on the way, not the aim. Death is not a release from the body into a better life without it.
3. What makes someone the same person?
Any hope of life after death, and any story of uploading, has to meet a question: who is it that continues? If a person after death or after a transfer is to be the same person, something must make that so. Philosophers call this the question of personal identity. It has several well-known answers, which we can set out as a structure. We do not say which is right.
The body answer. A person is the same person as long as the same living body continues. On this view, a new body, or a copy, is not the same person even if it resembles the first.
The soul answer. A person is the same person because of a soul, a non-material part, that continues. The body may change completely, but the soul stays. The weak point is to say what the soul carries, and how anyone could know it had continued.
The memory and character answer. A person is the same person as long as there is continuity of memory, character and the pattern of a life. This is a popular modern view. Its weak point appears when we ask what happens if two copies of a pattern were made: they cannot both be the person, and yet each would have the same claim.
The "whole person held by God" answer. Some Christian thinkers hold that what makes a person the same person is, in the end, that God knows and holds that person, and raises that person. On this view, the identity of the one raised does not depend on a single mechanism we can name; it depends on God’s faithfulness to the one he made and loved. The weak point is that it does not say how we should think about the matter in terms others can test. Its strength is that it matches the Bible’s way of speaking, in which God is faithful to the dead (Jesus speaks of the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob as the God of the living).
None of these answers has won general agreement among philosophers or theologians. An honest student can say: we do not know exactly what makes a person the same person, and each answer has a difficulty. This sentence is an important one for the next section.
4. What an upload story assumes
Now look at the story of an uploaded mind, as its supporters tell it. Remember that we do not say it could or could not be done. We ask only what the story assumes about persons, if it were possible.
It assumes that what matters in a person is a pattern. The story supposes that what makes you you is a structure of information and process, and that the stuff it is made of is not essential. Supporters hold this as a serious view. It is the memory-and-character answer above, pressed far.
It assumes that a copy or a transfer would be the person. The story depends on there being no important difference between the original and a successful continuation. This is exactly where the difficulty of the two-copies case bites. A supporter may answer that identity is not all-or-nothing, or that what matters is the continuation of the pattern and not the question of "the same one". That is a possible reply. But it is a move away from the ordinary sense in which a person hopes to survive.
It assumes that the body is a carrier, not part of the person. If the body is only the medium for a pattern, then a change of medium is like moving a text from one page to another. Christians, as lecture 6-2 showed, have long held that the body is part of the person who is made and saved.
It assumes that the problem is a lack of the right means. The story treats death as a problem of method: if the means were found, the problem would be solved. This is what makes it a story of technique.
It leaves out whatever the pattern does not contain. Christians would ask where such a story places the forgiveness of sins, the healing of what was wrong in a life, and the meeting with God. A long life, or an unending one, is not by itself a healed one. A pattern kept would also be kept with its wounds and its sins. The Christian hope is not only of more life; it is of life renewed, and of a person made whole.
These are not charges against those who tell the upload story; they are the assumptions the story needs. It is for the supporter to defend them, and for the Christian to say clearly that these are not the assumptions of the creed.
5. How the resurrection hope differs
Set the two side by side.
| The upload story | The Christian hope | |
|---|---|---|
| What is saved | A pattern of information and process | The whole person, body included |
| Who acts | People, by method | God, by gift |
| What the body is | A carrier | Part of the person, raised and changed |
| What the problem is | Death as a lack of means | Death as an enemy, and sin as its root |
| What is promised | More life | Life renewed, and a person made whole |
| Who is included | Those who can take part | All the dead, in Christ, in God’s order |
Two lines of the table need a word.
"Raised and changed". The risen Christ in Luke 24:39 says that he has flesh and bones, that he is no spirit, and invites the disciples to touch. Yet the gospels also say that the risen Jesus was not at once recognised and that he came into a closed room. So the early church read the resurrection body neither as the old body brought back unchanged, nor as a ghost. Paul calls it a spiritual body. Readers have taken this in different ways. The common reading in all three streams of Christian thought is that "spiritual" does not mean "made of spirit-stuff", but a body completely alive to God’s Spirit, no longer perishable. We must not use this to say how the dead are raised. The tradition does not know that. It trusts that God can, and will.
"Not a return to this life". Some in the Gospels were raised and then died again. The resurrection that Christians hope for is not of that kind. It is the raising of the dead into a life that does not end.
6. Resurrection is not a technology
This is the central sentence of the lecture, and we should state carefully what it means.
A technology is something that people can make, repeat and control, given enough knowledge and means. The resurrection, as the New Testament speaks of it, is none of these. It is not made by people. It is not a method that could be learned. It does not wait on skill. It is a promise, and the Christian response to a promise is trust and waiting, not engineering. This is why Romans 8, which we meet in lecture 6-4, speaks of hope as waiting with patience.
We say this without any judgement on what technology may or may not do. Nothing here tells us whether any method to prolong life would work. The claim is only that the resurrection hope is not in the same category. If a technology to preserve a pattern of a person were ever made, it would be a technology: a human work, like writing or a photograph, even if a far more powerful one. And it would be something else than the thing the creed names. It would not be wrong to say so. It would be wrong to call it resurrection, and it would be wrong to call it nothing.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Suppose that some day a technology could keep or continue the pattern of a person's mind. How should a Christian regard it? One view holds that it would be a tool like any other: a human help to memory and continuity, which might be used well or badly, which would not rival the resurrection any more than a book rivals it, and which could be received with thanks and without confusion. Those who hold this view say that Christians should not treat every new capacity as a threat to faith, and that the hope of resurrection is safe because it never depended on human means. Another view holds that such a technology would be misleading at its root: it would offer a counterfeit of the hope by promising survival to a pattern while leaving out the body, the gift and the healing, and it would tend to teach people to put their hope in method. Those who hold this view say that the danger lies less in the object than in what hearers would be taught to trust. Each view has a weak point. The first has to say how it prevents the tool from taking the place of hope. The second has to say whether any use of such a tool could be innocent, and on what ground. This course requires only that a student can state both views fairly, and can say what the creed hopes for without confusing it with either.
7. Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox emphases within the hope
All three streams hold the hope. Their emphases differ, and we describe each as it would describe itself.
Catholic teaching stresses the unity of body and soul, the continuing life of the soul with God after death, the final raising of the body, and the , the bond of the living and the dead in Christ. It prays for the dead and speaks of a purification for some after death. The hope of the resurrection is bound closely to the Eucharist and the sacraments of the church.
Orthodox teaching stresses Christ’s victory over death, "trampling down death by death", as the Paschal hymn sings. The resurrection of Christ is the centre of the church’s year, and the hope of the general resurrection belongs to the life of worship. The Orthodox speak of the dead as still in communion with the living, and pray for them. The language of , sharing in the life of God, shapes how the final state is described.
Protestant teaching stresses that the hope rests on Christ’s resurrection and on the promise of Scripture, and that it is received by faith. Protestant traditions differ in what they say of the time between death and resurrection and of the nature of the final state. Reformed and Lutheran confessions hold to the bodily resurrection; Evangelical and Pentecostal churches often stress the hope of the Lord’s coming and the raising of believers at that time, and the Spirit as the first instalment (a thought we meet in Romans 8:23 in the next lecture).
These descriptions are brief. The point is that on the centre, which is God’s raising of the whole person in Christ, the streams stand together, and that what differs is the account of the time between, the role of the church’s prayers and the details of the end.
8. A short case (an invented example)
A small study group meets after a talk on living forever. A member, Ruth in this example, says: "If my mind could be kept, I would still be me. What is the difference?" Another member, Daniel, answers: "I do not think that would be me. I think it would be a very good copy."
The leader does not say who is right. She asks them each to say what they would hope for, if they could name it. Ruth says she is afraid of ceasing to be. Daniel says he hopes that God will not let him go. A third member, who has been quiet, says: "I would rather be raised than saved." No one asks her to explain. They sit for a moment.
In this scene, each person is saying something true about their hope. The leader’s skill is to let the question of what a person is stay open, while making clear what the creed says. Notice that no one was asked to give up their fear of death, and no one was told that their question was foolish.
Diagram 1. Two stories of continuing life
핵심 요약
- 1 Corinthians 15 hopes for the raising of the body, through Christ the first fruits, with death as the last enemy abolished.
- The creeds say the church looks for the resurrection of the dead; Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant churches share this centre.
- The immortality of the soul and the resurrection of the dead are different ideas, though many Christians hold some form of both.
- What makes a person the same person over time is disputed, and each answer has a difficulty.
- The upload story assumes that the person is a pattern, that a copy would be the person, that the body is a carrier, and that death is a lack of means.
- Resurrection is a gift and a promise, not a technology; the Christian hope is of life renewed, not only of more life.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Resurrection of the body | God raising the whole person in Christ, changed; not the escape of a soul from the body. |
| Immortality of the soul versus resurrection | The first holds that a part survives death; the second that the whole person dies and is raised. |
| Personal identity | The question of what makes a person the same person over time; answers include body, soul, memory and character, and God holding the person. |
| What the upload story assumes | That the person is a pattern, a copy would be the person, the body is a carrier, and death is a lack of means. |
One sentence to remember Resurrection is not a technology: it is God's gift of a raised and healed person, promised in Christ.
This week's action Write the sentence from the creed about resurrection in your own language, and say in one line how it differs from "my mind kept in a machine".
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In 1 Corinthians 15, what is sown and what is raised? Why does it matter that it is the body?
- How is the immortality of the soul different from the resurrection of the dead? Where do Christians sometimes combine them?
- State two of the answers to the question "what makes someone the same person?" and give a weak point of each.
- Pick one assumption of the upload story and say why it is an assumption and not a fact.
- In what sense is resurrection "not a technology"? Does that claim depend on knowing what technology can do?
- In the study-group case, what is true in what Ruth says, and what is true in what Daniel says?