무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism

Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument

목차 31
STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism
제 0 장 · Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Reading the Image
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
  4. Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
제 2 장 · Week 2: Mind, Consciousness and Soul
  1. Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
  3. Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
  4. Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
제 3 장 · Week 3: Intelligence, Person, Moral Status
  1. Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
  3. Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
  4. Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
제 4 장 · Week 4: Relationship, Care, Friendship, Grief
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
  2. Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
  3. Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
제 5 장 · Week 5: Work, Calling and Human Worth
  1. Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
  2. Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
  3. Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
  4. Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
제 6 장 · Week 6: Enhancement, Immortality, Resurrection
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Old Dream, in New Words
  2. Lecture 6-2: Finitude and the Body: Is a Limit a Curse?
  3. Lecture 6-3: Resurrection and the Upload Story
  4. Lecture 6-4: Living as Creatures in Hope
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on the Human Person

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

26분

Week 1 asked how Christians have read the image of God. Week 2 asks about the inside of a person: the mind, the awareness, the soul, the freedom to choose. Before we can ask what a talking machine does or does not share with us, we need to ask what we think a human being is made of. That question is very old. People argued about it long before anyone built a computer, and they still do.

This lecture sets out three pictures of how mind and body relate, gives the strength and the weak point of each, and then asks how the Bible pictures a person and how Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers have taken that picture up. The lecture does not decide the argument. It gives you the pieces, so that when someone says "a machine could never think because it has no soul" or "the mind is only the brain", you can see what is being assumed.

The central claim of the course stands behind this lecture. What AI asks is not what a machine is but what a person is. This week we ask it about the mind. The principle of the week: the oldest questions about the mind are still open, and honesty about what we do not know is part of faith's wisdom.

이 26분으로 얻는 것

  • Describe dualism, physicalism and the embodied-mind view in a sentence each.
  • State one strength and one weak point of each of the three views.
  • Explain how the Bible speaks of a person as a living whole, and name what the words *nephesh* and *psyche* are used for.
  • Say in broad terms how Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers have joined body and soul, and why this matters for the hope of resurrection.
  • Separate what the text says, a tradition's reading, and our judgement when a verse is used in this argument.

Yahweh God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul." — Genesis 2:7

World English Bible

Don’t be afraid of those who kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul. Rather, fear him who is able to destroy both soul and body in Gehenna." — Matthew 10:28

WEB

It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body. There is a natural body and there is also a spiritual body." — 1 Corinthians 15:44

WEB

The first verse tells how the first human being became alive: dust and breath together. The second is often used to show that the soul is more than the body. The third speaks of the body that is raised. Each verse is used on more than one side of the argument, and we will see how.

1. Why start with an old argument

It is tempting to think that the question of mind and body was born with computers. It was not. Greek philosophers asked what it is that makes a body alive and able to think. Christian writers of the early centuries asked how the soul and the body were joined, and what happens to a person at death. Medieval teachers wrote long books on the soul. In the seventeenth century Descartes gave the question a new form that still shapes our talk today.

Starting here protects us from two mistakes. The first is to think that machines have made the old question easy ("now we can see that the mind is just a program"). The second is to think that machines have made it pointless ("a machine could never have a mind, so there is nothing to ask"). Both are ways of closing a question that is still open. We will keep it open and ask what each view says.

2. Three pictures

Picture one: dualism. Dualism means "two-ness". It holds that a human being has two different kinds of thing in it: a body, which is matter and takes up space, and a mind or soul, which is not matter. The best-known form comes from René Descartes in the seventeenth century (his Meditations appeared in 1641). He argued that the mind is a thinking thing, distinct from the body, which is an extended thing. Many people, Christians and others, hold some form of this view without having read Descartes. It feels natural. We seem to be someone who has a body, and not only a body.

Its strength. It matches the way we experience ourselves: my thoughts do not seem to be made of anything I could weigh. It also fits a common reading of the hope that a person goes on after the body dies.

Its weak point. It struggles to say how a thing that is not matter acts upon matter, and how matter acts upon it. When I decide to raise my hand, how does a non-material mind move a material arm? Descartes was pressed on this by a correspondent, Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia, in the 1640s, and he did not give an answer that satisfied her. Later writers have kept the problem. A second weak point is that the closer science links the mind to the brain, the harder it is to say what the separate mind does.

Picture two: physicalism. Physicalism holds that a human being is entirely physical. The mind is what a living brain, in a living body, does. There is no second thing. The twentieth-century philosopher Gilbert Ryle (in The Concept of Mind, 1949) mocked the dualist picture with the label the ghost in the machine. In summary, he argued that we talk as if there were a hidden inner thing behind what a person does, when "mind" is really a way of speaking about what people do and are able to do.

Its strength. It is simple. It fits the evidence that harm to the brain changes the mind, and that a person can be changed by injury, drug or illness. It leaves no puzzle about how mind moves body.

Its weak point. It struggles to say why there should be felt experience at all, why it should feel like something to be a person. We come to that puzzle in lecture 2-2. Many Christians also worry that if a person is only a physical thing, the hope of life beyond death has no support. Others reply that this worry is exactly why Christians speak of resurrection and not only of survival, and we come to that below.

Picture three: the embodied mind. This is not one theory but a family of views. It holds that a person is a living unity of body and mind, and that the mind cannot be pulled apart from the body, the history, the relationships and the world in which the person lives. Some forms of it are close to physicalism; some are close to an old teaching that the soul is the form of the body, a view that goes back to Aristotle and was taken up by Thomas Aquinas in the thirteenth century. On this teaching the soul is not a ghost inside a body but what makes this body a living human body. We use form here as those writers did: not shape, but the organising principle that makes a thing what it is.

Its strength. It takes both sides seriously. It respects the fact that mind is tied to the body, and it still speaks of something more than a collection of parts. It fits how we talk about people: we say that I am hungry, not that my body is hungry.

Its weak point. It can be hard to say exactly what it adds to physicalism, and a critic may say it is vague. It also has to say what happens to the person between death and resurrection, which we meet in lecture 2-3.

3. What the Bible pictures

The Bible does not offer a theory of mind and body. It does not use our modern word "mind" the way we do. But its way of speaking about a person has a clear character, and it is worth seeing before we ask how traditions have used it. We keep to what the text says.

Genesis 2:7 says that God formed the human being from the dust and breathed breath of life into him, "and man became a living soul". The Hebrew word that the World English Bible translates as "soul" is nephesh. In the Old Testament it is used for a living being, for a life, for a person, and sometimes for appetite or desire. It is also used of animals. So Genesis 2:7 does not say that a person has a soul added to a body. It says that the person became a living being, a whole made of dust and breath.

The New Testament word that is often translated "soul" is psyche. Like nephesh, it often means "life" or "the self". Jesus asks what a person gains by winning the world and losing his psyche, and in many translations this is "life" in one place and "soul" in another. The New Testament also speaks of "spirit" (pneuma) and "heart" (kardia) and "flesh" and "body". These words do not form a tidy list of parts. They look at the whole person from different sides.

Two things stand out. First, the Bible's most common picture is of a person who is a living unity: you are not a soul locked in a body, nor a body with a soul as passenger. Second, the Bible's great hope for the dead is not that a soul escapes the body but that the body is raised. When Paul writes about the resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15, he speaks of a body: "it is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body". Many readers take "spiritual body" to mean a body ruled by God's Spirit and fit for the new creation, not a body made of some ghostly stuff. Others read the phrase differently. All agree that Paul is speaking of a body, and not of the bodiless survival of a soul.

Matthew 10:28 is a different kind of verse. Jesus tells his hearers not to fear those who can kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Many readers take this to show that something of a person is beyond the reach of human killers, and that it can be distinguished from the body. Others point out that in the same verse God can destroy "both soul and body", and read the verse as being about where fear belongs and where trust belongs, and not as a lesson about the make-up of a person. The verse is used by those who hold a dualist view and by those who hold a more unified one.

4. Three layers

When a verse is used in this argument, we keep apart three things, as in the course Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (STEL5E).

  • What the text says. Genesis 2:7 says the human being became a living being through dust and breath. 1 Corinthians 15:44 speaks of a body that is sown and a body that is raised. Matthew 10:28 speaks of the body and the soul.
  • A tradition's reading. The church has read these verses in several ways, as we see next.
  • Our judgement. Whether the best account of a person is dualist, physicalist or embodied is not settled by these verses alone. The verses limit what we can say, but they do not hand us a theory. A theory is our judgement, and we hold it with humility.

5. How the traditions have joined body and soul

Here we say only what we can say in broad strokes, as each tradition would speak of itself. Any one tradition contains more variety than a paragraph can show.

Catholic teaching holds that the human being is one being of body and soul. The soul is not a second thing that happens to live in the body; the teaching, following Aquinas, is that the soul is the form of the body, so that the body and soul together make one nature. At the same time the church teaches that the soul is spiritual, that God creates each soul, and that it does not perish when the body dies. So Catholic teaching joins a strong unity of the person with a belief that the soul continues after death, awaiting the raising of the body at the end. It resists any view that treats the body as a prison or as unimportant.

Orthodox writers also stress that the human being is one whole of body and soul, made in the and called to share in God's life. They speak of death as an enemy and a separation, not as a natural release of the soul from a burden. The hope is the raising of the whole person. Orthodox writers differ in how far they use philosophical categories, and many prefer to speak in terms of the person in communion with God rather than in terms of parts.

Protestant streams differ more among themselves. Reformed confessions of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries speak of the soul that goes to God at death and the body that waits for the resurrection, and many Lutherans and other Protestants continue to hold this in some form. Some Protestant Christians, among them the Seventh-day Adventists, hold that the person is whole and that there is no conscious life between death and resurrection. Some contemporary Christian philosophers and scientists defend a form of physicalism, arguing that a person is wholly physical and that the hope is resurrection and not an immortal soul; others defend a form of dualism and argue that a person is a soul that has a body. Evangelical and Pentecostal communities often hold that the soul goes to be with Christ at death, and many do not make the make-up of a person a matter of dispute.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that a person is a body and an immaterial soul, and that this is the plainest way to take the Scripture and the church's long teaching, and the surest ground for the hope of life after death. They would add that giving up the soul puts the continuity of the person between death and resurrection at risk. Others hold that the person is a unity, that the Bible's own picture and its hope of bodily resurrection point this way, and that the separable soul owes more to Greek philosophy than to Moses and Paul. They would add that the old picture sits uneasily with all that we learn of how mind depends on body. Each side can say honestly what the other cannot easily answer: the first, what the unity view says about the dead before the resurrection; the second, how a separate soul acts on a body. What this course requires is less than either side requires: that you hold the question without contempt for the other view, that you do not rest a person's worth on the answer, and that you remember that every tradition above looks forward to the raising of the body.

6. What this means when a machine answers us

Notice what the three pictures do when they meet a talking machine, and notice that they do so as conditionals. We make no claim about what any machine can now do.

  • If dualism is true, the question is whether a machine could ever have a mind that is not matter, and many dualists would say no, since a machine is only matter. A dualist who is careful would add that we do not know whether God might join a soul to some other kind of body, and would say that we cannot settle that by looking at the machine.
  • If physicalism is true, then in principle a mind might arise from other matter than a brain. Whether it could is a further question; physicalism does not say that every machine has a mind, only that the mind is not ruled out by the stuff it is made of.
  • If the embodied view is true, then a mind belongs with a living body and a life of need, growth, risk and relationship, and a machine that lacks these would lack something that matters. A careful holder of this view would still ask what it is about a living body that does the work, and would not assume the answer.

Each of the three can be used by someone who is sure that machines are no threat to human uniqueness, and each by someone who is not sure. That is worth remembering. A view on mind and body does not tell you whether a machine has a mind. It only tells you what you would be looking for.

7. Worth does not wait on the answer

One last point, because it holds the whole course together. Whichever picture a Christian holds, the conviction of Week 1 stays where it was. A person's worth rests on what God has given, and not on a theory of how mind and body fit. A child who cannot yet reason, an old person whose memory has gone, a person whose body is badly damaged: no picture of mind and body takes away their dignity, and a Christian who used one of these pictures to say that such a person counts for less would have misused it. The argument of this week is an honest search for understanding. It is never a test that a human being must pass.


Diagram 1. Three pictures of mind and body

Three pictures of the person Each fits something and strains at something Dualism body + non-material soul Fits How we feel: I am more than what could be weighed Strains at How a non-material mind moves a material arm Its best-known form: Descartes, 1641 Physicalism only matter; mind is what it does Fits Injury to the brain changes the mind; no gap to bridge Strains at Why anything should be felt from the inside at all Ryle, the ghost in the machine (label), 1949 Embodied mind a living unity of body and mind Fits The Bible's whole person; the hope of a raised body Strains at Saying exactly what it adds; the time between death and raising Soul as the form of the body: Aristotle, Aquinas None of the three decides whether a machine could have a mind. Each only tells you what you would be looking for. Worth does not wait on the answer.

핵심 요약

  • Dualism says a person is body and non-material soul; physicalism says only matter; the embodied view says a living unity. Each has a strength and a weak point.
  • The Bible mostly pictures a person as a living whole: nephesh and psyche often mean life or self, not a separate part.
  • The Bible's great hope for the dead is the raising of the body, not the escape of the soul.
  • Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers all join body and soul and look to the resurrection, but they differ in how.
  • Readers do not agree on the make-up of a person; this course asks only that we hold the question fairly.
  • No picture of mind and body takes away a person's worth, and none tells us whether a machine has a mind.
Front Back
Dualism A person is a body plus a non-material mind or soul. Strain: how the two act on each other.
Physicalism A person is entirely physical; mind is what a living brain does. Strain: why anything is felt from the inside.
Embodied mind A person is a living unity of body and mind; the soul as the form of the body. Strain: what it adds, and the time between death and raising.
Nephesh and psyche Words often meaning life, living being or self; they do not name a part cut off from the body.

One sentence to remember A view of mind and body tells you what you would be looking for in a machine; it does not tell you whether you will find it.

This week's action Write down how you would answer a child who asks "Where is my mind?", then note which of the three pictures your answer used.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Which of the three pictures (dualism, physicalism, the embodied mind) is closest to how you spoke about yourself before this lecture? What in it do you now want to test?
  • Genesis 2:7 says the human being "became a living soul". How does this differ from saying that a human being "has" a soul? Does it change anything for you?
  • Matthew 10:28 is used by people on different sides of the argument. Why can one verse serve more than one view?
  • Each tradition in the lecture looks forward to the raising of the body. Why might that be a common ground for people who disagree about the make-up of a person?
  • Why does the lecture say that a person's worth does not wait on the answer to the mind-body question? Who might be hurt if it did?
  • If a friend said "a machine can never think, because it has no soul", what would you ask before replying?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.