Lecture 4-1: Genesis 1 and 2: Two Accounts, One Creator
Contents 37
- Lecture 1-1: What Torah and Pentateuch Mean, and Why the Difference Matters
- Lecture 1-2: The Shape of the Five Books: Narrative, Law, and the Seams Between Them
- Lecture 1-3: A History of Reading: Jewish, Patristic, Reformation, and Modern
- Lecture 2-1: Mosaic Authorship, Tradition, and the Rise of Source Criticism
- Lecture 2-2: The Documentary Hypothesis in Its Classic Form
- Lecture 2-3: After Wellhausen: Fragment, Supplement, and the Present Debate
- Lecture 3-1: Creation and Flood Accounts: Enuma Elish, Atrahasis, Gilgamesh
- Lecture 3-2: Law Collections: Hammurabi, Eshnunna, and the Covenant Code
- Lecture 3-3: Treaty and Covenant Forms: Hittite Vassal Treaties and Deuteronomy
- Lecture 4-1: Genesis 1 and 2: Two Accounts, One Creator
- Lecture 4-2: Genesis 3-5: Disobedience, Cain, and the Line of Seth
- Lecture 4-3: Genesis 6-11: Flood, the Noahic Covenant, and Babel
- Lecture 5-1: The Call of Abram and the Shape of the Promise
- Lecture 5-2: Covenant, Circumcision, and the Binding of Isaac
- Lecture 5-3: Jacob: Deception, Wrestling, and the Making of Israel
- Lecture 6-1: The Joseph Narrative as Literature
- Lecture 6-2: Providence, Human Evil, and Genesis 50:20
- Lecture 6-3: Jacob's Blessing, Judah, and the Bridge into Exodus
- Lecture 7-1: Oppression, the Midwives, and the Call of Moses
- Lecture 7-2: The Plagues and the Hardening of Pharaoh's Heart
- Lecture 7-3: Passover, the Sea, and Provision in the Wilderness
- Lecture 8-1: Sinai and the Decalogue
- Lecture 8-2: The Covenant Code and the Ratification of the Covenant
- Lecture 8-3: The Golden Calf, Intercession, and the Tabernacle
- Lecture 9-1: The Sacrificial System of Leviticus 1-7
- Lecture 9-2: Priesthood, Purity, and the Day of Atonement
- Lecture 9-3: The Holiness Code and What It Asks of a People
- Lecture 10-1: Census, Camp, and the Order of the Wilderness March
- Lecture 10-2: Rebellion, the Spies, and the Judgment on a Generation
- Lecture 10-3: Balaam, the Second Generation, and the Plains of Moab
- Lecture 11-1: Deuteronomy as Covenant Document and as Sermon
- Lecture 11-2: The Deuteronomic Code and the Question of Centralization
- Lecture 11-3: Blessing, Curse, and the Death of Moses
A student who reads Genesis 1 and Genesis 2 slowly, one after the other, in almost any translation, notices something before anyone points it out. The two chapters do not sound alike. The first is measured and repetitive, built from formulas that return in a fixed order. The second is quick, concrete, and physical: a man shaped from soil, a garden planted, animals brought to be named, a woman built from a rib. The first calls God by a title, elohim, "God." The second calls him by a name and a title together, YHWH elohim, rendered in the World English Bible as "Yahweh God." And the two do not put events in the same sequence. Genesis 1 has vegetation on the third day, animals on the fifth and sixth, and human beings — male and female together — last. Genesis 2 has the man first, before there is any plant of the field, then the garden, then the animals, then the woman.
This lecture argues that the honest place to begin is with those differences stated plainly, before any explanation is offered. A student who first meets them from a hostile source will reasonably conclude that they were being kept from her; a student who meets them from a defensive source, already wrapped in a solution, will not be able to judge whether the solution is needed. So the lecture describes first and explains second.
It then sets out the two principal explanations in their strongest forms. The first is compositional: two accounts of different origin, from different circles, were placed side by side by an editor who did not think the differences fatal. The second is literary: one writer designed a two-part opening in which a cosmic overview is followed by a close-up, a common enough narrative technique in the ancient world and outside it. These explanations are not simply opposites, and the lecture will say where they overlap. After that it takes up the internal architecture of Genesis 1, the position of the seventh day, the phrase "in our image, after our likeness," and finally the four principal ways the six days have been read — naming them, and declining to argue for one, since the relationship between Genesis and modern natural science is not this course's subject.
What these 40 minutes give you
- State accurately, without exaggeration in either direction, the differences of divine name, style, vocabulary, geographical horizon, and order between Genesis 1:1-2:3 and Genesis 2:4-25.
- Present both the compositional and the unified-design explanations of those differences in their strongest form, and identify what each explains well and what each strains to explain.
- Describe the internal structure of Genesis 1 — the correspondence of days one to three with days four to six, and the placement of the seventh day outside the pattern — and say why that structure is more secure than most proposed structures in Genesis.
- Set out the main interpretations of `imago Dei` (a capacity, a function, a relation) and explain the ancient Near Eastern royal background invoked in support of the functional reading, together with the objections to it.
- Name the four principal readings of the six days — twenty-four-hour days, day-ages, literary framework, functional inauguration — and state the strongest consideration in favour of each.
God said, “Let us make man in our image, after our likeness: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the sky, and over the livestock, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth.” God created man in his own image. In God’s image he created him; male and female he created them. God blessed them. God said to them, “Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it. Have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the sky, and over every living thing that moves on the earth.” — Genesis 1:26-28
World English Bible
This is the history of the generations of the heavens and of the earth when they were created, in the day that Yahweh God made the earth and the heavens. — Genesis 2:4
WEB
Yahweh God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul. — Genesis 2:7
WEB
The heavens, the earth, and all their vast array were finished. On the seventh day God finished his work which he had done; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had done. God blessed the seventh day, and made it holy, because he rested in it from all his work of creation which he had done. — Genesis 2:1-3
WEB
These four passages mark the lecture's four main stops. Genesis 1:26-28 is the single densest verse-cluster in the chapter and the seat of the imago Dei question. Genesis 2:4 is the hinge: it contains the first toledot heading of the book and it is also the verse in which the two divine designations meet, "Yahweh God" appearing here for the first time. Genesis 2:7 shows the difference of texture at its sharpest — dust, nostrils, breath, where Genesis 1 had only speech and a verdict. And Genesis 2:1-3, the seventh day, is placed here fourth rather than in sequence because the lecture will argue that it is best read as the destination of the first account rather than as its appendix.
1. What is actually different
Start with description. The following differences between Genesis 1:1-2:3 and Genesis 2:4-25 are not in dispute among careful readers of any position; what is disputed is what they mean.
The divine designation. Genesis 1:1-2:3 uses elohim alone, thirty-five times, and never uses the divine name. From 2:4 the text uses YHWH elohim, "Yahweh God," and does so consistently through the end of chapter 3. That compound is itself unusual — it is rare in the Hebrew Bible outside these chapters — and it functions, at minimum, as a bridge joining the God of the first account to the God who now walks in a garden.
Style and rhythm. The first account is formulaic in the strict sense: "God said... and it was so... God saw that it was good... there was evening and there was morning." The formulas recur in a fixed order and the reader can predict them. The second account has no formulas of that kind. It narrates in ordinary Hebrew prose, with dialogue, motivation, and physical detail.
Vocabulary for the act of making. The first account uses bara, a verb used in the Hebrew Bible only with God as subject, alongside asah, "to make." The second uses yatsar, "to form" — the verb used of a potter working clay — and banah, "to build," of the woman in 2:22.
Geographical horizon. Genesis 1 has no geography at all: sky, sea, land, lights, living things, nothing named. Genesis 2 names four rivers, two of which (Tigris and Euphrates) are identifiable, and a region called Eden with a garden planted "eastward."
Order. This is the difference that carries the most argumentative weight, so it should be stated precisely. In Genesis 1 the order is vegetation (day three), sea creatures and birds (day five), land animals and then humanity, male and female (day six). In Genesis 2 the man is formed at a point when, according to 2:5, "no plant of the field was yet in the earth, and no herb of the field had yet sprung up"; the garden is planted afterward; the animals are formed and brought to the man to be named after that; and the woman is made last of all.
What the two accounts are about. Genesis 1 is about the whole: heavens, earth, seas, luminaries, every category of living thing, with humanity as the final item in a series. Genesis 2 is about a garden, a man, a command, and a companion. The cosmos is not its subject.
None of these observations is modern. The rabbinic tradition noticed the change of divine name and treated it as significant; the medieval Jewish commentator Rashi discussed the difference between elohim and the name at Genesis 1:1 in terms of the attributes of justice and mercy. What is modern is the use of these observations as evidence for a theory of the text's composition.
2. The compositional reading, in its strongest form
State this case at full strength before criticising anything. As lecture 2-2 of this course described, the classic — the theory that the was assembled from four written sources — assigned Genesis 1:1-2:3 to the Priestly source and Genesis 2:4-25 to the Yahwistic source. The strength of that assignment does not rest on the divine name alone, which by itself would be weak evidence. It rests on the fact that a whole cluster of features moves together.
The chapter that uses elohim also uses bara, also employs fixed formulas, also shows an interest in ordering, separating, and blessing days, also ends by sanctifying a day of rest, and also uses precise category language ("after their kind," repeated ten times). The chapter that uses "Yahweh God" also uses yatsar, also has no formulas, also has concrete geography, also is anthropocentric in structure, and also is comfortable describing God in strongly human terms — forming, breathing, planting, walking. Those clusters are what a source theory predicts. If the two blocks differed only in the divine name, or only in style, the case would be thin. They differ in a coordinated way, and coordination is the argument.
The compositional reading also has a good answer to the question a modern reader asks next: why would an editor leave two accounts that do not agree in order? The answer is that ancient compilers of authoritative traditions frequently preserved what they received rather than smoothing it, and that harmonisation is a value of later readers more than of ancient tradents. On this reading, the differences are not a problem the text failed to solve. They are a sign that the material was treated as too valuable to reshape.
3. The unified-design reading, in its strongest form
The alternative case is not simply a denial of the first. It accepts that the two blocks are different in the ways described and argues that the difference is a compositional technique rather than a seam.
The technique in question has a name in the study of ancient Semitic narrative: a general account followed by a particular account of one element within it. The narrative first covers wide ground quickly, then returns to a single item and treats it at length. Umberto Cassuto argued along these lines in the mid-twentieth century, and the argument has been developed since by writers including Kenneth Mathews and Bruce Waltke. The pattern is not confined to Genesis 1-2: Genesis 10 gives the nations broadly and Genesis 11 returns to one episode within that spread, and Genesis 37 opens the Joseph material broadly before individual episodes are narrated in detail.
On this reading, the change of divine designation is deliberate rather than inherited. Elohim is the appropriate word when God is being presented as the maker of everything that exists; the divine name is appropriate when the same God enters into relationship with a particular creature and gives a particular command. The compound "Yahweh God" at 2:4 is then not an editorial stitch but the writer's own way of insisting that these are not two deities.
On the ordering difference, the unified reading argues that Genesis 2 is not offering a sequence at all. Its interest is thematic: the man is placed at the centre because the section is about the man. The remark in 2:5 that no plant of the field had yet sprung up is, on this reading, a description of the specific condition of a specific place — cultivated land without rain and without a farmer — rather than a claim about the state of the whole earth. The animals in 2:19 are then formed not after the man in absolute time but brought to him in the narrative's own order of concern.
What each reading strains to explain. The compositional reading has to account for the fact that the two blocks, however different, are joined so as to be read consecutively and were transmitted that way from the earliest evidence we have; it explains the difference well and the unity by appeal to a redactor whose intentions are inferred from the result. The unified reading has to account for the coordination of features described above, and it tends to explain each feature individually — the name here, the verb there — which is exactly what the coordination makes difficult. Neither difficulty is fatal. Both are real, and a student should be able to state both.
Three scholars, three views
This is a point where readers will not agree. Claus Westermann held that the two accounts have distinct prehistories and distinct concerns and that reading them as one composition flattens both. Umberto Cassuto held that the differences are entirely accounted for by the writer's subject matter and rhetorical purpose. Bruce Waltke occupies a middle position that is worth noting because it is often overlooked: he accepts that the material may have distinct origins and argues that the final form is nevertheless a deliberate literary unity whose meaning is found in that form. That middle position is not a compromise for its own sake — it separates two questions, the origin of the material and the design of the received text, which the two headline positions tend to answer together.
4. The architecture of Genesis 1
Genesis 1:2 states the problem the chapter then solves: the earth was "formless and empty." Those two words are the chapter's agenda, and days one to three address the first while days four to six address the second.
Days one to three separate and establish domains. Day one divides light from darkness. Day two divides the waters, making an expanse between them. Day three gathers the lower waters so that dry land appears, and clothes that land with vegetation. Days four to six fill those domains in the same order. Day four fills the light and darkness with the luminaries that govern them. Day five fills the sky and the sea with birds and sea creatures. Day six fills the land with animals and with humanity, and the vegetation of day three is designated as their food (1:29-30).
This correspondence is unusually secure as structural claims in Genesis go, for a reason worth stating: it is not imposed from outside but announced by the text at 1:2 and then executed in order. The reader is told what the two problems are before either is addressed. That is a different situation from a structure a modern interpreter proposes on the basis of resemblances the text never names — the flood discussed in lecture 4-3 is a case of the latter kind. Even here, though, the fit is not perfect: day three does two things rather than one, and the vegetation it produces is arguably a filling rather than a forming. A structure with a loose element is still a structure; it is not a theorem.
The seventh day stands outside the pattern entirely. It has no evening and morning formula, no act of making, and no "it was good." What it has is three verbs applied to the day itself: God finished, God blessed, God made holy. Nothing else in Genesis 1 is called holy — not the luminaries, not the human beings, not the land. The first thing sanctified in the Pentateuch is a period of time. Jon Levenson and others have argued that this placement makes the seventh day the goal of the account rather than its epilogue, and the argument is strong on the text's own terms: the creation account does not conclude at 1:31 with a completed world but at 2:3 with a hallowed day.
5. The image of God
Genesis 1:26-28 says that God resolved to make humanity "in our image, after our likeness," that he did so, and that the making is immediately followed by a blessing and a mandate: be fruitful, multiply, fill, subdue, have dominion. The Hebrew terms are tselem, "image," a word used elsewhere of a statue or physical representation, and demut, "likeness," a somewhat more abstract term of resemblance. The text does not define either. What it supplies is a context — the sentence moves directly from the image to dominion — and that adjacency is where most of the interpretation begins.
Three main lines have been taken.
The image as a capacity. The oldest and long the dominant Christian reading locates the image in something human beings possess that other creatures do not: reason, will, self-awareness, moral capacity, or the soul. Augustine developed a version of this in the De Trinitate, finding in the mind's memory, understanding, and love a created reflection of the triune life. Thomas Aquinas, following Aristotle's psychology, located the image chiefly in the intellectual nature. The reading has obvious strengths — it explains why the image is spoken of as something humans are rather than something they do — and one persistent weakness, which is that Genesis 1 never mentions reason, soul, or will. The capacity has to be supplied from outside the passage.
The image as a function. On this reading, to be made in God's image is to be commissioned to represent God's rule within the created world; the image is a role, not a component. The main external support is a documented ancient Near Eastern practice: an Egyptian or Mesopotamian king could be described as the image of a god, and a monarch could erect a statue — an image — of himself in a territory he governed as a standing assertion of his authority there. On that analogy, Genesis 1 takes language reserved for kings and applies it to humanity as such, male and female, which is a striking democratisation of royal ideology if the analogy holds. J. Richard Middleton's The Liberating Image is the fullest recent development of this case; Gerhard von Rad advanced an earlier version.
The functional reading also draws objections that should be stated. The parallel with royal statues is an inference from context rather than a statement of the text; Genesis 1 says humanity is made in God's image and given dominion, and it is a further step to say that the image is the dominion rather than its ground. Grammatically the clause "and let them have dominion" can be read as consequence rather than definition. And critics have noted that if the image is a commission, it becomes harder to say what is violated when a human being is killed — though Genesis 9:6, which grounds the prohibition of bloodshed in the image, is compatible with either reading.
The image as a relation. Karl Barth argued that the decisive clue is in the verse itself: "male and female he created them" stands in apposition to the statement about the image, so the image is found in the human being as a being-in-relation, corresponding to a differentiation within God's own life. This reading takes seriously a phrase the other two tend to treat as an addendum. Its difficulty is the reverse: Genesis 1:27 also says "in God's image he created him," singular, and the relational reading has to carry a great deal of weight on a single juxtaposition.
Claus Westermann, characteristically, argued that the search for the content of the image is misdirected, because the text's interest is in the act — God's making of a creature capable of being addressed by him — rather than in a property to be identified. Henri Blocher offered a reading that holds capacity and function together, arguing that the mandate presupposes capacities and the capacities are given for the mandate, and that the text's refusal to separate them is the point. That synthesis is attractive, and attractiveness is exactly what the build principle of this course warns about: a reading that resolves a long dispute neatly deserves a second look, not a first acceptance. The honest summary is that Genesis 1 asserts the image, connects it to dominion, and does not define it, and every account of its content is an interpretation that goes beyond the wording.
6. The six days: naming the positions
Two things must be said before the positions themselves.
First, the relation between Genesis and modern natural science is not the subject of this course. This is a course on the Pentateuch, and questions about the age of the earth, the mechanisms of biological development, and the epistemology of the natural sciences are addressed properly in a course on science and theology, with the relevant scientific literature in front of the class. Passing over them here is a decision about scope, not a verdict.
Second, a student nonetheless needs the vocabulary, because these positions appear in commentaries and in congregations, and a reader who cannot name them cannot follow the discussion. So here they are, with the strongest consideration for each and nothing more.
Twenty-four-hour days. The Hebrew word yom with a numeral and with the "evening and morning" formula ordinarily denotes an ordinary day elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible; and Exodus 20:11 grounds the seven-day week in this account, which suggests the days are of the same kind as the week's days. Strongest consideration: the plain sense of the words in their usual usage.
Day-ages. Yom does bear extended senses in Hebrew, including at Genesis 2:4 within these very chapters ("in the day that Yahweh God made"); and the seventh day is not closed by an evening-and-morning formula, which may suggest the days are not being counted as ordinary units. Strongest consideration: internal evidence within Genesis itself that yom is not being used uniformly.
Literary framework. The days are a topical arrangement rather than a chronological one, organised by the forming-and-filling correspondence described above; the sun is made on day four although light and the day-night cycle exist from day one, which is difficult on a strictly sequential reading and natural on a topical one. Henri Blocher's In the Beginning is the clearest short statement. Strongest consideration: the structure the chapter itself displays.
Functional inauguration. John Walton has argued that ancient Near Eastern accounts of origins, Genesis included, are concerned with the assignment of function and role rather than with the production of material, and that the seven days describe something closer to the inauguration of a cosmic temple than the manufacture of matter. Lecture 3-1 of this course set out this proposal and the objections it has drawn, which include the charge that the material-versus-functional distinction is a modern dichotomy imposed on texts that did not draw it, and that bara in the Hebrew Bible resists so clean a functional restriction. Strongest consideration: it takes the comparative material seriously rather than treating Genesis as an isolate.
These four are not exhaustive and they are not always held in pure form. What matters for this course is that a student can identify which one an author is working with, because a commentator's reading of the days quietly shapes a great deal else in the chapter.
7. One creator
Whatever a reader concludes about composition, both accounts make the same fundamental claim, and it is a claim that lecture 3-1 showed to be far from universal in the ancient world: the world was made by one God who was not himself made, out of no conflict, from no divine corpse, and human beings exist not to relieve the gods of labour but as bearers of the image and recipients of a blessing. Genesis 1 makes that claim in the register of order and category. Genesis 2 makes it in the register of dust, breath, and a garden. The two registers are genuinely different, and the second account's God, who forms with his hands and breathes into nostrils, is not a lesser or more primitive conception than the first — it is a different mode of speech about the same claim. That the received text places them together, in this order, without an explanatory note, is the most important fact about them, and it is a fact both of the readings surveyed here have to work with.
The diagram sets the two triads of days side by side so that the correspondence announced at 1:2 can be checked rather than merely asserted. Two honest qualifications are marked on it. Day three does two things and therefore does not sit as cleanly in the "forming" column as the other two; and day two, alone among the six, lacks the "it was good" verdict, a small irregularity that the neat presentation of this structure often silently repairs. The seventh day is shown detached because that is its position in the text, not because a designer found it convenient.
6. Further Reading
- Claus Westermann, Genesis 1-11: A Continental Commentary, trans. John J. Scullion (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1994). The fullest treatment of the two accounts as distinct traditions, and of the history of the
imago Deidiscussion. - Umberto Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Genesis, Part I: From Adam to Noah, trans. Israel Abrahams (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1961). The classic case that the differences between the chapters are functions of subject and rhetoric rather than of sources.
- Bruce K. Waltke with Cathi J. Fredricks, Genesis: A Commentary (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2001). Useful precisely for separating the question of the material's origin from the question of the received text's design.
- Henri Blocher, In the Beginning: The Opening Chapters of Genesis, trans. David G. Preston (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 1984). The clearest short presentation of the literary framework reading, and of a combined account of the divine image.
- J. Richard Middleton, The Liberating Image: The in Genesis 1 (Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2005). The royal-functional reading argued at length, with a survey of the history of interpretation.
- John H. Walton, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate (Downers Grove: IVP Academic, 2009). The functional-inauguration proposal in its accessible form; read alongside the critical responses noted in lecture 3-1.
- Jon D. Levenson, Creation and the Persistence of Evil: The Jewish Drama of Divine (San Francisco: Harper and Row, 1988). Argues for the seventh day as the goal of the first account and situates Genesis 1 within a wider biblical discussion of creation.
- Nahum M. Sarna, Genesis, JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1989). Attentive to the Hebrew vocabulary distinctions (
bara,asah,yatsar) and to the rabbinic reading of the divine names.
In short
- Genesis 1:1-2:3 uses
elohimalone and the formulaic verbsbara/asah, while Genesis 2:4-25 uses the compound "Yahweh God," the verbyatsar("to form," used of a potter), concrete geography (four rivers, Eden), and an order in which the man is formed before any plant of the field (2:5) — differences that are not disputed even though their explanation is. - The compositional reading (classic Documentary Hypothesis, assigning 1:1-2:3 to a Priestly source and 2:4-25 to a Yahwistic source) rests on the coordination of features moving together, not on the divine name alone; the unified-design reading (Cassuto, developed by Mathews and Waltke) treats the two chapters as a deliberate literary technique — general account followed by particular close-up — with Bruce Waltke's middle position separating the question of the material's origin from the design of the received text.
- Genesis 1's architecture answers its own stated agenda at 1:2 ("formless and empty"): days one to three separate and establish domains (light/dark, waters, land and vegetation) and days four to six fill those same domains in the same order, with the seventh day standing outside the pattern entirely — no evening-and-morning formula, no "it was good," but three verbs (finished, blessed, made holy) that Jon Levenson argues make it the goal of the account rather than its epilogue.
- Genesis 1:26-28's
imago Deihas been read as a capacity (Augustine's De Trinitate, Aquinas locating it in the intellect), a function (J. Richard Middleton's royal-representative reading, building on ancient Near Eastern kings called "the image" of a god), or a relation (Karl Barth, reading "male and female he created them" as in apposition to the image) — and Genesis never defines the term, connecting it only to the mandate of dominion that immediately follows. - The four named positions on the six days — twenty-four-hour days (the plain sense of
yomwith a numeral), day-ages (yom's extended sense already at Genesis 2:4), the literary framework (Henri Blocher, based on the forming/filling structure itself), and functional inauguration (John Walton's cosmic-temple proposal) — are presented without the lecture arguing for one, since the relation of Genesis to modern natural science is treated as outside this course's scope.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Genesis 1:1-2:3 and Genesis 2:4-25 differ in divine name (elohim versus "Yahweh God"), vocabulary for creating (bara/asah versus yatsar), style, geography, and the order of vegetation, animals, and humanity — differences real enough that the classic Documentary Hypothesis assigned them to separate Priestly and Yahwistic sources, while Cassuto and others argue the same differences are a deliberate literary technique, a cosmic overview followed by a human-centered close-up, with Bruce Waltke's position holding that the material's origin and the final text's design are separable questions. Whichever explanation is preferred, Genesis 1 itself announces its structure at 1:2 ("formless and empty") and executes it as days one-to-three forming what days four-to-six fill, before ending not at a completed world but at a sanctified seventh day that Jon Levenson reads as the account's actual goal. The imago Dei of 1:26-28 is asserted and tied to dominion but never defined, which is why capacity (Augustine, Aquinas), function (Middleton's royal-image reading from ancient Near Eastern kingship), and relation (Barth) all remain live readings, and why the four standard positions on the length of the days — twenty-four-hour, day-age, literary framework, and Walton's functional inauguration — are named here as vocabulary a student needs rather than a question this course settles.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The lecture insists on describing the differences between Genesis 1 and 2 before offering any explanation of them. Why might the order of description and explanation matter for how a student evaluates the competing accounts — and is there a cost to that order as well as a benefit?
- The compositional reading's real strength is said to be the *coordination* of features rather than any single feature. Explain in your own words why a cluster of correlated differences is stronger evidence than one large difference, and describe what a unified-design reading would need to show in order to answer it.
- Of the three main readings of `imago Dei` — capacity, function, relation — which do you find best supported by Genesis 1:26-28 read on its own, without importing later theology? Now state the strongest objection to your own choice.
- Genesis 2:1-3 sanctifies a period of time before any place or person in the Pentateuch is called holy. What follows, if anything, for how the rest of the Pentateuch's holiness language should be read?
- The lecture declines to argue for one reading of the six days on the ground that the science-and-Genesis question belongs to another discipline. Do you accept that boundary? If not, what would a Pentateuch course need to include in order to cross it responsibly?
- Blocher's synthesis of the capacity and function readings is described as attractive, and the lecture treats that attractiveness as a reason for caution rather than confidence. Is that a sound methodological instinct, or does it risk penalising a reading simply for being coherent?