FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT605E The Historical Books

Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King

Contents 37
BT605E The Historical Books
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
  1. Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Reading Israel's Story
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
  3. Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Joshua - Entering the Land
  1. Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
  3. Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Judges - The Cycle and Its Collapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Ruth - A Story Set Against the Judges
  1. Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: 1 Samuel - From Judge to King
  1. Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
  2. Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
  3. Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: 2 Samuel - David's Reign
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
  2. Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
  3. Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: 1 Kings - Solomon and the Division
  1. Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
  3. Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: 2 Kings - Two Kingdoms to Two Exiles
  1. Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
  3. Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: 1-2 Chronicles - The Same Story Retold
  1. Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
  2. Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
  3. Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Ezra-Nehemiah - Return and Rebuilding
  1. Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
  2. Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Esther - Survival Without a Named God
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
  3. Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: What the Historical Books Are Doing
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Deuteronomistic History and the Debate About It
  2. Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole
  3. Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

Jump to the key points ↓

38 min

Judges does not end with Samson. After chapter 16 come five more chapters, and they are unlike anything before them. There is no oppressor, no cry to Yahweh, no raising up of a deliverer, and no rest. There is a stolen quantity of silver that becomes a household idol, a tribe that migrates north and takes the idol and its priest with it, a Levite whose concubine is raped to death by men of an Israelite town, a war of eleven tribes against the twelfth, and two schemes — one a massacre, one an abduction — to supply wives to the survivors of the tribe the others have almost destroyed. Older commentaries call these chapters an appendix. The word is convenient and slightly misleading, and part of this lecture is about why.

Four times in these chapters the narrator says that in those days there was no king in Israel. Twice he adds: every man did what was right in his own eyes. This is the most quoted sentence in the book, and it is quoted with confidence in two opposite directions. Read one way, it is an editor arguing that the chaos of the period was the absence of monarchy, and that the reader — who lives under a king — should be grateful. Read another way, it is bitter, an irony aimed at a monarchy the reader knows collapsed, and the sting is that Israel under kings did no better. The evidence genuinely supports both, and this lecture will lay it out rather than pick.

The centre of the lecture is chapter 19. That chapter is regularly used as an illustration: proof that things had got very bad, a rhetorical high-water mark for the descent argued in the previous two lectures. This lecture does not use it that way. It reads it as a text — attending to what it narrates, in what order, with what emphasis, and above all to what and whom it does not report — and then traces what readers have done with it over two thousand years, including the period since Phyllis Trible gave it a name in 1984. Students should expect this section to be difficult. It is meant to be read slowly, and it is not softened.

What these 38 minutes give you

  • Describe the contents and structure of Judges 17-21 and state the case for and against calling them an appendix.
  • Give an accurate account of Judges 19 — what the narrator reports, what he attributes to whom, and where the narrative withholds information — without either euphemism or embellishment.
  • Summarize the reception history of Judges 19, including the Greek textual variant at 19:2, the rabbinic discussion, and the shift marked by Trible's *Texts of Terror*.
  • Set out both readings of the refrain "there was no king in Israel," name a representative scholar for each, and give at least two pieces of textual evidence for each.
  • Explain why Gibeah and Benjamin, specifically, complicate any reading of these chapters as neutral reporting.

In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes. — Judges 17:6

World English Bible

In those days, when there was no king in Israel, there was a certain Levite living on the farther side of the hill country of Ephraim, who took to him a concubine out of Bethlehem Judah. His concubine played the prostitute against him, and went away from him to her father’s house to Bethlehem Judah, and was there the space of four months. — Judges 19:1-2

WEB

As they were making their hearts merry, behold, the men of the city, certain base fellows, surrounded the house, beating at the door; and they spoke to the master of the house, the old man, saying, “Bring out the man who came into your house, that we may have sex with him!” The man, the master of the house, went out to them, and said to them, “No, my brothers, please don’t act so wickedly; since this man has come into my house, don’t do this folly. Behold, here is my virgin daughter and his concubine. I will bring them out now. Humble them, and do with them what seems good to you; but to this man don’t do any such folly.” But the men wouldn’t listen to him: so the man laid hold of his concubine, and brought her out to them; and they had sex with her, and abused her all night until the morning: and when the day began to dawn, they let her go. — Judges 19:22-25

WEB

Her lord rose up in the morning, and opened the doors of the house, and went out to go his way; and behold, the woman his concubine was fallen down at the door of the house, with her hands on the threshold. He said to her, “Get up, and let us be going!” but no one answered. Then he took her up on the donkey; and the man rose up, and went to his place. When he had come into his house, he took a knife, and laid hold on his concubine, and divided her, limb by limb, into twelve pieces, and sent her throughout all the borders of Israel. It was so, that all who saw it said, “There was no such deed done nor seen from the day that the children of Israel came up out of the land of Egypt to this day! Consider it, take counsel, and speak.” — Judges 19:27-30

WEB

The tribes of Israel sent men through all the tribe of Benjamin, saying, “What wickedness is this that has happened among you? Now therefore deliver up the men, the base fellows, who are in Gibeah, that we may put them to death, and put away evil from Israel.” But Benjamin would not listen to the voice of their brothers the children of Israel. — Judges 20:12-13

WEB

In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes. — Judges 21:25

WEB

You shall not do after all the things that we do here this day, every man whatever is right in his own eyes; — Deuteronomy 12:8

WEB

That last verse matters for the refrain. The phrase "right in his own eyes" is not invented by the editor of Judges; Deuteronomy uses it of a situation the law is designed to end, and the situation Deuteronomy has in mind is not the absence of a king but the absence of the central sanctuary.

1. What is actually in chapters 17-21

Chapters 17-18: Micah's image and the migration of Dan. A man in the Ephraimite hills, Micah, has stolen eleven hundred pieces of silver from his mother. He confesses when he hears her curse; she blesses him, dedicates the silver to Yahweh, and has part of it made into an image. Micah installs it in a household shrine with an ephod and teraphim, and consecrates one of his sons as priest. A wandering Levite from Bethlehem arrives, and Micah hires him instead — "now I know that Yahweh will do me good, since I have a Levite as my priest" (17:13). Then six hundred armed men of the tribe of Dan, looking for territory because their allotted inheritance has not materialized, pass through. They take the image, the ephod, the teraphim, and the Levite, who accepts the promotion from one household's priest to a tribe's. They march north, destroy the quiet and unsuspecting town of Laish, rebuild it as Dan, and set up the image there. The narrator adds that the priest was Jonathan son of Gershom, son of Moses, and that his descendants served there "until the day of the captivity of the land" (18:30).

Note what this account is doing. Every element of Israelite religion is present — a Levite, an ephod, consecration, the name of Yahweh invoked repeatedly, and a descendant of Moses himself — and every one of them is deployed in the service of an image, a stolen one at that. The story is not about irreligion. It is about religion that has become entirely instrumental, and it ends by locating that religion at Dan, which in 1 Kings 12 will be one of the two shrines that define the northern kingdom's sin.

Chapters 19-21: Gibeah, the war, and the wives. A Levite from the same Ephraimite hills takes a concubine — Hebrew pilegesh, a wife of secondary legal status, not a mistress — from Bethlehem in Judah. She leaves him. He goes to fetch her; her father detains him with hospitality for several days; they leave late. They pass Jebus, the future Jerusalem, and the Levite refuses to lodge in a foreign city, preferring Gibeah of Benjamin. In Gibeah no one takes them in until an old man, himself from Ephraim, does. That night the men of the city surround the house. What follows is quoted above, in full, because it should not be summarized. In the morning the Levite carries the body home and cuts it into twelve pieces, which he sends through all the territory of Israel.

Israel assembles at Mizpah — four hundred thousand men, the text says — and asks what happened. The Levite tells them, and his telling is not what chapter 19 reported: he says the men of Gibeah intended to kill him and that they raped his concubine and she died, omitting entirely that he handed her out the door. Israel demands the guilty men from Benjamin; Benjamin refuses and musters instead. Three days of battle follow, in which Israel loses forty thousand men over the first two days despite consulting Yahweh each time, and on the third destroys Benjamin almost completely — putting to the sword the towns, the livestock, and everything found, and burning the cities.

Then Israel discovers that it has sworn two oaths: not to give daughters to Benjamin, and to kill anyone who failed to come to Mizpah. Six hundred Benjaminite men survive. To provide them wives, Israel executes the inhabitants of Jabesh Gilead, which had not sent troops, sparing four hundred virgins; and when that is not enough, it instructs the remaining Benjaminites to hide in the vineyards at Shiloh and seize girls from the annual festival dance as they come out — a device that lets the elders keep the letter of their oath, since the fathers will not have given their daughters. The book then ends with the refrain.

2. Are they an appendix?

Martin Noth held that 17-21 stood outside the Deuteronomistic History — outside the great editorial work running from Deuteronomy through Kings — and were added later; on his account the History's Judges section ended at 16:31. The case for this is substantial. The chapters contain none of the framework language: no "did evil in the sight of Yahweh," no anger, no selling into an enemy's hand, no cry, no deliverer, no rest. They have no chronological notices. They are not attached to any judge. And chapter 2's programmatic paragraph plainly describes a different kind of material.

The case against treating them as a mere addendum is equally substantial, and it has grown stronger in recent decades. The chapters are linked to the book's beginning by clear verbal and thematic hooks: chapter 1 lists tribes that failed to take their territory, and chapter 18 shows one of them taking territory by massacring a defenceless town instead; chapter 1 opens with Israel inquiring of Yahweh, "Who shall go up for us against the Canaanites first?" and 20:18 has Israel inquiring in almost the same words — but against Benjamin. The book that begins with Israel asking how to fight Canaanites ends with Israel asking how to fight Israelites, in the same formula. That is design, not accretion. Yairah Amit (The Book of Judges: The Art of Editing, 1999) and Barry Webb both argue on such grounds that the closing chapters are integral to the book as it now stands, whatever their compositional history.

Both can be true. Material can originate separately and still be placed deliberately. What a student should avoid is the practical consequence of the "appendix" label, which is that these chapters get skipped.

3. Judges 19, read as a text

Set aside for a moment what the chapter proves. Look at how it tells.

What the narrator attributes, and to whom. The chapter opens by stating that the concubine "played the prostitute against him." That is the narrator's word, not a character's, and it is the only thing we are told about her before she is handed out the door. She never speaks in the chapter. She has no name. The Levite is not named either, and neither is the old man; but the Levite acts throughout, and she is acted upon throughout, and the grammar makes that visible: she is taken, she goes, she is brought in, she is seized, she is brought out, she is let go, she falls, she is told to get up, she is taken up, she is divided.

Where the narrative withholds. The most discussed silence is at 19:28: "He said to her, 'Get up, and let us be going!' but no one answered." The Hebrew does not say she was dead. It says no one answered. Whether she died in the night, on the threshold, or on the journey home is not stated, and the ancient versions differ: the Greek tradition adds a clause at this point indicating that she was dead. The Hebrew text as it stands leaves the reader to complete the sentence, and interpreters have noticed for centuries that this makes the dismemberment ambiguous in a way that is nearly unbearable. The lecture does not resolve it; the text does not.

What the Levite says afterwards. In 20:4-5 he reports the night to the assembly, and his report is false in a specific way: he says the men of Gibeah rose against him intending to kill him, and that they forced his concubine so that she died. He does not mention that he put her outside. This is one of the clearest cases in the Old Testament of a narrator reporting an event and then reporting a character's misreport of the same event, and it is easy to miss, because chapter 20 moves fast. Everything Israel then does is done on the basis of the second version.

The rhetoric of the closing verse. "There was no such deed done nor seen from the day that the children of Israel came up out of the land of Egypt to this day." This is a superlative, and superlatives are worth watching. Whether it refers to the rape, the death, the dismemberment, or the distribution of the pieces is not specified — and readers have divided on that, because it changes what Israel is being summoned to avenge.

The Sodom parallel. The scene at the door repeats Genesis 19 closely: strangers taken in, the men of the city surrounding the house, the demand, the host's offer of women in their place. Stuart Lasine argued in an influential 1984 article that Judges 19 is a deliberate inversion — the world of Genesis 19 turned inside out. In Genesis, angels intervene and the daughters are not surrendered; here there are no angels, and the woman is surrendered. Read against Genesis, the point is not that Gibeah is like Sodom but that Gibeah is worse, and that it is Israelite.

4. The reception of Judges 19

The chapter has never been ignored, but until recently it was mostly discussed as a legal or political episode rather than as what happened to a woman.

Antiquity. Josephus retells the episode in Antiquities Book 5, and adjusts it: the woman's departure becomes a quarrel arising from her husband's treatment rather than her infidelity, and the sequence is generally smoothed. Hosea twice refers to "the days of Gibeah" (9:9; 10:9) as a byword for corruption, which shows the story functioning as a national memory well before the Judges scroll reached its present form. And 1 Samuel 11:7, where Saul cuts a yoke of oxen in pieces and sends them through Israel to summon a muster, uses the same startling device — a fact that will matter in a moment.

Rabbinic discussion. The Babylonian Talmud takes up the chapter at Gittin 6b, and the discussion there is instructive precisely because of what it is about. Amoraic teachers dispute what the Levite found objectionable — the well-known exchange concerns whether he found a fly or a hair in his food — and use the episode to make a point about domestic anger and its consequences. The woman's death is present but not the subject. That is characteristic of most premodern engagement with the chapter: it is read for what it says about the men in it.

Later Christian use. The chapter appears in Christian writing chiefly as evidence for the necessity of civil order, or as an argument in disputes about tribal and national punishment. It is largely absent from preaching. It does not appear in the Revised Common Lectionary, and it is not read on any Sunday in the Roman Catholic lectionary — so a churchgoer in most Western traditions can attend for a lifetime without hearing it. That absence is itself part of the reception history.

The nineteenth century. Elizabeth Cady Stanton's The Woman's Bible (1895-98) treated the Judges narratives, this one among them, as evidence in an argument about how scripture had been used against women — one of the earliest sustained readings that made the treatment of the woman, rather than the offence against the Levite, the subject.

Trible and after. Phyllis Trible's Texts of Terror (1984) devoted a chapter to this narrative under the title "An Unnamed Woman: The Extravagance of Violence." Her method was literary rather than polemical: close attention to the Hebrew, to the verbs, to who is the subject of each clause, and to the systematic silence of the woman. Trible's argument was that the text itself exposes what is done to her — that reading it carefully is not an act against scripture but an act of attention scripture invites — and that the interpretive tradition, not the text, is what had disappeared her. The book changed the field. Since 1984 the chapter has been treated at length by, among many others, J. Cheryl Exum, who has examined how narrative technique positions the reader; Gale Yee, who has read it in terms of the social and economic organization the story assumes; and Ken Stone, who has analysed the episode in terms of ancient honour, shame, and the male body. Not all of this work agrees with Trible, and some of it criticizes her for reading a modern moral sensibility into a text that has none. The point for a student is that the chapter now has a scholarly literature of its own, and that this is recent.

Does the text judge him?

This is a point where readers will not agree. There is a real dispute about whether Judges 19 contains an implicit judgement on the Levite. One position holds that the narrative condemns him by construction: the Sodom parallel, his false report in chapter 20, his single recorded sentence to her body, and the placement of the whole account under the refrain about everyone doing what was right in his own eyes. Trible, Exum, and Webb — from very different starting points — all read some form of authorial disapproval. The other position holds that this is more than the text will bear: the narrator condemns the men of Gibeah explicitly ("base fellows," "folly") and never criticizes the Levite in his own voice, and reading condemnation into the arrangement risks making the text say what a modern reader needs it to say. Both positions are held by careful readers. What neither can do is make the chapter comfortable.

5. What remains difficult

Three things should be left standing at the end of this section, unresolved, because they are unresolved.

First, God is absent from chapter 19. There is no divine speech, no divine action, no prophet, and no evaluation. In chapter 20 Israel consults Yahweh three times and receives answers, and the first two answers are followed by defeats costing forty thousand men, without explanation. A book that has spent sixteen chapters explaining events theologically stops explaining exactly here.

Second, the response to the crime is worse than the crime. A woman is raped to death by a gang in one town; the answer is the destruction of a tribe, the massacre of a second town including its women, and the abduction of two hundred more women at a religious festival. If chapters 19-21 are a , the argument is not that Israel failed to punish evil. It is that Israel's machinery for punishing evil produced more of it.

Third, the woman is never given anything. No name, no speech, no lament, no burial reported, no annual remembrance — unlike Jephthah's daughter, who at least receives four days a year. If the text has a verdict on her fate it is delivered entirely by arrangement and by silence, and readers must decide how much weight silence can carry.

6. The refrain: whose voice?

Now to the sentence. It occurs at 17:6, 18:1, 19:1, and 21:25, and the long form — with "every man did that which was right in his own eyes" — at 17:6 and 21:25, framing the whole block.

The pro-monarchic reading. On this view the refrain is an editorial argument: these horrors happened because there was no king, and the reader who has one should draw the obvious conclusion. Julius Wellhausen and, in the twentieth century, Noth read the refrain as the mark of a later hand with monarchic sympathies. The strongest recent version of the case is Marc Zvi Brettler's, in The Book of Judges (2002) and earlier work, and it turns on a detail that is easy to miss. Gibeah is Saul's home town (1 Samuel 10:26; 11:4). The tribe that harbours the criminals and is nearly destroyed is Saul's tribe, Benjamin. The woman comes from Bethlehem in Judah — David's town. The device the Levite uses to summon Israel, cutting a body in twelve pieces, is the device Saul uses in 1 Samuel 11:7. And Judges 1 opens by declaring that Judah shall go up first. On Brettler's reading the closing chapters are political literature: an argument for a Judahite, Davidic monarchy, made by showing what Benjamin and Gibeah were. Yairah Amit has argued along related lines that the Micah and Dan material is a concealed polemic against the sanctuary at Bethel.

Supporting evidence: the refrain's placement at the head and foot of the block; the relentlessly negative presentation of Benjamin; the absence of any positive alternative to monarchy anywhere in these chapters.

The ironic or anti-monarchic reading. On this view the refrain is not an argument for kingship at all. Robert Polzin, in Moses and the Deuteronomist (1980), reads the Deuteronomistic material as sustained irony in which apparently authoritative narratorial statements are undercut by what surrounds them. Barry Webb, working from the book's own composition, points out that Judges has already shown what Israelite kingship looks like: Abimelech in chapter 9, who murdered seventy brothers to obtain it, and whose reign produced nothing but the destruction of the city that made him king. A book containing chapter 9 cannot straightforwardly recommend monarchy as the cure.

Supporting evidence: Gideon's refusal in 8:23 states the theological objection to kingship in the book's own voice — "Yahweh shall rule over you." Abimelech's account is a demonstration of what an Israelite king does. And, crucially, the phrase "right in his own eyes" is Deuteronomic language (Deuteronomy 12:8) whose remedy in Deuteronomy is not a king but the central sanctuary and the law. If the editor is quoting Deuteronomy, the deficiency he names is not the lack of a monarch.

A third possibility worth weighing. Some readers take the refrain as neither advocacy nor irony but as a historical marker: the editor is telling a later audience that these events belong to a period whose institutions were different, in order to explain conduct that would otherwise be inexplicable. This reading has the advantage of not requiring the editor to have a programme, and the disadvantage that it does not account for the placement of the long form at exactly the two ends of the block.

There is no neutral way to settle this. What can be said is that anyone who cites Judges 21:25 as a straightforward endorsement of monarchy is citing it without chapter 9, and anyone who reads it as pure anti-monarchic irony has to explain why the material is so thoroughly organized around Benjamin, Gibeah, Bethlehem, and Judah. The honest position is that the refrain does at least two things at once, and that the book was very likely edited more than once, by hands with different interests.

7. What the ending refuses to do

One last observation. Judges could have ended at 16:31, with Samson buried between Zorah and Eshtaol, and the book would have had a shape: a decline, a last deliverer, a grave. Instead it ends with two hundred women taken from a dance at Shiloh, an oath technically unbroken, and a sentence about everyone doing as he saw fit. There is no resolution, no restoration, and no promise. Whoever arranged this material declined to give the reader an ending — and that refusal is the strongest formal argument that the book is not a collection of hero tales but a sustained account of something going wrong, handed over to the reader unfinished.

Judges 17-21: the refrain, and the two ways of hearing it Four occurrences; the long form frames the block at both ends Where the refrain stands 17:6 long form — opens the block. Micah's silver becomes an image; a Levite is hired as a household priest. 18:1 short form — Dan has no inheritance; six hundred men take image, priest, and the town of Laish. 19:1 short form — a Levite, a concubine from Bethlehem Judah, a night in Gibeah of Benjamin. 21:25 long form — closes the block and the book. No resolution follows it. Read as an argument FOR monarchy Wellhausen; Noth; Brettler (2002); Amit (1999) Gibeah is Saul's town (1 Sam 10:26). Benjamin is Saul's tribe, and is destroyed. The woman is from Bethlehem — David's town. The dismemberment summons matches Saul's oxen in 1 Samuel 11:7. Judges 1:2 — "Judah shall go up first." No alternative to kingship is offered here. Read as irony, or against monarchy Polzin (1980); Webb (2012) Judges 9 already shows an Israelite king: Abimelech, seventy brothers on one stone. Gideon: "Yahweh shall rule over you" (8:23). "Right in his own eyes" is Deuteronomy 12:8, where the remedy is the sanctuary and the law, not a king. The reader already knows how monarchy ended. Chapter 19 — three things the lecture leaves standing 1. God is absent from the chapter entirely. 2. The response (ch. 20-21) kills far more than the crime did. 3. The woman receives no name, no speech, no burial, and no annual remembrance. One structural hook against calling 17-21 a mere appendix 1:1 — Israel asks Yahweh who shall go up first against the Canaanites. 20:18 — Israel asks, in nearly the same words, against Benjamin.

The two central panels are set side by side deliberately: they are not a spectrum with a midpoint, and a student who wants to combine them should be able to say which piece of evidence from each panel survives the combination.

6. Further Reading

  • Phyllis Trible, Texts of Terror: Literary-Feminist Readings of Biblical Narratives (Fortress, 1984), chapter 4 — the reading that reoriented discussion of Judges 19; read it before reading anything written about it.
  • Marc Zvi Brettler, The Book of Judges (Routledge, 2002) — the clearest statement of the pro-Judahite, pro-monarchic reading of the closing chapters.
  • Yairah Amit, The Book of Judges: The Art of Editing, trans. Jonathan Chipman (Brill, 1999) — on the editorial shaping of 17-21 and the concealed polemic against Bethel.
  • Robert Polzin, Moses and the Deuteronomist (Seabury, 1980) — the case for reading the Deuteronomistic narrator ironically.
  • Stuart Lasine, "Guest and Host in Judges 19: Lot's Hospitality in a World Turned Inside Out," Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 29 (1984) — the Genesis 19 comparison, done rigorously.
  • J. Cheryl Exum, Fragmented Women: Feminist (Sub)versions of Biblical Narratives ( Press International, 1993) — narrative technique and the positioning of the reader.
  • Gale A. Yee, ed., Judges and Method: New Approaches in Biblical Studies, 2nd ed. (Fortress, 2007) — several methods applied to these chapters side by side; the best single book for seeing how the approaches differ.
  • Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges, NICOT (Eerdmans, 2012) — on 17-21 as integral to the book's design rather than appended to it.

In short

  • Judges 17-21 has no oppressor, cry, deliverer or rest. It tells of Micah's image and the migration of Dan, then of Gibeah, a war against Benjamin, and schemes to find wives for the survivors.
  • Noth saw these chapters as a later addition. Amit and Webb see them as part of the design, since 1:1 and 20:18 ask nearly the same question. Either way, the label "appendix" should not lead readers to skip them.
  • Judges 19 is read closely: the woman is unnamed and never speaks, the Hebrew of 19:28 does not say she was dead, and the Levite's later account in 20:4-5 leaves out his part. Phyllis Trible's 1984 reading changed the field.
  • Scholars disagree whether the narrative implicitly condemns the Levite (Trible, Exum, Webb) or condemns only the men of Gibeah. God is absent from the chapter, and the response in chapters 20-21 does more harm than the crime.
  • The refrain "no king in Israel" is read as pro-monarchic (Brettler, Wellhausen, Noth), as ironic (Polzin, Webb), or as a historical marker. Gibeah is Saul's town, but Judges 9 already shows an Israelite king.

Topic: This lecture reads the closing chapters of Judges, treats Judges 19 as a text with its reception history, and sets out the readings of the refrain about a king.

Remember: The book ends with no resolution. Judges 19 needs slow reading: who acts, who is silent, and what the Levite later says about it.

Caution: The lecture does not pick between the pro-monarchic and ironic readings or settle whether the Levite is condemned. Do not cite 21:25 as plain support for monarchy without Judges 9.

One line to carry into ministry: Do not skip or soften Judges 19; read it slowly, say what it reports, and let the unresolved questions stand.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Compare Judges 19:22-28 with the Levite's own account in 20:4-5, clause by clause. List every difference. Then answer: what does the narrative accomplish by giving us both, and what would be lost if only one stood?
  • Judges 19 reports no divine speech and no divine evaluation. Some readers take the silence as condemnation by arrangement; others take it as evidence that the narrator's interest lies elsewhere. Argue one side, then state the strongest evidence against yourself.
  • Read Genesis 19 and Judges 19 together. Make a list of the correspondences and a list of the divergences. Which list carries more interpretive weight, and why?
  • Brettler's argument depends on the reader knowing that Gibeah is Saul's town. What does an argument of that kind assume about the book's original audience? Is that assumption defensible?
  • The chapter appears in no major Sunday lectionary. Write a short case for reading it publicly and a short case against, and then say what you would actually do and why.
  • Israel's response to Gibeah destroys a tribe, massacres Jabesh Gilead, and abducts two hundred women at Shiloh — all of it within the letter of oaths sworn to Yahweh. What is the book saying about oaths, and how does that connect with Jephthah in the previous lecture?
  • Suppose the refrain were removed from all four places. How would your reading of chapters 17-21 change? What does that tell you about how much interpretive work the refrain is doing?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.