Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
Contents 37
- Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
- Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
- Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
- Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
- Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
- Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
- Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
- Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
- Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
- Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
- Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
- Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
- Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
- Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
- Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
- Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
- Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
- Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
- Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
- Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
- Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
- Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
- Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
- Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
- Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
- Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
- Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
- Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
- Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
- Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
- Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
- Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
- Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
The first third of 2 Kings belongs to Elisha, and it does not read like the rest of the book. Kings is, structurally, a set of royal annals: a king accedes, the writer gives his age, the length of his reign, his mother's name if he is a king of Judah, a one-line verdict, and a reference to a source where the reader may find more. Into that dry frame the Elisha material has been set, and it is not dry at all. A widow's oil does not stop flowing until she runs out of jars. A borrowed iron axe head floats. A Syrian general is cured of a skin disease by washing in a river he despises. A dead man is thrown into Elisha's tomb, touches the bones, and stands up. There are more miracles in these chapters than in the Elijah cycle before them, and most of them are smaller — food, debt, illness, a poisoned pot of stew.
That difference of texture is the first thing this lecture examines, because it has consequences for how the material should be read. Alexander Rofé and Burke O. Long, working independently and from different starting points, both argued that these episodes belong to recognizable narrative genres — the brief legend, the exemplary tale, the account of a wonder attached to a holy man's tomb — and that they circulated as stories about a prophet before they were placed in a book about kings. Whether or not one accepts every detail of their classifications, the observation that the material has a form of its own is hard to avoid once it is pointed out.
The second thing this lecture examines is the other Elisha, the one who is not a village wonder-worker at all. This prophet tells a Syrian officer that he will be king of Syria, and the officer goes home and smothers his master. This prophet sends a member of his guild to pour oil on an army commander's head, and within a chapter the reigning dynasty of Israel has been exterminated. Prophets in 2 Kings do not only comment on politics; they start it. And that leads to the hardest problem in the lecture, which is that the book approves of what Jehu did and Hosea does not. Both statements are in the canon. The lecture will describe the disagreement precisely and will not pretend it can be dissolved.
What these 35 minutes give you
- Describe the distinctive character of the Elisha narratives and summarize the proposals of Rofé and Long about what kind of material they are.
- Explain what a "double portion" meant in Israelite inheritance law and why Elisha's request is not a request to be twice as great as Elijah.
- State plainly what 2 Kings 2:23-24 reports, survey at least three ways it has been handled, and identify what each way costs.
- Narrate the Hazael and Jehu episodes and explain what they show about the relation of prophet to throne in this book.
- Set 2 Kings 10:30 beside Hosea 1:4 and state the disagreement between them without collapsing either into the other.
- Place the Tel Dan stele and the Black Obelisk of Shalmaneser III in relation to this material, and say what each does and does not establish.
When they had gone over, Elijah said to Elisha, “Ask what I shall do for you, before I am taken from you.” Elisha said, “Please let a double portion of your spirit be on me.” He said, “You have asked a hard thing. If you see me when I am taken from you, it shall be so for you; but if not, it shall not be so.” — 2 Kings 2:9-10
World English Bible
Now there cried a certain woman of the wives of the sons of the prophets to Elisha, saying, “Your servant my husband is dead. You know that your servant feared Yahweh. Now the creditor has come to take for himself my two children to be slaves.” Elisha said to her, “What shall I do for you? Tell me: what do you have in the house?” She said, “Your handmaid has nothing in the house, except a pot of oil.” — 2 Kings 4:1-2
WEB
He went up from there to Bethel. As he was going up by the way, some youths came out of the city and mocked him, and said to him, “Go up, you baldy! Go up, you baldy!” He looked behind him and saw them, and cursed them in Yahweh’s name. Two female bears came out of the woods, and mauled forty-two of those youths. — 2 Kings 2:23-24
WEB
His servants came near, and spoke to him, and said, “My father, if the prophet had asked you do some great thing, wouldn’t you have done it? How much rather then, when he says to you, ‘Wash, and be clean?’” Then went he down, and dipped himself seven times in the Jordan, according to the saying of the man of God; and his flesh was restored like the flesh of a little child, and he was clean. — 2 Kings 5:13-14
WEB
Hazael said, “Why do you weep, my lord?” He answered, “Because I know the evil that you will do to the children of Israel. You will set their strongholds on fire, and you will kill their young men with the sword, and will dash in pieces their little ones, and rip up their women with child.” Hazael said, “But what is your servant, who is but a dog, that he should do this great thing?” Elisha answered, “Yahweh has shown me that you will be king over Syria.” — 2 Kings 8:12-13
WEB
He arose, and went into the house. Then he poured the oil on his head, and said to him, “Thus says Yahweh, the God of Israel, ‘I have anointed you king over the people of Yahweh, even over Israel. You shall strike the house of Ahab your master, that I may avenge the blood of my servants the prophets, and the blood of all the servants of Yahweh, at the hand of Jezebel. — 2 Kings 9:6-7
WEB
Yahweh said to Jehu, “Because you have done well in executing that which is right in my eyes, and have done to the house of Ahab according to all that was in my heart, your sons of the fourth generation shall sit on the throne of Israel.” But Jehu took no heed to walk in the law of Yahweh, the God of Israel, with all his heart. He didn’t depart from the sins of Jeroboam, with which he made Israel to sin. — 2 Kings 10:30-31
WEB
Yahweh said to him, “Call his name Jezreel; for yet a little while, and I will avenge the blood of Jezreel on the house of Jehu, and will cause the kingdom of the house of Israel to cease. — Hosea 1:4
WEB
The problem is debt slavery, which is a legal problem, and the solution is a commodity that can be sold. This is the tone of most of the Elisha material.
Two verses, no comment from the narrator, no stated consequence for Elisha. They are quoted here in full because a lecture that skipped them would be dishonest about what the chapter contains.
Read 2 Kings 10:30 and Hosea 1:4 one after the other. The same bloodshed, at the same place, is a reason for a four-generation dynasty in one text and a reason for that dynasty's destruction in the other.
1. The succession, and what a double portion is
2 Kings opens with the transfer of prophetic office, and the transfer is staged with unusual care. Elijah and Elisha walk from Gilgal to Bethel to Jericho to the Jordan; at each stop Elijah tells Elisha to stay behind and Elisha refuses in identical words; at each stop a company of prophets tells Elisha that his master is about to be taken and Elisha tells them to be quiet. The Jordan divides when Elijah strikes it with his rolled-up cloak, and it divides again when Elisha strikes it with the same cloak on the way back. The narrative is showing continuity of office by repetition, in the way a legal document establishes a chain of custody.
Not twice as great
Elisha's request is regularly misunderstood. "A double portion of your spirit" is not a request to be twice the prophet Elijah was. The phrase comes from inheritance law: Deuteronomy 21:17 requires that the firstborn son receive a double portion — that is, two shares where each other son receives one. Elisha is asking to be treated as Elijah's heir, not as his superior. The English idiom pulls the other way, and generations of sermons have gone with the idiom.
The condition attached is odd and worth noticing: "If you see me when I am taken from you." The succession depends on witnessing, not on or on a ritual. Elisha does see, cries out "My father, my father, the chariots of Israel and its horsemen!" — a phrase he will hear applied to himself at his own death in 13:14 — and tears his clothes.
2. What kind of stories are these?
Between chapter 2 and chapter 8 the book gives us a run of episodes that are short, self-contained, and only loosely dated. A poisonous stew is made edible with flour. Twenty barley loaves feed a hundred men with some left over. A borrowed axe head is recovered from the water. A woman of Shunem is given a son, loses him, and receives him back. Naaman, commander of the Syrian army, is cured. A besieged Samaria is relieved when four men with a skin disease find the enemy camp abandoned. And in 13:20-21 a corpse touches Elisha's bones and revives — a story attached to a tomb, told after the prophet is dead.
This is a point where readers will not agree. How this material should be classified, and what follows from the classification, is genuinely contested.
Alexander Rofé, in The Prophetical Stories (1988), sorted the prophetic narratives of Kings into genres — the brief legendum, the elaborated legendum, the vita, the exemplum, the parable — and dated them relative to one another on the basis of their form and their theological interests. On his account the shortest Elisha units are among the earliest prophetic narrative material in the Hebrew Bible, transmitted in prophetic circles, with the more theologically reflective compositions coming later. Burke O. Long, in his form-critical commentary on Kings and in a series of articles, argued similarly that many of these units are self-contained popular narratives about a holy man, of a type well attested cross-culturally, and that their placement in the annalistic framework is secondary.
Against this, Iain Provan and others have cautioned that genre labels drawn from folklore studies carry assumptions about oral transmission and historical value that the labels themselves do not establish, and that the placement of these episodes in the book may be more purposeful than the "inserted collection" model allows. A reader who notices that the Elisha stories cluster around Israel's wars with Syria, and that Elisha appears at the beginning and end of the Jehu material, has grounds for that caution.
What both sides agree on is the observation that provoked the argument: these chapters have a different texture from the annals around them. That is not in dispute; what it implies is.
One further feature deserves attention regardless of genre. Elisha's miracles are overwhelmingly directed at ordinary people with ordinary problems — a widow facing the seizure of her children for debt, a childless woman, a workman who has lost a borrowed tool, a group of prophets with nothing safe to eat. Elijah confronted a king on a mountain; Elisha spends most of his time in villages. And two of the beneficiaries are foreigners: Naaman is a Syrian, and the narrative has him say that there is no God in all the earth but in Israel, having been directed to the prophet in the first place by an Israelite slave girl captured in a Syrian raid. Jesus cites this episode in Luke 4:27, in a context where the point is precisely that the recipient was an outsider.
3. The bears
2 Kings 2:23-24 has to be dealt with, not managed. Elisha is walking up to Bethel. A group comes out of the town and jeers at him — "Go up, you baldy!", plausibly a taunt about the ascent of Elijah, and if so a mockery of the prophetic office rather than of the man's hairline. Elisha curses them in Yahweh's name. Two bears come out and maul forty-two of them. The narrator says nothing else. There is no verdict on Elisha, no report that anyone died, and no report that anyone repented.
This is a point where readers will not agree. At least four approaches are in circulation, and each of them costs something.
The lexical approach. The Hebrew na'arim qetannim is often rendered "little children" in older English versions; the same word na'ar is used of Joseph at seventeen and of soldiers. Rendering it "youths" or "young men," as the World English Bible does here, makes the episode a confrontation with a hostile gang rather than an attack on small children. Cogan and Tadmor take the group as young men of Bethel — Bethel being one of the two royal sanctuaries with a golden calf, so the taunt is a town's hostility to a prophet, not children's rudeness. The cost: the adjective qetannim, "small," still sits in the text, and the lexical range does not by itself decide the case. It reduces the difficulty; it does not remove it.
The genre approach. If Rofé and Long are right that this is a brief legend about the power attached to a holy man, then it belongs to a category of story whose purpose is to establish that the man is not to be trifled with, and whose ethical framework is not the narrator's own. The cost: this explains how such a story could be told without excusing what it says, and a reader who wants the text to be edifying will not be satisfied.
The structural approach. The episode stands immediately after Elisha has healed the water of Jericho, forming a pair: blessing on a town that receives him, curse on a town that does not. Marvin Sweeney and others read the two together, and note that Bethel is the site of Jeroboam's calf. The cost: a literary function is not a moral defence, and the reader is still looking at forty-two mauled young men.
The honest refusal. Some interpreters decline to defend the passage and say so. The position is that a text can report something as done in God's name without the reader being obliged to approve, that the narrative offers no evaluation, and that supplying one is the interpreter's addition. The cost is obvious and is felt most sharply by readers whose doctrine of Scripture makes the refusal difficult.
Two things should be said about all four. First, the ancient reception of this passage was not uniformly comfortable either; patristic writers reached for allegory here more quickly than they did for most narrative, which is itself evidence that the plain sense troubled them. Second, whichever approach a reader takes, the discipline is to describe what the text says before deciding what to do with it. Most bad handling of this passage begins with the decision.
4. Prophets who make and unmake kings
From chapter 8 the material turns political, and the turn is abrupt.
Elisha goes to Damascus. Ben-Hadad, king of Syria, is ill, and sends his officer Hazael to ask the prophet whether he will recover. Elisha's answer is a puzzle in itself — tell him he will certainly recover, but Yahweh has shown me that he will certainly die — and then the prophet stares at Hazael until Hazael is embarrassed, and weeps. Asked why, he describes what Hazael will do to Israel: burn fortresses, kill young men, dash children, rip open pregnant women. Hazael protests that he is nobody, a dog. Elisha tells him he will be king of Syria. The next verse has Hazael smothering his master with a wet cloth and taking the throne.
What has the prophet done here? He has not commanded the murder. He has also not prevented it, and the information he supplied is what made it possible. The narrative does not comment, and this reticence is characteristic of the book.
There is external evidence bearing on Hazael, and it is worth being precise about what it does. The Tel Dan stele, discovered in fragments in 1993 and 1994, is an Aramaic victory inscription set up by a king of Damascus — almost certainly Hazael, though the relevant line naming the author is broken — who claims to have killed a king of Israel and a king of the "house of David." The stele's importance for this course is twofold: it contains the phrase bytdwd, "house of David," which is the earliest extra-biblical reference to David that most scholars accept, and it has a Syrian king claiming credit for two royal deaths that 2 Kings 9 attributes to Jehu. Whether that is a contradiction, a boast, or a claim that Jehu acted as Hazael's client is argued — Nadav Na'aman and André Lemaire have taken different lines on the restoration and its implications. What the stele establishes is that Hazael existed, campaigned in Israel, and thought this worth commemorating. What it does not establish is the truth or falsity of the Elisha scene.
Then chapter 9. Elisha sends an unnamed member of the prophetic guild to Ramoth-gilead with a flask of oil and instructions: anoint Jehu son of Jehoshaphat son of Nimshi king over Israel, then open the door and run. The young man does rather more than instructed — the speech he delivers in 9:7-10 is longer than the commission Elisha gave him — and the coup begins within the hour.
This is the sharpest instance in the historical books of a pattern that runs through them: the prophet is not an adviser to the throne but a power over it. Samuel anointed Saul and then rejected him. Ahijah told Jeroboam he would have ten tribes. Elijah was told at Horeb to anoint Hazael and Jehu, a commission that only now, two books later, is carried out — by his successor rather than by him, which is one of several loose threads the Elijah-Elisha material leaves.
5. Jehu, and the disagreement inside the canon
What Jehu did occupies chapters 9 and 10 and should be stated plainly. He shot Joram of Israel in the back with an arrow and had the body thrown into Naboth's field. He pursued and killed Ahaziah of Judah. He had Jezebel thrown from a window and trampled. He wrote to the guardians of Ahab's seventy sons in Samaria and had their heads sent to him in baskets, then displayed them in two heaps at the city gate. He killed forty-two relatives of Ahaziah he met on the road. He gathered the worshippers of Baal into their temple on the pretext of a great sacrifice, posted eighty men outside, and had everyone inside killed. Then he made the building a latrine.
2 Kings 10:30 records God's verdict on this: "Because you have done well in executing that which is right in my eyes, and have done to the house of Ahab according to all that was in my heart, your sons of the fourth generation shall sit on the throne of Israel." The very next verse withdraws part of it — Jehu did not walk in the law with all his heart, and did not abandon the calves. The book's approval is therefore partial and precise: he did the thing he was anointed to do, and he was not otherwise a good king.
Hosea, prophesying in the northern kingdom in the following century, names his first son Jezreel, "for yet a little while, and I will avenge the blood of Jezreel on the house of Jehu, and will cause the kingdom of the house of Israel to cease."
This is a point where readers will not agree. There is no way to read these two texts that does not cost something.
The chronological reading holds that the two are consistent because they judge different things: 2 Kings commends the elimination of Ahab's house as an act of judgment, and Hosea condemns the excess and the dynasty's later conduct, announcing the end of a dynasty whose founding mandate had been fulfilled and exhausted. The cost: Hosea does not say "the excess of Jezreel," he says "the blood of Jezreel," and Jezreel is where the mandate was carried out.
The dissenting-tradition reading, argued in various forms and with particular force by scholars who take Hosea as evidence of a prophetic critique of the Jehu revolution from within Israel, holds that these are simply two evaluations of one event by two parties who disagreed, and that the has preserved both. Marvin Sweeney has stressed how much of the northern prophetic material is unfriendly to the dynasty that a Judean-edited book of Kings had reason to treat favourably. The cost: readers who require the canon to speak with one voice on questions of fact and value will find this reading unavailable, and it also has to explain why an editor would leave the tension in place.
The reading by literary function notes that 2 Kings itself does not leave the approval unqualified — verse 31 immediately restricts it — and that the four-generation limit is itself a sentence with an expiry date. On this reading Kings and Hosea are pulling in the same direction at different speeds. The cost: this is the most elegant of the three, which by the standing warning of this course is a reason to check it rather than to adopt it.
What all three have to accept is the underlying fact, which is that the canon contains a divine commendation and a divine condemnation of one bloody afternoon at Jezreel. A student who can state that fact accurately has understood the problem, whatever position they then take.
One further piece of external evidence belongs here. The Black Obelisk of Shalmaneser III, now in the British Museum, shows a register of a figure prostrate before the Assyrian king, with a caption naming "Jehu son of Omri" and listing tribute of silver, gold, and other goods. Two things about it are instructive. First, it is the only contemporary depiction of a named Israelite king that we have. Second, the caption calls Jehu "son of Omri" — that is, of the dynasty he had just destroyed — because to Assyrian scribes Israel was "the house of Omri" as a matter of standing nomenclature. The obelisk tells us Jehu paid tribute to Assyria, which 2 Kings never mentions. That silence is itself worth thinking about, and is the subject of the next lecture.
The two columns are deliberately the same size. It would be easy to treat the left column as the picturesque part and the right as the serious part, and the book does not present them that way — the same prophet appears in both, and 13:14-21 puts his death and the wonder at his tomb after the political material, not before it.
6. Further Reading
- Alexander Rofé, The Prophetical Stories: The Narratives about the Prophets in the Hebrew Bible (Magnes, 1988) — the fullest statement of the genre argument.
- Burke O. Long, 2 Kings, Forms of the Old Testament Literature 10 (Eerdmans, 1991).
- Mordechai Cogan and Hayim Tadmor, II Kings, Anchor Bible 11 (Doubleday, 1988) — see the notes on 2:23-24 and on the Jehu material.
- Marvin A. Sweeney, I & II Kings: A Commentary, Old Testament Library (Westminster John Knox, 2007) — attentive to northern traditions and to Hosea's relation to Kings.
- Wesley J. Bergen, Elisha and the End of Prophetism (Sheffield Academic Press, 1999) — a literary reading that takes the difficult episodes as difficult.
- Robert L. Cohn, 2 Kings, Berit Olam (Liturgical Press, 2000) — narrative-critical, strong on the shape of individual episodes.
- George Athas, The Tel Dan Inscription: A Reappraisal and a New Interpretation (Sheffield Academic Press, 2003) — for the stele, its restoration, and the range of readings.
- Hallvard Hagelia, The Dan Debate (Sheffield Phoenix, 2009) — a survey of the argument over the inscription rather than an advocacy of one side.
In short
- Elisha's request for a "double portion" in 2 Kings 2:9 borrows from inheritance law (Deuteronomy 21:17). He asks to be Elijah's heir, not twice as great.
- The Elisha wonders are small and domestic, and they help ordinary people and foreigners such as Naaman. Rofe and Long see recognizable story genres; Provan cautions that their placement may be purposeful.
- 2 Kings 2:23-24, the bears, is read four ways: lexical (young men, not small children), genre, structural, and an honest refusal to defend it. Each approach has a cost.
- Elisha tells Hazael he will be king, and Hazael murders his master. A prophet anoints Jehu, and Ahab's house is destroyed. Prophets here start politics and do not merely comment on it.
- 2 Kings 10:30 approves what Jehu did and Hosea 1:4 condemns the blood of Jezreel. Three readings are offered (chronological, dissenting tradition, literary), and each has a cost.
- The Tel Dan stele and the Black Obelisk show Hazael and Jehu's tribute outside the Bible. They do not confirm or refute the Elisha scenes.
Topic: This lecture studies Elisha's wonders, the bears of 2 Kings 2, the prophets who make and unmake kings, and the disagreement between Kings and Hosea over Jehu.
Remember: The canon contains both a divine commendation (2 Kings 10:30) and a divine condemnation (Hosea 1:4) of the same bloodshed at Jezreel. State that fact accurately before choosing a reading.
Caution: Do not decide how to handle the bears or Jehu before describing what the text says. The lecture warns that most bad handling begins with the decision.
One line to carry into ministry: When teaching a disturbing passage, first say plainly what it reports, then say honestly what the options are, and do not pretend any option is free of cost.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Explain what Elisha asks for in 2:9 and why the common English understanding of "double portion" is misleading. What difference does the correction make to how the succession is read?
- Take one small Elisha episode — the axe head, the widow's oil, the poisoned stew — and describe its narrative shape in your own words. Then ask what such a story is for, and whether your answer depends on accepting Rofé's genre classification.
- Write a paragraph on 2 Kings 2:23-24 for a class of adults who have just read it and are upset. Do not defend the passage and do not condemn it anachronistically; describe what it says, what it does not say, and what the options are.
- Elisha tells Hazael both that he will be king and what he will do to Israel, and then Hazael murders his master. Is the prophet implicated? Argue both sides.
- Set 2 Kings 10:30-31 and Hosea 1:4 side by side and state the disagreement in two sentences without using the words "really" or "actually." Then choose a position and give the strongest objection to it.
- The Black Obelisk records Jehu's tribute to Assyria and 2 Kings does not mention it. Give two different explanations for that silence, and say what evidence would help you decide between them.
- Naaman the Syrian is healed and Israelite towns are not conspicuously blessed in these chapters. What is the narrative doing with foreigners in the Elisha material, and how does Luke 4:27 read it?