Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
Contents 37
- Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
- Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
- Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
- Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
- Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
- Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
- Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
- Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
- Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
- Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
- Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
- Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
- Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
- Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
- Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
- Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
- Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
- Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
- Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
- Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
- Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
- Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
- Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
- Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
- Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
- Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
- Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
- Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
- Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
- Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
- Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
- Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
- Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
A book that is going to be about the founding of a monarchy opens with a childless woman praying at a provincial sanctuary. That is not what an ancient royal history looks like. Assyrian and Babylonian accounts of a dynasty's origin begin with the god's choice of the king; Egyptian ones begin with the king. This one begins with a private grief and a vow, and it stays with that grief long enough for the reader to notice that the narrator considers it important.
This lecture argues that chapters 1 to 7 are an overture, in the strict sense: they state the themes the rest of the book will develop, and they demonstrate those themes on a small scale before the large scale arrives. Hannah's song in chapter 2 announces a God who inverts positions — the armed are broken, the hungry are filled, the barren bears seven, the poor are seated with princes. The narrative then inverts three positions in quick succession. A priestly dynasty holding a hereditary office is destroyed. The ark of the covenant, the object at the centre of Israel's worship, is captured by Philistines and paraded in the temple of another god. And a child with no lineage claim, who at the start of chapter 3 does not yet recognise God's voice, ends the chapter as the prophet through whom, in the book's own words, God speaks to all Israel from Dan to Beersheba.
The lecture also has two more technical tasks. The first is to face the question of whether Hannah's song was written for its present position or is an older poem placed here — a genuine scholarly disagreement with real evidence on both sides, and a good early example of the kind of question this course keeps meeting. The second is to examine chapters 4 to 6, the account of the ark's capture and return, which for a century has been the leading candidate in these books for a section that was once an independent composition. Whether it was is worth deciding carefully, because the reasons offered are exactly the reasons that will be offered in the next lecture about chapters 8 to 12, and it is easier to weigh them here, where nothing theological hangs on the outcome.
One thing this lecture will not do is treat chapters 1 to 7 as mere background to the monarchy question. They set up that question, but they are also making claims of their own — about how God deals with institutions that have become secure, about what happens to a sacred object when the people holding it treat it as a weapon, and about what it means that the word of God can become, in the narrator's arresting phrase, precious — that is, rare.
What these 39 minutes give you
- Explain how the song of Hannah functions as an overture to 1 Samuel, identifying at least three of its themes and where each returns in the book.
- State the case for and against the view that the song was composed independently of its present setting, naming representatives of each position.
- Describe the offences of Eli's sons and the oracle against Eli's house, and set out the main proposals about who the promised faithful priest is.
- Explain what the call narrative of chapter 3 establishes about Samuel, and what the phrase about the rarity of God's word in that period implies about the situation the book describes.
- Set out the argument that chapters 4 to 6 were once an independent ark narrative, name its principal advocates and its critics, and state what kind of evidence would count for and against.
Yahweh kills, and makes alive. He brings down to Sheol, and brings up. Yahweh makes poor, and makes rich. He brings low, he also lifts up. He raises up the poor out of the dust. He lifts up the needy from the dunghill, To make them sit with princes, and inherit the throne of glory. For the pillars of the earth are Yahweh’s. He has set the world on them. — 1 Samuel 2:6-8
World English Bible
Those who strive with Yahweh shall be broken to pieces. He will thunder against them in the sky. “Yahweh will judge the ends of the earth. He will give strength to his king, and exalt the horn of his anointed.” — 1 Samuel 2:10
WEB
The child Samuel ministered to Yahweh before Eli. Yahweh’s word was precious in those days; there was no frequent vision. — 1 Samuel 3:1
WEB
Now the sons of Eli were base men; they didn’t know Yahweh. — 1 Samuel 2:12
WEB
She named the child Ichabod, saying, “The glory has departed from Israel”; because the ark of God was taken, and because of her father-in-law and her husband. — 1 Samuel 4:21
WEB
The men of Beth Shemesh said, “Who is able to stand before Yahweh, this holy God? To whom shall he go up from us?” — 1 Samuel 6:20
WEB
Samuel spoke to all the house of Israel, saying, “If you do return to Yahweh with all your heart, then put away the foreign gods and the Ashtaroth from among you, and direct your hearts to Yahweh, and serve him only; and he will deliver you out of the hand of the Philistines.” — 1 Samuel 7:3
WEB
The centre of the song, and the sentence the rest of the book will illustrate. Notice that the reversals run both directions. This is not a poem about the poor being lifted; it is a poem about positions being unstable because they are held at somebody else's pleasure. That cuts against a priestly dynasty and a royal one alike.
The last line of the song, and the reason the song is discussed as much as it is. There is no king in Israel at this point in the story, and there will not be one for another six chapters. The word rendered anointed is Hebrew mashiach, from which the English word Messiah comes; at this stage it means simply a person marked out by anointing with oil, most often a king or a priest, with none of the later expectations attached.
Precious here translates Hebrew yaqar, which covers both "costly" and "scarce" — the two senses meet in the idea of something rare enough to be valuable. The point is not that revelation was treasured; it is that there was hardly any. The opening sentence of the call narrative tells you the state of the institution before it tells you anything about the boy.
Four words in Hebrew for the verdict, and the phrase didn't know Yahweh is deliberate: these are the men who conduct Israel's worship.
The lowest point of the first half of the book, spoken by a dying woman in childbirth. The name means something like where is the glory? or no glory. Note the order of the reasons the narrator gives: the ark first, the family second.
The ark comes home and the town that receives it wants it moved on. Whatever else these chapters are doing, they are not a story about a talisman recovered.
Chapter 7 ends the overture by showing the older arrangement working: a prophet-judge, a national repentance, a deliverance. Hold this in mind for the next lecture. The demand for a king in chapter 8 follows immediately on a chapter that says the existing system succeeded.
1. A song placed at the front of a book
Hannah's song occupies 2:1-10, and almost nothing in it is about Hannah. There is one line that fits her situation exactly — the barren has borne seven — and the rest is about warfare, wealth, poverty, the grave, the stability of the earth, and, in the final verse, a king. A woman who has just handed over a small boy to a sanctuary does not obviously need a stanza about the bows of the mighty being broken.
That mismatch is the whole scholarly question, and it is worth stating both answers properly.
This is a point where readers will not agree. P. Kyle McCarter Jr., in the Anchor Bible commentary on 1 Samuel, takes the majority critical view: the song is an older poem, probably a royal or victory psalm, which existed independently and was inserted here by an editor who saw the connection with the barrenness line and with the theme of reversal. The evidence is internal. The poem's language is archaic, its concerns are military and royal, its structure is that of a thanksgiving psalm rather than a personal prayer, and its final verse presupposes a monarchy that the narrative has not yet produced. On this reading the song is a splendid piece of early Hebrew poetry, and its position in 1 Samuel 2 is an editorial achievement rather than an authorial one.
Robert Alter, in The David Story, does not dispute that the poem may be older. He disputes what follows from that. The technique of putting a poem at a structural hinge, and of choosing one whose language exceeds the immediate situation, is used repeatedly in Hebrew narrative — the Song of the Sea in Exodus 15, the Song of Deborah in Judges 5, David's lament in 2 Samuel 1. In each case the poem is doing work the surrounding prose cannot do: it states the meaning of the episode in a register the narrative does not use. Whether the composer wrote the poem or found it is, on this account, a question about the history of the text, not about how the text works. What matters is that somebody put a poem about God overturning the mighty at the entrance to a book in which a priesthood, a sanctuary and a king are all overturned in turn.
Both positions are held by serious scholars and neither is a defensive manoeuvre. It is worth noticing what they do not dispute: that the song's themes match the book, and that the placement is deliberate. The disagreement is over origin, not over function.
There is a third observation which belongs to neither camp and is often mentioned in passing: the song stands in a clear relationship with the Magnificat, the song of Mary in Luke 1:46-55, which speaks of the mighty being put down from their seats and the humble exalted, the hungry filled and the rich sent away empty. The relationship runs one direction — Luke's Greek is written in the idiom of the Greek Old Testament, and the parallels with Hannah are unmistakable and evidently intended. What that shows for our purposes is that the earliest Christian readers took Hannah's song to be about reversal as a pattern of divine action, and not about one woman's fertility. They were reading it the way the placement invites.
2. The house of Eli
The narrator's treatment of Eli's sons is unusually direct. Hebrew narrative normally withholds moral judgement and lets the action speak; here the judgement comes first, in 2:12, before a single incident is described. Then the incidents follow, and they are specific.
The first is a matter of portions. In 2:13-16 the sons send a servant with a three-pronged fork while the meat is boiling and take whatever it brings up, and if the worshipper objects that the fat should be burnt first, they threaten to take it by force. This is not petty. In the sacrificial system the fat portions belong to God and are burnt; the priests receive a defined share afterwards. What is described is priests helping themselves ahead of God and enforcing it with threats against the people who came to worship. The narrator's summary in 2:17 is that the men despised the offering of Yahweh, and that the sin was very great.
The second is sexual: 2:22 reports that they lay with the women who served at the entrance of the tent of meeting. Eli rebukes them — 2:23-25 preserves the rebuke, and it is not weak — and they do not listen.
Then comes the difficult clause at the end of 2:25: they did not listen to their father, because Yahweh intended to kill them. The narrator offers this as an explanation, and it is the kind of sentence that a modern reader stops at. It belongs to a pattern found elsewhere in these books — Pharaoh's hardened heart, the spirit sent to deceive Ahab's prophets in 1 Kings 22 — in which a judgement already determined is carried out partly through the offender's own continuing refusal. Stating what the text says is the first duty here; explaining how it can be just is a genuine problem in these books, and one that chapter 12 of this course returns to when it examines the limits of the retribution scheme.
The oracle against Eli's house arrives twice, from two mouths. An unnamed man of God delivers it in 2:27-36, and the boy Samuel receives it again in 3:11-14. The doubling is itself informative: it means the announcement is confirmed prophetically before it is executed, which is how these books normally handle a major reversal.
The oracle's centre is 2:30, and it is a striking sentence for a book that will spend the rest of its length on hereditary office. God had said Eli's house would walk before him forever; God now says be it far from me, and states a different principle: those who honour me I will honour, and those who despise me shall be lightly esteemed. A promise of permanence is revoked. If you are reading forward to the promise made to David in 2 Samuel 7, which chapter 6 of this course examines, file this away: 1 Samuel has already shown a perpetual grant being withdrawn, and it did so at the start of the book.
Then 2:35 promises a faithful priest with a sure house who will walk before God's anointed. Who is meant?
This is a point where readers will not agree. The dominant critical answer, argued by McCarter and widely followed, is Zadok, the priest whom Solomon installs in 1 Kings 2:35 after removing Abiathar — and 1 Kings 2:27 says explicitly that the removal of Abiathar fulfilled the word spoken against the house of Eli at Shiloh. That cross-reference is about as close to an internal interpretation as these books ever provide, and it is decisive for many readers. On this account the oracle is at least partly a retrospective of the Zadokite priesthood that served the Jerusalem temple.
A second answer, found in patristic and later Christian and Jewish commentary alike, takes the figure more broadly: the promise is of a faithful priesthood rather than a named individual, and the Kings passage is one stage of its fulfilment rather than its exhaustion. Walter Brueggemann argues along these lines that the oracle establishes a criterion — faithfulness, not descent — which then judges everyone who follows, including Zadok's successors.
A third reading, less common but not without support, sees Samuel himself as the immediate referent, since he is the one who immediately takes over the sanctuary functions and stands before the anointed king. The difficulty is that Samuel's own sons prove corrupt in 8:3, so a sure house fits him poorly.
The three readings are not mutually exclusive, and the point for a student is to notice what kind of evidence each rests on: the first on an explicit cross-reference in Kings, the second on the logic of the oracle itself, the third on narrative sequence.
3. The call of Samuel
Chapter 3 is short and famously well told, and the details matter.
The setting is night in the sanctuary at Shiloh, with the lamp of God not yet gone out — a detail that fixes the time as just before dawn and, given what has just been said about the rarity of vision, functions as an image as well. Eli's eyes have begun to grow dim; he cannot see. Samuel does not yet know Yahweh, in the sense the narrator specifies in 3:7: the word of Yahweh had not yet been revealed to him. So the boy who will become the prophet begins the chapter in the same condition as the priest's sons, who didn't know Yahweh — except that the narrator uses the phrase for the sons as a moral verdict and for Samuel as a simple statement of fact.
Three times Samuel is called and three times he runs to Eli. The third time, Eli understands. And the old man, whose house has just been condemned, tells the boy exactly what to say:
Yahweh came, and stood, and called as at other times, “Samuel! Samuel!” Then Samuel said, “Speak; for your servant hears.” — 1 Samuel 3:10 (WEB)
The message Samuel then receives is the judgement on Eli. In the morning Eli asks what was said and insists on hearing all of it, and Samuel tells him everything. Eli's response — that it is Yahweh, let him do what seems good — has been read as resignation and as faith, and the text does not say which. What the scene establishes is procedural rather than emotional: it shows a transfer of authority in which the outgoing figure instructs his replacement in how to receive the word that will destroy him. Whatever else Eli is, the narrator does not make him a fool.
The chapter closes with a summary that is easy to read past:
Samuel grew, and Yahweh was with him, and let none of his words fall to the ground. All Israel from Dan even to Beersheba knew that Samuel was established to be a prophet of Yahweh. — 1 Samuel 3:19-20 (WEB)
Two things follow. First, the criterion of a true prophet stated in Deuteronomy 18:22 — that his word comes to pass — is here applied to Samuel as a narrative fact. Second, and this will matter greatly in the next lecture, the narrator has told us that Samuel is known throughout the country, from the northern to the southern limit of the standard formula. Six chapters later, in 9:6-14, Saul's servant will have to explain to Saul who the man of God in the town is, and the two of them will scrape together a quarter shekel of silver as a consultation fee. Some explanation of that is required, and the explanations offered are the subject of lecture 5-2.
4. The ark narrative: chapters 4 to 6
Now the section that has generated a distinct literature of its own.
At 4:1 the story leaves Samuel entirely. He is not mentioned again until 7:3. In the intervening chapters, Israel loses a battle at Aphek, sends for the ark from Shiloh, loses a second and far worse battle with the ark present, and Hophni and Phinehas are killed carrying it. Eli, sitting by the road, hears the news and falls backwards off his seat and dies. Phinehas's wife goes into labour, names the child Ichabod, and dies. The ark is taken to Ashdod, placed in the temple of Dagon, and the statue of Dagon is found fallen and then broken. Plague follows the ark from city to city. The Philistines convene their priests and diviners, who advise sending it back on a new cart drawn by two milk cows separated from their calves, with a guilt offering of gold models of the tumours and the mice. The cows walk straight to Beth Shemesh without turning aside. And then the men of Beth Shemesh are struck for looking into the ark, and they send it on to Kiriath Jearim, where it stays for twenty years.
The case that this was once an independent composition was made most influentially by Leonhard Rost in 1926 — the same study in which he proposed the Succession Narrative that lecture 6-3 will examine — and developed at length by Antony F. Campbell in The Ark Narrative. The arguments are these. The section has its own protagonist, and it is not a person: the ark acts, and the human characters react to it. The leading Israelite characters of the surrounding book are absent; Samuel, who dominates chapters 1 to 3 and 7 to 12, does not appear. The section has a clean beginning and a clean end, and its end is not where 1 Samuel needs it: the ark reaches Kiriath Jearim and stays there, unresolved, until 2 Samuel 6 picks it up when David brings it to Jerusalem. Rost accordingly treated 1 Samuel 4:1b-7:1 and 2 Samuel 6 as two halves of one work. The style is distinct, and the theology is unusual for these books: God's honour is vindicated among foreign gods without any Israelite agent doing anything at all.
Patrick D. Miller and J. J. M. Roberts, in The Hand of the Lord, accepted the independence but proposed a different purpose. They argued that the composition answers a specific charge. When a city fell in the ancient Near East its gods were understood to have been defeated or to have abandoned it; Mesopotamian texts describe exactly this, and the return of a captured divine statue was a standard theme. The ark narrative, on their reading, is Israel's counter-statement: Yahweh was not defeated, Yahweh left deliberately as judgement on Eli's house, and Yahweh humiliated Dagon in his own temple without an Israelite army present. The narrative is a theological polemic composed in response to the loss of Shiloh.
The case against independence is less often set out and deserves a hearing. Lyle Eslinger and others reading chapters 1 to 12 as a rhetorical unit point out that the ark section is not free-floating at all: it executes the oracle delivered in chapters 2 and 3. The man of God said both of Eli's sons would die on one day (2:34); chapter 4 kills them on one day. The book has set up a judgement and then carried it out, which is the ordinary structure of these narratives rather than evidence of a seam. Further, the absence of Samuel is exactly what the story needs — the point is that no Israelite delivers the ark — and an author capable of the ironies in chapters 4 to 6 is capable of removing his main character for three chapters on purpose.
How would one decide? Honestly, not easily, and this is worth saying plainly. Style-based arguments for separate authorship are weak in a corpus this small. The strongest single piece of evidence for Rost's proposal remains the fact that the story is unfinished where it stops and finished in 2 Samuel 6; the strongest against it is that the section discharges a debt the surrounding book incurred. A reader may reasonably conclude that an older ark composition has been used, skilfully, to do a job in the present book — which is what a good many commentators do conclude, and which is not a compromise so much as a recognition that "inherited" and "integrated" are not opposites.
5. Two details worth pausing on
The number at Beth Shemesh. The WEB rendering of 6:19 reads that God struck fifty thousand seventy men. The figure is impossible for the site: Beth Shemesh in this period was a modest town, and estimates of its population run to a few hundred. The Hebrew text here is awkward — the two numbers stand side by side without the usual connective — and a number of Hebrew manuscripts, along with Josephus in the first century AD, have only seventy. Most critical commentators regard the fifty thousand as an intrusion into the text. Trap number four of this course applies: a population or casualty figure you cannot defend is a defect, and the honest course is to report the figure the text carries, report the difficulty, and not build anything on it.
Shiloh. The narrative never says Shiloh was destroyed. It says the ark left and never returned there, and 1 Samuel 22 later shows the surviving priest of Eli's line at Nob, not Shiloh. But Jeremiah 7:12 tells Judah to go to Shiloh and see what God did to it, which presupposes a well-known ruin. Excavation at Khirbet Seilun, the accepted site, has found a destruction layer that the Danish excavators of the 1920s and Israel Finkelstein's excavations in the 1980s both dated to roughly the middle of the eleventh century BC. Whether that destruction is the one implied by 1 Samuel 4 is not something excavation can settle — the layer shows burning, not a cause — and trap number two of this course warns against promoting archaeology into a judge. What can be said is that the biblical picture of a sanctuary at Shiloh that ceased to function in this general period is consistent with what the site shows, and that consistency is a weaker claim than confirmation.
6. What chapter 7 does, and why it matters for the next lecture
Chapter 7 restores the older arrangement in full. Samuel calls for the removal of foreign gods, gathers Israel at Mizpah, and the Philistines attack while Israel is at worship. The battle is won without a standing army, in the manner of the judges: God thunders, the Philistines are confused, Israel pursues. Samuel sets up a stone and calls it Ebenezer. And the chapter ends with a summary of Samuel's administration — a circuit of Bethel, Gilgal and Mizpah, returning each year to his home at Ramah.
Samuel judged Israel all the days of his life. — 1 Samuel 7:15 (WEB)
Read as the introduction to chapter 8, this is a considerable problem, and lecture 5-2 will show how differently the two main schools of reading handle it. If the arrangement described in chapter 7 was working — the Philistines subdued, justice administered, deliverance granted — then the demand for a king in chapter 8 is not a response to a crisis. It looks like a rejection of something that was functioning. That is precisely the reading chapter 8 itself puts on it. But 8:3 also tells us that Samuel's sons, whom he had installed as judges, took bribes and perverted justice; and 9:16 speaks of a Philistine oppression that chapter 7 said had ended. The overture closes, in other words, with the tension already sounding.
The right column is not an argument that the song was written for this book. It is an argument that whoever put it here understood the book extremely well.
6. Further Reading
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel, Anchor Bible 8 (Doubleday, 1980) — the fullest technical treatment in English of the song of Hannah, the Eli oracle and the ark chapters, with the Qumran readings.
- Robert Alter, The David Story (W. W. Norton, 1999) — the commentary on chapters 1 to 3 is the clearest demonstration of how the opening chapters are constructed as an overture.
- Antony F. Campbell, The Ark Narrative (1 Sam 4-6; 2 Sam 6): A Form-Critical and Traditio-Historical Study (Scholars Press, 1975) — the developed case for the independence of these chapters.
- Patrick D. Miller and J. J. M. Roberts, The Hand of the Lord: A Reassessment of the "Ark Narrative" of 1 Samuel (Johns Hopkins, 1977) — argues the composition answers the ancient assumption that a captured god is a defeated one.
- Lyle M. Eslinger, Kingship of God in Crisis: A Close Reading of 1 Samuel 1-12 (Almond, 1985) — the sustained unified reading, useful precisely where you disagree with it.
- Walter Brueggemann, First and Second Samuel, Interpretation (John Knox, 1990) — theologically alert exposition of the Eli material and the call narrative.
- Israel Finkelstein (ed.), Shiloh: The Archaeology of a Biblical Site (Tel Aviv University, 1993) — the excavation report for the site, for readers who want to see what the stratigraphy does and does not say.
In short
- Chapters 1 to 7 of 1 Samuel work as an overture. Hannah's song says God reverses positions, and the narrative then overturns a priestly house, the ark and the old order of leadership.
- Scholars differ on the song's origin. McCarter sees an older royal psalm placed here, while Alter says placing a poem at a hinge is itself the composer's work. Both agree its fit with the book is deliberate.
- Eli's sons take sacrificial portions by force and lie with the women at the sanctuary. An oracle against Eli's house comes twice. The faithful priest of 2:35 is read as Zadok (McCarter), a faithful priesthood (Brueggemann), or Samuel.
- Samuel is called at night while God's word is rare. Chapters 4 to 6, the ark narrative, may once have been independent (Rost, Campbell, Miller and Roberts), but Eslinger notes it carries out the oracle of 2:34.
- The fifty thousand at Beth Shemesh is a doubtful figure and nothing should be built on it. Chapter 7 shows the old order working, which sets up the tension over a king in chapter 8.
Topic: This lecture reads the opening of 1 Samuel: Hannah's song, the fall of Eli's house, Samuel's call and the ark narrative, as an overture for the book.
Remember: The song says God lifts and brings low, and the book shows both. No position, priestly or royal, is secure at human hands.
Caution: The lecture does not settle whether the song or the ark narrative was once independent, or who the faithful priest is. Archaeology at Shiloh is consistent with the story but does not confirm it.
One line to carry into ministry: Be wary of treating a sacred office, building or object as a guarantee; the book shows God can set it aside.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Read 1 Samuel 2:1-10 aloud and list every line that does not fit Hannah's situation. Then decide which of two conclusions your list supports: that the poem came from elsewhere, or that the poem was chosen because it exceeds the occasion. Say what would make you change your mind.
- The narrator condemns Eli's sons before describing anything they did. What does that departure from the usual reticence of Hebrew narrative achieve, and what does it cost?
- 1 Samuel 2:25 says the sons did not listen *because Yahweh intended to kill them*. Set out what the sentence claims, and then describe two different ways interpreters have tried to make sense of this pattern elsewhere in the Bible. Do not resolve it in a sentence.
- God tells Eli that a promise of a perpetual priestly house is withdrawn. Read 2 Samuel 7:12-16 and ask what 1 Samuel 2:30 implies for how that later promise should be heard.
- Take the three proposals about the identity of the faithful priest in 2:35 and rank them by the kind of evidence each rests on. Which kind of evidence do you find most persuasive in general, and why?
- State Rost's case for an independent ark narrative in your own words without using the word "source." Then state the strongest objection to it. Which parts of the argument survive the objection?
- Chapter 7 says the arrangement under Samuel was working. Chapter 8 says the people demanded a king. Before reading lecture 5-2, write down the explanation that occurs to you first — then keep it and see which of the scholarly positions it turns out to resemble.