FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT605E The Historical Books

Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told

Contents 37
BT605E The Historical Books
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
  1. Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Reading Israel's Story
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
  3. Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Joshua - Entering the Land
  1. Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
  3. Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Judges - The Cycle and Its Collapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Ruth - A Story Set Against the Judges
  1. Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: 1 Samuel - From Judge to King
  1. Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
  2. Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
  3. Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: 2 Samuel - David's Reign
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
  2. Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
  3. Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: 1 Kings - Solomon and the Division
  1. Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
  3. Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: 2 Kings - Two Kingdoms to Two Exiles
  1. Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
  3. Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: 1-2 Chronicles - The Same Story Retold
  1. Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
  2. Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
  3. Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Ezra-Nehemiah - Return and Rebuilding
  1. Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
  2. Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Esther - Survival Without a Named God
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
  3. Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: What the Historical Books Are Doing
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Deuteronomistic History and the Debate About It
  2. Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole
  3. Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

Jump to the key points ↓

47 min

The rebellion of Absalom is the most detailed piece of political narrative in the Hebrew Bible. Nothing else in these books gives so much attention to how power is actually gathered and lost: a prince standing at a city gate for years intercepting petitioners, a conspiracy timed to a religious vow, a capital abandoned overnight, two rival counsellors whose advice decides a war, a priest's sons carrying messages down a well, a battle in a forest that kills more men than the fighting does, and a victory ruined by the victor's grief. It is also, from beginning to end, a family story, and the narrative refuses to let the two levels separate.

This lecture reads that narrative closely and then asks a question about it that has occupied the field for a century. In 1926 the German scholar Leonhard Rost published a short book arguing that 2 Samuel 9-20 together with 1 Kings 1-2 was a single, independent literary work with a single question — who will sit on David's throne after him — written by an author with access to the court, probably in Solomon's reign. He called it the Thronfolgeerzählung, the Succession Narrative. For roughly fifty years this was one of the most secure results in Old Testament study; today every part of it is disputed, including where it begins, where it ends, whether it is one work, when it was written, and whether it is friendly to the dynasty or hostile to it.

The lecture will present Rost's case as strongly as it can be made, then the main criticisms, and then leave the question genuinely open — because the alternatives on offer are incompatible with one another and none commands assent. Along the way it takes up a related question that matters more than it first appears: what is this narrative for? A court apology defending Solomon's accession, a critique of the monarchy, wisdom literature in narrative form, and serious storytelling for its own sake are four answers currently in circulation, and the same text supports all four to some degree, which is itself worth explaining.

Finally, the lecture handles the end of the book. 2 Samuel does not conclude with a successor. It concludes with four chapters of appended material and, last of all, with a census, a plague, and the purchase of a threshing floor.

What these 47 minutes give you

  • Narrate the course of Absalom's rebellion from 2 Samuel 15 to 19, identifying the decisive moments and explaining why each was decisive.
  • Explain the political function of Absalom's action on the palace roof and of the contest between Ahithophel's counsel and Hushai's.
  • State Rost's Succession Narrative hypothesis precisely, including its proposed boundaries, theme, and date.
  • Present at least three distinct lines of criticism of that hypothesis, naming a scholar associated with each.
  • Set out the dispute over whether this narrative defends the dynasty or criticizes it, and give textual evidence used on both sides.
  • Describe the arrangement of 2 Samuel 21-24 and explain why the placement of chapter 24 at the end is significant.

The king was much moved, and went up to the room over the gate, and wept. As he went, he said, “My son Absalom! My son, my son Absalom! I wish I had died for you, Absalom, my son, my son!” — 2 Samuel 18:33

World English Bible

Absalom said to him, “Behold, your matters are good and right; but there is no man deputized by the king to hear you.” Absalom said moreover, “Oh that I were made judge in the land, that every man who has any suit or cause might come to me, and I would do him justice!” It was so, that when any man came near to do him obeisance, he stretched out his hand, and took hold of him, and kissed him. Absalom did this sort of thing to all Israel who came to the king for judgment. So Absalom stole the hearts of the men of Israel. — 2 Samuel 15:3-6

WEB

The king said to Zadok, “Carry back the ark of God into the city. If I find favor in the eyes of Yahweh, he will bring me again, and show me both it, and his habitation; but if he say thus, ‘I have no delight in you;’ behold, here am I. Let him do to me as seems good to him.” — 2 Samuel 15:25-26

WEB

Someone told David, saying, “Ahithophel is among the conspirators with Absalom.” David said, “Yahweh, please turn the counsel of Ahithophel into foolishness.” — 2 Samuel 15:31

WEB

Ahithophel said to Absalom, “Go in to your father’s concubines, that he has left to keep the house. Then all Israel will hear that you are abhorred by your father. Then the hands of all who are with you will be strong.” So they spread Absalom a tent on the top of the house; and Absalom went in to his father’s concubines in the sight of all Israel. — 2 Samuel 16:21-22

WEB

Absalom and all the men of Israel said, “The counsel of Hushai the Archite is better than the counsel of Ahithophel.” For Yahweh had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel, to the intent that Yahweh might bring evil on Absalom. — 2 Samuel 17:14

WEB

When Ahithophel saw that his counsel was not followed, he saddled his donkey, and arose, and went home, to his city, and set his house in order, and hanged himself; and he died, and was buried in the tomb of his father. — 2 Samuel 17:23

WEB

Joab came into the house to the king, and said, “You have shamed this day the faces of all your servants, who this day have saved your life, and the lives of your sons and of your daughters, and the lives of your wives, and the lives of your concubines; in that you love those who hate you, and hate those who love you. For you have declared this day, that princes and servants are nothing to you. For today I perceive that if Absalom had lived, and all we had died this day, then it would have pleased you well. — 2 Samuel 19:5-6

WEB

There happened to be there a base fellow, whose name was Sheba, the son of Bichri, a Benjamite: and he blew the trumpet, and said, “We have no portion in David, neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse. Every man to his tents, Israel!” — 2 Samuel 20:1

WEB

The king said to Araunah, “No; but I will most certainly buy it from you for a price. I will not offer burnt offerings to Yahweh my God which cost me nothing.” So David bought the threshing floor and the oxen for fifty shekels of silver. David built an altar to Yahweh there, and offered burnt offerings and peace offerings. So Yahweh was entreated for the land, and the plague was stayed from Israel. — 2 Samuel 24:24-25

WEB

This is one of very few places in the whole narrative where the narrator states a divine cause. It is worth marking how rare that is, and where it falls.

1. How a rebellion is built

Absalom returns from three years of exile in Geshur, his mother's home territory, and spends two further years in Jerusalem without being received by his father. Joab arranges the reconciliation by means of a staged legal petition — a woman from Tekoa is coached to present David with an invented case about a surviving son who has killed his brother, so that David's own ruling can be turned against him. It is the second time in five chapters that David is trapped by a fictitious lawsuit, and the repetition is not accidental: the narrative is making a point about a king who judges well in the abstract and badly at home.

The reconciliation is a kiss and nothing more. What follows is a long stretch of patient political work, described with unusual specificity. How long is a textual problem: the Masoretic Hebrew of 15:7, which the World English Bible follows, says "at the end of forty years," which cannot be right within David's reign; the Greek, Syriac and some other witnesses read four, and most modern translations and commentators adopt that. Take "four years" as a widely accepted emendation rather than as what the received Hebrew says. Absalom acquires a chariot, horses, and fifty runners — the visible equipment of a king, and the same phrase will be used of Adonijah in 1 Kings 1:5. He rises early and stands beside the road at the gate, which is where legal cases were heard. He intercepts petitioners, asks each what tribe he is from, tells each that his case is good and right, and then observes that there is nobody appointed by the king to hear it. And he adds the wish: if only I were judge in the land.

Three things are being done here, and students should be able to name all three. First, he is exploiting a genuine administrative failure. The complaint that there is no one deputized to hear cases is either true or plausible enough to be believed, and the narrative does not deny it. A kingdom that has grown from a tribal federation into something larger has an unbuilt judicial system, and the man promising to fix it is promising something real. Second, he is targeting the north — "what tribe are you from" is a question that lets him tailor his approach, and the men who rally to him are men of Israel rather than of Judah. Third, he refuses obeisance and gives a kiss instead: an heir behaving as an equal to commoners while his father behaves as a king. The narrator's summary is a striking metaphor: he stole the hearts of the men of Israel.

The coup itself is launched under cover of a vow to be paid at Hebron — David's own first capital, and a place with reasons of its own to be discontented at having been superseded by Jerusalem. Absalom sends agents through the tribes with instructions to proclaim him at the sound of the trumpet. Two hundred men from Jerusalem go with him as guests, not knowing anything about it, which makes them hostages to appearances. And he sends for Ahithophel, David's counsellor, who is at his own town.

David's response is to leave the city immediately. The narrative gives no siege, no defence of the walls, only a rapid evacuation with the household, the professional troops, and the priests. Whether this is panic, strategic sense (Jerusalem's water supply was vulnerable and its population uncertain), or a wish to spare the city, the text does not say — again, the characteristic withholding. What it does report at length is the sequence of encounters on the road: Ittai the Gittite, a foreign mercenary who refuses to leave; Zadok and Abiathar with the ark, whom David sends back with the sentence quoted above; Hushai, sent back to give bad advice; Ziba, with supplies and an accusation against his master; and Shimei, a Benjamite of Saul's family, walking along the ridge cursing David as a man of blood and throwing stones, whom David refuses to have killed on the grounds that Yahweh may have told him to curse.

The ark scene deserves a moment. David sends the national shrine back into the city he is fleeing, and says why: if I find favour, he will bring me back; if not, let him do what seems good. It is the one unambiguous statement of religious submission in the whole rebellion, and it stands out precisely because the narrative is otherwise so reticent about David's inner life. It is also, of course, tactically useful — the priests in the city become an intelligence network, and the text says so two verses later. Both things are true at once, and neither cancels the other. That combination is characteristic of this narrative and is one reason it resists being classified as either praise or attack.

2. The roof, and the two counsels

Absalom enters Jerusalem without resistance and asks Ahithophel what to do first. The advice is to go in publicly to the ten concubines David left to keep the house. Ahithophel's stated reason is political and precise: all Israel will hear that you have made yourself odious to your father, and the hands of your followers will be strengthened. In the ancient Near East, taking a predecessor's harem was a claim on his position — the same logic appears when Abner is accused over Saul's concubine in 2 Samuel 3:7 and when Adonijah's request for Abishag is treated by Solomon as a bid for the throne in 1 Kings 2:22. The point of doing it in public is that it burns the bridge: after this, no reconciliation is possible, and men who have committed themselves to Absalom know there is no way back.

The narrator sets a tent on the roof for the purpose and says it was in the sight of all Israel. This fulfils Nathan's word in 12:11-12, and it happens on the roof from which David first saw Bathsheba. The narrative does not comment. It does not need to.

Then comes the strategic decision that loses the war. Ahithophel — whose counsel the narrator says was regarded in those days as if a man had inquired of the oracle of God — advises an immediate pursuit that night with twelve thousand men, striking David while he is weary, killing only the king, and bringing the people back. It is excellent advice. Speed is Absalom's only real advantage; David's professional troops are the best in the country but few, and the rebellion's momentum depends on David never having time to organize.

Hushai, David's man, argues the opposite: that David and his men are seasoned fighters, dangerous when cornered, that a first setback would panic the levy, and that Absalom should instead gather all Israel from Dan to Beersheba and lead them in person. The speech is a masterpiece of flattery disguised as caution, and it works. The narrator then adds the sentence that changes the register of the whole account: for Yahweh had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel, to bring evil on Absalom.

God and ordinary causes

This is worth pausing over. Across some twenty chapters of extremely dense narrative, direct statements of divine causation are very rare — this one, the evaluation at 11:27, and the note that Yahweh loved Solomon are close to the whole list. Rost himself made much of this reticence. The narrative shows God working through ordinary political and psychological causes: a good adviser's advice is rejected because a vain man prefers the flattering option. The theological claim and the human explanation are laid on top of each other without friction, and the narrator makes no attempt to say how they relate.

Ahithophel's response is one of the coldest sentences in the Hebrew Bible. He sees his counsel was not followed, saddles his donkey, goes home to his city, sets his house in order, and hangs himself. Everything in that verse is a considered action, including the last one; he has understood exactly what will happen, and he has time to arrange his affairs. He is buried in his father's tomb. There is no comment.

3. The forest, the oak, and the weeping

David reaches Mahanaim — the same town where Ishbosheth had been made king — is resupplied by three notables including Barzillai, and organizes his forces in three divisions. He intends to go out himself and is told not to. His last instruction, given in the hearing of the whole army, is to deal gently with the young man Absalom.

The battle is fought in the forest of Ephraim, and the narrative reports that the forest devoured more people that day than the sword devoured. That is not a metaphor: an untrained levy in broken wooded country, against professionals, dies of the terrain. Twenty thousand are reported dead.

Absalom, riding a mule, passes under a great oak and his head catches in the branches; the mule goes on and leaves him hanging between sky and earth. A soldier sees him and reports it to Joab, and their exchange is one of the sharper pieces of dialogue in the book: Joab asks why the man did not kill him and offers a reward; the man replies that he heard the king's order in front of everyone, and that if he had done it Joab would have stood back and let him take the blame. Joab does not argue. He takes three darts and thrusts them into Absalom's heart, and ten of his armour-bearers finish it. The body is thrown into a pit and covered with stones — the burial of a criminal, and the deliberate opposite of the monument Absalom had raised for himself, mentioned two verses later.

The reporting of the death is handled with extraordinary care. Ahimaaz wants to run with the news; Joab, who knows what the news is, sends a Cushite instead and then lets Ahimaaz go as well. Ahimaaz arrives first, says the victory is won, and then, asked directly about Absalom, claims he saw a commotion but does not know what it was. The Cushite arrives and answers the question with a diplomatic formula: may the enemies of my lord the king be as that young man is. David does not ask again.

What follows is the moment the whole book is remembered for. He goes up to the chamber over the gate and weeps, and the words are given twice, once in chapter 18 and once in chapter 19, with the repetitions of "my son" varying slightly between them. The army, returning from a victory, hears that the king is grieving, and comes into the city ashamed, like men who have run away.

And then Joab, who has just committed a murder in defiance of a royal order, tells the king the truth. His speech is brutal and correct: you have shamed the men who saved your life and the lives of your household; you love those who hate you and hate those who love you; you have made it clear that if Absalom had lived and all of us had died you would have been content; go out now and speak to your servants, or by morning not one man will remain with you, and that will be worse than everything that has happened to you since your youth. David goes out and sits in the gate.

There is no better single scene in these books for the question the chapter began with. David's grief is the most human thing in the narrative and the most politically ruinous; Joab's intervention is the most callous thing in the narrative and saves the kingdom; and the narrator, as always, evaluates neither.

4. The return, and a rebellion that shows what has broken

The restoration is not clean, and the narrative dwells on the negotiation. David has to court the elders of Judah to invite him back, which he does through the priests, and he offers Absalom's commander Amasa the position of army chief — a direct provocation to Joab, and one Joab will answer with a knife in chapter 20. Shimei comes to meet him and is pardoned. Ziba and Mephibosheth both appear with incompatible accounts of the same events, and David's ruling — divide the land between them — has been read as fatigue, as shrewdness, and as an admission that he cannot tell who is lying.

Then a quarrel breaks out between the men of Judah and the men of Israel over who has the greater claim to the king, and out of it comes Sheba son of Bichri, a Benjamite, who blows a trumpet and says: we have no portion in David, neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse; every man to his tents, Israel. The men of Israel follow him; the men of Judah stay with David.

Those words are worth memorizing, because they are said again. In 1 Kings 12:16, when the northern tribes reject Rehoboam and the kingdom divides permanently, they say almost exactly the same sentence. The rebellion of Sheba is put down quickly — a wise woman in a besieged town negotiates and throws Sheba's head over the wall, which is one of the few genuinely successful pieces of diplomacy in the book — but the sentence survives. Absalom's revolt and Sheba's revolt together display the fault line that will split the kingdom two generations later, and the narrative places them at the end of David's reign for that reason.

The ten concubines return to a house in Jerusalem, where the text says they were shut up until the day of their death, living as widows though their husband was alive. That verse is the whole notice they receive.

5. Rost's hypothesis, and what happened to it

Now the source-critical question.

The hypothesis. Leonhard Rost, Die Überlieferung von der Thronnachfolge Davids (1926), argued that 2 Samuel 9-20 and 1 Kings 1-2 constitute a self-contained literary work, distinguishable from the material around it by four things: a continuous plot with a single organizing question (who will succeed David), a consistent and unusually developed prose style, a sustained interest in individual psychology, and an almost complete absence of overt divine intervention. He identified the closing verse of 1 Kings 2 — the kingdom was established in the hand of Solomon — as the answer the whole work was written to give, and located the author in or near the Jerusalem court in Solomon's reign, someone with access to what happened inside the palace. Gerhard von Rad developed the theological side of the proposal in a 1944 essay, arguing that this narrative represented a new kind of historiography in which God works through the ordinary chain of human causes rather than by miracle, and connecting it with what he called a Solomonic enlightenment.

The hypothesis was attractive for good reasons. The stylistic difference between these chapters and, say, the ark narrative or the Samson stories is real and can be felt in translation. The plot genuinely does run continuously. And the near-total reticence about divine action genuinely does distinguish these chapters from most of the surrounding material.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Every element of it has been attacked, from several directions at once.

First, the boundaries. Rost's beginning at 2 Samuel 9 has never been secure: chapter 9 opens by referring back to material in the earlier chapters, and many have argued the unit must include chapters 2-4 or 6, or begin at 11, or begin at 13. James Flanagan argued in 1972 that the succession theme was secondary — that the core was a court history about the consolidation of the kingdom, into which the Solomon material was later inserted. Others have questioned the end: 1 Kings 1-2 differ in vocabulary and in interest from 2 Samuel 13-20, and treating them as one work with a single author requires ignoring those differences.

Second, the theme. If the work exists to answer "who will succeed David," it is oddly constructed, because Solomon is barely present for eleven of its chapters. Whole sections — the Ammonite war, Tamar, Sheba, much of the Absalom material — have no visible bearing on the succession. Gillian Keys, in The Wages of Sin (1996), assembled these objections into a sustained argument that the succession theme is imposed on the material rather than derived from it, and proposed instead that the unifying subject is the consequences of David's sin. That reading has the advantage of taking 2 Samuel 12:10-12 as the announced programme of what follows, which the text at least invites.

Third, the genre and purpose. R. N. Whybray, in The Succession Narrative (1968), accepted the unity but redescribed the work as a didactic composition in the spirit of the — teaching about counsel, restraint, the consequences of desire — and as broadly favourable to Solomon. David Gunn, in The Story of King David (1978), rejected the political framing altogether and argued that the work is serious storytelling: traditional narrative art meant to be heard and enjoyed, with themes of giving and grasping running through it, and not a document with a political purpose. If Gunn is right, most of the debate about whether it defends or attacks the dynasty is asking the wrong question of the wrong kind of text.

Fourth, the date. John Van Seters, in In Search of History (1983) and The Biblical Saga of King David (2009), placed the whole David narrative late — a post-Deuteronomistic composition of the Persian period, added to an existing history, and deliberately anti-messianic in effect, showing the founder of the dynasty as a man unfit to be a model. That is the furthest end of the spectrum, and it is a minority position; but it is argued, not asserted, and it demonstrates how much depends on dating. If the narrative comes from Solomon's court it is a near-contemporary document about a living dynasty. If it comes from the Persian period it is a literary reflection on a dynasty four centuries gone. The same sentences mean very different things in the two cases.

6. Court apology, or critique?

This is a point where readers will not agree, and it is the most interesting of the disputes because both sides can point at the same chapters.

Read as apology. Everyone who dies is killed by someone else, and David is repeatedly shown mourning, cursing the killer, or unaware. Abner: Joab. Ishbosheth: two officers, executed by David. Amnon: Absalom. Absalom: Joab, in defiance of an explicit royal order given in front of the whole army. Amasa: Joab again. Shimei and Joab themselves are killed by Solomon, on instructions David gives from his deathbed but does not carry out himself. The Saulide descendants in 2 Samuel 21 are handed over to the Gibeonites at their request, and David is careful to spare Mephibosheth on account of an oath. If you were writing to answer the charge that David and Solomon built a throne on a pile of bodies, this is very close to the document you would write. P. Kyle McCarter made the apologetic case in a restrained form for the rise material; Halpern and McKenzie extend it through the reign.

Read as critique. The same narrative reports, without excuse, that David arranged a murder by letter, that he did nothing when his daughter was raped, that his son's rebellion nearly succeeded, that he had to be spoken to like a fool by his own general to save his throne, and that his last recorded instructions were to arrange two deaths he had personally sworn not to cause. No apologist had to include the letter to Joab. And 1 Kings 1 presents Solomon's accession in terms that are, at a minimum, ambiguous: an old and unaware king, a promise nobody else in the narrative has heard of, and a coalition of Nathan and Bathsheba who arrive in sequence with a coordinated story. Lienhard Delekat and Ernst Würthwein both argued in the 1960s that the work is fundamentally hostile to the dynasty, and that the apparent exculpations are so heavy-handed as to be ironic.

A third option — that the narrative is not primarily doing either, and that its interest is in human beings under pressure rather than in a verdict — is Gunn's, and it explains something the other two struggle with: why the text so consistently declines to evaluate. An apology would praise. A critique would condemn. This narrative reports and stops, and leaves the reader to do the work.

There is no consensus, and a student is not obliged to produce one. What a student should be able to do is say which passages support each reading and what each reading has to explain away.

7. How the book ends

2 Samuel 20 ends with a list of officials, which is where a court history might reasonably stop. But the book has four more chapters, and they are not narrative continuation.

Chapters 21-24 contain six pieces arranged so that the first and last correspond, the second and fifth correspond, and the two poems sit together in the middle: a three-year famine caused by Saul's violation of an oath to the Gibeonites and ended by handing over seven of his descendants; a list of four fights with Philistine champions; a long psalm, essentially identical with Psalm 18; a short poem called the last words of David; a list of the mighty men and their deeds; and the census with its plague. This arrangement has been recognized since at least the work of Karl Budde and was described in its modern form by Hans Wilhelm Hertzberg; it is now a standard observation, though what it means is not agreed.

Two things about the arrangement are worth taking away.

First, the list of the mighty men ends with a name. After a catalogue of thirty-seven heroes it closes: Uriah the Hittite: thirty-seven in all. The narrative has said nothing about him for twelve chapters. Whether this is deliberate placement or the accident of an inherited source list is unresolvable, but the effect on any reader who has read chapter 11 is considerable, and it is worth asking a class what they feel when they reach it.

Second, and more important, the book ends with chapter 24. David orders a census, against the objection of Joab, who asks why the king delights in this thing. The census is completed; David's heart strikes him; he confesses; he is offered a choice of three punishments and chooses to fall into the hand of Yahweh rather than of men; a plague kills a reported seventy thousand. When the destroying angel reaches Jerusalem it is stayed at the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite. David sees the angel and says the sentence that is the moral high point of the book: I have sinned and done perversely, but these sheep, what have they done? Let your hand be against me and against my father's house. He is told to build an altar there, and refuses Araunah's offer of the site as a gift on the ground that he will not offer to God what costs him nothing. He pays fifty shekels of silver. The plague stops.

Three notes on this chapter. The census was probably resented for the reason censuses have always been resented — they precede taxation and conscription — and Joab's objection reads like a soldier's, not a theologian's. The site becomes, in the tradition, the site of the temple; 2 Chronicles 3:1 says so explicitly, and 2 Samuel does not. And the opening verse contains the difficulty this course flagged in Chapter 1: here Yahweh's anger is kindled and he moves David to number Israel, while the parallel in 1 Chronicles 21:1 says that Satan stood up against Israel and moved David. The two accounts also give different totals and different prices for the site. Chapter 9 of this course will take up what that difference means. Note here only that Chronicles has made a change at precisely the point where 2 Samuel is theologically hardest — a God who incites the act he then punishes — and that this is a fact requiring explanation rather than a scandal requiring defence.

Why end here? If Rost is right that a succession narrative runs on into 1 Kings 1-2, then whoever assembled the book of 2 Samuel deliberately interrupted it, and put the interruption at the end. What the reader is left with is not a throne secured but a king confessing, a plague stopped, and a piece of ground bought at full price. Every reader has to decide for themselves whether that is a better ending for the book of David than a coronation would have been. It is at least a more honest one.

The Succession Narrative: Rost's proposal, and what became of it One work or several? Which chapters? For whom, and when? Rost, 1926 — the proposal Unit: 2 Samuel 9-20 + 1 Kings 1-2. Theme: who will sit on David's throne? Answer: 1 Kings 2:46. Date: Solomon's reign. Author: someone with access to the court. Four marks: continuous plot · developed prose style · interest in motive · almost no overt divine action. Von Rad (1944): a new historiography — God working through ordinary human causes. Four lines of criticism BOUNDARIES — ch. 9 looks back; 1 Kgs 1-2 differ in vocabulary. Flanagan (1972). THEME — Solomon is absent for 11 chapters. Keys (1996): the subject is David's sin. GENRE — Whybray (1968): wisdom teaching. Gunn (1978): serious storytelling, not politics. DATE — Van Seters: Persian period, and hostile. Apology or critique? Same chapters. APOLOGY: every rival dies by another hand — Abner, Ishbosheth, Amnon, Absalom, Amasa. David mourns each. Halpern; McKenzie. CRITIQUE: the letter to Joab is included; the king is rebuked by his general; 1 Kgs 1 is ambiguous. Delekat; Wurthwein. Or neither: the text declines to evaluate. The rebellion, moment by moment — and why each moment decided something 15:1-6 Years at the gate (15:7 "forty" in MT; four in LXX). A real administrative gap, exploited. "He stole the hearts of the men of Israel." 15:13-37 Jerusalem emptied overnight. The ark sent back; Hushai sent back; the priests become a message line. 16:22 The roof — an irreversible public claim, and the fulfilment of 12:11-12 on the very roof of 11:2. 17:1-23 Ahithophel's speed vs. Hushai's flattery. Vanity chooses wrong; 17:14 names the divine cause; 17:23 ends it. 18-20: victory, and what it costs The forest kills more than the sword. The oak. Joab's three darts, against a public order. The weeping; Joab's brutal, correct rebuke. 20:1 "We have no portion in David" — said again, and permanently, at 1 Kings 12:16. 21-24: the book refuses to end on a throne Six pieces, matched outward from two poems. The list of heroes closes on "Uriah the Hittite." The last scene: a census, a plague, a confession, and a threshing floor bought at full price — "which cost me nothing" refused.

Take the bottom right panel as an argument, not a summary. If Rost's narrative really did run on into 1 Kings, then somebody chose to interrupt it here, and the choice tells you what that editor thought the book of David was about.

6. Further Reading

  • Leonhard Rost, The Succession to the Throne of David, trans. Michael D. Rutter and David M. Gunn (Almond Press, 1982; German original 1926) — read the original argument rather than summaries of it; it is short.
  • Gerhard von Rad, "The Beginnings of Historical Writing in Ancient Israel," in The Problem of the Hexateuch and Other Essays (Oliver and Boyd, 1966) — the theological development of Rost's proposal.
  • R. N. Whybray, The Succession Narrative: A Study of II Samuel 9-20 and I Kings 1 and 2, SBT 2/9 (SCM, 1968) — the wisdom-literature reading.
  • David M. Gunn, The Story of King David: Genre and Interpretation, JSOTSup 6 (Sheffield, 1978) — the case that this is traditional storytelling rather than a political document.
  • Gillian Keys, The Wages of Sin: A Reappraisal of the "Succession Narrative", JSOTSup 221 (Sheffield, 1996) — the fullest dismantling of the succession theme.
  • John Van Seters, The Biblical Saga of King David (Eisenbrauns, 2009) — the late-dating, anti-dynastic reading; a minority position, argued in detail.
  • Charles Conroy, Absalom Absalom! Narrative and Language in 2 Sam 13-20, Analecta Biblica 81 (Biblical Institute Press, 1978) — a close literary and linguistic study of exactly these chapters.
  • Hans Wilhelm Hertzberg, I and II Samuel, Old Testament Library (SCM, 1964) — still among the clearest treatments of the arrangement of 2 Samuel 21-24.
  • Walter Brueggemann, First and Second Samuel, Interpretation (John Knox, 1990) — for the political and theological reading of the rebellion and of the closing chapters.

In short

  • Absalom built his rebellion slowly. He used a real gap in the king's justice system, targeted the northern tribes, and "stole the hearts" of Israel. David left Jerusalem at once.
  • Absalom's public act on the palace roof made reconciliation impossible. Hushai's flattering advice beat Ahithophel's sound advice, and 2 Samuel 17:14 states that Yahweh ordained this.
  • Joab killed Absalom against the king's order, then rebuked David's grief. Sheba's cry "We have no portion in David" foreshadows the split in 1 Kings 12:16.
  • Rost proposed a Succession Narrative in 2 Samuel 9-20 and 1 Kings 1-2. Critics dispute its boundaries (Flanagan), its theme (Keys), its genre (Whybray, Gunn) and its date (Van Seters).
  • Scholars divide on whether the narrative defends David's dynasty (McCarter, Halpern, McKenzie) or criticizes it (Delekat, Wurthwein). Gunn suggests it simply tells the story without a verdict.
  • 2 Samuel 21-24 is arranged in a matching pattern and ends with the census, a plague and the purchase of a threshing floor, not with a throne secured.

Topic: This lecture reads Absalom's rebellion and the end of 2 Samuel, and asks what the Succession Narrative is, who wrote it, and what it was for.

Remember: The same chapters are read as a defence of David's dynasty, a critique of it, or neither, and Rost's single-work hypothesis is now disputed in every part.

Caution: Rost's hypothesis was once treated as secure. Do not present it as settled, and do not treat the lecture as choosing between apology and critique.

One line to carry into ministry: When a biblical narrator declines to judge, tell the story faithfully and let the listeners do the moral work, as the text does.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Absalom's complaint at the gate is that there is no one appointed by the king to hear cases. Assume the complaint is true. What does that tell you about the state of David's administration, and how does it change your assessment of the rebellion?
  • Ahithophel's advice was better than Hushai's, and 17:14 says Yahweh had ordained that the better advice be rejected. Explain, in your own words, how the narrative holds together a fully human explanation (Absalom's vanity) and a divine one, without either cancelling the other. Find one other place in these chapters where the same double explanation is available.
  • Joab kills Absalom in defiance of an explicit royal order and then rebukes the king for grieving. Write a defence of Joab's conduct in this chapter, then a prosecution. Which was harder to write, and why?
  • State Rost's hypothesis in four sentences. Then choose the criticism of it that you find strongest, state it in four sentences, and say what evidence would settle the matter between them.
  • The same chapters are read as a defence of the dynasty and as an attack on it. Choose three passages and show what each side does with them. Then answer: what would the text have to contain for one of the two readings to become untenable?
  • 2 Samuel 24:1 and 1 Chronicles 21:1 give different accounts of who incited the census. Without reading ahead to Chapter 9 of this course, list every explanation you can think of for the difference, including explanations you do not believe. Which of them could evidence decide?
  • The book ends with a purchase rather than a coronation. Write the alternative ending — 2 Samuel closing at 20:26, with the list of officials — and say what would be lost.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.