FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT605E The Historical Books

Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against

Contents 37
BT605E The Historical Books
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
  1. Introduction: Why These Books Are Called History
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Reading Israel's Story
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Historical Books Are, and What They Are Not
  2. Lecture 1-2: Two Histories of the Same Events: Samuel-Kings and Chronicles
  3. Lecture 1-3: Archaeology, Sources, and What History Can Settle
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Joshua - Entering the Land
  1. Lecture 2-1: Conquest, Infiltration, or Revolt: The Models and Their Evidence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Rahab, Achan, and the Ban
  3. Lecture 2-3: Dividing the Land, and a Covenant at Shechem
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Judges - The Cycle and Its Collapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Pattern: Sin, Oppression, Cry, Deliverer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Deborah, Gideon, Jephthah, Samson
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Closing Chapters and the Refrain About a King
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Ruth - A Story Set Against the Judges
  1. Lecture 4-1: Famine, Loyalty, and a Moabite Woman
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Redeemer, the Threshing Floor, and the Law Behind Them
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Genealogy, and Why the Book Ends With It
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: 1 Samuel - From Judge to King
  1. Lecture 5-1: Hannah, Eli, and the Call of Samuel
  2. Lecture 5-2: Israel Asks for a King: The Case For and Against
  3. Lecture 5-3: Saul's Rise and Rejection
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: 2 Samuel - David's Reign
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Rise of David and the Covenant of 2 Samuel 7
  2. Lecture 6-2: Bathsheba, Nathan, and the Consequences
  3. Lecture 6-3: Absalom, the Succession Narrative, and How It Is Told
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: 1 Kings - Solomon and the Division
  1. Lecture 7-1: Solomon: Wisdom, Temple, and the Cost of Both
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Kingdom Splits, and the Sin of Jeroboam
  3. Lecture 7-3: Elijah, Ahab, and the Contest on Carmel
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: 2 Kings - Two Kingdoms to Two Exiles
  1. Lecture 8-1: Elisha, and Prophets Who Make and Unmake Kings
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Fall of Samaria and the Assyrian Crisis
  3. Lecture 8-3: Josiah's Reform, and the Fall of Jerusalem
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: 1-2 Chronicles - The Same Story Retold
  1. Lecture 9-1: Genealogies, and Who the Chronicler Was Writing For
  2. Lecture 9-2: David and Solomon Without Their Failures
  3. Lecture 9-3: What the Chronicler Adds, Omits, and Why It Matters
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Ezra-Nehemiah - Return and Rebuilding
  1. Lecture 10-1: Cyrus, the Return, and the Second Temple
  2. Lecture 10-2: Nehemiah's Wall, and Governing a Small Province
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Law Read Aloud, and the Marriage Crisis
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Esther - Survival Without a Named God
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Persian Court, the Plot, and the Reversal
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Book That Never Names God
  3. Lecture 11-3: Purim, the Greek Additions, and the Book's Canonical History
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: What the Historical Books Are Doing
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Deuteronomistic History and the Debate About It
  2. Lecture 12-2: Land, Kingship, Temple, Exile: The Theology of the Whole
  3. Lecture 12-3: Reading These Books Honestly Today

Jump to the key points ↓

40 min

Five chapters of 1 Samuel describe how Israel got a king, and they do not agree about whether it should have. This lecture is about that disagreement: what exactly is in the text, how the two great families of explanation account for it, and why neither of them can be dismissed.

The bare data first, because everything depends on getting it right. In chapter 8 the elders come to Samuel and ask for a king. Samuel is displeased; God tells him that the people have rejected God himself; Samuel warns them at length about what a king will take from them; they refuse to listen; God tells Samuel to give them one. In 9:1 to 10:16 the tone changes completely: a young man from Benjamin goes looking for lost donkeys, meets a seer, and God — who has told Samuel in advance, in the language he used about slaves in Egypt — has him anointed as nagid, leader, over Israel. In 10:17-27 Saul is chosen again, this time publicly by lot at Mizpah, in a speech that opens by accusing Israel of rejecting God. In chapter 11 Saul relieves the besieged town of Jabesh Gilead and the narrator does not criticise him once. In 11:14-15 the kingdom is renewed at Gilgal with sacrifices and great rejoicing. And in chapter 12 Samuel delivers a farewell address in which he calls down thunder in the dry season to prove that asking for a king was wickedness, and then tells the people that if they and the king fear God, both will stand.

Two ways of accounting for this dominate the field. The first, descending from Julius Wellhausen, is that two bodies of material with opposite attitudes have been combined, and that the joins can be located. The second, argued in different forms by Robert Alter, Lyle Eslinger, Robert Polzin and V. Philips Long, is that the ambivalence is a compositional strategy rather than an accident of transmission. A third position, associated with Frank Crüsemann, accepts the division of material but reverses the usual dating, treating the anti-monarchic voice as an early protest rather than a late verdict.

This lecture sets out all three at their strongest and does not decide between them. That is not neutrality for its own sake. The evidence they rely on is of different kinds — the source-critical case rests on doublets and inconsistencies of narrative knowledge, the literary case on documented conventions of Hebrew composition — and a reader who has only mastered one will misdescribe the other. It is also worth saying that the choice is not a choice between belief and unbelief. Serious readers within every tradition this course serves hold each of these positions.

What these 40 minutes give you

  • Set out the pro-monarchic and anti-monarchic material in 1 Samuel 8 to 12 block by block, and identify the verses that belong to both categories at once.
  • State the source-critical account in its strongest form, naming its specific evidence (the multiple accessions, the two portraits of Samuel, the two named enemies) and its principal representatives.
  • State the unified-narrative account in its strongest form, explain what "composite artistry" claims, and name its representatives.
  • Explain Crüsemann's reversal of the traditional dating and why it changes the meaning of the anti-monarchic material.
  • Describe precisely what Deuteronomy 17:14-20 permits and restricts, and explain how dating that law earlier or later than 1 Samuel 8 changes what the elders' offence is taken to be.

But the thing displeased Samuel, when they said, “Give us a king to judge us.” Samuel prayed to Yahweh. Yahweh said to Samuel, “Listen to the voice of the people in all that they tell you; for they have not rejected you, but they have rejected me, that I should not be king over them. According to all the works which they have done since the day that I brought them up out of Egypt even to this day, in that they have forsaken me, and served other gods, so do they also to you. Now therefore listen to their voice: however you shall protest solemnly to them, and shall show them the way of the king who shall reign over them.” — 1 Samuel 8:6-9

World English Bible

He said, “This will be the way of the king who shall reign over you: he will take your sons, and appoint them to him, for his chariots, and to be his horsemen; and they shall run before his chariots; and he will appoint them to him for captains of thousands, and captains of fifties; and he will assign some to plow his ground, and to reap his harvest, and to make his instruments of war, and the instruments of his chariots. He will take your daughters to be perfumers, and to be cooks, and to be bakers. He will take your fields, and your vineyards, and your olive groves, even their best, and give them to his servants. — 1 Samuel 8:11-14

WEB

But the people refused to listen to the voice of Samuel; and they said, “No; but we will have a king over us, that we also may be like all the nations, and that our king may judge us, and go out before us, and fight our battles.” — 1 Samuel 8:19-20

WEB

Tomorrow about this time I will send you a man out of the land of Benjamin, and you shall anoint him to be prince over my people Israel; and he shall save my people out of the hand of the Philistines: for I have looked on my people, because their cry has come to me.” — 1 Samuel 9:16

WEB

but you have this day rejected your God, who himself saves you out of all your calamities and your distresses; and you have said to him, ‘No! Set a king over us.’ Now therefore present yourselves before Yahweh by your tribes, and by your thousands.” — 1 Samuel 10:19

WEB

Then Samuel said to the people, “Come, and let us go to Gilgal, and renew the kingdom there.” All the people went to Gilgal; and there they made Saul king before Yahweh in Gilgal; and there they offered sacrifices of peace offerings before Yahweh; and there Saul and all the men of Israel rejoiced greatly. — 1 Samuel 11:14-15

WEB

When you saw that Nahash the king of the children of Ammon came against you, you said to me, ‘No, but a king shall reign over us;’ when Yahweh your God was your king. Now therefore see the king whom you have chosen, and whom you have asked for: and behold, Yahweh has set a king over you. If you will fear Yahweh, and serve him, and listen to his voice, and not rebel against the commandment of Yahweh, then both you and also the king who reigns over you are followers of Yahweh your God. But if you will not listen to the voice of Yahweh, but rebel against the commandment of Yahweh, then will the hand of Yahweh be against you, as it was against your fathers. — 1 Samuel 12:12-15

WEB

When you have come to the land which Yahweh your God gives you, and possess it, and dwell in it, and say, “I will set a king over me, like all the nations that are around me”; you shall surely set him king over yourselves, whom Yahweh your God chooses. You shall set as king over you one from among your brothers. You may not put a foreigner over you, who is not your brother. — Deuteronomy 17:14-15

WEB

Then the men of Israel said to Gideon, “Rule over us, both you, and your son, and your son’s son also; for you have saved us out of the hand of Midian.” Gideon said to them, “I will not rule over you, neither shall my son rule over you. Yahweh shall rule over you.” — Judges 8:22-23

WEB

Four verses containing the whole problem. The request is a rejection of God, on a par with idolatry; and the instruction is to grant it. Note also the reason God gives Samuel for not taking it personally, which is not flattering to anyone.

The Hebrew phrase behind the way of the king is mishpat hammelek, which can mean the king's customary right, the king's manner of ruling, or the judgement passed on kingship — the ambiguity is real and unresolved. Whatever it is called, the content is a list of takings, and the verb take governs six of the eight sentences. Scholars have long noted that the list corresponds closely to what administrative texts from Ugarit and later Israelite practice show royal households actually doing.

Three functions are named: judging, leading out, fighting. Every one of them is something the text has said God or a God-raised deliverer did. That is the reason the request is treated as a rejection, and it is a more precise charge than "they wanted a king."

The other voice. Prince here renders nagid, a word this book prefers to melek, king; it means something closer to designated leader, and much has been made of the difference. The last clause is exodus vocabulary.

Said at the ceremony that makes Saul king. The accusation and the installation are in the same speech.

Unqualified rejoicing, thirty verses after the accusation.

And here the two voices are laid one on top of the other. Verse 12 also contains a chronological difficulty that the lecture will address: Samuel says the request followed the Ammonite threat, but in the narrative as it stands the request comes in chapter 8, three chapters before Nahash appears.

The law of the king, and the words in the people's mouth are nearly the words the elders will use.

The canonical statement of the case against dynastic rule, made two books earlier — by a man whose son Abimelech promptly makes himself king in Shechem and murders his brothers.

1. First, get the data straight

Before any theory, the material. Read the five chapters and sort them.

Hostile to the monarchy. Chapter 8 in its entirety: the request, God's verdict that it is a rejection, the catalogue of royal takings, the people's refusal to hear. 10:17-19, the speech at Mizpah that begins with the exodus and turns into an accusation. 12:12, 12:17 and 12:19-20: Samuel's insistence that asking was wickedness, the sign of thunder and rain during the wheat harvest — in the climate of the Judean hills, rain in late May is close to unknown, which is the whole force of the sign — and the people's confession that they have added this evil to all their sins.

Favourable to the monarchy. 9:1-10:16, the whole account of Saul's discovery and private anointing, in which God takes the initiative, gives a compassionate reason, and identifies Saul as the man who will save Israel from the Philistines. Chapter 11: Saul, seized by the spirit of God, musters Israel, relieves Jabesh Gilead, and then refuses to execute the men who had opposed him. Read chapter 11 on its own and you have a straightforward account of a charismatic deliverer in the mould of the judges, and the narrator's approval is total. 11:14-15, the renewal at Gilgal with sacrifices and rejoicing.

Both at once. 8:7, where the same sentence names the request a rejection of God and orders it granted. 8:22, Listen to their voice, and make them a king. 12:13-14, where Samuel says the people chose wrongly, that God has nevertheless set this king over them, and that king and people together may yet stand if they are faithful. These verses are the reason the problem is genuinely hard. A book that simply alternated approving and disapproving blocks would be much easier to explain than a book with sentences like these.

And two complications that belong to neither list. First, 8:3: Samuel's sons took bribes and perverted justice. That is the narrator speaking, not the elders; the reason given for the request is conceded to be true. Second, 9:16 names the Philistines as the oppressor from whom Saul will save Israel, while 12:12 names Nahash the Ammonite as the occasion of the request — and chapter 7 had already reported that the Philistines were subdued during Samuel's lifetime and did not come again into Israelite territory.

2. The source-critical account, at full strength

This is a point where readers will not agree, and the first position must be given properly rather than summarised into a caricature.

Julius Wellhausen, in the Prolegomena to the History of Israel (1878, English 1885), set out the classic form. Two sources lie behind chapters 8 to 12: an early one, close to the events and favourable to the monarchy (9:1-10:16 and chapter 11), and a later one, hostile (chapter 8, 10:17-27, chapter 12), written from a standpoint that already knew how the monarchy ended. On this reading the hostile material is not eyewitness reflection on a decision being taken; it is a verdict delivered after two kingdoms had fallen, projected back into the mouth of Samuel.

The evidence is specific and it is not weak.

Saul is made king three times. He is anointed privately near Zuph in 10:1, selected by lot at Mizpah in 10:20-24, and made king at Gilgal in 11:15. Three procedures — prophetic anointing, sacred lot, popular acclamation — in three places. And 11:14 says renew the kingdom, a word which several critics regard as an editorial stitch inserted precisely to reconcile a third accession with the earlier two.

Samuel is two different people. In 3:20 all Israel from Dan to Beersheba knows he is a prophet. In 7:15-17 he judges Israel from a fixed circuit for his whole life. But in 9:6-10 Saul, who lives at Gibeah a few hours' walk away, has never heard of him; his servant knows of a man of God in the town; they worry about having nothing to bring and produce a quarter of a shekel of silver as a fee; and the narrator inserts a note explaining that people used to say seer where they now say prophet. That note is itself revealing: someone thought the vocabulary of this passage needed explaining to a later reader. A local seer paid in small silver and a national judge known from Dan to Beersheba are not easily the same portrait.

The enemy is not the same enemy. The oppressor in 9:16 is Philistine; the crisis that produces the demand in 12:12 is Ammonite; chapter 7 has already said the Philistines were subdued.

The hostile material shares vocabulary and outlook with Deuteronomy and Kings. Chapter 12 in particular — a farewell speech, a recital of the exodus and the judges, a condition with blessing and curse, a warning that both people and king will be consumed — has the shape and phrasing that Martin Noth identified as the work of the Deuteronomistic Historian, the single exilic editor he proposed for the whole run from Deuteronomy to Kings. Lecture 12-1 examines that hypothesis and its later modifications; here the point is narrower. Chapter 12 does not read like an eleventh-century document, and the strongest form of the source-critical case rests on that observation rather than on the doublets alone. Bruce C. Birch, in The Rise of the Israelite Monarchy, works this out in detail; Timo Veijola pressed it further, assigning most of the anti-monarchic material to Deuteronomistic hands and leaving very little early hostile tradition at all.

A student should be able to state this case without hedging it. It is built on observable features of the text, and the observations are correct: the accessions really are three, the two portraits of Samuel really are hard to combine, and chapter 12 really does sound like Deuteronomy.

3. The unified-narrative account, at full strength

The literary reading does not begin by denying any of that. It begins by asking what follows from it.

Robert Alter's formulation is the most useful. In The Art of Biblical Narrative he describes what he calls composite artistry: the practice, visible throughout the Hebrew Bible, of setting variant accounts of the same thing beside one another rather than merging them. Genesis opens with two creation accounts and does not reconcile them. The flood story runs two sets of numbers together. Ancient Hebrew writers evidently did not share the modern assumption that a single coherent version is always preferable to two versions in tension. If that is the convention, then the presence of divergent materials in 1 Samuel 8 to 12 is not by itself evidence that nobody was in charge of the result. It may be evidence of what being in charge looked like.

Alter presses a second point about chapter 8 in particular. The catalogue of royal takings is not a general denunciation; it is a specific and accurate description of a bureaucratic monarchy, and it is placed in the mouth of the man who is about to install one. Someone assembled that. And 8:7, where the rejection and the grant occupy one sentence, is not a seam between sources — it is a single sentence, and no division of the text can put its halves in different documents.

Lyle Eslinger, in Kingship of God in Crisis, reads chapters 1 to 12 as one continuous rhetorical unit and argues that the apparent contradictions dissolve when you attend to who is speaking. The narrator, God, Samuel and the people each have positions, and those positions differ. Samuel's hostility is Samuel's; he is an old man whose sons have just been rejected as his successors, and the text tells us in 8:6 that the thing displeased him before God says anything. God's response in 8:7 can be read as consolation to a wounded man as much as a theological verdict. On this reading the book is not ambivalent; the book is reporting a disagreement among its characters with great precision, and readers have been mistaking the characters' voices for the book's.

Robert Polzin, in Samuel and the Deuteronomist, takes a different unified route: the whole is ironic, and the irony is directed at the reader's desire for a straight answer. V. Philips Long, in The Reign and Rejection of King Saul, argues on narrative-critical grounds that the sequence from chapter 8 through chapter 15 is coherent as it stands, with each stage of Saul's installation serving a distinct function — designation, confirmation, and inauguration — a pattern he compares with other ancient accession sequences.

That last point is worth weighing carefully, because it is the strongest counter to the doublet argument. A three-stage accession is not intrinsically implausible. Private designation by a prophet, public confirmation by a sacred procedure, and popular inauguration after a proving victory is a sequence that makes political sense; the text itself distinguishes the stages, and the Gilgal ceremony explicitly renews what already exists rather than creating it. Whether you find this convincing depends largely on whether you think 11:14's word renew is an author's link or an editor's patch — and that is not a question the word itself can settle.

4. A third position: the protest may be the early voice

Frank Crüsemann, in Der Widerstand gegen das Königtum (1978), accepted that distinguishable material lies behind these chapters and then attacked the assumption that the hostile strand must be the late one.

His argument runs like this. Opposition to monarchy is not something people only work out in retrospect. It is what those who will pay for a monarchy say while it is being established. The list in 8:11-18 is not a theological abstraction; it is a schedule of conscription, corvée labour, land expropriation and a ten per cent levy — precisely the burdens a village agricultural economy would feel when a state apparatus is built on top of it. Crüsemann pointed to comparable material elsewhere: Jotham's fable in Judges 9, where the trees ask each useful plant to rule and only the worthless bramble accepts, is an anti-royal parable that fits an early setting far better than an exilic one; Gideon's refusal in Judges 8:23 is another. On this reading the anti-monarchic voice comes from the countryside and from the period of state formation itself, and its preservation in the text is evidence that the argument was live at the time and never entirely lost.

The consequence matters. If Wellhausen and Veijola are right, chapter 8 is a post-mortem: the monarchy failed, and a later theologian explains that it was a mistake from the beginning. If Crüsemann is right, chapter 8 is a contemporary dissent that turned out to be correct, and the book preserves both sides of a real eleventh-century argument. The same words carry a different weight in each case.

You do not have to adopt Crüsemann's conclusion to profit from his objection. Its methodological value is that it exposes a hidden premise in the standard account — that ideological criticism of an institution belongs to the period after that institution's failure. Stated openly, that premise is much less obvious than it looks.

5. Deuteronomy 17 and what the offence actually was

Now to the law that stands behind, or alongside, all of this.

Deuteronomy 17:14-20 anticipates the request. It even anticipates the wording: I will set a king over me, like all the nations that are around me. The elders in 1 Samuel 8:5 ask for a king to judge us like all the nations, and in 8:20 repeat that we also may be like all the nations. Then the law grants what is asked, with conditions. The king must be one whom God chooses and an Israelite. He must not multiply horses — that is, must not build a chariot corps, and specifically must not send to Egypt to do it. He must not multiply wives, and must not greatly multiply silver and gold. And he must write out a copy of the law and read it every day of his life, so that his heart is not lifted above his brothers.

Set that beside 1 Samuel 8:11-18 and the relationship is arresting. Samuel's warning is, almost item for item, a description of a king doing what Deuteronomy 17 forbids: taking sons for chariots and horsemen, taking daughters, taking fields and vineyards, taking a tenth. And, as chapter 7 of this course will show, 1 Kings 10 and 11 will report Solomon doing exactly those things — horses imported from Egypt, seven hundred wives, silver made as common as stones in Jerusalem. Someone in this tradition is working with a coherent set of categories.

This is a point where readers will not agree, and what is at stake is the meaning of the offence in 1 Samuel 8.

If Deuteronomy 17 stands behind the narrative — the position of readers who date the core of Deuteronomy early, and of most who read the as a finished whole — then the institution of monarchy is authorised in advance. Asking for a king is therefore not the sin. The sin lies in the terms of the request. The elders do not ask for the king Deuteronomy describes, a man under the law who reads it daily; they ask for a king who will judge us, and go out before us, and fight our battles — three functions the book has attributed to God — and they ask because they want to be like the nations, which is the opposite of what Deuteronomy's conditions are for. On this reading God's word in 8:7 is not a rejection of monarchy but a diagnosis of motive, and 12:14, where a faithful king and a faithful people stand together, is the position the whole narrative has been working towards.

If Deuteronomy 17 is later than the narrative — the common critical view, on which the law of the king belongs with the Deuteronomic legislation associated with the seventh century and the reforms of Josiah, treated in lecture 8-3 — then the direction of influence reverses. The law is a retrospective attempt to domesticate an institution that had already done great damage: it permits a king because there had been kings, and it hedges him about with restrictions drawn from the specific failures of Solomon and his successors. In that case 1 Samuel 8 and Deuteronomy 17 are two products of the same later reflection, and their agreement is not the agreement of a law with its test case but of a school with itself.

Notice that both readings explain the verbal overlap. What they dispute is which text is reacting to which, and that is a dating question, not a theological one. Notice also that neither reading makes the monarchy simply good or simply bad. Deuteronomy 17 permits and restricts; 1 Samuel 8 condemns and grants. Whatever the compositional history, the tradition that produced both was not of one mind.

6. What the chapters do not say

Two clarifications, both of which prevent common errors.

The text never says God's kingship and human kingship are incompatible in principle. It says that in this instance the people preferred the second to the first. 12:14 explicitly imagines both together: fear Yahweh, and both you and the king who reigns over you are followers of Yahweh your God. Any reading which makes 1 Samuel a treatise against monarchy as such has to explain that verse away, and the same tradition will shortly produce 2 Samuel 7.

The complaint about Samuel's sons is never answered. The elders say the sons do not walk in Samuel's ways; the narrator has already confirmed it in 8:3. Samuel's reply in chapter 12 is a defence of his own conduct — whose ox have I taken, whom have I defrauded — and it is a good defence, and it is not to the point, since nobody accused him. The narrative allows the old man his dignity and leaves the actual grievance standing. That is a fine piece of characterisation on any account of the text's origin, and it is the kind of detail that makes the flat labels pro-monarchic and anti-monarchic feel too coarse for what is actually on the page.

7. Why this lecture stops here

You are entitled to ask what the lecturer thinks. The honest answer is that the strongest available position is a limited one: the text contains materials of different origin and outlook, and the arrangement of those materials in the present book is purposeful rather than careless. That much is held, in some form, by a large majority of working scholars across the traditions this course serves, and it concedes the central observation of each camp.

What it does not do is settle the two questions the camps really divide over: whether the hostile material is early protest or late verdict, and whether the tensions in the final text are a composer's design or a compiler's tolerance. Those are questions about dating and about intention, and the evidence available does not close them. Trap number one of this course is that elegance is a warning sign, and there is no more elegant temptation in this book than the offer to explain, in one sentence, how a request can be both an act of rebellion and a gift of God.

Three Accessions, or Three Stages? The same five chapters, sorted twice ch. 8 request · 9:1-10:16 anointing near Zuph · 10:17-27 lot at Mizpah · ch. 11 Jabesh Gilead · 11:14-15 Gilgal · ch. 12 farewell Source-critical reading Wellhausen · Noth · Birch · Veijola Early, favourable: 9:1-10:16, ch. 11 Late, hostile: ch. 8, 10:17-27, ch. 12 Evidence: three accessions; two portraits of Samuel; Philistines vs. Ammonites; ch. 12 sounds like Deuteronomy and Kings "Renew the kingdom" (11:14) = the stitch Unified-narrative reading Alter · Eslinger · Polzin · Long Designation (privately, by a prophet) Confirmation (publicly, by lot) Inauguration (after a victory) Evidence: composite artistry is a documented convention; character voices differ from the narrator's 8:7 cannot be split: one sentence, both views Crüsemann's reversal Accepts the two strands. Denies that the hostile one must be late. Conscription, corvée and a ten per cent levy are what villagers complain about while a state is being built — compare Jotham's fable (Judges 9) and Gideon (Judges 8:23). What each account must explain Source-critical: why 8:7 and 12:13-14 hold both views inside one sentence, and why an editor left the contradiction visible. Unified: why Saul's own neighbour has never heard of the prophet known from Dan to Beersheba, and why ch. 12 speaks exilic language. Neither difficulty is fatal. Neither has been made to disappear. This lecture does not rule between them. The Law of the King and the Warning of Samuel Deuteronomy 17:14-20 · 1 Samuel 8:11-18 · 1 Kings 10-11 Deuteronomy 17 forbids Multiplying horses (and returning to Egypt for them) Multiplying wives Multiplying silver and gold A foreign king and requires He writes out the law himself and reads it every day, so his heart is not lifted up above his brothers. 1 Samuel 8 warns He will take your sons for his chariots He will take your daughters He will take your fields, vineyards, olive groves He will take a tenth You shall be his servants The verb "take" governs almost every line. 1 Kings reports Horses imported from Egypt (1 Kings 10:28-29) Seven hundred wives (1 Kings 11:3) Silver as common as stones (1 Kings 10:27) Forced labour (1 Kings 5:13) Lecture 7-1 takes this up. Both datings explain the overlap. They disagree about direction. Law first: the offence in 1 Samuel 8 is the motive, not the institution. · Narrative first: the law is a later attempt to fence in a king who had already done the damage.

6. Further Reading

  • Julius Wellhausen, Prolegomena to the History of Israel (1885; English translation reprinted, various editions) — read the section on Samuel and Kings in the original rather than in summary; the argument is more careful than its reputation.
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel, Anchor Bible 8 (Doubleday, 1980) — the standard source-critical treatment of these chapters in English, with full text-critical notes.
  • Bruce C. Birch, The Rise of the Israelite Monarchy: The Growth and Development of 1 Samuel 7-15 (Scholars Press, 1976) — the detailed working out of the redactional case.
  • Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative (Basic Books, 1981) and The David Story (W. W. Norton, 1999) — for composite artistry, and for the commentary on chapters 8 to 12.
  • Lyle M. Eslinger, Kingship of God in Crisis (Almond, 1985) — the unified reading that pays closest attention to which character is speaking.
  • Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist (Harper and Row, 1989) — a literary reading that keeps the Deuteronomistic frame and reads it ironically.
  • V. Philips Long, The Reign and Rejection of King Saul (Scholars Press, 1989) — the three-stage accession argument, and the best short answer to the doublet objection.
  • Frank Crüsemann, Der Widerstand gegen das Königtum (Neukirchener, 1978) — for the case that the anti-monarchic voice is early; German only, but summarised in most recent commentaries.
  • Gerald Eddie Gerbrandt, Kingship According to the Deuteronomistic History (Scholars Press, 1986) — argues that the Deuteronomistic writers were not anti-monarchic at all, which is a useful corrective to a common assumption.

In short

  • First Samuel 8 to 12 holds hostile material (chapter 8, 10:17-27, chapter 12), favourable material (9:1-10:16, chapter 11) and verses that are both, such as 8:7, which calls the request a rejection of God yet grants it.
  • The source-critical account (Wellhausen, Noth, Birch, Veijola) points to three accessions, two portraits of Samuel, two enemies, and a chapter 12 that sounds like Deuteronomy. It sees an early favourable source and a late hostile one.
  • The unified account (Alter, Eslinger, Polzin, Long) says placing variant accounts side by side was a normal convention. It reads the accessions as three stages: designation, confirmation and inauguration.
  • Crüsemann accepts the two strands but argues that the hostile one may be an early protest from people who would bear the costs of a state, since the list in 8:11-18 describes conscription, forced labour and levies.
  • Deuteronomy 17 permits a king with limits. If it is earlier, the elders' offence is their motive. If it is later, the law is a later fence around kings. The text never says God's rule and human kingship cannot coexist (12:14).

Topic: This lecture sets out three ways of explaining why 1 Samuel 8 to 12 both condemns and grants the request for a king, and how Deuteronomy 17 bears on it.

Remember: The lecture rules for no side. It holds that the text has materials of different outlook, and that their arrangement in the book is purposeful.

Caution: The chapters do not say kingship is wrong in principle. Whether the hostile strand is early or late, and whether the tensions are design or tolerance, remain open.

One line to carry into ministry: Do not boil 1 Samuel 8 down to "kings are bad" or "kings are good"; ask what the people wanted from a king and why.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Sort 1 Samuel 8 to 12 into three columns — favourable, hostile, both — without using any commentary. Then compare your sorting with the one in the first diagram and account for every difference.
  • State the source-critical case in your own words in a single paragraph, without the words "contradiction" or "error." Then state the unified case the same way, without the words "harmonise" or "unity." What did each restriction force you to notice?
  • Chapter 11 contains no criticism of Saul at all. If you had only chapter 11, what would you conclude the book thinks about kingship? Now ask what it means that this chapter sits between two hostile ones.
  • 1 Samuel 8:7 makes the rejection and the grant one sentence. Explain why this verse is difficult for a strict two-source account, and then explain how a source critic might reasonably answer.
  • Crüsemann argues that opposition to monarchy is what people say while it is being built, not only afterwards. Test this against any historical case you know of a state being established. Does the analogy help or mislead?
  • Read Deuteronomy 17:14-20 and 1 Samuel 8:11-18 side by side and list the correspondences. Then argue, in two paragraphs, first that the law is earlier and then that it is later. Which paragraph required you to assume more?
  • The elders' complaint about Samuel's corrupt sons is never actually answered. What does the narrative gain by leaving it unanswered, and what does that suggest about how carefully these chapters were put together?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.