Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
- Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
- Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
- Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
- Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
- Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
- Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
- Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
- Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
- Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
- Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
- Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
- Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
- Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
- Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
- Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
- Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
- Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
- Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
- Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
A minister is looked at. People notice what is said from the front, how a funeral was led, how a visit went, how a church building looks, how a ministry compares with another. They tell the minister what they noticed, and they tell others. Some of it is kind, some is hard, and some is not true. Over the years a minister learns to live inside this stream of opinion, and the way of living in it can slowly shape the minister's inner life.
This lecture looks at three streams: the minister's own comparing of self with other ministers; praise, and what a minister does with it; and criticism, and how it lands. It asks one question of each. Where does the minister stand while this is going on? If the answer is "on the opinions", then each of the three has power over the minister's peace. If the answer is "on belonging to God" (lecture 2-1), then they are information to be weighed, and they cannot make or unmake the person.
It does not teach a way to stop feeling these things. Ministers are human, and praise pleases and criticism hurts. It looks at what to do with the feeling.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Describe the forms comparison takes among ministers, and what Jesus says to Peter in John 21:20-22.
- Explain why living on praise is a danger and why refusing all praise is also a mistake.
- Describe a way to receive criticism: to pause, to weigh it, and to decide what to do, without being crushed or defensive.
- Explain what it means to be "the minister who needs to be needed", and describe a better path.
- Say how a person giving feedback to a minister can speak about what was done without judging the person.
Peter seeing him, said to Jesus, “Lord, what about this man?”" — John 21:21
World English Bible
Jesus said to him, “If I desire that he stay until I come, what is that to you? You follow me.”" — John 21:22
WEB
They said, “Has Yahweh indeed spoken only with Moses? Hasn’t he spoken also with us?” And Yahweh heard it." — Numbers 12:2
WEB
Now the man Moses was very humble, above all the men who were on the surface of the earth." — Numbers 12:3
WEB
But let each man test his own work, and then he will take pride in himself and not in his neighbor." — Galatians 6:4
WEB
For each man will bear his own burden." — Galatians 6:5
WEB
But with me it is a very small thing that I should be judged by you, or by man’s judgment. Yes, I don’t judge my own self." — 1 Corinthians 4:3
WEB
For I know nothing against myself. Yet I am not justified by this, but he who judges me is the Lord." — 1 Corinthians 4:4
WEB
Peter looks sideways at another disciple and is told to look to his own following. Miriam and Aaron measure themselves against Moses. Paul says that his own verdict and other people's verdicts both fall short of the Lord's, and he does not say they do not matter at all.
1. Comparing
Comparison is one of the oldest habits of people who serve. It takes several forms.
Looking at another minister. A pastor hears that a colleague's church is growing, a priest sees that a neighbouring parish has a full choir, a missionary hears of another worker who learned the language in half the time. A feeling comes, and often it is a mixture. There may be real gladness. There may also be a small sting.
Looking at a predecessor. A minister who comes after a beloved leader may spend years in the shadow of a person who is not there. The people compare, and the minister compares too.
Looking at the ideal. Some compare themselves not with a person but with a picture: the saint in a book, the teacher on a recording, the founder of the movement. A picture never has a bad day.
Looking online. Pictures and posts of other ministries come in a steady stream, and they show the best of each. A minister who looks at them for an hour and then looks at his own parish is comparing the best moments of other people with the ordinary days of his own.
Comparison has two faces, and both are damaging. One is envy: "Why not me? Why do they have what I lack?" The other is contempt: "Look at the way they do it. It is shallow." Contempt is often envy that looks respectable. Both take the minister's attention away from the work given to him and place it on someone else's.
A minister can also be pulled the other way, into trying to imitate. A style that works for one person, in one place, does not always travel. A priest who tries to preach like a famous preacher, or a young pastor who tries to lead like an older one, may find that what he has borrowed does not fit him, and that people can tell.
2. What Jesus says to Peter
The Gospel of John ends with a scene that is worth reading slowly. Jesus has risen. He has met Peter on the shore, has asked him three times whether he loves him, and has told him that his own road will end in a way Peter does not wish (John 21:15-19). Then Peter turns, sees the other disciple, and asks, “Lord, what about this man?” Jesus answers, “If I desire that he stay until I come, what is that to you? You follow me.”
Notice what the scene does and does not say. Peter has just been given something heavy, a task and a hard future. He looks sideways, which is what a person does when the weight is great, and asks about the other. Jesus does not say that the other disciple does not matter. He does not forbid Peter to care about him. He says that the other's road is not Peter's business in this matter. You follow me.
Paul says something near to this in Galatians 6:4-5. "But let each man test his own work, and then he will take pride in himself and not in his neighbor." It is the minister's own work that is to be tested, and a measure that depends on a neighbour is a poor measure. The next verse says, "For each man will bear his own burden." A careful reader should add that Paul has said in the same chapter, a few verses earlier, "Bear one another's burdens" (Galatians 6:2). The two sentences do not argue. They speak of different things: in one, a person must answer for his own life and work; in the other, a person who is carrying too much needs help. Neither says that a minister should be isolated.
In Numbers 12, Miriam and Aaron speak against Moses. Their words show that they are measuring themselves against him: “Has Yahweh indeed spoken only with Moses? Hasn’t he spoken also with us?” The text adds that Yahweh heard it. The text says that Moses was a very humble man (12:3), and that it was God who answered, and Moses who did not defend himself. This should be read with care. It is not a recipe: it does not say that every minister who is criticised should be silent, or that every critic is wrong. It shows, for one situation, a person who was secure enough in his standing that he could leave the answer to God.
3. Praise
Praise is a gift. A person who says, "Your words last week helped me through a hard time," has given something real, and to refuse it with a show of modesty (Oh, it was nothing, it was not me) is a small unkindness. A minister is allowed to be glad, and may say, "Thank you. That is good to hear."
The danger is not praise but living on it. It is possible to notice a pattern:
- A warm word after a service lifts the whole week, and silence after another service leaves a grey feeling for days.
- The minister begins to prepare for the response and not only for the people.
- The minister looks, without knowing it, at the face in the third row that shows that the point has landed.
- A minister who is not thanked begins to feel used, and one who is thanked begins to need it.
A person who lives on praise is poorer when it stops, and it will stop. Praise depends on the mood of others, on the season, on how a person looks at that moment, on what has been happening in their own lives. It is a poor foundation, because it can be taken away for reasons that have nothing to do with the minister.
Titles belong here too. In many places a priest is called Father, a pastor Reverend or Pastor, a monastic Abbot or Mother, a leader or Apostle. These names are used with real respect, and they are part of a community's way of speaking. They are not a fault. But they can also be a weight. A person who is always called by a title may find that the title has become who he or she is, and that the person under it has no one who says his or her first name. In some places this is no concern. In others it is a quiet loss, and a minister may want one or two people who use the first name.
There is a plain test that helps. If this praise were taken away tomorrow, what would remain? If the answer is a fear, the praise has become a foundation.
4. The minister who needs to be needed
A related pattern deserves a name. A minister may come to need being needed. The one who is called at night, who is the only one who can do certain things, who is thanked as indispensable, may be quietly pleased by this and quietly dependent on it. Being needed feels like being loved.
This is not a vice in itself. A minister should be available to people who need help, and there are seasons when a minister is the only one who can come. The sign that something has shifted is subtle: the minister is uneasy when others can do what he did. He does not hand work on. He does not train anyone. He is unsettled by the person who says, "We managed without you." A congregation that cannot function without one person is not strong. It is dependent, and its minister may be both the cause and the sufferer of the dependence.
A good use of being needed is a minister who works, over years, to be needed less: who trains others, hands tasks on, and is glad when someone else does what once only he did. Moses was told by his father-in-law to share the work of judging among the people (Exodus 18), and this was not a loss to the people.
5. Criticism
Criticism arrives in many forms. A member says to the minister's face that the sermon was too long. A letter comes without a name. A leader raises a concern in a meeting. A family member says what nobody else dares. A senior person, a bishop or an elder or an overseer, raises a matter about the minister's work. A review appears online. Some criticism is accurate, some is half right, some is false, and some is cruel. A minister who serves long will meet all kinds.
How it lands depends partly on what it says and partly on where the minister is standing. A minister who is standing on belonging to God can hear "that was poorly done" as something about the sermon or the visit. A minister who is standing on results will often hear it as something about himself. The same sentence is a different sentence.
Here is a short pattern for the first days after hard criticism. It is a pattern, and not a rule.
- Pause. Do not answer in the first hour, and if possible not in the first day. A reply written in the heat of hurt is seldom the one the minister would choose later.
- Ask three questions. Is any of it true? Even a cruelly worded criticism may have a true core. Who is saying it, and what are they carrying? A person who is angry with the minister may be angry about something else. What is it asking of me? Some criticism asks for a change, some for an apology, some for nothing but a listening ear.
- Take it to one trusted person. Not a group, and not the whole church, but one person who will tell the truth gently. Where there is no one near, a letter written and not sent can help to set out what is true and what is not.
- Decide what to do, and what to leave. Some of it will need a change. Some of it may need a conversation. Some of it may need to be let go.
Paul speaks about being judged in 1 Corinthians 4. "But with me it is a very small thing that I should be judged by you, or by man’s judgment. Yes, I don’t judge my own self." This is not a statement that he does not care what others think. Elsewhere he cares a great deal, and in this very letter he asks the Corinthians to take his words seriously. He goes on to say, "For I know nothing against myself. Yet I am not justified by this, but he who judges me is the Lord." Notice that he does not trust his own acquittal either. He does not say, "I know nothing against myself, so I am fine." The final judge is the Lord. This frees a minister from two things at once: the crushing verdict of a critic, and the easy self-approval of a person who has decided that all criticism is unfair.
The book of Proverbs says, "Faithful are the wounds of a friend; although the kisses of an enemy are profuse." (Proverbs 27:6). A friend who says a hard thing may be doing the minister a service. A minister who has surrounded himself with people who only praise has made himself poor.
6. Giving feedback to a minister
The lecture has spoken from the minister's side. It is worth one paragraph for the person who gives feedback to a minister, whether a member, a colleague, a leader or an overseer.
Speak about what was said or done, and not about what kind of person the minister is. "The talk on Sunday ran for fifty minutes and several children were restless" is information. "You do not care about families" is a verdict. A person who is told what happened can do something about it. A person who is told what he is can only defend himself or sink. Where there is a serious concern about harm, or about a minister's conduct, the matter belongs elsewhere, and Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E) sets out how it is to be raised. Feedback of the ordinary kind should leave the minister's standing before God alone.
7. A good use of all three
(An invented example.) Elena teaches the church school and leads the adult study group in a small Orthodox parish in a city where there is only one other church of her tradition. She hears that the other church has a young choir and a growing school. She feels the sting and notices it. She does not decide it is nothing, and she does not decide it is a judgement on her. She writes a note to the priest there, and congratulates him sincerely. Later in the same week, a parishioner thanks her warmly for a talk, and she says "Thank you" and means it. In the same week a member says she thinks Elena's talks are too long and too hard to follow. She waits a day, asks a friend who attends whether this is fair, and decides to shorten the next one. She does not feel any of these three as a verdict.
What Elena has done is not extraordinary. She let comparison, praise and criticism each be what they are: a feeling, a gift and a piece of information. None of them became her ground.
8. Two small cases
(An invented example.) Pastor Joel spends an hour each evening on his phone, looking at pictures and short films from other ministries. He tells himself this is research. He finds that he feels flat afterwards and a little irritated with his own church, and that he has begun to say to his wife that "the people here will never be ready for that". He has not once, in this time, asked what the people here are ready for.
What was crossed: a stream of other people's best moments has become the standard against which he judges real people.
A better path: he can limit the hour, choose two or three ministries to learn from, and say what he is looking for before he looks. He can also name to a friend the sting he feels, since a feeling spoken aloud is smaller. And he can spend part of the hour on the question he has not asked: what are these people ready for, and who could tell him?
(An invented example.) Sister Anita helps to run a small clinic that her community supports. A visiting inspector, whose visit was friendly, wrote a report that names several things that are done poorly and includes one remark that she finds unfair. She reads it three times that night and cannot sleep.
What was crossed: a report about the clinic has been heard as a report about her.
A better path: she can leave the report until morning. She can ask a fellow sister or a trusted friend to read it with her and tell her which parts are fair. She can answer the unfair remark in writing, calmly, with facts, and act on the parts that are right. She need not decide, that night or any night, whether the report shows what kind of person she is.
Diagram 1. Three streams, one place to stand
Diagram 2. Fair and unfair ways to give feedback
| Information about what was done | A verdict on the person |
|---|---|
| "The talk ran fifty minutes and children were restless." | "You do not care about families." |
| "I could not hear the reading from the back." | "You never think of the old." |
| "The notice came after the vote." | "You do things behind our backs." |
In short
- Comparison takes the minister's attention from the work given and has two faces: envy and contempt. Jesus tells Peter, "You follow me."
- Praise is a gift to be received with thanks. Living on it is a danger, because it can be taken away for reasons that have nothing to do with the minister.
- A minister who needs to be needed is uneasy when others can do what he did. A good use of being needed is to be needed less.
- In criticism: pause, ask what is true, who says it and what is asked, take it to one trusted person, and decide.
- Feedback should speak of what was done, not pass a verdict on the person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| John 21:22 | Jesus tells Peter that another disciple's road is not his concern in this matter: "You follow me." |
| Living on praise | Letting a warm word lift the week and silence darken it. The test: if it stopped, what would remain? |
| The first days after criticism | Pause; ask what is true, who says it, what it asks; take it to one trusted person; decide. |
| Fair feedback | It speaks of what was said or done and does not judge what kind of person the minister is. |
One sentence to remember Comparison, praise and criticism are real, and none of them is the place to stand.
This week's action The next time a word of praise or criticism lands hard, wait a day, then name in one sentence what is true in it and what is not.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In John 21:20-22, Jesus does not say the other disciple is unimportant. What is he telling Peter? How might you hear that sentence when you compare yourself with another minister?
- What is the difference between receiving praise with thanks and living on praise? How could someone tell which is happening?
- Where does the title used for ministers in your tradition help, and where might it weigh? Is there anyone who calls a minister by a first name?
- Think of the four steps for the first days after criticism. Which step is the hardest, and why?
- If you wish: who is the one trusted person to whom you could take a hard criticism? If you cannot think of one, what might you do about that?