FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS103E Spiritual Formation for Ministers: Calling, Inner Life and Lasting Service

Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call

Contents 31
FS103E Spiritual Formation for Ministers: Calling, Inner Life and Lasting Service
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Formed Before Useful
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Formed Before Useful
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Calling and Discernment
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
  2. Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
  3. Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
  4. Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Identity and Achievement
  1. Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
  3. Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
  4. Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Inner Life and Public Ministry
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
  2. Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
  3. Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
  4. Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Tiredness and Recovery
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
  2. Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
  4. Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Walking With Others, and Rhythm
  1. Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
  2. Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
  4. Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Long Road
  1. Lecture 6-1: Failure and Wound
  2. Lecture 6-2: Doubt and Dryness
  3. Lecture 6-3: Staying or Changing
  4. Lecture 6-4: Finishing Well
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My One-Page Plan for the Long Road

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

Lecture 1-1 asked what a calling is. This lecture asks a harder question: how does a person tell whether a call is real, and what it is a call to? People ask it at several points in life. A young person asks it before choosing a path. A volunteer asks it when she is offered a larger role. A minister of twenty years asks it again when the work changes. In each case the person is trying to hear a word and be sure it is not their own wish.

"Discernment" is the word many traditions use for this. It means looking carefully, over time, at several kinds of evidence, and with other people, so that one is not the only judge. We will name five kinds of evidence, warn against treating any single one as final, describe how different communities confirm a call, and meet one of the points on which readers honestly disagree.

The central claim of the course applies here in a quiet way. If a call is part of standing before God as a person, then discernment is not a technique for getting a result. It is a way of listening, and the listener may be told "not now" or "not this."

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Name five kinds of evidence that are read together when discerning a call.
  • Explain why one sign taken alone is a poor basis for a decision.
  • Describe how different traditions and communities confirm a call to serve.
  • State fairly two positions on whether an inner call or the church's confirmation comes first.
  • Describe how a confirming community should treat the person it is testing.

Now in the assembly that was at Antioch there were some prophets and teachers: Barnabas, Simeon who was called Niger, Lucius of Cyrene, Manaen the foster brother of Herod the tetrarch, and Saul." — Acts 13:1

World English Bible

As they served the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit said, “Separate Barnabas and Saul for me, for the work to which I have called them.”" — Acts 13:2

WEB

Then, when they had fasted and prayed and laid their hands on them, they sent them away." — Acts 13:3

WEB

This is a faithful saying: if a man seeks the office of an overseer, he desires a good work." — 1 Timothy 3:1

WEB

For even as we have many members in one body, and all the members don’t have the same function," — Romans 12:4

WEB

so we, who are many, are one body in Christ, and individually members one of another." — Romans 12:5

WEB

Having gifts differing according to the grace that was given to us, if prophecy, let us prophesy according to the proportion of our faith;" — Romans 12:6

WEB

In Antioch the call is heard while a group worships and fasts. In Romans, gifts are given to members of one body, and each member needs the others.

1. Five kinds of evidence

Discernment does not rest on one thing. When people have thought about it carefully across many centuries, they have tended to look at five kinds of evidence together. Here they are, each with what it can tell you and what it cannot.

The inner pull. This is the desire, the sense of being drawn, or the restlessness that does not go away. Scripture treats such a desire as a good thing: "if a man seeks the office of an overseer, he desires a good work" (1 Timothy 3:1). But a desire can also come from many places: a wish to be respected, an escape from a boring job, a family expectation, or a real response to God. The desire alone does not say which.

Gifts. Can you do the things this service asks, or can you learn to? Romans 12 speaks of gifts "differing according to the grace that was given to us" (Romans 12:6). A person who loves to teach, but cannot make a lesson clear after years of trying, should look at that fact honestly. The opposite is also true. A person may have a real gift they have never seen, and others may see it first.

Need. Is there a place where this person's service is needed? A need is a real pointer, because God's call often meets a need. But need is not by itself a call. Many needs exist, and no one person can answer all of them. A church that is short of leaders may say "we need you," and mean it, and still be wrong about whether this person is the one.

Confirmation by others. Do people who know you, and who are free to say no, recognise this in you? We will spend most of this lecture on this one, because it is the one most often skipped.

Time and difficulty. Does the call hold up over months and years, and through hard times? A real call is not always steady. But a pull that appears on one emotional evening and is gone by the weekend tells you something. And a call that has been present through setbacks tells you something too.

The point of listing them is that they are read together. A call is more likely to be real when several of these point the same way, and the person should slow down when they do not. If the inner pull is strong but no gift is seen and no one confirms it, that is a reason to ask more questions. If the gift and the need are plain but there is no desire at all, that is also a reason to ask.

2. The danger of one sign

Some people treat one thing as final: a voice they heard, a dream, a verse that seemed to leap off the page, a strong feeling after a service. These can be real moments of God's leading, and many people can name one. The danger is in treating them as settled and complete in themselves, so that no further checking is needed.

Why is that a danger? Because the same kinds of experience can come from other sources. Tiredness, grief, praise from a crowd, a loved one's wish, or a strong feeling in a charged setting can each shape a dream or an inner sense. The person who has the experience is usually the last to see this, because it feels so clear from the inside.

There is a mirror danger as well. Some people treat a single closed door as final: one refusal, one bad review, one season of discouragement. A call that is real may meet an honest "no, not yet." A good discernment asks why before it gives up.

The way to avoid both is the same. Put every sign beside the others, and bring them to people.

3. What Acts 13 shows

Acts 13:1-3 is one of the clearest pictures in the New Testament of a call being recognised. Four things can be seen in it.

First, the setting is a community at worship. The church at Antioch had "prophets and teachers," and the Spirit spoke as they "served the Lord and fasted" (Acts 13:1-2). The word came in the middle of shared prayer, not to a person alone on a mountain.

Second, the word was addressed to the group. "Separate Barnabas and Saul for me." It was the community that was told to set them apart. The two men are named, but those who must act are the others.

Third, the call was recognised by the church's action. The group fasted, prayed and laid their hands on the two men and sent them away (Acts 13:3). The sending was a public act.

Fourth, the two were already serving. Barnabas and Saul were among the prophets and teachers named in the first verse. The new task came to people who were already faithful in an earlier one.

We should also say what the passage does not say. It does not say how the Spirit spoke: whether through one of the prophets, through a shared sense in the room, or in some other way. It does not say whether Barnabas and Saul had already felt something before. Readers sometimes fill in these gaps in ways that suit their own tradition. A careful reader leaves them open.

4. How communities confirm a call

Different communities have developed different ways of confirming a call. None of them is perfect, and each fits its own setting.

Many Protestant denominations have an ordination process: a time of study, interviews, references from the home church, examinations, a period of supervised work, and a decision by a committee or an assembly. Some churches of this kind add a period of trial before ordination.

In Catholic life, a person who thinks he may be called to the priesthood usually speaks with a priest or a director, and later enters a seminary. The formation takes years and includes interviews, a period of pastoral work and the judgement of the bishop. A person who thinks she may be called to a religious community typically visits, then enters stages of probation, often several years long, before taking vows. At each stage either side may say no.

In Orthodox life, practice differs between churches, but a candidate for ordination is generally brought to the bishop's attention through the community and a spiritual guide, and the community's affirmation is part of the ordination itself. A monastic candidate is received first as a guest and then through stages, with an or abbot guiding. The community's assent is part of the act, not a formality.

In Pentecostal and charismatic churches, elders or senior ministers often see a person's gifts in action, speak to them, lay hands on them and release them for service. Many have training programmes or apprenticeship under a more experienced leader.

In independent and house-church settings, recognition may be more informal. The group sees what a person is doing and says so, sometimes with a simple prayer of commissioning. This can work well in a close community. It works less well if the only people who confirm are those who gain from the person's service.

Where there is no body above you, a person can still arrange a version of this. Choose two or three mature believers who know you well, who are not dependent on you, and who are free to say no. Ask them to meet with you more than once. This is not a full substitute for the processes above. It is far better than having no one.

5. A small note on who may be called

Traditions differ about who may be ordained to particular offices, and some differ about this for reasons of conscience. This course does not try to settle those questions. This lecture speaks about the process of discernment, which is useful to anyone, and leaves aside which offices are open to whom. A reader may need to check what their own church teaches.

6. Ignatian discernment, in brief

Many Christians of different traditions have found help in the teaching of Ignatius of Loyola, a sixteenth-century Spanish founder of the Jesuits. He taught attention to what he called consolation and desolation: the movements of peace or of heaviness that follow in the heart as one lives with a choice over time. He advised against making a large change while in a time of desolation. He also described weighing the reasons for and against a choice calmly, as if one were advising another person in the same situation.

That is all this lecture will say about it. A guide in the Ignatian tradition can say far more, and The History and Practice of Prayer (LM106E) and and a Rule of Life (LM107E) take up the practices of prayer on which discernment draws.

7. This is a point where readers will not agree

Which comes first: the inner call or the church's confirmation?

Some readers, many of them in Protestant, Pentecostal and independent traditions, hold that the inner call comes first. Their reasoning is this. God calls individuals, and the church's role is to recognise what God has already done. If the church were to make the call, the church would be taking God's place. A church can also make mistakes: a committee may refuse a person with a real gift, or may be moved by its own interests. For these readers, the person's own sense of God's word to them must not be set aside.

Other readers, most strongly in Catholic and Orthodox life and also among many Protestants, hold that the church's confirmation is part of the call itself, especially for an office. Their reasoning is this. An office in the church is a public trust, given by the body and for the body. A person's inner sense, however sincere, is the sense of one person, and may be shaped by wishes that person cannot see. In the Catholic view, for example, no one has a right to ordination; it is the Church, through the bishop, that calls a person to orders after testing the sign. For these readers, a call that the church has not recognised is not yet a call to that office, whatever the person feels.

Both positions have a serious defence and a serious risk. The first can leave a person standing alone on a feeling. The second can leave a person without a hearing if the church's process is closed or unfair.

What this course requires is less than either tradition requires. Do not settle it alone. Do not treat your own inner sense as final, and do not treat a refusal as proof that there was no call without hearing and weighing the reasons. In either case, bring the question to people who know you and are free to say no.

8. Two small cases

(An invented example.) Miriam is thirty-four and works as an accountant. After a retreat she has a strong sense that she should leave her work and serve in a chaplaincy. She tells her family she has heard God and will give notice on Monday.

What was crossed here is that one sign, a strong feeling after a retreat, was treated as final. A better path keeps the feeling and asks four more questions over the next months. Does she have gifts for chaplaincy, such as listening and staying calm near sorrow? Is there a need that she could actually meet? Do two or three people who know her well recognise it? Does it hold when the retreat feeling fades? She might begin by serving a few hours a week as a volunteer visitor. If the call is real, it will grow with the work. If it is not, she has lost nothing and learned something.

(An invented example.) Joseph is twenty-two. His father and grandfather were ministers, and the older members of his community say warmly, "You will take over from your father." Joseph has no strong pull of his own. He is afraid of disappointing everyone.

What was crossed here is that the confirmations came from people with an interest in the answer. Their words are kind, and they carry weight, but they do not tell Joseph whether he is called. A better path asks Joseph for time. He could speak with one person who loves him but does not depend on his decision, such as an older relative from another congregation or a teacher. He could serve for a year in a small role and watch how it feels. If a call comes, it will be his own. If it does not, he can say so honestly without being thought a failure.

9. What a confirming community owes a person

Those who test a call hold a kind of power over the person being tested, because they can say yes or no to something that person cares about deeply. A good use of that power looks like this: giving reasons, not only a result; speaking with the person, not only about them; letting a "not yet" be a real "not yet" with a clear path forward; and refusing to flatter someone because the community is short of leaders. A person who is told "no" kindly and honestly has been served, even if it hurts.

Beware of agreeable voices

Confirmation from those who gain from your service, or from those who cannot bear to disappoint you, is weak confirmation. Seek at least one voice that is free to say no.


Diagram 1. Five kinds of evidence, read together

Discerning a Call No single sign is final. Read them together, with others. Inner pull a desire that stays; but it has many sources Gifts can you do it, or learn to? Need a real pointer, but not a call by itself Others people free to say no Time does it hold through hard seasons? Read together, with trusted people then take the next small step Two dangers One sign treated as final: a voice, a dream, a feeling after a service One closed door treated as final Where readers disagree Which comes first: the inner call or the church's confirmation? Minimum: do not settle it alone.

In short

  • Discernment reads five kinds of evidence together: inner pull, gifts, need, confirmation by others, and time with difficulty.
  • No single sign (a voice, a dream, a feeling, or a closed door) should be treated as final.
  • Acts 13 shows a call heard in worship, addressed to the group, recognised by a public act, and given to people already serving.
  • Traditions confirm calls in different ways; each has strengths and risks, and none is the villain.
  • Readers disagree on whether the inner call or the church's confirmation comes first. This course requires: do not settle it alone.
  • A confirming community should give reasons, speak with the person, and not flatter.
Front Back
Five kinds of evidence Inner pull, gifts, need, confirmation by others, and time with difficulty, read together.
Danger of one sign A voice, dream or feeling may come from tiredness, praise or wishes; treated as final it needs no checking.
What Acts 13 shows A call heard in worship, addressed to the group, confirmed by a public act, given to people already serving.
What this course asks Do not settle it alone; bring the question to people who know you and are free to say no.

One sentence to remember A call is tested by reading many signs together, with people who are free to say no.

This week's action Name two or three people who know you well, are not dependent on you, and would tell you the truth, and decide when you will ask one of them to talk.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Of the five kinds of evidence, which do you tend to trust most? Which do you tend to skip?
  • Why is confirmation from people who gain from your service weaker than confirmation from someone free to say no?
  • In Acts 13, the call is heard in the middle of worship and addressed to the group. What does that suggest about where discernment is best done?
  • State in your own words the strongest form of the view that the inner call comes first, and of the view that the church's confirmation comes first. Which parts of each would you keep?
  • If you had to ask two or three people to help you discern a call, whom would you choose, and why those people?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.