FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS103E Spiritual Formation for Ministers: Calling, Inner Life and Lasting Service

Lecture 6-3: Staying or Changing

Contents 31
FS103E Spiritual Formation for Ministers: Calling, Inner Life and Lasting Service
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Formed Before Useful
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Formed Before Useful
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Calling and Discernment
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
  2. Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
  3. Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
  4. Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Identity and Achievement
  1. Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
  3. Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
  4. Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Inner Life and Public Ministry
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
  2. Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
  3. Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
  4. Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Tiredness and Recovery
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
  2. Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
  4. Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Walking With Others, and Rhythm
  1. Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
  2. Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
  4. Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Long Road
  1. Lecture 6-1: Failure and Wound
  2. Lecture 6-2: Doubt and Dryness
  3. Lecture 6-3: Staying or Changing
  4. Lecture 6-4: Finishing Well
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My One-Page Plan for the Long Road

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Sooner or later, almost every minister asks: Should I stay? The question may come after a wound, in a long dry season, when the family needs something else, when the work has changed, when health is poor, or on an ordinary Tuesday with no clear reason. It may be asked for a day and put away, or it may stay for years.

This is a hard question, and ministers often answer it badly in one of two ways. Some stay because leaving feels like betrayal, and they go on until they have nothing left. Others leave quickly, to get away from pain, and carry the same pain to the next place. This lecture tries to help with a third way: to ask the question honestly, to give it time and company, and, if the answer is to go, to go in a way that is true and kind to the people left behind.

The central claim of the course is that formation is standing before God as a person, apart from the work. This matters here. A minister whose whole worth is in the post cannot ask about leaving without fear. A minister who stands first before God can ask, more calmly, "What is the faithful next step?" The question is still hard. But it is not a question about whether one is a person at all.

This lecture does not tell you whether to stay or to go. It cannot, because it does not know you or your place. It gives questions to ask, a way to leave honestly, a view of the forms that change can take, and a fair account of why Christians disagree about whether leaving ministry is a failure of calling.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Tell healthy reasons for changing from escape reasons, and say why most real cases are mixed.
  • Name questions that help in discerning, and say why timing matters.
  • Describe a responsible way to leave: telling the right people in the right order, a handover and an honest word to the community.
  • Name several forms that change can take, including bivocational work, leave and a different kind of service.
  • State fairly two positions on whether leaving ministry is a failure of calling, and say what this course requires.

Now Paul and his company set sail from Paphos, and came to Perga in Pamphylia. John departed from them and returned to Jerusalem." — Acts 13:13 (World English Bible) "and because he practiced the same trade, he lived with them and worked, for by trade they were tent makers." — Acts 18:3 (WEB) "For everything there is a season, and a time for every purpose under heaven:" — Ecclesiastes 3:1 (WEB) "a time to seek, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;" — Ecclesiastes 3:6 (WEB) "a time to tear, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;" — Ecclesiastes 3:7

WEB

John Mark leaves the party at Perga and goes home to Jerusalem. The text gives no reason. Paul, in Corinth, works with his hands beside Aquila and Priscilla and serves at the same time. And a wise saying about seasons reminds us that there is a time to keep and a time to let go. None of these passages answers the question "Should I stay?" They give us company in asking it.

1. Mark leaves, and what the text does not say

Acts 13:13 is one short sentence about a departure: Paul and his company came to Perga, and "John departed from them and returned to Jerusalem." That is all. The reader is not told whether he was ill, homesick, afraid, in disagreement, or called elsewhere. In lecture 6-1 we saw that Paul later judged the departure harshly (Acts 15:38), and that Barnabas thought differently. We also saw that later, Paul asked for Mark again.

Two cautions follow. We should not build a rule from this verse. It does not say that leaving is wrong, and it does not say that leaving is fine. And we should not guess his reasons. A single verse cannot support a theory of why people leave. What the passage does give us is a plain fact: people have left service in Scripture, and the story did not end there.

2. Healthy reasons and escape reasons

In real life, a minister who thinks of leaving usually has several reasons at once. It helps to sort them, as long as we remember that the sorting is rarely clean.

Some reasons are often healthy:

  • Health. The minister's own health, or a family member's, cannot be served in this place or this role.
  • A changed season. The call has changed shape, or the gifts that fit the role are no longer the ones the minister has. Lecture 1-4 spoke of calls that change over a life.
  • A real mismatch. The role asks for things the person cannot do well, and a fair attempt, with help, has not changed that.
  • The family. Children, a spouse or an elderly parent need something that this place cannot give.
  • The community's good. Sometimes another person would serve the community better, and the minister, after honest counsel, sees it.
  • A refusal to do what is wrong. A minister may be asked to take part in something that conscience cannot accept.
  • Money. The post cannot support the household, and no honest change in the arrangement is possible. We do not judge this; many ministers worldwide carry two jobs for this reason, and lecture 5-4 touched on it.

Some reasons are often escape:

  • To avoid a conflict that would be better faced.
  • To get away from a wound that has not yet been looked at.
  • To leave because of tiredness, when what is needed is rest, care or a change of rhythm, not a change of post.
  • To move toward a place where one will be admired.
  • To get out ahead of a wrong that is about to come to light. That belongs to FS102E, and honest leaving is not the same as running from a reckoning.

Notice that "escape" is not always a wicked word. A person who is being harmed has every reason to get away. Part of the work is to tell a need to be safe from a wish to avoid.

Most real cases are mixed. Someone may be truly tired, truly hurt, truly called to something else, and also truly afraid of a hard conversation. The sorting is not to condemn. It is to know what is being decided.

3. Questions that help

There is no formula, but some questions are useful. They are best asked with a guide, a companion or a trusted friend (lectures 5-1 and 5-2), not alone.

  • Would this reason survive rest? If I had three months of proper rest and care, would I still want to leave? It is not a test that always settles things. It is a way to separate tiredness from something deeper.
  • Am I running from something or toward something? Running from alone is a warning sign. Running toward alone can be a dream. Often there is a little of both, and the question is which is larger.
  • Whom have I told who does not depend on my staying? A person with nothing to gain or lose from my decision can say what I have not seen.
  • What would I say to a friend in my place? We are often kinder and clearer with others.
  • What has changed, and what have I changed in answer? Have I tried the changes I could make, such as a different rhythm, a delegated task or a clear talk with an overseer?
  • What do the people closest to me, and those I serve, see? Their view is not final, but it is information.
  • Is there a wound, or a low mood, that I have not named? If low mood is heavy and lasting, speak to a doctor or another professional first, and let that care go forward before a large choice. Lecture 4-2 speaks of this.

Timing matters. A large decision made in the first weeks after a wound, a death, a conflict or a crash of tiredness is usually made partly by the wound, the grief or the tiredness. Where it can wait, let it wait. Where it cannot wait, because of danger or health, act with care and with help.

4. The forms that change can take

"Stay or leave" is too narrow. There are many ways to change, and some of them keep what is good in both.

A change of rhythm. Lectures 5-3 and 5-5 spoke of rest and rhythm. Some questions about leaving turn out to be questions about a week that cannot be lived.

Leave or sabbatical. A period away, with a plan to return, which many traditions know in some form. It is not always possible, and the arrangements differ widely. Where it is possible, it can separate tiredness from .

A change of assignment or role. A different parish, a different team role, a different community, or a part-time arrangement.

Bivocational or "tentmaking" service. Paul worked as a tentmaker and served at the same time (Acts 18:3). Many ministers today earn their living another way and serve without salary or with a small one. Some move to this form when a full-time post becomes too heavy or no longer pays. It is not a lesser form of service. It is a different shape.

A career change. A minister may leave paid church work, take another occupation, and remain a faithful member, a lay leader, or a quiet helper in the community. Many in the community may still call on that person for prayer.

Retirement. Lecture 6-4 treats this.

5. Priests and religious who are bound by vows

This part is short and respectful, because it touches the deepest promises that some people have made.

In several traditions, priests, monks, nuns and others make solemn promises or vows, and they are not only employees who give notice. A Catholic priest or a religious, or an Orthodox priest or monastic, has made commitments, in ordination or in vows, before God and the community that are meant to last. The way a person is released, if ever, or is given leave, or moves to another community, is handled under the rules of that Church and with its bishop or superior. The procedures differ by tradition, and they are not described here. If you are in this position, speak first to your spiritual director or guide, and then to your bishop or superior, and ask what steps exist. Some paths short of a final one often exist: a time of leave, a change of assignment, a move to a different house or community, a time of rest and discernment. Please do not decide in secret and alone. The weight of the promise deserves a careful road, and the person who made it deserves to be heard.

6. How to leave honestly

If, after time and counsel, the answer is to go, how you go matters as much as the fact. Here is a pattern. It is not a law, and customs and rules differ by place and by tradition.

Tell the right people, in the right order. Usually this begins with those closest, such as a spouse, and with those to whom you answer: an overseer, a bishop, a board, an agency or a council of elders. Then the wider community. People should not hear of it first from a rumour or from the pulpit when they had no warning.

Give a true reason, in a form that fits. You do not have to tell everything. You may keep private your health, your family's difficulties, or matters of confidence. But you should not give a false reason. "I feel God is leading me elsewhere" may be true, and it may also be a way of hiding a conflict. If the real reason cannot be shared, a simple, true statement can be given instead: "There are reasons that I am not free to share, and I ask you to trust that I have thought and prayed over them."

Make a handover. Write down what a successor or the leaders need: who needs visits, which matters are in progress, where the keys, accounts and records are, what promises have been made, which people need special care. Introduce the people who carry things on. Matters told in confidence are handled with confidence, and a person who told you something in trust may be asked whether it may be passed on. Do not leave the community to find the gaps by falling into them.

Give time where you can. Weeks or months, where possible, are kinder than days. Where you must leave quickly, because of health or safety, do as much of this as you can and ask someone to do the rest.

Say goodbye. A farewell, even a short one, is a pastoral act. It lets the community grieve, thank and let go.

Leave the door open for the one who follows. Do not recruit followers to go with you. Do not speak against the community or the successor afterwards. Do not return to lead what you have left unless the leaders ask and the way is agreed. Lecture 6-4 speaks of this again.

(An invented example.) A sudden departure. A pastor, tired after a conflict, announces at the end of a Sunday service that this is his last. He gives no reason and does not return. The church has no written record of what he had begun. A family that he was counselling hears the news with everyone else and does not know whom to ask. Some members decide that he was driven out, and some that he had lost faith.

What was crossed: the community was given no time, no true word, and no handover, and a family in the middle of care was left. A better path would have used the same decision with a different route: telling the overseers first and asking them to share the news; saying a simple, true sentence to the community; setting a date a few weeks away; writing a short list of what was in progress; and speaking in person to the family he had been counselling, with their consent to pass the care to another. The decision to leave could be the same. The way would be less costly to everyone.

(An invented example.) A good leave-taking. A part-time minister in a small church realises over a year that her health and her family need more than the role allows. She talks with a mentor and with the church's elders. They agree on a six-month notice. She writes a two-page summary of the congregation's needs, introduces two members who will help, and tells the church plainly that she is leaving for family and health reasons. In her last service, they pray for her and she prays for them. Afterwards she stays in the church as an ordinary member and does not comment on how things are done.

Notice what a good use of power looks like here: she uses her position to make the change smooth for others, and then lays the position down.

Is leaving ministry a failure of calling?

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that a call to ministry, and especially an ordination or a vow, is for life, and that leaving is a breach, even if sometimes allowed or excused by illness or need. Their strongest argument is that the weight of the promise protects the community and the minister from treating service as a job to be dropped when it is hard, and that the Church recognises something that lasts even when duties end. Others hold that a call is first to God and to service, that it takes different shapes in different seasons, and that leaving a role is not leaving the call. Their strongest argument is that Scripture shows callings moving, and that holding a person in a role that harms them or the people they serve is not faithfulness. Some also hold that when the Church or community releases a minister, the call to that role is ended. This course requires less than any of these: that, whatever the view, the minister leave honestly, with a responsible handover and a true word to the community, and that nobody be called a failure for asking the question.

7. A call does not end when a job does

Lecture 1-1 said that a call has layers: belonging to God, living faithfully where you are, and a particular task. A particular task may end, change or pass to another. The first two layers do not. A minister who leaves a post is still called to belong to God and to live faithfully in the next place. Many people find, a few years later, that their time in ministry, including its hard end, formed them for the service they do now.

We must not say this too fast. Some leave in pain, and the pain does not turn into a lesson for years. Do not press such a person to find meaning on a timetable.


Diagram 1. Staying or changing: a way to look

Staying or Changing Sort the reasons, wait, ask with a guide Often healthy health, family a changed season a real mismatch conscience Often escape avoiding a conflict fleeing a wound tiredness read as the end Questions would it survive rest? from something or toward? whom have I told? Forms of change rhythm, leave, new role bivocational, new career retirement Leaving honestly tell the right people first a true and fitting reason handover, time, farewell Bound by vows guide first, then superior procedures differ paths short of the last Wait where you can. Do not decide alone.

Diagram 2. Reasons, sorted but mixed

Often healthy Often escape Mixed (most cases)
Health; family needs; a changed season; a real mismatch; conscience Avoiding a conflict; fleeing an unexamined wound; tiredness mistaken for the end of a call Tired, hurt, called elsewhere and afraid all at once

In short

  • Most reasons for leaving are mixed. Sort healthy from escape reasons without condemning, and ask with a guide whether the reason would survive rest.
  • Timing matters: a large decision made soon after a wound, a loss or a collapse of strength is partly made by it. Where it can wait, wait.
  • Change takes many forms: a change of rhythm, leave, a new assignment, bivocational service, a career change, retirement.
  • Leave honestly: tell the right people first, give a true reason that fits, make a handover, give time, say goodbye, and leave the door open for your successor.
  • Readers disagree whether leaving is a failure of calling; this course requires honesty and a responsible handover, and calls no one a failure for asking.
Front Back
Healthy and escape reasons Health, family, a changed season and conscience are often healthy; avoiding conflict or an unexamined wound is often escape. Most cases are mixed.
Why timing matters A decision made soon after a wound, loss or collapse is partly made by it. Wait where you can.
An honest leaving The right people first, a true and fitting reason, a handover, time, a farewell, and a clear door for the successor.
For those bound by vows Speak first to a guide and then to your bishop or superior; procedures differ by tradition, and paths short of a final one often exist.

One sentence to remember How you leave can be as faithful as how you served.

This week's action Write, for a general minister and with no names, a one-page handover list for a post: what is in progress, who needs care, where records are, and who knows. Keep it as a model for yourself.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Acts 13:13 gives no reason for Mark's leaving. Why might it be a mistake to supply one?
  • Think of the lists of healthy and escape reasons. Which reason on each list is hardest to judge from outside? Why?
  • Why does this lecture advise against large decisions in the first weeks after a wound or a loss?
  • In the invented sudden departure, which step would have cost the pastor the most? Which step would have helped the community most?
  • State one position on whether leaving ministry is a failure of calling in the way its holders would most want it stated. Then state the other.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.