Lecture 6-2: Doubt and Dryness
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
- Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
- Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
- Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
- Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
- Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
- Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
- Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
- Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
- Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
- Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
- Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
- Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
- Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
- Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
- Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
- Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
- Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
- Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
- Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
A minister is expected to be sure. People come with questions about death, suffering, forgiveness and meaning, and they hope that the one who stands in front of them has an answer, or at least a steady faith. So it is hard to admit that something has gone quiet inside. A minister may pray as usual, read as usual, lead as usual, and notice that the inner life is dry, as if the well has gone down. Or a question may have grown that will not go away: Is any of this true? Does prayer do anything? Why did this happen?
This lecture is about two experiences. Doubt is a question that is held and not settled. Dryness is a long time in which prayer, Scripture and worship feel empty, or in which God seems far away. They are related, and they are not the same. A person can doubt a great deal and still feel God near. A person can feel nothing and have no doubt at all.
The central claim of the course applies directly. If a minister's formation were only fuel for the work, dryness would be a breakdown of the machine, and the answer would be to fix it quickly. But if formation is standing before God as a person, then a dry season is still a season of standing there. It may be painful and may be hard to bear. It is not proof that the standing has stopped.
Two cautions from the start. This lecture does not treat doubt or dryness as lack of faith. And it does not treat them as always spiritual. Tiredness, grief, illness and low mood can make prayer feel empty, and lecture 4-2 speaks about lasting low mood and about when to speak to a doctor or another professional. Prayer and care are not rivals.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Say how doubt differs from unbelief, using Psalm 73, Matthew 11 and John 20.
- Describe dryness and list some ordinary and some spiritual causes, without assuming which one is at work.
- Explain how the Catholic tradition speaks of the "dark night," and describe parallels in Orthodox, Protestant and Pentecostal experience fairly.
- Say where a minister can voice doubt, and what a minister should not do with it.
- Read an invented case and say what a good next step would be.
But as for me, my feet were almost gone. My steps had nearly slipped." — Psalms 73:2 (World English Bible) "For I was envious of the arrogant, when I saw the prosperity of the wicked." — Psalms 73:3 (WEB) "Surely in vain I have cleansed my heart, and washed my hands in innocence," — Psalms 73:13 (WEB) "When I tried to understand this, it was too painful for me;" — Psalms 73:16 (WEB) "Until I entered God’s sanctuary, and considered their latter end." — Psalms 73:17 (WEB) "Now when John heard in the prison the works of Christ, he sent two of his disciples" — Matthew 11:2 (WEB) "and said to him, “Are you he who comes, or should we look for another?”" — Matthew 11:3 (WEB) "Jesus answered them, “Go and tell John the things which you hear and see:" — Matthew 11:4 (WEB) "the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised up, and the poor have good news preached to them." — Matthew 11:5 (WEB) "Blessed is he who finds no occasion for stumbling in me.”" — Matthew 11:6 (WEB) "The other disciples therefore said to him, “We have seen the Lord!” But he said to them, “Unless I see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.”" — John 20:25 (WEB) "Then he said to Thomas, “Reach here your finger, and see my hands. Reach here your hand, and put it into my side. Don’t be unbelieving, but believing.”" — John 20:27 (WEB) "Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!”" — John 20:28 (WEB) "Jesus said to him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed. Blessed are those who have not seen, and have believed.”" — John 20:29
WEB
A psalmist whose feet almost slipped. A prophet in prison who sends a question to Jesus. A disciple who says what it would take for him to believe. In each case, the question is spoken out loud, and in each case it is answered, though not always at once or in the way the speaker expected.
1. Doubt is not the same as unbelief
In everyday speech, people use "doubt" and "unbelief" as if they were one thing. It helps to separate them.
Doubt is a question held while still turning toward God. The person says, "I am not sure," or "I do not understand," or "I cannot see how this is true," and goes on praying, sometimes in anger. Unbelief is a refusal to trust: a closing of the door. The words overlap, and only the person and God can see the difference from the inside. But the difference is real, and it matters, because a community that treats every question as unbelief teaches its ministers to hide questions.
Three people in Scripture show the difference.
The psalmist of Psalm 73. He says openly that his feet had almost slipped, because he envied people who did wrong and seemed to do well. He says that he had kept his heart clean in vain. He does not hide this: the psalm is in Scripture. Then he says something careful. If he had said all this aloud to the community, he would have betrayed God's children (verse 15). So he carries it, and it is too painful to understand, "until" he went into the sanctuary of God and considered the end of those he envied. The text does not say that he received a full answer. It says that his view changed in a particular place. We must not turn that into a method ("go to church and your doubts will go"). We can say that he did not leave the place where God was, even while his mind was in pain.
John the Baptist. He is in prison, and he hears about the works of Jesus. He sends two disciples to ask whether Jesus is the one who was to come, or whether they should look for another. This is the man who had pointed to Jesus. The question is a real one, not an attack. Jesus does not rebuke him. He tells the messengers to report what they see and hear, and he adds a blessing for those who are not offended by him. He then speaks of John to the crowd with great respect, in the verses that follow in Matthew 11. We should not claim too much from this. It is clear that a question put honestly to Jesus from a hard place did not lose John his standing.
Thomas. He says what he needs. John 20:25 gives the words: he will not believe unless he sees and touches. A week later, Jesus comes and gives him exactly what he asked, and says, "Don't be unbelieving, but believing." Thomas answers, "My Lord and my God!" Jesus then speaks a blessing over those who have not seen and have believed. Two things are true in this one scene: Jesus does not reject Thomas for asking, and Jesus also names a blessing on those who trust without such proof. The scene does not say that Thomas's way is wrong or that the others' way is higher. It holds both.
One more thing from all three: in each case, the question is said to someone. The psalmist says it to God. John sends a message to Jesus. Thomas says it to his friends. A question that is spoken is usually easier to carry than one that is hidden.
2. What dryness is
Dryness is harder to describe than doubt, because it often has no question in it. It is a quiet. Prayer feels like speaking into an empty room. The Bible reads like any other book. The worship that once moved the minister is now a task to be done well. Sometimes there is also a flatness in everything else.
Some ordinary causes are worth looking at first.
- Tiredness. A tired mind cannot pray with feeling, and a body that has not rested will not feel anything fully.
- Constant speaking. A minister who speaks about God all day may have little left to speak to God. Lecture 3-1 described how Scripture can become only material for sermons.
- Grief or a wound. A loss or a hurt can dull everything, and lecture 6-1 described how a wound can sit under the surface.
- Illness or lasting low mood. If the dryness comes with heavy sadness, loss of interest in things once enjoyed, or lasting sleeplessness, talk to a doctor or another mental-health professional. Access and cost differ by country, so use what is reachable where you are. If thoughts of self-harm or of death ever appear, do not carry them alone: tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once, and in danger call your local emergency number.
- Neglect, or a hidden escape. It would be dishonest to leave this out. Sometimes a minister has simply stopped praying, or has put something in its place, such as constant screens, extra work or something worse, that numbs the inner life. Honest looking is part of formation, and we do not excuse ourselves from it.
Some causes may be spiritual, in the sense that the person is going through something that the great teachers of prayer have described. That brings us to the next section.
3. The "dark night" and its neighbours
In the Catholic tradition, the best-known name for a certain kind of dryness is the dark night. It comes from John of the Cross, a Spanish Carmelite friar of the sixteenth century, who wrote about a time in which the usual comforts of prayer are taken away and a person feels that God is absent, though the desire for God has not gone. Teresa of Avila, another Spanish Carmelite of the same century, also wrote of seasons of dryness in prayer. In this tradition the dark night is not first read as punishment. It is read by some as God drawing a person toward a love that does not depend on pleasant feeling. A guide is usually thought important for reading it, because it is easy to mistake other things for it.
Other traditions describe neighbouring experiences, and we should not say they are the same.
- Orthodox and early monastic writing. Monks of the desert in the fourth century and after wrote about a weariness of the heart that they called by the Greek word acedia, a listlessness in which prayer and work seem pointless. They advised patience, a regular rule, work with the hands and a spiritual father or mother to talk to. The spiritual father or mother (an experienced monk or nun, or another person trusted to guide) is central in Orthodox life, and it is usually to such a person that dryness is first taken.
- Protestant experience. Writers in some Protestant traditions have described seasons in which God seems to withdraw, sometimes using the old term "spiritual desertion." Others speak simply of "a wilderness season." Preaching and in these traditions have often leaned on the psalms of lament, and on the plain advice to keep to the (Scripture, prayer, fellowship) even when they feel empty.
- Pentecostal and charismatic experience. These communities often prize the felt presence of God, and this can make a dry season harder to speak about, because it may seem a failure to feel nothing. Many believers in these traditions also have strong practices for such seasons: praying with others, giving testimony of earlier times, and waiting. A minister here may need especially to hear that quiet is not necessarily absence.
- Independent and house-church communities. With no formal structure, the minister may have neither a spiritual director nor an overseer. A trusted friend outside the group can serve.
None of this is meant to say that every dry season is a dark night. Many are plain tiredness. Others have mixed causes.
Is dryness sent, or is it ordinary?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some, especially in the Carmelite and monastic traditions, hold that certain dry seasons are given or allowed by God to loosen a person's hold on feeling and to lead toward deeper trust. Their strongest argument is that the long witness of people who prayed through such times says so, and that to treat all dryness as a problem to be fixed would skip something real. Others, including many pastors and many Protestant readers, hold that it is wiser to look first for ordinary causes such as tiredness, grief and illness, and not to give a spiritual name too quickly. Their strongest argument is that ministers are very good at giving spiritual names to what is actually a need for sleep or for medical help. This course requires less than either: look first at ordinary causes and at care; do not rule out that there may also be a deeper meaning; and do not decide alone. Take it to a trusted guide.
4. Where a minister can voice doubt
A minister has a double problem. Hiding a question for years wears a person down. And pouring it all out in front of the community may leave hearers who came for strength without a place to stand. So the question is not whether to speak, but where.
To a guide or a companion. Lecture 5-1 spoke of spiritual direction, a spiritual father or mother, a soul friend and a mentor. This is one of the main reasons to have one. A person who can hear "I am not sure I believe this today" without alarm is a gift.
To a peer. Lecture 5-2 spoke of peers. Another minister has probably known the same quiet.
In the forms that carry you. Where there is a , the minister can say words that are not his own feeling. The prayers of the Church were prayed by people who were certain, and by people who were not. The same is true of the psalms. A person who cannot find words of their own can say theirs.
In the pulpit, with care. This is the delicate one. A minister does not have to pretend to a certainty that is not felt at the moment. A minister can also say true things: "I cannot promise you that you will feel God near. I can tell you what this psalm has said to people for thousands of years." That is honest. What a minister should avoid is using the pulpit as the place to work out a personal crisis, and using hearers as unwilling counsellors. The test is to ask: whom is this for? If it is for the hearer, it may belong in the sermon. If it is for me, it belongs with a guide.
Not in secret and alone, for ever. A minister who tells nobody for years often finds that the doubt has grown larger in the dark.
5. Two small cases
(An invented example.) A who feels nothing. Isaac is a deacon in a large parish. He prepares well, he serves well, and people thank him. Inside, for about eight months, he has felt nothing in prayer. He has begun to say the words and think of other things. He is not sad, and he does not doubt anything in particular. He thinks: "If I tell anyone, they will think I should not be serving."
What is happening is not clear, and a good guide will not hurry to name it. A better path: he tells his spiritual director, plainly, and they look together at the ordinary things first. Has he been resting? Is there some loss he has not named? Has he prayed only in the course of duty? They also consider whether there is a dryness that simply needs to be waited through with faithfulness. He keeps the daily prayer of the Church as a rule, even without feeling. And he sees a doctor if the flatness spreads to the rest of his life. None of this is a promise that the feeling returns by a date.
(An invented example.) A missionary teacher with a hard question. Ruth teaches in a village school and helps in the local church. A child she knew well became ill and died. People prayed hard for healing. Since then Ruth has a question that she cannot put aside: why does prayer seem to be answered at some times and not at others? She still prays. She also feels she cannot say this to her colleagues, who would be troubled, or to the villagers, who look to her for faith.
This is mainly doubt, with grief. A better path: she writes the question down, plainly. She finds one person outside the village, perhaps a mentor by letter or a friend from her home country, with whom she can speak honestly. She does not stop praying, and she lets the psalms of lament give her words. She does not teach an answer she does not have, and she does not claim to lack one when she does have part of one. In time, she may find she can say to others, "I do not know why, and I stay here." That, too, is a form of faith.
6. What a minister should not do
A few things deserve a clear warning.
- Do not read your own dryness as a verdict on your . Lecture 1-3 said that a wavering call does not prove that there was none. The same is true here.
- Do not make others pay for it. A sharp tongue or a cold manner toward a community is not the answer to an inner dryness.
- Do not decide alone to leave, or to change what you believe, in the middle of a dry time. Lecture 6-3 returns to this.
- Do not turn to something that numbs. An escape feels like relief for a while.
- Do not promise others what you cannot know. The honest line "I do not know, and I am staying with you" is better than a borrowed certainty.
And one thing on the other side: do not let a minister off by saying "it is only a season." Honest looking is also part of formation.
Diagram 1. Doubt and dryness: first look at ordinary causes
Diagram 2. Where doubt can be spoken
| Place | What it gives | What to keep in mind |
|---|---|---|
| A guide (director, spiritual father or mother, mentor) | Someone who has walked with others through quiet times | Take it there first |
| A peer | Recognition: "I have known this too" | Choose someone who keeps confidence |
| The prayers and psalms of the Church | Words when you have none | They carry you; they are not a test |
| The pulpit | An honest sentence, said with care | Ask whom it is for |
| A doctor or mental-health professional | Care for tiredness, grief or lasting low mood | Access differs by country |
In short
- Doubt is a question held while turning toward God; unbelief is a refusal to trust. Psalm 73, John the Baptist and Thomas all ask openly and are not cast out.
- Dryness is a long season in which prayer and worship feel empty. Look first at ordinary causes: tiredness, constant speaking, grief, illness, low mood, neglect.
- The Catholic "dark night" and neighbouring Orthodox, Protestant and Pentecostal experiences are described without ranking; a guide helps read them.
- Voice doubt to a guide, a peer or a doctor, and in the prayers of the Church; ask whom a pulpit sentence is for.
- Do not read dryness as a verdict on your calling, and do not decide alone to leave during it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Doubt and unbelief | Doubt is a question held while still turning to God; unbelief is a refusal to trust. |
| Dryness: first look at | Tiredness, constant speaking, grief, illness or lasting low mood, and neglect, before giving it a spiritual name. |
| The dark night | In Catholic teaching, a time when the comforts of prayer are taken away and God seems absent; a guide helps read it. |
| Where to voice doubt | To a guide or a peer, in the prayers and psalms, to a doctor if mood is low, and in the pulpit only with care. |
One sentence to remember A question spoken to someone is easier to carry than one kept in the dark.
This week's action Write one honest sentence about a question or a quiet you carry, in general terms. Decide one safe person or place where you could say it aloud this month.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what is the difference between doubt and unbelief? Why might a community prefer not to see the difference?
- Psalm 73 says that going into God's sanctuary changed how the psalmist saw. Why is it wrong to turn this into a method?
- Jesus did not rebuke John the Baptist for his question. What might this change in how you answer a doubting colleague?
- Which ordinary cause of dryness do you think ministers most often overlook, and why?
- Where could a minister voice a doubt in the place where you serve or would serve? What would make that place safe?