Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
- Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
- Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
- Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
- Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
- Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
- Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
- Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
- Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
- Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
- Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
- Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
- Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
- Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
- Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
- Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
- Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
- Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
- Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
- Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
It may seem strange to say that a person who is surrounded by people all day can be lonely. A priest or pastor is greeted at the door, asked to pray, invited to meals, called at night. A missionary lives among neighbours. A monk or nun lives in community. Yet many who serve say, if they are asked kindly and have time to answer, that they are lonely in a way that is hard to explain to others.
This lecture describes several kinds of loneliness that belong to ministry, looks at what Scripture shows in the lives of Elijah, Paul and Jesus, and asks what helps and what does not. It does not offer a cure. It does not say that loneliness is a failure of faith. It asks only that a minister name it plainly, and that ministers and those who care for them learn to tell the difference between solitude, which a person chooses and which can be a gift, and loneliness, which a person suffers and which can wear a person down over years.
What these 31 minutes give you
- Name at least four kinds of loneliness that ministers meet, and say how they differ.
- Describe what the stories of Elijah, Paul and Jesus in Gethsemane show about the need for company.
- State fairly two positions on whether a minister can have close friends in his or her own congregation, and say what this course requires.
- List what tends to help and what tends not to help, and judge an invented case.
- Say when loneliness should be taken to a doctor, a mental-health professional or another trusted person.
He came there to a cave, and lodged there; and behold, Yahweh’s word came to him, and he said to him, “What are you doing here, Elijah?”" — 1 Kings 19:9
World English Bible
He said, “I have been very jealous for Yahweh, the God of Armies; for the children of Israel have forsaken your covenant, thrown down your altars, and slain your prophets with the sword. I, even I only, am left; and they seek my life, to take it away.”" — 1 Kings 19:10
WEB
Yet will I leave seven thousand in Israel, all the knees which have not bowed to Baal, and every mouth which has not kissed him.”" — 1 Kings 19:18
WEB
for Demas left me, having loved this present world, and went to Thessalonica; Crescens to Galatia, and Titus to Dalmatia." — 2 Timothy 4:10
WEB
Only Luke is with me. Take Mark, and bring him with you, for he is useful to me for service." — 2 Timothy 4:11
WEB
At my first defense, no one came to help me, but all left me. May it not be held against them." — 2 Timothy 4:16
WEB
But the Lord stood by me, and strengthened me, that through me the message might be fully proclaimed, and that all the Gentiles might hear; and I was delivered out of the mouth of the lion." — 2 Timothy 4:17
WEB
He took with him Peter, James, and John, and began to be greatly troubled and distressed." — Mark 14:33
WEB
He said to them, “My soul is exceedingly sorrowful, even to death. Stay here, and watch.”" — Mark 14:34
WEB
Elijah says "I only" and is told there are seven thousand. Paul, near the end of his life, asks a friend to come, names who has left and who is with him, and says the Lord stood by him. Jesus, in the garden, asks three friends to stay awake with him.
1. Solitude and loneliness
The two words are often used as if they meant the same. They do not. Solitude is time alone that a person has chosen and that gives something: quiet, prayer, thought. The long Christian traditions of retreat, of the desert, of the cell and of the early morning all speak of it with respect. Loneliness is the pain of lacking company or being unknown, and no one chooses it. A person can be alone and at peace, and can be in a full room and lonely. When a minister says, "I need more quiet," that is a wish for solitude. When a minister says, "No one here knows me," that is loneliness. A minister who has plenty of the first may still need the second to be answered, and the reverse is also true.
2. Kinds of loneliness
Ministry produces some loneliness that belongs to it in particular. A list helps to see its shapes. They are not separate; one person may have several.
The loneliness of the office. In many places the person who holds the role is treated, kindly and with respect, as the role. People are careful around a priest or a pastor. They stop a joke in the middle. They tell their best news and their worst news, but they do not often ask how the minister is. A person may stand in a crowded hall and find that no one has spoken to him as a person for weeks.
The loneliness of kept confidences. A minister hears things that others do not hear: a marriage in trouble, a fear about money, a long-hidden wrong. In some traditions the rule of confession or of confidentiality is strict, and the minister must not repeat it. In others the minister must use judgement about what may be said, and the community's written rules, the local law and a qualified person guide that judgement. In every case, the minister carries what is heard, and may not set it down in anyone's hands. Over the years the weight can be great. How to carry it, and where limited and careful consultation is allowed, is a matter for the minister's own community and for the courses on and ethics (Ministry Ethics and Boundaries, FS102E, and the counselling courses PT719E and PT723E).
The loneliness of the new place. A minister moves to a new parish, a new city, a new country. The people there have their own long friendships. The minister's family or friends are far away. A missionary may be learning a language and cannot yet say a joke. A newly ordained person may be sent to a place where the nearest colleague is a day away. For months, or for years, there may be no one who knew him before.
The loneliness of being the only one. A pastor of the only church of its kind in a region, a priest in a large rural parish, a believer in a village where almost no one shares the faith, a lay leader in a house church without any overseer: each can be the only person in a place who carries a particular role. There is no one to compare with, no one to ask.
The loneliness of deciding. A leader who must make a choice that others will not like, who cannot ask everyone, and who will be blamed if it goes wrong, may feel the weight of it alone. The choice may be about money, about a person, about a direction.
The loneliness of the unvoiced inner life. A minister may have doubts, or dryness, or anger, or fear, and may believe that these cannot be said to the people who look to him for strength. A person who must seem sure is often not sure, and may feel quite alone about it. This kind of loneliness is close to the questions of lecture 6-2.
The loneliness within a close circle. A married minister may find that a spouse is the only person who knows what the work is like, and may be carrying the whole weight alone. A celibate priest, monk or nun may live in a house or a community where people are near, and still be alone in the sense of having no one with whom to speak freely. A single lay minister may go home to an empty house every evening. These are different, and none is a failure of the , whatever shape it takes. No state of life guards against loneliness, and none is condemned to it.
3. Elijah
In 1 Kings 19, Elijah has run from a threat to his life. He has been fed and has slept (this part belongs to lecture 4-1). He comes to a cave on the mountain, and God asks him a plain question: "What are you doing here, Elijah?" (1 Kings 19:9). He answers, “I have been very jealous for Yahweh, the God of Armies; for the children of Israel have forsaken your , thrown down your altars, and slain your prophets with the sword. I, even I only, am left; and they seek my life, to take it away.”
Notice the words "I, even I only, am left." Elijah is lonely, and he believes he is the last. It is not a lie to say that he feels this. Notice also that God does not scold him for it. God asks the same question a second time, hears the same answer, and then does two things. He gives Elijah a task, and the task includes a companion. Elijah is to anoint Elisha as prophet in his place (1 Kings 19:16). And God tells him a fact he did not know: “Yet will I leave seven thousand in Israel, all the knees which have not bowed to Baal, and every mouth which has not kissed him.” Elijah was not the only one left, though he had no way to see that from the cave.
Three things follow, and none should be pushed beyond what the text gives. First, loneliness can be real and heavy for a faithful person, even a great one, and the account does not treat it as a fault. Second, loneliness can distort what a person sees: Elijah's I only was not the whole truth. A minister who feels alone may be more alone than he should be, and also may not be as alone as it feels. Third, the answer included a person. Elisha was given to Elijah to follow, to be with and to carry on the work. It was not only a private message.
This is not a formula, and it should not be heard as one. We are not told that every lonely minister will be given a companion by tomorrow. It is a story, and it shows what is possible.
4. Paul
Near the end of his life, Paul writes to Timothy from prison. The last chapter of 2 Timothy is one of the most personal passages in the New Testament. He asks Timothy to come soon (4:9). He tells him who has left: "for Demas left me, having loved this present world, and went to Thessalonica; Crescens to Galatia, and Titus to Dalmatia." He says, "Only Luke is with me. Take Mark, and bring him with you, for he is useful to me for service." He asks for his cloak and his books (4:13). And he says, looking back at his trial, "At my first defense, no one came to help me, but all left me. May it not be held against them." Then he adds, "But the Lord stood by me, and strengthened me, that through me the message might be fully proclaimed, and that all the Gentiles might hear; and I was delivered out of the mouth of the lion."
Several things are worth noting. Paul is not ashamed to say that he is lonely, and he does not hide his need for people. He wants his friend near. He wants Mark, who is usually identified with the John Mark whom he once declined to take on a journey (Acts 15:37-38), and whom he now calls useful. He asks for a cloak, because it is cold, and for books, because he needs to read. A man who writes some of the most important letters in the Bible also needs a coat. Second, Paul states what happened without bitterness: "May it not be held against them." Third, he does not claim that the Lord's standing by him means he does not need people. He says both things.
It would be wrong to read this passage as a lesson that a minister's loneliness is always a sign of holiness, or that the Lord's presence replaces people. Paul is not asking his readers to admire his isolation. He is asking for company.
5. Jesus in the garden
In the garden of Gethsemane, Jesus takes Peter, James and John with him, and "began to be greatly troubled and distressed" (Mark 14:33). He says to them, “My soul is exceedingly sorrowful, even to death. Stay here, and watch.” He does not ask them to solve anything or to say anything. He asks them to stay and to be awake. Then he goes a little further and prays alone. When he comes back, he finds them asleep, and he asks Peter whether he could not watch one hour (Mark 14:37). He returns to pray, and returns to them twice more.
A careful reader should not push this too far. The passage is not about the failure of friends. It does not say that companions will always fail. It does say that the Lord of the Church, in the hour of his deepest trouble, asked for the presence of others and not only for their advice. If that is not shameful in him, it is not shameful in a minister who asks for company.
The account also shows that the presence of others does not take the weight away. Jesus still had to pray the prayer alone. Companions cannot carry what only the minister can carry. They can be near.
6. What helps
None of this is a plan. People differ and places differ. But these things have helped many.
- One or two people who know you as a person. Not as a minister, and not as a source of advice. It may be an old friend, a relative, a colleague in the same work, or a neighbour. It matters more that the person is a friend than that he or she is wise.
- A place with no role. A club, a walking group, a family meal, a class, a sport, a shared craft: any place where the minister is a participant and not the one in charge.
- Regular contact with other ministers, even when they are far away. A phone call on a set day, a letter, a visit once a season, a meeting twice a year. Many who serve alone find that a small, steady link is worth more than a great gathering once a year. (Lecture 5-2 takes this further.)
- A spiritual companion or guide, in whatever way your tradition provides one. (Lecture 5-1.)
- Saying it aloud. Many ministers have found that a lonely feeling grows when kept hidden and shrinks a little when said to one trusted person.
- Ordinary care of the body. Loneliness is felt in the body. Sleep, food and movement do not cure it, and do help a person to bear it. (Lecture 4-3.)
- Honest prayer. The psalms are full of the lonely. Praying them is a way of saying aloud, before God, what is true.
7. What does not help
- Filling the evenings with more activity. More meetings can look like company and be none.
- Using a church member as a confidant for the minister's own burdens. A person who comes for help and finds the minister weeping about his own troubles has been put into a role that is not theirs to carry. It also blurs the line between minister and member, and the lines of this are set out in FS102E.
- Telling yourself that God is enough and that no one else is needed. God is the one on whom a minister rests. But the Bible says, "Yahweh God said, “It is not good for the man to be alone. I will make him a helper comparable to him.”" (Genesis 2:18), before there has been any sin, which suggests that need for company is part of how people are made and not a defect.
- Calling it a lack of faith. A person who tells himself that a faithful minister would not be lonely is adding shame to loneliness.
- Retreating further. Loneliness often tells a person to withdraw, which deepens it. A small step toward one person is usually better than a large plan.
This is a point where readers will not agree: may a minister have close friends within the congregation he or she serves? Some hold that the answer is no, or only with great care. They point out that a minister who is close to some members will be thought to favour them, that what the friend knows about the minister's work may become a burden or a tool, and that a friend who is also a member of the church may find it hard to tell the minister the truth or to leave if the friendship ends. In some traditions, particularly where priests and monastics live under a rule, this caution is part of the formal discipline. Others hold that it is natural and good for a minister to have friends in the church. They point out that a person who has no friends in the place he lives and serves is truly alone, that Jesus and Paul both had friends within the circle of those they led, and that to forbid friendship is to make loneliness a rule. Each position protects something: the first protects fairness and the free speech of members; the second protects the person of the minister. This course requires less than either: that a minister have at least one real friend, and that friendships inside a congregation be held with care about favour, confidences and power, as set out in FS102E, and where it is possible, that at least one friend be someone outside the congregation.
8. Loneliness and low mood
Loneliness is not the same as depression, and it is not for this lecture to say which a person has. But long loneliness can sit beside low mood, and low mood can make a person pull away from others, which deepens loneliness. Lecture 4-2 speaks of low mood honestly. If loneliness has become heavy and lasting, or if there are thoughts of harming yourself, do not carry it alone. Tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once. If there is danger now, call your local emergency number. Access to care and its cost differ from country to country; a trusted pastor, priest or friend can often help you find what is near.
9. Two small cases
(An invented example.) Pastor Amara has moved to a city she did not know to serve a church that welcomed her warmly. The people are kind, and also formal. She has no relatives within a day's travel. After the first year she has found one member, a woman of her own age, with whom she speaks easily on the telephone most evenings. She tells her about her doubts, her anger about a leader's decision, and her worries about the church's finances. The woman is a good listener. Then a vote on the church's budget comes up, and the woman votes against what Amara wanted, and both are hurt.
What was crossed: nothing wicked was done. But Amara had placed all of her loneliness on one person who was also a member of the church and who had a voice in its decisions. The friendship had too much to carry.
A better path: Amara can say, without blame, that she values the friendship and that some of what she has been sharing belongs elsewhere. She can look for a friend or colleague outside the congregation, such as a pastor of another church in the city or an old friend, to whom she can speak about the church's matters. She can keep the friendship with the member and keep what is said in it lighter. She can also tell one person about the loneliness itself.
(An invented example.) Father Luka is the only priest for eleven villages. His nearest fellow priest lives a long journey away. He is busy from morning to night. In the evening he is tired and sits in silence. He has noticed that he has not had a conversation about anything other than parish business for more than two months. He has begun to feel that this is how his life will always be, and that to complain would be ungrateful.
What was crossed: his loneliness has turned into a rule about himself: I must not complain.
A better path: he can take a small, definite step. He can write to the priest at a distance and ask whether they might speak by telephone once a month. He can set a date in the diary for a meal and a conversation with a friend, and treat it as seriously as a visit to the sick. He can also say to one person, in plain words, "I am lonely." These steps cost little, and each is within reach.
Diagram 1. Kinds of loneliness, and what helps
Diagram 2. A minister's circle
| Who | What they can give |
|---|---|
| A friend who knows you as a person | Being known without a role |
| A colleague in the same work | Understanding of what the work is like |
| A spiritual companion or guide | Company in prayer and in the inner life |
| A person outside the congregation | A place to speak of what cannot be said inside it |
| A doctor or mental-health professional | Care when loneliness or low mood has become heavy |
In short
- Solitude is chosen and can be a gift. Loneliness is suffered, and ministry produces kinds of it that belong to the work.
- The kinds include the office, kept confidences, the new place, being the only one, deciding, the unvoiced inner life, and the close circle.
- Elijah is not scolded for "I only." Paul asks for friends and a cloak. Jesus asks three friends to stay awake with him.
- Helpful: one or two friends, a place with no role, steady contact with other ministers, and saying it aloud. Not helpful: more activity, or a member as the only confidant.
- If loneliness is heavy and lasting, or there are thoughts of self-harm, tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Solitude and loneliness | Solitude is time alone a person chooses and that gives something. Loneliness is suffered. |
| Elijah's "I only" | God does not scold him, gives him a companion in Elisha, and tells him that seven thousand remain. |
| Paul in 2 Timothy 4 | He asks his friend to come, names who has left, asks for a cloak and books, and says the Lord stood by him. |
| What this course requires about friends | At least one real friend, with care about favour and confidences inside a congregation, and if possible one outside it. |
One sentence to remember Loneliness is not a failure of faith, and one small step toward one person is better than a large plan.
This week's action Choose one person, a friend or a colleague, and set a time to speak with them in the coming two weeks about something other than work.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What is the difference between solitude and loneliness? When have you seen one become the other?
- God does not scold Elijah for saying "I only." What does this suggest about how to speak to a lonely minister?
- Paul asks for a cloak and for books as well as for friends. What does that say about how a minister may speak of ordinary needs?
- State the case for a minister having close friends in the congregation, and the case against, each in the form its holders would accept. What does this course require?
- If you wish: what is one small step toward another person that is within reach in the coming week?