Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
- Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
- Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
- Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
- Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
- Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
- Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
- Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
- Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
- Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
- Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
- Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
- Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
- Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
- Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
- Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
- Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
- Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
- Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
- Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
So far this week has looked at the minister: the tired minister, the low and hurting minister, the road back. But ministers do not live alone. They serve a congregation, a parish, a community, a school, a mission or a group of friends. Above or beside them there may be a bishop, a superior, an elder board, a church council, a denomination or a sending agency. These people and bodies can make a great difference when a minister is struggling. They can notice, ask, make rest possible and pay for care. They can also, without meaning to, add to the weight by blame, silence or pressure.
This lecture asks what the people around a minister can do, and what a minister can arrange who has no body above them at all. For simplicity it uses the word overseer for anyone who has a responsibility for a minister's wellbeing or work. That may be a bishop, a superior in a religious community, an elder or a board, a church council, a senior pastor, a mission leader or a denominational officer. Structures differ widely, and some ministers have none of these. The lecture is written to be useful across those differences.
One boundary is stated early. Care and accountability are two different questions. This lecture is about care. A minister's conduct, the keeping of boundaries, and what is done when wrong comes to light belong to Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E). Do not mix them. Illness does not cancel responsibility for a wrong that was done, and a wrong done does not cancel the duty to care for the person.
This lecture is again about the course's central claim. A minister's spiritual formation is not fuel for better ministry. When a congregation cares for a minister, it should do so for the minister's sake as a person, and not only to keep the work going.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Read Galatians 6:2, Acts 20:28 and 1 Thessalonians 5:12-13 in context, and say what they ask of a community.
- Describe five things a congregation or an overseer can do: notice, ask, provide rest, pay for care where possible, and avoid blame.
- Explain how a community should respond if it fears for a minister's life.
- State fairly the positions on how much a minister should tell a congregation, and what this course requires.
- Describe what a minister with no body above them can arrange in advance: a trusted outside friend and a written plan.
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
World English Bible
Take heed, therefore, to yourselves, and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to shepherd the assembly of the Lord and God which he purchased with his own blood." — Acts 20:28
WEB
But we beg you, brothers, to know those who labor among you, and are over you in the Lord, and admonish you, and to respect and honor them in love for their work’s sake. Be at peace among yourselves." — 1 Thessalonians 5:12-13
WEB
Paul asks believers to carry one another's burdens. He tells the elders of Ephesus to watch over themselves before the flock. He asks a church to "know" and honour those who labour among them. In each case the care runs both ways.
1. Three passages, read in their place
Galatians 6:2. "Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." The verse is often used as a general call to help each other, and it is one. Its setting is a letter about how believers live together, and the verses just before it speak of gently restoring someone who has been caught in a fault. Three verses later, Paul says "each man will bear his own burden" (Galatians 6:5). The two sentences belong together. A burden that is too heavy for one person is to be shared, and every person also has a load that is their own to carry. A community that forgets the first leaves its minister alone. A community that forgets the second can take away a person's own responsibility. The lecture asks for the first without dropping the second.
Acts 20:28. Paul is speaking to the elders of the church at Ephesus as he says goodbye to them. He tells them, "Take heed, therefore, to yourselves, and to all the flock," Notice the order. Yourselves come first. The ones who care for the flock are told to look after themselves too. This verse does not say that self-care is more important than the flock. It says that those who shepherd must not be left out of the shepherding. A congregation or overseer that reads this verse will see that it is part of their task to make it possible for the minister to take heed to himself or herself.
1 Thessalonians 5:12-13. "But we beg you, brothers, to know those who labor among you, and are over you in the Lord, and admonish you, and to respect and honor them in love for their work’s sake." To "know" those who work among you is more than to know their names. It means to know how they are. Respect and honour are asked, in love. The verse is often used to ask congregations to obey their leaders, and it can be read that way. It can also be read as a call to know how their leaders are. The next sentence in the passage is, "Be at peace among yourselves." The text does not set honouring the leader against peace in the community. The same passage asks for both.
None of these passages gives a structure for any particular church. They give a direction: the people of God carry the load together, the shepherds are shepherded too, and a community knows its ministers as people.
2. Five things that can be done
Here are five things that a congregation, a board or an overseer can do. They are not a programme, and no church needs to do them all in the same way. Small and poor communities may do very little of the fifth and a great deal of the first two.
1. Notice. Notice patterns over time, not single moments. A minister who has become short with people, who has stopped coming to gatherings they used to enjoy, who looks very tired, who has not taken a day off in a long time, or who seems different from before, may be struggling. Noticing is not diagnosing. It is the first act of care, and it does not require special training. A rule of thumb helps: if you would say, "Something has changed," it is worth a quiet word.
2. Ask. Ask privately and kindly, and ask the person, not about them. "How are you, really? I have noticed that you have seemed very tired." Do not ask in public, in a meeting or in front of others. Do not ask in a way that already contains the answer ("You are burned out, aren't you?"). Be ready to listen, and be willing to hear "I am not sure" or "I would rather not say now." The aim is to open a door, not to pull a person through it.
3. Provide rest. An overseer can make rest possible: reduce the load, arrange for someone to cover the preaching, the visiting or the services, give days off, and where possible arrange leave, as lecture 4-3 described. A congregation can offer concrete help, such as taking over a duty or sharing meals, so that the minister's family is not left alone. This is the good use of power in this lecture: power to grant time. A bishop, a superior, a board chair or a senior pastor has the authority to say, "You are excused from this for now." Used for care, this power is a gift.
4. Pay for care, where possible. Care costs money, and the minister may have little. Where it can be done, a church or an agency may continue a minister's pay during leave, may pay for visits to a doctor or other qualified person, and may help with the cost of travel to reach help. Many communities are poor, and cannot do much in money. They can still do something: give time, give help in kind, or raise a small fund. Even a small gift, offered without condition, tells the minister that they are not alone. This is the good use of money in this lecture: spending it for the minister's sake, with no strings attached. The money must not become a weapon or a way of controlling the minister.
5. Avoid blame. This is the hardest. A congregation in trouble may ask, "How could our minister let this happen?" An overseer may feel that a minister's exhaustion reflects badly on the church. Some may wonder whether the minister's faith has failed. These reactions are human, and they must be set aside. Lecture 4-1 said that exhaustion is not a failure of faith, and lecture 4-2 that the same is true of low mood. A community that blames adds a second burden. It also teaches the next minister to hide.
Three further cautions go with these five.
Do not gossip. What a minister says in trust is not for talk. A matter of health is the minister's own. Do not pass on guesses and do not turn a person's pain into news.
Do not decide the minister's in a hard moment. A person in a low time may be unable to say whether they are called to continue. Do not press for a decision about leaving or staying while they are unwell. Lecture 6-3 considers that question in its own right.
Do not mix care and discipline. If there is a separate concern about conduct, it should be dealt with separately and according to the community's own rules, as FS102E describes. It is wrong to use someone's illness as a cover for avoiding a real wrong, and it is equally wrong to treat someone's illness as if it were a wrong.
3. If a community fears for a minister's life
Sometimes a person in a congregation or an overseer will become afraid for a minister's life. The minister may have said something that suggests thoughts of self-harm or suicide, or may have shown signs of deep despair. If so, the guidance of lecture 4-2 applies, and it is repeated here because it matters most.
- Ask directly and kindly whether the minister is thinking of ending their life.
- Stay with them, and do not leave them alone if you think they may be in danger.
- Help them to professional care: a doctor or a mental-health professional, and in danger the local emergency number.
- Do not argue, preach or call the person sinful.
- Do not promise secrecy if a life is at risk.
- Look after yourselves, as people carrying something heavy.
A minister has the same right as anyone to be met with care. This is not a matter for the board's next meeting. It is a matter for today.
4. How much should a minister tell the congregation?
This is a point where readers will not agree. When a minister is unwell or on leave, how much should the congregation be told?
Some hold that openness is best. A community that is told the truth can help, and a minister who speaks honestly about weakness shows that weakness is not shameful. They say that a vague reason invites speculation and that concealment teaches people to hide pain. Others hold that privacy is best. A minister's health is personal. Telling the whole community may burden people, invite gossip, cause some to lose confidence, or make it harder for the minister to return. They point out that nobody else in the congregation is expected to announce their medical history. Many hold a middle path: tell the overseer or the elders fully, and tell the community a short, true statement, such as "Our minister is unwell and will be resting for a time," with no details.
Each of these has a serious case. Openness can be a gift in a community with a deep trust, and it can be a burden where trust is thin. Privacy protects the person, and it can leave a community to guess. The middle path is common but it still leaves the question of who decides what the short statement says.
What does this course require? Less than any of these. First, no minister should be forced to disclose details of their health or their pain to a congregation. Second, at least one trusted person or overseer should know the truth, so that the minister does not carry it entirely alone. Third, whatever the congregation is told must be true. A false reason ("a family matter," when it is not) damages trust later. A short true statement, such as that the minister is unwell and resting, is enough. Beyond that the minister, with a trusted person, decides what to say.
5. A minister with no body above
Many ministers have no overseer, no board and no agency. A lone pastor of a small group, a missionary far from any home office, a chaplain in a place with no chaplaincy structure, a bivocational leader or a house-church leader may be accountable to nobody in particular. What can such a minister arrange, while well, so that help is within reach when needed?
A trusted outside friend. Choose one person who is not part of your own congregation or work, who is able to ask how you really are, and who will listen without fixing. It may be a minister from another place, an older Christian, a friend you have known for years, or someone you meet by telephone or letter. Ask them in advance: "If you see that I am not well, will you ask me directly?"
A written plan. Write a half-page, while you are well. It might include your early signs (lecture 4-5 helps you to name them), the one or two people you will tell, who could cover your duties for a short time, the kind of doctor or other help that can be reached where you live, and the date on which you will look at the plan again. Give a copy to your trusted friend. A plan written in a good week is easier to use in a bad one.
Two named people in the congregation. Even in a small community, it helps to tell two people, "If I seem unwell, please say so, and please help find someone to cover." Ask them not to share it more widely.
None of this replaces professional care, and it is not a substitute for a doctor. It is a way of being known before a crisis, so that no minister is entirely alone.
6. Two invented cases
(An invented example.) A congregation's council notices that their pastor has changed. For some months he has looked very tired and has begun to cancel meetings at short notice. One council member, Ruth, has been worried. At first she says nothing, because "it is not our place." At a council meeting someone says, "Maybe he has lost his zeal. Maybe we need a younger person."
What is crossed? The council is moving from concern to blame, and from blame to talk of replacement, without having asked him anything. A better path begins with Ruth, or another trusted person, asking the pastor privately: "I have noticed that you seem very tired. How are you, really?" If he says he is struggling, the council can ask what would help, and can offer a short, defined rest with cover for his duties. It can ask whether he has seen a doctor, and whether the church can help with the cost. It tells the congregation a short, true statement. It does not decide his future in the meeting. The council continues to hold its own responsibilities, and if there were a real concern about conduct, that would be dealt with separately.
(An invented example.) Esther is a missionary teacher working alone in a distant region. There is no agency office nearby. Before leaving she had agreed with a friend at home to a half-page plan. It lists her early signs (not sleeping, and snapping at her students), her friend's name, a colleague at a school two hours away who can cover for a few days, and the kind of clinic that can be reached in the nearest town. After a hard year Esther notices the signs. She follows her plan. She writes to her friend, asks the colleague to cover for a week, and visits the clinic.
What does this show? The plan did not stop the tiredness. It made it possible for Esther to act without having to decide everything while exhausted. Where help is far, a plan made in advance is a form of care.
Both cases give only the shape of a situation. They do not belong to one tradition, and neither makes any kind of church the problem.
Diagram 1. What a community can do
Diagram 2. Care and accountability: two questions
| Question | What it asks | Where it is taught |
|---|---|---|
| Care | How is this person? What do they need to rest and recover? | This lecture |
| Accountability | Was a wrong done? What is owed, and to whom? | Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E) |
In short
- Galatians 6:2 and 6:5 hold shared burdens and each person's own load together. Acts 20:28 tells elders to take heed to themselves first.
- A congregation or overseer can notice, ask, provide rest, pay for care where possible, and avoid blame. Small and poor communities can do these in small ways.
- Do not gossip, do not decide a minister's calling in a hard moment, and do not mix care with discipline. Conduct belongs to FS102E.
- If a community fears for a minister's life: ask directly and kindly, stay, do not leave them alone, help them to professional care, and in danger call the local emergency number.
- On telling a congregation, readers differ. This course requires that nobody is forced to give details, one trusted person knows, and what is said is true.
- A minister with no body above can arrange a trusted outside friend and a written plan while well.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Acts 20:28 | Elders are told to take heed to themselves and then to all the flock. |
| Five things a community can do | Notice, ask, provide rest, pay for care where possible, avoid blame. |
| If you fear for a minister's life | Ask directly and kindly, stay, do not leave them alone, help them to professional care, call the local emergency number in danger. |
| A lone minister's preparation | A trusted outside friend and a half-page written plan made while well. |
One sentence to remember A community that knows its minister as a person, and does not blame, makes recovery possible.
This week's action If you serve with an overseer or a team, ask one person how they would want you to raise it if you were struggling. If you serve alone, name your trusted outside friend.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Acts 20:28 tells the elders to take heed to themselves first, and then to the flock. What does it mean for a congregation to help its minister do this?
- Galatians 6:2 and 6:5 sit in the same passage. What goes wrong if a community remembers only one of them?
- Which of the five things (notice, ask, provide rest, pay for care, avoid blame) is hardest in a small and poor community? What small form of it is possible?
- State fairly two of the positions on how much a minister should tell the congregation, as their holders would most want them stated. What does this course require beyond them?
- If you serve with no body above you, what would you put on a half-page plan, and whom would you ask to be your trusted outside friend?