FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS103E Spiritual Formation for Ministers: Calling, Inner Life and Lasting Service

Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship

Contents 31
FS103E Spiritual Formation for Ministers: Calling, Inner Life and Lasting Service
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Formed Before Useful
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Formed Before Useful
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Calling and Discernment
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
  2. Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
  3. Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
  4. Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Identity and Achievement
  1. Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
  3. Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
  4. Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Inner Life and Public Ministry
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
  2. Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
  3. Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
  4. Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Tiredness and Recovery
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
  2. Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
  4. Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Walking With Others, and Rhythm
  1. Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
  2. Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
  4. Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Long Road
  1. Lecture 6-1: Failure and Wound
  2. Lecture 6-2: Doubt and Dryness
  3. Lecture 6-3: Staying or Changing
  4. Lecture 6-4: Finishing Well
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My One-Page Plan for the Long Road

Jump to the key points ↓

31 min

Most ministers spend their days listening to other people. They hear confessions, hear troubles, hear arguments, hear prayer requests, hear the same worry told ten different ways. Very few ministers have anyone who listens to them in the same way. The minister is the one who gives counsel, and so it feels odd, and sometimes shameful, to need counsel.

This lecture is about one particular kind of companion: a person who walks beside you for the sake of your own life with God. Traditions give this person different names and different shapes. Spiritual direction (a regular, unhurried conversation with a trusted guide about how you are living before God) is common in Catholic life. The spiritual father or spiritual mother has a long place in Orthodox life. Protestant, Pentecostal and independent communities use words such as mentor, soul friend, discipler or pastor to a pastor. The names differ. The need is the same.

The central claim of this course is that a minister's spiritual formation is not fuel for better ministry. It is standing before God as a person, apart from the work. A companion who is attentive to you, and not to your usefulness, is one of the ways that claim becomes real instead of remaining a sentence in a book.

What these 31 minutes give you

  • Describe, without ranking them, how Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, Pentecostal and independent communities think of a guide for the inner life.
  • Explain how spiritual direction differs from counselling, therapy, coaching and a supervisor's meeting.
  • Say what a minister can reasonably expect from a guide, and what a guide cannot do.
  • State fairly the main positions on how a guide should be chosen, and say what this course requires.
  • Recognise, in an invented case, when closeness to a guide helps and when it has begun to take over.

Moses’ father-in-law said to him, “The thing that you do is not good." — Exodus 18:17

World English Bible

You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone." — Exodus 18:18

WEB

Let them judge the people at all times. It shall be that every great matter they shall bring to you, but every small matter they shall judge themselves. So shall it be easier for you, and they shall share the load with you." — Exodus 18:22

WEB

While they talked and questioned together, Jesus himself came near, and went with them." — Luke 24:15

WEB

He said to them, “What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?”" — Luke 24:17

WEB

Beginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself." — Luke 24:27

WEB

Their eyes were opened, and they recognized him, and he vanished out of their sight." — Luke 24:31

WEB

They said one to another, “Weren’t our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us?”" — Luke 24:32

WEB

Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." — Proverbs 27:17

WEB

Moses is told by an outsider, and a relative, that he cannot carry everything alone. Two travellers on a road are joined by a stranger who asks them a question before he says anything else. A proverb says that one person shapes another. None of these passages describes a programme. Each shows what it looks like when someone is accompanied.

1. Why the person who gives counsel needs counsel

Moses is a good place to begin, because his situation is so familiar. His father-in-law watches him sit from morning to evening while the people stand around him (Exodus 18:14). Moses explains that he is doing God's work: the people come to inquire of God and he settles their disputes. His father-in-law does not argue with the purpose. He says, "The thing that you do is not good" (Exodus 18:17), and then gives the reason: "You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you" (Exodus 18:18).

Three things in this story are worth noticing.

First, the person who sees the problem is not inside the daily work. He has come for a visit. He can see what Moses cannot, because Moses is standing in the middle of it. This is one reason a companion is useful: not because the companion is wiser, but because the companion stands somewhere else.

Second, the advice is about the shape of the work and also about the man. "The thing is too heavy for you" is a sentence about a person. A good guide cares about the whole of you, not only about what you produce.

Third, Moses listens. The text says he "listened to the voice of his father-in-law" and did what he was told. A person of great authority accepts correction from someone who has no authority over him. That is rarer than it sounds.

We should not make the story say more than it says. It is not a rule about how to build a church organisation. It does show that a leader who is alone with the work can be mistaken about what is good, and that someone outside can see it.

2. A stranger on the road

The second picture is gentler. In Luke 24 two followers of Jesus walk away from Jerusalem, talking about everything that had happened. Jesus himself comes near and walks with them, but "their eyes were kept from recognizing him" (Luke 24:16). He does not begin with teaching. He begins with a question: "What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?" (Luke 24:17). They tell him. He listens first and speaks afterwards.

When he does speak, he "explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself" (Luke 24:27). When they reach the village, they invite him to stay, and in the breaking of the bread their eyes are opened. Then he disappears. They are left saying, "Weren't our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way?" (Luke 24:32).

This passage is not a description of spiritual direction, and we should not pretend it is. But it shows several things a good companion tends to do. The companion walks at the pace of the other person. The companion asks before telling. The companion points beyond himself, so that the people he walks with end by meeting someone greater than he is. And the companion does not hold on. He is there for a stretch of road.

Both pictures leave out something we should say plainly: neither guarantees a happy result. Moses' burden was lightened, but the people still had disputes. The two travellers were still afraid that evening until the bread was broken. A companion is a gift, not a method.

3. Kinds of companionship, described without ranking

Different communities have grown different practices. A fair description says what each tends to offer, and what each can risk.

Catholic life. Spiritual direction is a recognised ministry. A person meets a director (a priest, a religious sister or brother, or a trained lay person) at regular intervals, often about once a month, and talks about prayer, daily life, and how God seems to be at work or seems to be absent. The director listens, asks questions and helps the person notice patterns. Many seminaries and religious communities expect their members to have a director during formation (the years of training); how far this continues afterwards differs from place to place. A parish priest or a sister in a small community may find it hard to find a director nearby. This practice offers training, a long tradition and a shared language. It can risk becoming formal, or a director may be asked to do what a counsellor or a confessor (a priest who hears confession) does.

Orthodox life. The spiritual father or spiritual mother is a person of prayer and experience, often a monk or nun but not always, whom a believer trusts for guidance over a long time. In Slavic usage an experienced monastic guide is called a starets (an ""); in Greek usage the word is geron. Confession and guidance are related but not the same. Some people go to their confessor for guidance as well; others seek a monastic elder. Orthodox teaching speaks of trust, openness and a slow building of the relationship. The strength is depth and patience. The risk is dependence: a person may stop making their own decisions, and a guide with great authority may be hard to question.

Protestant communities. The practice is usually less formal and goes by many names: a mentor, a discipler (an older believer who helps a younger one grow), a prayer partner, a pastor's pastor, a "soul friend" (a phrase some writers trace to early Irish Christianity), a peer group of pastors. Some Protestant churches now have trained spiritual directors, and many ministers meet an older minister once a month. The strength is flexibility. The risk is that nobody is trained, nobody is expected, and the whole matter is left to chance. A mentor with no training may also not know where the limits of the role lie.

Pentecostal and charismatic communities. In many of these communities a respected leader is called a spiritual father or mother, and there may be a relationship of oversight between a younger minister and an older one, sometimes called a "covering" (the older leader is said to protect and answer for the younger one). The strength is warmth and close attention. The risk is that guide and supervisor are the same person, so that the younger minister cannot be honest about doubt, tiredness or disagreement without fearing for the position. Because the older leader also holds power, this is where misuse of power is most likely to hide behind warmth.

Independent and house-church communities. Here a minister may have no denomination above them and no official guide. The companion is often a friend: another pastor in another town, an older believer, a former teacher. The strength is freedom. The risk is isolation, and the next lecture, 5-2, takes this up directly.

Celibate and married ministers. A celibate priest, monk or nun usually lives in a structure where a superior, a director or a community knows them. A married minister's closest companion is often a spouse, who is a gift but cannot be the only one. A spouse knows too much, is affected by what is said, and cannot be a neutral listener about the work. Lecture 5-4 returns to the household.

No tradition on this list is the villain, and none has solved the problem. Each has found a way of providing for it, and each leaves a gap.

4. What spiritual direction is, and what it is not

Many mistakes come from confusing one kind of conversation with another. Here is a plain comparison.

Kind of conversation Main attention Who usually does it
Spiritual direction or guidance How I live before God: prayer, , what draws me, what I avoid A guide, elder, mentor or trained director
Counselling or therapy Distress, relationships or patterns of thought and behaviour, treated with trained methods A licensed or recognised professional
Coaching Goals and skills: how to do a task better A coach or experienced colleague
Supervision or oversight The quality and conduct of the work A superior, board, bishop or senior
Confession (where practised) Naming sin and receiving forgiveness within the tradition's own pattern A priest or confessor

These overlap, and in real life one person may do two of them. But the purposes are different, and a good guide knows which one is needed.

If the conversation reveals lasting low mood, heavy anxiety, thoughts of self-harm, a trauma or any condition that needs treatment, a good guide does not try to treat it. The guide says so, kindly, and helps the person reach a doctor or a mental-health professional. Access and cost differ from country to country; where help is scarce, the guide can still help the person find the nearest kind of care and can stay with them while they do. And prayer and professional care are not rivals. Lecture 4-2 says more about this. This lecture does not replace that care.

Ministers sometimes ask for a guide when what they need is a counsellor, or for a counsellor when what they need is a rest. Part of a guide's gift is to say, "I think you need a different kind of help than I can give."

5. What to expect, and what not to expect

If you have never met with a guide, a few things may help.

The pace is slow. A first meeting may be mostly getting to know one another. Do not expect answers. Often the guide's work is to ask a good question and then let the silence stand.

The subject is you, not your church. A minister arriving at a first meeting often begins with the congregation's problems, because that is what is on the desk. A good guide will, sooner or later, ask where you are in all this. You may find it hard to answer. That is normal.

You do the deciding. A guide can offer an observation, a question or a passage to pray with. The guide does not make your decisions for you. Where a tradition values obedience to an elder, this is understood within a long relationship built on trust, and the person can still ask questions, take time and choose another guide if there is a real difficulty. A guide who prefers to decide everything is a reason for care.

What is said is kept private, within limits. A good guide tells you at the start what is kept in confidence and when something would have to be shared (for example, where someone is in danger). The rules differ by tradition and by country. Ask. In Catholic practice the seal of confession has its own strict rules, and these are not the same as the privacy of spiritual direction; a director can explain which applies.

There is no promise of results. A guide cannot guarantee that you will feel closer to God, that your tiredness will lift or that your ministry will thrive. The guide's task is faithful attention, not an outcome.

You may stop. If after some months the fit is wrong, you may say so and end it with thanks. This is not a failure.

6. Finding a guide where you live

The question people ask first is "Where do I find one?" The honest answer is that it depends very much on where you live.

Some places to ask: a monastery or retreat house, a diocesan or denominational office that keeps a list, a seminary or training college, an older minister whose life you respect, a minister of another church whom you already trust. Some guides ask a fee. Others give their time freely. Cost and availability differ widely, and it is reasonable to say what you can afford.

If nobody is nearby, a guide can be met by telephone, by video, or by letter. A monthly letter and reply can work well for a missionary or a minister in a remote place. A trusted friend who listens well, even without training, is better than no companion at all, as long as you both understand what the friendship is for and what it is not.

Qualities to look for are few and simple: the person prays; the person listens more than speaks; the person is not shocked by doubt or weakness; the person keeps confidence; the person does not need you to depend on them; and the person has someone to whom they themselves are accountable. It is fair to ask a possible guide about their own experience and training and about how they work. A good guide will not be offended.

Choosing a guide

This is a point where readers will not agree: who should a minister's guide be?

Some hold that the guide should come from within one's own tradition and, where there is one, from inside its structure: a priest, a bishop's appointee, an elder of the same communion. Their reasons are serious. Such a person knows the tradition's language and practice, understands its pressures, and is likely to be trusted. They also argue that a minister's life is shaped by the community that sent them and should be guided from within it.

Others hold that the guide should be outside the minister's chain of authority, and sometimes outside the tradition altogether. Their reasons are equally serious. A guide who also decides about the minister's placement or pay cannot easily be told the truth. An outsider can hear what an insider cannot.

Some argue that the guide must be formally trained and recognised, because the work can do harm. Others say that a wise, older friend is worth more than a certificate.

Some hold that a minister needs one guide for the long term, because depth takes time. Others say that several people, each helping in a different way, protect against dependence on one.

This course requires less than any of these positions requires. It asks that you have at least one person who has no power over your position, whom you trust, who is able to keep what you say private within known limits, and whom you can reach on a regular basis. Beyond that, the choice depends on your tradition, your place and your need.

7. Two small cases

(An invented example.) A priest in a remote parish has a director who lives six hours away. They speak by telephone every six weeks, for about forty minutes. In the early months the priest talks mostly about administration. His director listens and then asks, "When did you last pray without preparing something?" The priest has no answer. They stay with that question for the rest of the call. Over some months the conversation moves. The priest does not feel dramatically better, and the work is no lighter. But he notes that he can now say what he is afraid of. The director's part was small: a regular hour, an unhurried voice, a few honest questions.

(An invented example.) A young pastor in a growing network of churches is guided by the senior pastor who sent him. At first this is a great help. Then the young pastor notices that every decision, including where to live and whom to marry, is discussed in these meetings, and that the senior pastor expects to be told. When the young pastor says he is tired, the senior pastor says that tiredness is a test of commitment. The young pastor begins to say less.

Something has gone wrong here, and it is not mainly that the senior pastor is a bad man. The roles have been joined: the guide is also the supervisor, the sponsor and the voice of authority, so the younger man has no place where he can say what is true. A better path is possible without anyone being accused. The young pastor can ask for one additional conversation partner outside the network, such as an older minister he respects, for the specific purpose of speaking about his own life with God. He can say plainly to the senior pastor that he wants this, as an addition and not as a rejection. If the senior pastor cannot accept that, the young pastor takes the matter to someone he trusts. Where a guide's conduct has crossed a line, the matter of boundaries and what to do about it belongs to Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E).

Notice that the second case is not a story about the wrong tradition. A guide in any tradition can become too central, and a guide in any tradition can be exactly what is needed.

8. Warning signs, and good signs

A relationship with a guide is probably healthy when you leave it freer than you came, more able to think and pray for yourself, and less afraid. It deserves a second look when the guide wants to decide for you, asks you to keep the relationship secret, discourages you from other friendships, makes you feel that disagreement is disloyalty, or is angry when you want to stop. These are reasons to speak to another trusted person. They are not proof of bad intent, and they are not for you to settle alone.

Good signs are quieter: you are listened to without being hurried; you are asked questions more than given instructions; the guide is glad when you have other friends; and the conversation keeps returning, gently, to God and to your actual life.

9. A word to the one who thinks "I do not need this"

Some ministers feel they do not need a companion. They pray, they read, they are experienced. That may all be true. But Moses was all of those things. The need is not caused by weakness. It comes from the nature of the work: those who serve others are placed in a position where they are seldom seen as persons. A companion sees the person. This is not an extra, added when there is time. It is part of what keeps the person there at all.


Diagram 1. Who walks beside the minister

Different Kinds of Conversation A guide knows which one is needed Spiritual guidance my life before God prayer, calling, what draws me guide, elder, mentor Counselling, therapy distress and patterns treated with trained methods a professional Coaching goals and skills how to do a task better coach, colleague Oversight quality and conduct of the work superior, board Good signs You leave freer than you came You are asked more than told The guide is glad of your other friends Talk returns to God and to your real life At least one person with no power over you Reasons to look again The guide decides for you Secrecy is asked of you Other friendships are discouraged Wanting to stop is treated as disloyalty Speak to another trusted person

Diagram 2. What to ask when looking for a guide

Question Why it helps
Who else do you talk with about your own life with God? A guide who has no companion may lean on you
What is kept private, and when would you have to tell someone? You know the limits before you speak
What do you do when someone needs a doctor or counsellor? A good guide refers and does not try to treat
How will we know whether this is working? Either of you may end it with thanks

In short

  • Moses was told by an outsider that the work was too heavy for him; a minister alone with the work can be mistaken about what is good.
  • Catholic direction, the Orthodox spiritual father or mother, and Protestant mentors and peers meet one need in different shapes. Each has a strength and a risk.
  • Direction is not counselling, therapy, coaching, oversight or confession; a good guide refers where help of another kind is needed.
  • Expect slow pace, questions, privacy within stated limits, and no promise of results. You decide, and you may stop.
  • This course requires at least one person with no power over your position, whom you trust and can reach regularly.
  • Signs of care: you leave freer. Reasons to look again: secrecy, control, discouraging other friends.
Front Back
Exodus 18 An outsider tells Moses the work is too heavy for him alone; Moses listens.
Direction versus counselling Direction attends to a person's life with God; counselling treats distress with trained methods. A good guide refers on.
Minimum this course asks At least one trusted person, with no power over your position, whom you can reach regularly.
Reasons to look again The guide decides for you, asks for secrecy, discourages other friends, or treats leaving as disloyalty.

One sentence to remember A minister who is listened to as a person, and not as a worker, has a place to stand when the work is heavy.

This week's action Write down the name of one person who could be a companion for your inner life, or one place you could ask for such a person, and make the first contact.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Moses listened to a person with no authority over him. Who in your life could say "The thing that you do is not good" to you, and would you hear it?
  • On the road to Emmaus the stranger asks before he tells. What would change in your ministry if you were asked a question like that and not given advice?
  • Which of the five kinds of conversation in the table do you already have? Which are missing?
  • The disagreement over choosing a guide has serious positions on every side. State two of them as their holders would want them stated. Which risks matter most in your place?
  • If a guide's way of working began to feel like control, whom could you speak to? What would you say?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.