Lecture 6-2: Hard Passages
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Inductive" Means
- Lecture 1-2: Getting Ready to Read
- Lecture 1-3: Meeting Familiar Words Again
- Lecture 1-4: Seeing the Whole Method on One Short Passage
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading Psalm 23 Three Times
- Lecture 2-1: Who, What, When, Where, How
- Lecture 2-2: Repeated Words, Contrasts and Connectors
- Lecture 2-3: Context and Genre
- Lecture 2-4: Questions That Open a Text
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Twenty Observations on Mark 4:35-41
- Lecture 3-1: What Did This Mean Then?
- Lecture 3-2: Scripture Interprets Scripture
- Lecture 3-3: Getting Help and Weighing It
- Lecture 3-4: Writing an Interpretation Sentence
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: From Twenty Observations to One Sentence
- Lecture 4-1: From Meaning to Principle
- Lecture 4-2: One Concrete Step
- Lecture 4-3: When Application Does Harm
- Lecture 4-4: Application in Community
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: From Interpretation to One Sentence of Application
- Lecture 5-1: Dictionaries, Concordances, Commentaries, Study Bibles
- Lecture 5-2: Studying in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-3: Learning From Other Ways of Reading
- Lecture 5-4: Reading Different Kinds of Writing
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading the Same Passage Again with a Tool
Sooner or later every reader meets a passage that will not sit still. Some passages are confusing. Some seem to praise violence, or to treat people unequally. Some have been used against the reader or against someone the reader loves. Some are hard because they speak of pain that does not lift. Reading honestly means meeting these passages as they are, and not skipping them or pretending they are easy.
This lecture does not promise to solve any of them. It offers a way to stay with a hard passage without lying about it. The way is simple, and it is not quick. You say exactly what is hard. You look at everything the passage actually says. You use context and good help. You ask trustworthy people. And you let yourself write, where it is true, three words that many readers find very difficult: "I do not know."
A caution first. If a passage touches something painful in your own life, you do not have to read it today. Resting is allowed. If a passage is being used to make you accept harm, that is a safety matter and not a Bible-study matter, and the section "When a passage is used to hold you in harm" tells you what to do.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Name four ways in which a passage can be hard and say which one you are facing.
- Explain the difference between a text that reports something and a text that approves it.
- Describe three kinds of "I do not know" and when each is honest.
- State fairly the different ways in which readers receive hard passages, and say what this course asks of every reader.
- Say what to do, and whom to contact, when a passage is used to cover harm or when a reader is in despair.
Yahweh, the God of my salvation, I have cried day and night before you. Let my prayer enter into your presence. Turn your ear to my cry." — Psalm 88:1-2
World English Bible
You have put lover and friend far from me, and my friends into darkness." — Psalm 88:18
WEB
I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you. Therefore I abhor myself, and repent in dust and ashes.”" — Job 42:5-6
WEB
After these things, God tested Abraham, and said to him, “Abraham!” He said, “Here I am.” He said, “Now take your son, your only son, whom you love, even Isaac, and go into the land of Moriah. Offer him there for a burnt offering on one of the mountains which I will tell you of.”" — Genesis 22:1-2
WEB
He said, “Don’t lay your hand on the boy, neither do anything to him. For now I know that you fear God, since you have not withheld your son, your only son, from me.”" — Genesis 22:12
WEB
The first two verses open and close a psalm that has no turn toward light; its last word is darkness. The third is part of Job's final answer. The last two come from a story that has been read, loved and found troubling for a very long time. None of these passages is easy. The lecture does not make them easy.
1. Four ways a passage can be hard
It helps to name the kind of difficulty, because each kind asks for a different response.
- It is confusing. The words are strange, the setting is far away, or the passage seems to contradict another. Here the tools of weeks 2, 3 and 5 are the first help.
- It troubles us morally. It reports or seems to approve something we find wrong, such as violence in war, the treatment of women or children, or slavery. Here we ask what kind of writing it is, what it says and what it does not say.
- It has been used to wound. The passage may be quite clear, but someone used it to demand silence, to excuse harm, or to make a hurting person feel at fault. Here the first task is not interpretation. It is safety and care.
- It leaves us in pain or doubt. Prayers that are not answered, suffering that is not explained, a God who seems far away. Here the question is not "what does it mean?" so much as "may I stay here?"
A passage may be hard in more than one of these ways. If you can say which kind it is for you, you have already done part of the work.
2. Say exactly what is hard
(an invented example) Amara reads Genesis 22 and writes in her notebook only: "This is terrible." That sentence is honest, but it is not yet useful. Later she writes: "What I find hard is that God asks Abraham to offer his son (22:2), that Abraham rises early and goes (22:3), and that the text gives no word from Isaac's side except one question (22:7)." Now she has something she can bring to a teacher and test.
The first step with any hard passage is to turn a general reaction into particular observations. Write down which words trouble you, which verse number they are in, and what you would like to know. A hard passage described exactly is already half-way to a good question.
3. A report is not an approval
This idea from the last lecture matters most here. A narrative writer tells us what people did and what happened. Telling is not the same as recommending. The Bible reports betrayal, murder and cruelty, and it does not praise them for being reported. Whether a writer approves, condemns or leaves the matter open has to be decided from the passage and from the book around it, not assumed.
Prayers are a special case. Some psalms bring anger, grief and even a wish for harm to enemies. Psalm 137:8-9 is a well-known example, and its closing lines ask for violence against the children of Babylon. (If you would rather not read that passage today, you may skip it.) Readers have long noticed that the psalm speaks its anger to God, in prayer, and does not itself carry out any act. A prayer of rage is not a command to the reader to do what the psalmist wishes. Many readers, in many traditions, have found it important that this honest anger is brought to God and not taken out on other people. Others find the psalm hard to read at all, and that, too, is allowed.
4. Psalm 88: a prayer that ends in the dark
Many psalms of lament turn somewhere. The singer complains, asks, and then finds a reason to trust or to praise. Psalm 88 does not. It begins by saying that the speaker has cried to God day and night, asks that the prayer reach him (88:1-2), and then moves through grief, isolation and a sense of being cut off. The last verse is not a word of hope. It speaks of friends gone into darkness (88:18).
Several things can honestly be said. The psalm is in the Bible, so a prayer with no turn is a prayer the Scriptures keep. It is addressed to God, from beginning to end, even where it complains of him. And the psalm does not answer its own pain. A reader who tries to add a happy ending is not reading it but rewriting it.
A word of care. Some readers who are in deep despair find that Psalm 88 says what they cannot say. That can be a comfort, and it can also be a danger if the reader is alone. If you are having thoughts of ending your life, or you are afraid for someone who is, please do not keep this to yourself and do not wait to finish a Bible study. Tell a person now: a pastor, a priest, a doctor, a counsellor or a trusted friend. If there is danger now, call your local emergency number or a crisis line where you live. Study and medical or counselling care go together, and care comes first.
5. Job: the answer that is not tidy
The book of Job is about a man who suffers and who asks God to explain. His friends offer explanations. Near the end, Job answers God: "I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you. Therefore I abhor myself, and repent in dust and ashes" (Job 42:5-6). What exactly Job repents of, and what the last phrase means, are matters on which careful readers differ. Be slow to settle that question quickly.
What can be said plainly is in the next verses. God turns to Job's three friends, who had given tidy explanations of his suffering, and says that they had not spoken of him rightly, "as my servant Job has" (Job 42:7). The book thus refuses the quick answer. It does not give an account of why Job suffered. For a reader who is tempted to explain someone's pain in a sentence, this is a sobering fact.
6. Genesis 22: reading a very hard story slowly
The story of Abraham and Isaac may be the hardest narrative in the book of Genesis for many readers. Let us read it as the method asks, by observation first. We do not pretend to settle it.
(an invented example) Here is a short sheet in three columns, such as a student might make. It is invented, and it is only a beginning.
| What I see in the passage | What I do not know | Whom I might ask |
|---|---|---|
| God tests Abraham (22:1) | What "tests" means here, and why this test | A teacher, a study Bible |
| God tells him to offer his son, his only son, whom he loves (22:2) | Why this command is given in this form | A pastor or priest, a teacher |
| Abraham rises early and goes (22:3) | What he thought and felt; the text does not say | A teacher |
| Isaac asks where the lamb is; Abraham says God will provide it (22:7-8) | How much Abraham knew or hoped | A teacher |
| An angel calls and says not to lay a hand on the boy (22:11-12) | Why the test ends this way | A teacher, a trustworthy commentary |
| A ram is found and offered in the son's place (22:13) | What the ram is meant to show | A teacher |
Three observations are worth making. First, the story does not end with the death of a child. The angel's word in 22:12 stops it. Second, the narrator tells us at the start that this is a test (22:1), so the reader knows something that Abraham and Isaac do not. Third, the text gives us very little of Abraham's inner life. Where the text is silent, we should say so.
Nothing in the passage gives anyone permission to harm a child, or to claim that God has told them to. A person who says so is misusing it. Children are to be kept safe, and if a child is in danger now, the local emergency number is the right call.
Readers have received the story in different ways. In Jewish tradition it is called the binding of Isaac, a name taken from the story itself, and it has been read and discussed over many centuries. Many early Christian writers read Isaac as a picture that points toward Christ. Some modern readers find the story deeply disturbing and say so. None of these readers is outside the conversation.
7. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: how we should receive the hard passages of the Bible.
Some readers hold that a hard passage shows the limits of our understanding, not any fault in Scripture. For them the right response is trust that God is good, patience, and a willingness to wait for light, perhaps for many years. They say that to treat Scripture as a thing we can sit in judgment over is to put ourselves in the place of God. Others hold that Scripture itself teaches us to protest: Job argues, the lament psalms accuse, and the prophets plead. For them, to say honestly "this troubles me deeply" is not rebellion but the kind of faith the Bible itself shows. Catholic and Orthodox readers often read hard passages inside the church's long reading, together with the Fathers, the and the teaching of their church, and find that the hard text is held in a larger whole. Jewish readers have long kept the habit of arguing over a text without leaving it. All of these ways take Scripture seriously.
The course requires less than any one of them. Say honestly what you do not know. Do not force a quick answer. Look for trustworthy company. You do not have to explain a hard passage to read it, and you do not have to give it up to question it.
8. Three kinds of "I do not know"
Writing "I do not know" feels like failure to many people. It is better thought of as a careful report. There are at least three kinds.
| The sentence | What it says | When it is honest |
|---|---|---|
| "I do not know yet" | I have not yet used the tools or asked | Early in the study, before you have looked |
| "I do not know, and careful readers differ" | I have looked, and trustworthy people disagree | After using tools and asking others |
| "I do not know, and the text does not say" | The passage is silent on this | When the passage gives no answer, as with Abraham's thoughts |
Each of these is a finished sentence. Each tells the next reader, or your later self, exactly where you stand.
9. The temptation to fill the gap
When we do not know, we are tempted to put something in the space. Gap-filling is often kind in intention and it often does damage. It is the same slip as reading into the text (lecture 6-1), done under stress.
(an invented example) After reading Genesis 22, a student reaches for a quick relief: "It was only a test, so there is nothing to worry about," or "Abraham surely knew it would turn out all right." The first sentence skips the distress that many readers feel, and the second claims knowledge of Abraham's mind that the text does not give. A better note would read: "The text calls it a test. It does not tell me what Abraham knew. I find it hard. I will ask."
The same temptation comes when we talk to someone who is suffering. The lesson of Job's friends is that confident explanations of another person's pain can be wrong and unkind. If you are with a hurting person, listening is nearly always better than explaining.
10. Asking trustworthy people
A hard passage need not be carried alone. To ask well, bring the passage and your notes. Say what you see and what troubles you. Ask, "What do you do with this?" and not "Defend this." A good teacher will not be offended by honest questions and will tell you what they do not know as well as what they do. Ask more than one person, from more than one tradition if you can. If everyone you ask gives you the same quick answer and none will admit a difficulty, take that as a sign to ask again.
11. When a passage is used to hold you in harm
Some passages are hard because someone has used them against you. If a verse is used to tell you that you must submit to violence, that you must keep silent about abuse, that you must stop medicine or treatment, or that suffering at another person's hands is your duty, this is not a question for Bible study. A passage cannot be used to hide harm.
Please speak, as soon as you can, to a responsible person you trust: a pastor, a priest, a counsellor, a doctor, a member of a support service. If there is danger now, call your local emergency number. Domestic violence is a safety matter. Taking safe steps is not unfaithfulness. When you are safe, you can return to the passage with someone who will read it with you carefully.
12. Resting from a passage
You may put a hard passage down. This is not cowardice. Some passages are too heavy for some seasons of life, and they will still be there later. No one is required to read what injures them. A short Psalm, a rest, a meal or a walk is a proper answer to a hard day. Many readers return to a hard passage years later and read it very differently.
Diagram 1. An honest way through a hard passage
In short
- A passage can be hard in four ways: confusing, morally troubling, used to wound, or leaving us in pain or doubt.
- Say exactly which words are hard, and look at everything the passage says before judging it.
- A report is not an approval, and a prayer of anger is not a command to act on it.
- Writing "I do not know yet", "careful readers differ" or "the text is silent" is an honest report.
- Do not fill the gap with a tidy answer the text does not give.
- When a passage is used to hide harm or a reader is in despair, speak to a responsible person and use the local emergency number if there is danger now.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four kinds of hard | Confusing; morally troubling; used to wound; leaving us in pain or doubt. |
| First step with a hard passage | Say exactly what is hard: which words, which verse, which kind. |
| Three kinds of "I do not know" | Not yet; careful readers differ; the text is silent. |
| A passage used to hide harm | A safety matter: speak to a pastor, priest or counsellor, and call the local emergency number if there is danger now. |
One sentence to remember An honest "I do not know" is better than a tidy answer the text does not give.
This week's action Find one passage that has troubled you and write on one page what is hard, what the passage says, and one of the three kinds of "I do not know"; then choose one person to ask.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four kinds of difficulty (confusing, morally troubling, used to wound, leaving us in pain) have you met in a passage? You may pass on the example.
- Why is it important to say exactly which words in a passage are hard, and not only "this is hard"?
- What is the difference between a text that reports an action and a text that approves it? Where in Scripture have you seen the difference?
- Which kind of "I do not know" is easiest for you to write, and which is hardest? Why might the hardest one be the most honest?
- Job's friends gave explanations and were told they had not spoken rightly. What does this suggest about how we speak to someone who is suffering?