Lecture 5-3: Learning From Other Ways of Reading
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Inductive" Means
- Lecture 1-2: Getting Ready to Read
- Lecture 1-3: Meeting Familiar Words Again
- Lecture 1-4: Seeing the Whole Method on One Short Passage
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading Psalm 23 Three Times
- Lecture 2-1: Who, What, When, Where, How
- Lecture 2-2: Repeated Words, Contrasts and Connectors
- Lecture 2-3: Context and Genre
- Lecture 2-4: Questions That Open a Text
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Twenty Observations on Mark 4:35-41
- Lecture 3-1: What Did This Mean Then?
- Lecture 3-2: Scripture Interprets Scripture
- Lecture 3-3: Getting Help and Weighing It
- Lecture 3-4: Writing an Interpretation Sentence
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: From Twenty Observations to One Sentence
- Lecture 4-1: From Meaning to Principle
- Lecture 4-2: One Concrete Step
- Lecture 4-3: When Application Does Harm
- Lecture 4-4: Application in Community
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: From Interpretation to One Sentence of Application
- Lecture 5-1: Dictionaries, Concordances, Commentaries, Study Bibles
- Lecture 5-2: Studying in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-3: Learning From Other Ways of Reading
- Lecture 5-4: Reading Different Kinds of Writing
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading the Same Passage Again with a Tool
The inductive method is a way of reading, and it has a history of its own. It grew in particular places and answers particular worries. Christians have read Scripture in other ways too, some much older. A reader who knows only one way of reading may think it is the only way, or the only safe way. A reader who knows several can see what each is good at, where each can go wrong, and how they can stand side by side.
This lecture describes five other ways of reading in outline: lectio divina, the lectionary, reading with the church's early teachers, reading with a catechism, and the habit of study in pairs found in many Jewish communities. A short note on reading aloud together comes last. It is not a full account of any of them, and each has its own teachers whom you should ask if you wish to go deeper. The aim is modest. For each way we say what it is, what it stresses, what it risks, and how it can sit beside the three steps. We do not say which is best. This course holds that none of these ways owns the Bible and each can teach the others something.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe lectio divina in four movements.
- Say what a lectionary is and what it gives to a reader.
- Explain how reading with the church's early teachers or with a catechism differs from reading alone.
- Name one strength and one risk of each way of reading, including the inductive way.
- Explain how at least one other way can sit beside inductive study.
but his delight is in Yahweh’s law. On his law he meditates day and night." — Psalm 1:2
World English Bible
But Mary kept all these sayings, pondering them in her heart." — Luke 2:19
WEB
He said to them, “This is what I told you, while I was still with you, that all things which are written in the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms, concerning me must be fulfilled.”" — Luke 24:44
WEB
Then he opened their minds, that they might understand the Scriptures." — Luke 24:45
WEB
Three scenes are set side by side. In Psalm 1:2 the one who delights in God's law meditates on it, which suggests staying with the words over time. In Luke 2:19 Mary is shown keeping and pondering what she has heard. In Luke 24:44-45 Jesus teaches his followers that the Law, the Prophets and the Psalms speak of him, and he opens their minds to understand. Different churches draw different lessons from these verses. What they show together is that Scripture has been read slowly, thoughtfully, and in company with a teacher.
1. Lectio divina
is Latin for "divine reading". It is a way of reading Scripture slowly, in prayer, that grew in the monasteries and is practised today by many Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and Protestant readers. It is usually described in four movements. A twelfth-century monk named Guigo is often credited with setting out these four in this order.
- Reading (in Latin, lectio). You read a short passage slowly, often aloud, and more than once.
- Meditation (meditatio). You stay with a word or phrase that caught you and turn it over, asking what it says to you.
- Prayer (oratio). You answer God in words: thanks, request, sorrow, praise.
- Rest or contemplation (contemplatio). You stop speaking and rest in God's presence, without trying to produce a thought.
Some teachers add a fifth movement, action (actio), in which the reading is carried into life.
What does lectio divina stress? It stresses that Scripture is read to meet God and not only to learn about him. It is patient with short passages, and it values the heart as well as the mind. Its strengths are the slow pace and the prayer.
What are its risks? Because the second movement turns on what a word means to you, a reader can slide from "what this says" to "what I feel", and may forget to ask what the passage meant where it stands. Lecture 4-3 discussed this when we looked at a personal sense of being addressed. The cure is not to drop the practice but to know the passage before you begin.
How can it sit beside inductive study? Very simply. First observe the passage with the methods of week 2 and write your interpretation sentence. Then take the same passage into a quiet time and read it as lectio: slowly, praying, resting. The study gives the prayer something to rest on, and the prayer gives the study somewhere to go. The course on prayer (LM106E) and the course LM102E, on reading plans and Bible meditation, go further.
2. The lectionary
A lectionary is a table of Scripture readings fixed for each day or Sunday of the church's year. Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Lutheran and many other churches use one. In many Catholic parishes the Sunday readings run in a cycle over three years. In Orthodox churches the readings are tied to the yearly cycle of feasts. Different churches have different tables, and the details are for the parish to explain.
A lectionary stresses that Scripture is read together, with the whole church, in a common order. A person in one city and a person in another may hear the same passage on the same day. A lectionary also pushes a reader toward passages they would not choose. A person who reads only what they like may never meet the harder books. The order of readings also follows the story of the church's year, so that the readings of Advent, Lent and Easter, for example, are chosen to fit those seasons.
Its limits are real. A lectionary reading is often short and may cut a passage out of its setting. A reader who studies only the Sunday reading may not see what comes before or after. And a lectionary is not Scripture: it is the church's choice of Scripture for a purpose. Many who use one find the answer in a simple habit: when you hear a reading, open the Bible and read the chapter around it.
Beside inductive study, a lectionary is a good gift. It gives you a passage chosen by someone other than yourself, which is a way of being corrected in your choices. Observe and interpret that passage with the three steps, and when you listen to the homily, notice what you saw and what the preacher saw.
3. Reading with the church's early teachers
The early teachers of the church, often called the fathers (and, as many add, the mothers), were bishops, monks, writers and preachers of the first centuries. They did not have our tools, and they did not write our kind of commentary. But they read the Bible all their lives, and they read it inside a community that already had a baptism, a creed and a pattern of worship. Many of them held that the Old Testament speaks of Christ, as Luke 24:44-45 suggests. Many also read passages on more than one level. In the Middle Ages, writers often spoke of four: the plain sense of the words (literal), what the passage shows about Christ and the church (allegorical), what it asks in conduct (moral), and what it points to in the world to come.
What does this way stress? It stresses that the church has read Scripture for a very long time, and a reader does well to listen to those who read before. It stresses the unity of the Bible: that Genesis and Revelation are one book. And it stresses the reader's life in prayer and worship.
What is the risk? Some early readings are very bold, and some use allegory so freely that a detail is made to mean almost anything. A modern reader may not be able to tell which readings are useful and which are fanciful. Also, the fathers did not all agree. To say "the fathers say" is as unsafe as to say "scholars say": you must ask which father, and in which work.
Catholic and Orthodox readers often hold that the church's long reading carries real weight in interpreting Scripture. Many Protestant readers value the early teachers highly but hold that no teacher or tradition stands above the text. These are different positions, and lecture 3-3 set them out. Both can read the fathers with profit. A simple use for a lay person is to look in a study Bible or a good commentary for notes that say how the early teachers read the passage, and to read what they offer as a second voice beside your own.
4. Reading with a catechism
A is a summary of Christian teaching, often in the form of questions and answers, used to teach children, new believers and congregations. Many churches have one. Reading with a catechism means that when you come to a passage, you ask what your church teaches about the matters it raises, and you read the passage in the light of that teaching.
The strength of this way is plain. It joins the passage to the whole of the faith, so that a single verse is not turned into a new doctrine. It guards against private novelty. It reminds a reader that they do not stand alone, and that the questions they ask have been asked before.
The risk is the reverse. If the catechism is always allowed to speak first, a reader may see in the passage only what the catechism says, and may stop being surprised by the text. This is the very habit of reading from a conclusion that the inductive method was built to meet. Each tradition feels the risk differently, and each has its answer. Many hold that a good catechism is itself drawn from Scripture and should be able to bear being tested against it.
How can the two sit together? Observe and interpret the passage first. Then ask where your church's teaching speaks to the matter. If they agree, you have a firmer hold on both. If they seem to differ, do not rush to a verdict. Hold the question, ask a pastor or priest, and look again at the passage. Disagreement between your reading and your church's teaching is a signal to slow down, and it does not follow that your church is wrong.
5. Study in pairs
In many Jewish communities, study of the sacred texts is often done in pairs, a practice called chavruta. Two people read a text together, read it aloud, ask each other questions, press each other with objections and try to understand. Argument in such study is not a quarrel. It is a way of honouring the text by testing every claim about it. This is a description of a living practice, and there is much more to it than a short paragraph can show. Christian readers who wish to know it better should learn from those who practise it.
What can a Christian reader take from this? The partner's way, which each Practice Lab of this course has used, is of the same family: two readers who study and then question each other. The strength of this way is that it makes a reader give reasons, and welcomes disagreement as a gift. Its risk, in a mixed setting, is that a reader may assume that all is open to challenge, when some members of the group hold some matters as settled by their tradition. Courtesy and clear speech help here.
6. Reading aloud together
One more way is the oldest. For much of history, most people met Scripture not by reading a page, but by hearing it read aloud in a gathering. Nehemiah 8 shows such a scene, and many churches still begin worship in this way. A reading aloud in a group or in a family has strengths that private study does not: it is heard in the cadence of speech, the listener cannot skip, and the whole group meets the same words at the same moment. Its risk is that it can pass too fast. A simple remedy, used in lecture 1-3, is to read the passage more than once and to leave a minute of silence between.
7. Where each way is strong, and where each can fail
| Way of reading | What it stresses | A strength | A risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inductive study | The words and context of the passage | Teaches careful looking; protects against reading in | Can become a solitary puzzle; may forget that the church has read before |
| Lectio divina | Meeting God in a short passage | Slow, prayerful, patient | Can slide from "what it says" to "what I feel" |
| Lectionary | Reading with the whole church in a common order | Gives passages you would not choose | Short readings can lose their setting |
| Early teachers | The church's long reading; the unity of the Bible | A second voice from far away | Bold readings; the teachers differ |
| Catechism | The Bible within the whole faith | Guards against private novelty | The summary may speak before the text |
| Study in pairs | Reasons given and tested | Welcomes disagreement | Not all matters are open in every setting |
| Reading aloud | Hearing together | Everyone meets the same words | Can pass too fast |
8. No ranking, and one common minimum
This table does not rank the ways. Some readers will prefer one, and some will hold that their own church's way is the true centre of the others. This is a point where readers will not agree, and lecture 1-1 and lecture 3-3 have already named it. What this course asks is less than any one way asks. It asks that you hold your reading as a hypothesis, that you test it with others and not alone, and that you do not become certain of a new teaching you built yourself. A reader of any of these ways can keep that rule.
Diagram 1. Many roads to the same passage
Diagram 2. The four movements of lectio divina
| Movement | Latin | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Reading | lectio | Read a short passage slowly, more than once |
| Meditation | meditatio | Stay with a word or phrase and turn it over |
| Prayer | oratio | Answer God in words |
| Rest | contemplatio | Stop speaking and rest in God's presence |
In short
- Lectio divina reads a short passage slowly in four movements: reading, meditation, prayer and rest.
- A lectionary gives passages chosen by the church, which corrects a reader's own choices but may cut a passage from its setting.
- Reading with the early teachers or a catechism joins a passage to the church's long reading and teaching, with the risk that the summary speaks before the text.
- Study in pairs, as in many Jewish communities, tests every claim with reasons.
- Each way has a strength and a risk, including the inductive way.
- None is ranked; the shared minimum is to hold your reading as a hypothesis and test it in company.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four movements of lectio divina | Reading, meditation, prayer, rest; some add action. |
| What a lectionary gives | Passages chosen by the church in a common order, including ones you would not choose. |
| A risk of reading with a catechism | The summary may speak before the text, so a reader stops being surprised by it. |
| The common minimum | Hold your reading as a hypothesis, test it in company, and do not become certain of a new teaching you built alone. |
One sentence to remember Each way of reading sees something the others may miss, so none needs to be ranked.
This week's action Take a passage you have already studied and spend five minutes with it in lectio divina, or read the chapter around a lectionary reading you heard this week.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of these ways of reading do you already practise, even without the name? Which is new to you?
- Why might a lectionary be a gift to a reader who studies on their own?
- A reader finds that the catechism of their church seems to disagree with what they have seen in a passage. What are two things they might do before deciding who is right?
- Each way in the table has a risk. Which risk do you think is most likely for you, and what could help?
- If you belong to a tradition that holds one of these ways as central, how would you describe it to someone from another tradition in words your own people would accept? You may pass.