Lecture 2-4: Questions That Open a Text
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Inductive" Means
- Lecture 1-2: Getting Ready to Read
- Lecture 1-3: Meeting Familiar Words Again
- Lecture 1-4: Seeing the Whole Method on One Short Passage
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading Psalm 23 Three Times
- Lecture 2-1: Who, What, When, Where, How
- Lecture 2-2: Repeated Words, Contrasts and Connectors
- Lecture 2-3: Context and Genre
- Lecture 2-4: Questions That Open a Text
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Twenty Observations on Mark 4:35-41
- Lecture 3-1: What Did This Mean Then?
- Lecture 3-2: Scripture Interprets Scripture
- Lecture 3-3: Getting Help and Weighing It
- Lecture 3-4: Writing an Interpretation Sentence
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: From Twenty Observations to One Sentence
- Lecture 4-1: From Meaning to Principle
- Lecture 4-2: One Concrete Step
- Lecture 4-3: When Application Does Harm
- Lecture 4-4: Application in Community
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: From Interpretation to One Sentence of Application
- Lecture 5-1: Dictionaries, Concordances, Commentaries, Study Bibles
- Lecture 5-2: Studying in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-3: Learning From Other Ways of Reading
- Lecture 5-4: Reading Different Kinds of Writing
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading the Same Passage Again with a Tool
A list of observations is a good start, but it is only a start. A page of facts about a passage does not yet tell you where to look next. What turns facts into a study is a question. A good question points back at the text and says, "Look again here."
This lecture is about the step between observation and interpretation: turning what you have seen into questions, and sorting those questions before you try to answer any of them. The sorting matters because questions are not all alike. Some the passage itself will answer. Some need help from outside it. And some the passage will not answer at all, however long you look.
The passage is Luke 24:13-35, the story of two travellers on a road. It is long enough to give a real list of observations, and it happens to be full of questions of its own.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Turn an observation into a question that sends you back to the text.
- Tell a leading question from an open one, and repair a leading one.
- Sort questions into three groups: the text answers, background answers, and I do not know.
- Say how you can tell that you have collected enough observations.
Behold, two of them were going that very day to a village named Emmaus, which was sixty stadia from Jerusalem." — Luke 24:13
World English Bible
They talked with each other about all of these things which had happened." — Luke 24:14
WEB
While they talked and questioned together, Jesus himself came near, and went with them." — Luke 24:15
WEB
But their eyes were kept from recognizing him." — Luke 24:16
WEB
He said to them, “What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?”" — Luke 24:17
WEB
One of them, named Cleopas, answered him, “Are you the only stranger in Jerusalem who doesn’t know the things which have happened there in these days?”" — Luke 24:18
WEB
He said to them, “What things?” They said to him, “The things concerning Jesus, the Nazarene, who was a prophet mighty in deed and word before God and all the people;" — Luke 24:19
WEB
and how the chief priests and our rulers delivered him up to be condemned to death, and crucified him." — Luke 24:20
WEB
But we were hoping that it was he who would redeem Israel. Yes, and besides all this, it is now the third day since these things happened." — Luke 24:21
WEB
Also, certain women of our company amazed us, having arrived early at the tomb;" — Luke 24:22
WEB
and when they didn’t find his body, they came saying that they had also seen a vision of angels, who said that he was alive." — Luke 24:23
WEB
Some of us went to the tomb, and found it just like the women had said, but they didn’t see him.”" — Luke 24:24
WEB
He said to them, “Foolish men, and slow of heart to believe in all that the prophets have spoken!" — Luke 24:25
WEB
Didn’t the Christ have to suffer these things and to enter into his glory?”" — Luke 24:26
WEB
Beginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself." — Luke 24:27
WEB
They drew near to the village, where they were going, and he acted like he would go further." — Luke 24:28
WEB
They urged him, saying, “Stay with us, for it is almost evening, and the day is almost over.” He went in to stay with them." — Luke 24:29
WEB
When he had sat down at the table with them, he took the bread and gave thanks. Breaking it, he gave to them." — Luke 24:30
WEB
Their eyes were opened, and they recognized him, and he vanished out of their sight." — Luke 24:31
WEB
They said one to another, “Weren’t our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us?”" — Luke 24:32
WEB
They rose up that very hour, returned to Jerusalem, and found the eleven gathered together, and those who were with them," — Luke 24:33
WEB
saying, “The Lord is risen indeed, and has appeared to Simon!”" — Luke 24:34
WEB
They related the things that happened along the way, and how he was recognized by them in the breaking of the bread." — Luke 24:35
WEB
He said to them, “This is what I told you, while I was still with you, that all things which are written in the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms, concerning me must be fulfilled.”" — Luke 24:44
WEB
1. From a fact to a question
A fact says what is there. A question asks about it. Take one fact from Luke 24: "Their eyes were kept from recognizing him" (verse 16). The fact stands on its own. Now ask about it: Who or what kept their eyes? For how long? Does the passage say? The question has no answer yet, but it has done something useful. It has sent your attention back to verse 16 and to the verses around it, and it has made you look at the wording.
The simplest way to make a question is to take an observation and add one of the old words: what, who, why, how, where, when. Another way is to put two observations side by side and ask what connects them. A third is to ask what the passage does not say.
Questions at this stage are not yet answered. This is hard for people who like answers. When we ask a question we want to settle it at once. But a question settled too early stops us from seeing the next one. For this lecture, write the question and leave it standing.
2. A working list for Luke 24:13-35
Here are some observations from the passage, as an invented working list. (an invented example) Each number is a verse.
- Two of them were going "that very day" to a village named Emmaus, sixty stadia from Jerusalem (13).
- They were talking with each other about "all of these things which had happened" (14).
- Jesus came near and went with them, "But their eyes were kept from recognizing him" (15-16).
- He asked, “What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?” (17).
- One of them, named Cleopas, answered with a question (18).
- Jesus replied with a question: “What things?” (19).
- They said, “we were hoping that it was he who would redeem Israel” (21).
- They told of the third day, the women at the tomb, a vision of angels, and some who went to the tomb and "didn't see him" (21-24).
- Jesus called them “Foolish men, and slow of heart”, and asked, “Didn’t the Christ have to suffer these things and to enter into his glory?” (25-26).
- “Beginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself” (27).
- He "acted like he would go further", and they urged him, “Stay with us” (28-29).
- At the table he took the bread, gave thanks, broke it and gave it to them. Their eyes were opened, they recognized him, and he vanished (30-31).
- They said, “Weren’t our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us?” (32).
- They returned “that very hour” to Jerusalem and found the eleven gathered (33), and told what had happened (35).
Count the question marks in the passage, and you find five: verses 17, 18, 19, 26 and 32. That is itself an observation. In this story, questions come before explanations.
3. Questions from the list
From these fourteen lines, a reader might ask the following. Do not try to answer them yet.
- Why were their eyes kept from recognizing him? Who kept them? (verse 16)
- Who was the second traveller? (verse 18 names only one)
- Where was Emmaus? How far is sixty stadia?
- What does "redeem Israel" mean for the people who said it? (verse 21)
- Why do they say "we were hoping" in the past tense? (verse 21)
- Which parts of Moses and the prophets did he explain? (verse 27)
- What does the passage show about why Jesus asks questions in verses 17 and 19?
- How does the burning of their hearts connect to his opening of the Scriptures? (verse 32)
- Why did they go back to Jerusalem that very hour? (verse 33)
Notice that these are questions of different kinds. Some ask about a word. Some ask about a person. Some ask about a reason. Some ask how two parts fit together. This variety is what you want.
4. Sorting the questions: three groups
Now sort. Make three columns on a page and put each question where it belongs.
1. The text answers. The passage itself, or the verses around it, can answer these. They need a closer look, not outside help. Why do they say "we were hoping" in the past tense? The disciples give their own reasons in verses 20 to 24: Jesus was condemned and crucified, it was the third day, and those who went to the tomb found it empty but did not see him. How does the burning of their hearts connect to his opening of the Scriptures? Verse 32 puts the two together with two "while" clauses: "while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us". The text speaks.
2. Background answers. These need help from outside the passage: geography, customs, the meaning of a word, other parts of the Bible. Where was Emmaus? How far is sixty stadia? A map and a study Bible will answer, and will say how sure they are. Sources differ about where Emmaus was, and a careful note says so. What does "redeem Israel" mean? This needs knowledge of what the word "redeem" meant to the people who said it, which lecture 3-1 takes up. Sometimes a wider circle of the Bible helps: a few verses later, the same chapter lists “the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms” (verse 44). That is a lead toward the question about verse 27, but it is a different scene, and it does not list the passages either.
3. I do not know. The text is silent, and no tool will quickly fill the silence. Why were their eyes kept from recognizing him? The verb is passive: "were kept". No agent is named, and no reason is given in the passage. Who was the second traveller? The passage does not say. Which passages in Moses and the prophets did he explain? Verse 27 does not list them. You may find guesses in commentaries and in sermons. Some of them are thoughtful. But a guess is not the passage.
The third column deserves respect. A reader who writes "I do not know" has told the truth about the text. A student who fills every blank with a confident answer has not done better work. In week 6 we will see that the courage to leave a question open is part of studying for the long run.
5. Leading questions
Not every question opens a text. Some close it. A leading question carries its answer inside it. It looks like a question, but the reader has already decided.
| A leading question | What it assumes | An open version |
|---|---|---|
| Why did Jesus pretend not to know what had happened? | That he was pretending. The text says only that he asked. | What does the passage show about why Jesus asks in verses 17 and 19? |
| Why were the disciples so stubborn? | A verdict on their character. | What do the travellers say they believed, and what do they say they did not see? |
| How does this passage prove that we must always be reading the Scriptures together? | A conclusion about what the passage teaches. | What do the travellers say about what happened when the Scriptures were opened? |
The repair is nearly always the same: remove the verdict, return to what the text says, and ask about that. A leading question is not wicked. We all ask them. The aim is to notice when we are doing it.
6. How many observations are enough?
No number guarantees a good study. Here are some signs.
- Your new looks give you the same things. When another pass through the passage brings only what you have already written, you have reached the edge of what observation will give for now.
- You can say the shape of the passage in two sentences. For Luke 24:13-35: Two travellers talk about the death and the reports of the empty tomb; a stranger joins them, asks questions and explains the Scriptures; they recognize him at table and go back to tell others. If you cannot do that, you may have missed the outline.
- You have asked each reporter question, and looked at the patterns of lecture 2-2.
- You have time and energy left to ask questions. A tired reader with twelve honest observations is better prepared than a reader who made forty and no longer cares.
In the lab of this week you will aim for twenty on a shorter passage. Twenty is a training figure. It helps beginners slow down. It is not a rule for every passage.
7. Questions in company
Questions often come better in a group. Another reader sees what you missed and asks about it. A good group question is shaped like "I wonder what is going on here" and not like "Surely this means...". The first invites the others to look at the text. The second invites them to argue. If you are in a small group, you can ask each person to bring one question they cannot answer, and one they think the text answers. The difference between those two will teach everyone something.
Diagram 1. Sorting the questions: three columns
Diagram 2. Leading and open questions
| If your question begins | Check |
|---|---|
| "Why did he pretend ..." | Does the text say he pretended? |
| "Why were they so ..." | Is that a verdict? What does the text say? |
| "How does this prove ..." | Have you already decided what it proves? |
In short
- A question turns an observation into a study; it sends you back to look again at particular words.
- A question can be made from a fact by adding what, who, why or how, or by setting two facts side by side.
- Sort questions into three groups: the text answers, background answers, and I do not know.
- Writing "I do not know" about a question the passage does not answer is honest, not a failure.
- A leading question carries a verdict; repair it by returning to what the text says.
- There is no number of observations that guarantees a good study; stop when new looks only repeat what you have.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three groups of questions | The text answers; background answers; I do not know. |
| A leading question | A question that already holds its answer; repair it by asking about what the text says. |
| Why leave a question open | A question settled too early stops you from seeing the next one. |
| When have you enough observations | When new looks give only repeats and you can state the shape of the passage in two sentences. |
One sentence to remember A good question sends you back to the text, and an honest "I do not know" is part of good study.
This week's action Choose a short passage, write five observations, turn each into a question, and put each question into one of the three groups.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is it useful to leave a question unanswered for a while before trying to settle it?
- In Luke 24:13-35 five questions are asked within the story. What do you notice about who asks them and when?
- Take one observation from your own reading this week and write three questions from it. Which group does each belong to?
- Why might "I do not know" be the most honest answer to a question about a passage?
- Rewrite this leading question as an open one: "Why does Cleopas answer so rudely?" You may pass if you would rather not say.