Lecture 4-2: People Who Come from Other Churches and Traditions
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Stranger in the Law and the Prophets
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus: Guest, Host and Stranger
- Lecture 1-3: The Early Church Learns to Welcome
- Lecture 1-4: How the Great Traditions Welcome
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Day You Were New
- Lecture 2-1: What a Stranger Sees
- Lecture 2-2: The First Conversation
- Lecture 2-3: Families with Children, and People Who Come Alone
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome in Different Kinds of Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Walk Your Own Entrance
- Lecture 3-1: The First Forty-Eight Hours
- Lecture 3-2: What You Ask For and What You Keep
- Lecture 3-3: Connecting People to People, and to the Church's Path
- Lecture 3-4: When Someone Stops Coming
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Ninety Days with One Person
- Lecture 4-1: Language, Culture and Migration
- Lecture 4-2: People Who Come from Other Churches and Traditions
- Lecture 4-3: People Wounded by the Church, and People with Doubts
- Lecture 4-4: Disability, Age and Access
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Welcoming Someone Unlike You
- Lecture 5-1: What You Hear Is Not Yours
- Lecture 5-2: Practical Help Without Dependency
- Lecture 5-3: Recognising Crisis and Passing It On
- Lecture 5-4: Safeguarding, Abuse and Reporting
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, Your Referral Map
Not everyone who walks into a church for the first time is new to church. Many have belonged to another congregation for years. Some have a settled faith and a long memory of how worship is done somewhere else. A welcome built entirely for the person who has never been inside a church can be both too slow and too simple for them. It can also be badly timed: a person who has just left a community may be tender, and a welcome that asks too much too soon will be one more thing to get away from.
This lecture asks what a volunteer owes to a Christian who comes from somewhere else, and where a volunteer's part ends and the pastor's or priest's begins. It is practical, and it carries a question that churches have argued about for a very long time: whether and how one community may receive a person who belongs to another.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Distinguish three kinds of people who arrive from another church, and say what each is most likely to need.
- Explain why a volunteer should not ask a newcomer to explain why they left, and should not give them a job on the first day.
- Describe, in outline, that the reception of baptised Christians from another communion is decided by the clergy, and say what a volunteer does instead.
- State fairly the concern behind "transfer growth", and the concern behind refusing to receive people from other churches.
For as the body is one, and has many members, and all the members of the body, being many, are one body; so also is Christ. For in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body, whether Jews or Greeks, whether bond or free; and were all given to drink into one Spirit." — 1 Corinthians 12:12-13
World English Bible
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28
WEB
being eager to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. There is one body, and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all, and through all, and in us all." — Ephesians 4:3-6
WEB
Paul writes to communities that were divided by background, rank and loyalty. He does not say that the differences vanish. He says that they do not decide who belongs. The three passages together give this lecture its attitude: one body, one Lord, one baptism, and a unity that has to be kept with effort.
1. Three kinds of newcomer who are not new to church
It is useful to separate three people who all say, "We have been going to another church." They are not alike.
The person who moved house. (an invented example) A couple has moved to a new town for work. They were active in their old parish or congregation for twenty years. They did not leave it; the job moved. What they need is not an introduction to Christianity. They need to learn how this community works: the names, the rooms, the times, the small habits, the way announcements are made, how to find the person who arranges the readers or the coffee. They also need to be allowed to grieve, a little, the community they left.
The person who left because of conflict. (an invented example) A man has left his old church after a dispute with the leaders. He does not say much about it. He is wary, and he is watching to see if this place is the same. What he needs is not to be asked. He needs a place where nothing is expected of him for a while, and where the people are not collecting grievances. If he wants to talk, he will, in his own time. Lecture 4-3 takes up the harder case of hurt that goes deeper.
The person looking for a different kind of worship. (an invented example) A young woman grew up in a free church and has become curious about : the order, the silence, the weekly Eucharist. Another grew up in a liturgical tradition and now wants a congregation where the singing is louder and the sermon longer. A third is simply tired of the style she knows. None of them is angry. They are searching, and they would like to look without being measured.
These three can look the same at the door. All of them tend to arrive with a good deal of knowledge of what church is, and some with firm opinions. Treat that knowledge as a resource. Do not explain what a hymn board is to someone who may have led worship for decades. Equally, do not assume that experience in one tradition prepares someone for another. A lifelong Pentecostal may be lost in a Divine Liturgy, and a lifelong Catholic may find an unscripted meeting bewildering. Each needs the first thing every newcomer needs: someone to say what is going to happen.
2. Do not ask them to explain themselves
The most natural question for a volunteer to ask is, "Where did you go before?" The second is, "Why did you leave?" The first is fine if it is a friendly interest and the person is free not to answer. The second should be left unasked.
There are several reasons. The honest answer may be painful, or may involve other people who are not present to speak for themselves. It may require the newcomer to criticise a community in front of a stranger, or to defend a decision they have not finished making sense of. And whatever they say, the volunteer is likely to be heard as taking a side, or as sizing up the newcomer. The rule from lecture 2-2 applies here without change: take what is offered. If a person says "we left because of some trouble", the right reply is "I am sorry; it is good to have you here", and nothing more.
Nor should the volunteer hand the newcomer a job on the first day. A capable person from another church may be exactly the reader, the singer, or the Sunday-school teacher the congregation is short of, and the temptation to say so is strong. Resist it. A person who is asked to serve before they have been received can feel they were noticed for what they could supply. That feeling is the opposite of the central claim of the course. Welcome is not a technique for gaining members. It is making room for a person because Christ has made room for us. Room for a person is not the same as room for a pair of hands. Gifts are welcome in time, when the person offers them, or when they have had time to settle and are invited with a real choice to decline.
3. Reception is the clergy's decision
A second matter concerns what the newcomer wants to become. Sooner or later a Christian who arrives from another church may ask: Can I take communion here? Do I need to be baptised again? Do I have to be confirmed? How do I join? These are good questions. A volunteer cannot answer them, and should not try.
The reason is not that the volunteer is unimportant. It is that different communities have different, serious teachings about who belongs to them and how. In outline:
- In the Catholic Church, a person who was validly baptised in another Christian community is not baptised again. Such a person is received into full communion after preparation, through a profession of faith, and usually in the same celebration receives the sacraments they have not yet received. The priest or the parish team arranges this.
- In Orthodox communities, practice varies by jurisdiction and by the person's background. Some Christians from other traditions are received by a profession of faith, some by chrismation (the anointing that follows baptism), and some are asked to be baptised. The priest and the bishop decide.
- Many Protestant communities receive people by letter of transfer from their previous church, by a statement of faith, or by an interview with the elders or a vote of the members. Some require of a person who was baptised only as an infant; others do not. The pastor and the leaders decide.
What these have in common is that the answer comes from the person who has charge of the community's life. What a volunteer can do is this: say "That is a good question, and the pastor (or the priest) is the right person to ask. Shall I find out when they are free, or give you their contact?" Then make sure it happens. Do not guess. Do not say "oh, I am sure it will be fine", and do not say "I think you would have to start again". A guess here may mislead a person about something they hold sacred.
The same applies to communion itself, which lecture 1-4 touched on. If it is not clear how your community handles it, find out in advance, and tell the person gently before the moment, so that nobody has to stand in the aisle deciding in front of others.
4. Two accusations to avoid
Two phrases are used in churches about people who come from elsewhere, and a volunteer should avoid both, even in thought.
"Sheep stealing" is the accusation that a community is drawing members away from another one. It is sometimes true, and it is a real wrong when it is done by deliberate recruiting from a neighbouring congregation. But as a label for any person who walks in, it treats the person as property of the church they left. People are not property. A volunteer who greets a newcomer with a worry about the neighbours is telling them they have been counted.
"Church shopping" is the accusation, from the other side, that the newcomer is a consumer who samples one community after another and commits to none. It, too, sometimes describes a real pattern. But as a first judgement of a stranger it is unfair. Many people who visit several churches are doing what you or I would do after a move or a loss: they are looking for a home. A volunteer who sees only a shopper will serve a customer, not a person.
Both accusations replace the individual with a category. They are also both lessons the previous lecture gave in a different form: people do not arrive as a category.
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is whether, and how, a community should receive Christians who already belong to another. Some leaders, and some writers who study church growth, use the term "transfer growth" for the situation where a congregation grows largely by drawing in members from other congregations. They fear that when this is the main source of growth, nothing is added to the whole body of Christ, neighbouring communities are weakened, and a church can mistake the movement of people for the spread of the gospel. They also point out that a congregation which welcomes any dissatisfied person from the street can end up taking in people who left a community without resolving a conflict, and so import the same conflict. Catholic and Orthodox leaders add a different concern: a person's reception into the Church is a sacramental matter and not a social one, and to treat it as casual membership trivialises it. Others reply that the church is one body, that a Christian who has moved, or whose spiritual needs are not met where they were, is free to worship where they can flourish, and that a community which treated every outsider as a stranger to the faith would be saying that the rest of the body of Christ does not count. Many Protestant traditions hold that membership is local, voluntary and should respect the earlier church's discipline, by asking for a letter. What this course requires is less than any one of these positions asks. Do not ask a newcomer to defend or explain their previous church, and leave all questions of reception to the pastor or the priest. A volunteer who keeps those two rules can serve in a parish with five Masses and in a house church of twelve, and cannot do much harm in either.
5. Practical words for the first conversation
Here are a few things that help. They sound very small.
- "You are welcome here, and you are not expected to do anything." This is the sentence for a person who left after a dispute.
- "Tell me how it was done where you were. I am interested." Ask only if you are interested, and only after some days. It is different from "why did you leave".
- "Here is how it goes this morning." Explain the order, and say plainly what parts are for members only, if any, and how to take part otherwise.
- "The pastor (or Father, or the ) would love to meet you, whenever you like." Make the introduction available, not obligatory.
In a liturgical community the same welcome may mean a visitor's card at the door that explains when to stand and what to say, and an offer to sit beside someone who knows the responses. In a free church it may mean a short word from the front, an explained order, and someone beside the newcomer who will tell them what is expected. Both ask the same of the volunteer: that they treat the experienced Christian as an experienced Christian, and as a guest who has not yet learned the house.
6. Unity that has to be kept
Paul's phrase in Ephesians 4:3, "being eager to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace", assumes that unity is not automatic. It is kept, with effort, by people who might otherwise divide. A volunteer keeps it in a small way every time they receive a person from another community without suspicion, without a lecture, and without a recruiting smile. The bigger questions of how churches relate to each other belong to bishops, councils and theologians. The welcome at the door can still say, in its small way: we have one Lord, one faith, one baptism, and you are not our competitor's property or our trophy. You are a person, and you are welcome.
Diagram 1. Three arrivals, and whose part is whose
In short
- Three people arrive from other churches: those who moved house, those who left after conflict, and those looking for a different worship. They need different things.
- Do not ask a newcomer why they left, and do not give them a job on the first day.
- How a baptised Christian from another communion is received is decided by the pastor or priest. The volunteer says who to talk to.
- "Sheep stealing" and "church shopping" both replace a person with a category. Avoid both.
- Communities disagree about transfer growth and reception. The course requires only that nobody is asked to defend their previous church.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three kinds of arrival | Moved house; left after conflict; looking for different worship. |
| What not to do on the first day | Do not ask why they left, and do not hand them a job. |
| Who decides reception | The pastor or priest. The volunteer says who to talk to, and does not guess. |
| Two accusations to avoid | "Sheep stealing" and "church shopping". Each turns a person into a category. |
One sentence to remember A Christian who comes from another church is a guest to be received, not a transfer to be processed.
This week's action Find out who in your community decides how a Christian from another church is received, and write down their name and how to reach them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the three kinds of arrival (moved house, left after conflict, looking for a different worship) is hardest for you to welcome well? Why?
- Why does the lecture advise against asking "why did you leave?" What could you ask instead, if you are really interested?
- Think of a time when you were asked to help with something soon after arriving somewhere new. How did it feel?
- How does your community receive a baptised Christian from another community? If you do not know, whom could you ask?
- Which is the greater temptation in your community: to treat a newcomer as a convert, or as a trophy? What would change that?