FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM207E Welcoming the Newcomer: Hospitality and Care in the Local Church

Lecture 4-3: People Wounded by the Church, and People with Doubts

Contents 31
LM207E Welcoming the Newcomer: Hospitality and Care in the Local Church
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Welcome Is Not a Technique
  1. Introduction: Welcome Is Not a Technique
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Welcome in Scripture and Tradition
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Stranger in the Law and the Prophets
  2. Lecture 1-2: Jesus: Guest, Host and Stranger
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Early Church Learns to Welcome
  4. Lecture 1-4: How the Great Traditions Welcome
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Day You Were New
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The First Ten Minutes
  1. Lecture 2-1: What a Stranger Sees
  2. Lecture 2-2: The First Conversation
  3. Lecture 2-3: Families with Children, and People Who Come Alone
  4. Lecture 2-4: Welcome in Different Kinds of Gathering
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Walk Your Own Entrance
Chapter 3 · Week 3: After the First Visit
  1. Lecture 3-1: The First Forty-Eight Hours
  2. Lecture 3-2: What You Ask For and What You Keep
  3. Lecture 3-3: Connecting People to People, and to the Church's Path
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Someone Stops Coming
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Ninety Days with One Person
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Welcoming Different People
  1. Lecture 4-1: Language, Culture and Migration
  2. Lecture 4-2: People Who Come from Other Churches and Traditions
  3. Lecture 4-3: People Wounded by the Church, and People with Doubts
  4. Lecture 4-4: Disability, Age and Access
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Welcoming Someone Unlike You
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Care, Boundaries and Referral
  1. Lecture 5-1: What You Hear Is Not Yours
  2. Lecture 5-2: Practical Help Without Dependency
  3. Lecture 5-3: Recognising Crisis and Passing It On
  4. Lecture 5-4: Safeguarding, Abuse and Reporting
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, Your Referral Map
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Welcome Team That Lasts
  1. Lecture 6-1: Roles and Structure for Different Sizes
  2. Lecture 6-2: Training, Communication and Mistakes
  3. Lecture 6-3: Welcome Without Burnout
  4. Lecture 6-4: Measuring Welcome Without Counting People
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, Review Your Welcome

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

Some people come to a church door with a particular weight. They were hurt in a church. It may have been a leader's harshness, a rejection, a rule applied without mercy, a betrayal of trust, or a long coldness. They may have left years ago and come back now, or they may be visiting for the first time since. Others come with no wound but with questions: they are unsure that God exists, unsure that the church tells the truth, unsure that they believe what they were taught.

Both sorts of people test a welcome in the same way. Each is deciding whether this room is safe enough to be honest in. This lecture is about how a volunteer can make it so, without pretending to be a counsellor or a theologian, and without defending the church or running from it.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Explain why a hurt received in a church differs from other hurts, and what that asks of a listener.
  • Describe what a volunteer does and does not do when a person speaks of being hurt, including why neither defending nor apologising is the first step.
  • Explain how Scripture treats doubt and hard questions, with at least two passages.
  • Use three honest sentences ("Good question", "I do not know", "Let me find someone") and say when care is beyond a volunteer.

How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me? How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?" — Psalms 13:1-2

World English Bible

Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24

WEB

The other disciples therefore said to him, “We have seen the Lord!” But he said to them, “Unless I see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.”" — John 20:25

WEB

He said to them, “What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?” One of them, named Cleopas, answered him, “Are you the only stranger in Jerusalem who doesn’t know the things which have happened there in these days?” He said to them, “What things?” They said to him, “The things concerning Jesus, the Nazarene, who was a prophet mighty in deed and word before God and all the people; and how the chief priests and our rulers delivered him up to be condemned to death, and crucified him. But we were hoping that it was he who would redeem Israel. Yes, and besides all this, it is now the third day since these things happened." — Luke 24:17-21

WEB

The psalmist speaks to God in the voice of a person who feels forgotten, and the psalm is kept in the Bible. A father asks for help with his unbelief, and gets it. Thomas says what it would take for him to believe, and is not thrown out. Two travellers on the road say aloud their disappointment to a stranger who turns out to be the Lord. In none of the four is the person turned away for speaking honestly.

1. A different kind of hurt

All hurt matters. A hurt received in a church is different, for a particular reason. People go to a church expecting it to be a safe place. They give it their trust, their secrets, their children, their money and sometimes their whole lives. When it breaks that trust, the injury is not only the thing that was done; it is that it happened there, in the place that spoke for God. Some people lose not just a congregation but the ability to believe that any congregation is safe. Some lose the words of prayer, because the words were used against them.

Hurt of this kind takes many forms, and a volunteer will almost never know which. A person may have been shamed from a pulpit. They may have been shunned after a divorce, a pregnancy, a question or a disagreement. They may have been exploited by a leader, or ignored when they asked for help. Some have been abused by someone with authority in a church. A volunteer should assume that such a person may be standing in front of them, and should never ask. This kind of harm has been recorded in a cathedral parish and in a house church, in congregations of thousands and of twenty, and for that reason no tradition is named here.

You may never be told. A person may only say, "I have had a bad experience of church", and look to see what you do with it. This is a test, and the person may not know they are setting it.

2. Listen first, and do not defend

When someone says they were hurt by a church, a volunteer who loves the church feels two strong pulls.

The first is to defend. "I am sure they did not mean it." "Every church has its problems." "Not everyone is like that." "Perhaps there is another side." Each of these may be true. Each one says to the person: I am more concerned about the reputation of the church than about what happened to you. Even if you did not intend it, they will hear it, and the conversation will be over.

The second is to apologise on behalf of the church. "I am so sorry the church did that." It sounds humble and warm. The difficulty is that a volunteer cannot apologise for something they do not know, and cannot speak for the leaders who did it or the institution that allowed it. An apology that is given too early is also a way of closing the subject: there, that is done. A real apology, from those who can make it, comes after the account has been heard and may involve changes and costs. A volunteer who offers one in the first minute has probably not heard anything yet.

What works is quieter. Listen. Let the person tell as much or as little as they like. Say things that stay close to what they said: "That sounds very painful." "I am glad you told me." "Thank you for trusting me with that." It is also right to say, as one person to another, "I am sorry that happened to you." That is a statement of your own sorrow, not an apology in the name of the church, and a hurt person can tell the difference.

Do not ask for names. Do not ask the person to prove it. Do not offer to confront anyone. Do not tell them what they should now do about forgiveness. Forgiveness is a large matter, and it is not a sentence for a doorway; the person who has been hurt will come to it in their own time, if they come to it, and with someone better prepared than a welcome volunteer.

Be honest about the church's own failures. If the person says "churches cover things up", it is not helpful to say they do not. Churches have, in many places and times, sheltered people who should have been held accountable and ignored those who spoke. A volunteer can say so truthfully, without describing any present-day group in unkind terms: "Yes. That has happened, and it was wrong." An honest church is a safer place for a hurt person than a perfect-sounding one.

3. Leave the door open, and let them set the pace

A hurt person's greatest need from a welcome is control. They were once in a place where they were not in charge of what happened to them. Here, they should be in charge of nearly everything.

That means:

  • They choose how close to sit. The back row, an aisle seat, the door. Do not move them forward.
  • They choose whether to speak. Say your name, offer a hand if they want one, and wait. Do not require a name in return.
  • They choose whether to return. Say "You are welcome again whenever you like", once, and do not follow up with pressure. The advice of lecture 3-4 applies fully: one message that asks nothing, and then wait.
  • They choose what they take part in. Not the greeting at the peace, not communion, not the prayer, not the song. A liturgical community has gestures at which a whole room acts together, and a free church has a time when everyone is asked to stand or speak. A hurt person needs to know quietly that they may stay seated, or step out, with no remark.
  • They choose whom to tell. Do not mention their wound to leaders or other volunteers without asking. The principle of lecture 3-2 and the next chapter holds: what you hear is entrusted to you, not owned by you.

There are limits. If a person tells you that a child is at risk now, or that someone in the community is harming a person, you cannot keep that to yourself, and you should not promise to. Say gently that there are things you would need to pass on to the person responsible for safety, and that you would tell them before doing it. Chapter 5 treats this in detail, and the answer to "what do I do" is always the same: do not carry it alone.

4. Doubt is not the enemy of faith

A second group of people arrive with questions. Some doubt a doctrine. Some doubt that there is a God. Some are not sure that they believe anything, and have come out of loneliness, or because of a death, or because of a friend. Some have been told all their lives that doubt is sin.

The Bible does not say that. The psalms are full of questions addressed to God, and the thirteenth asks How long? four times in its first two verses. The collection includes laments that end without a resolution. The father in Mark 9 cries out in the same sentence "I believe" and "Help my unbelief" and his child is healed, and no rebuke of the father's words is recorded. Thomas says he will not believe unless he sees; Jesus returns, gives him what he asked for, adds one gentle word about those who believe without seeing, and Thomas is still among the others a week later. The two on the Emmaus road are sad and disappointed and say so. The risen Jesus does not interrupt. He asks them what they are discussing, and lets them tell it, before he speaks. (He does then correct them. The stories do not say that every doubt is simply agreed with; they say that honesty is heard first.)

None of this means that every doubt is harmless or that every question has an easy answer. It means that the church has always had a place for the person who says I am not sure, and a welcome that closes the door on questions is not very Christian. A doubter who is made to feel unwelcome for their honesty learns only to hide it. Some questions are signs of seriousness, of someone who takes the matter so seriously that they refuse to say what they do not believe.

Traditions differ about where questions are handled. In many liturgical communities there are inquirers' sessions, , spiritual direction and a priest who hears questions in private. In many free churches there are small groups, a pastor's study, and courses for enquirers. A volunteer need not know all that. They need to know that such places exist in their community, and who to point to.

5. Three honest sentences

A volunteer who meets a hard question is usually afraid of being asked something they cannot answer. Three sentences can carry most of the weight.

"Good question." Say it and mean it. A question is not a threat. It tells you the person is thinking. Do not rush to answer it at once; sometimes the best next thing is, "What makes you ask?"

"I do not know." This is among the most important sentences in welcome. A volunteer who bluffs will say something false, or half true, or something their own tradition would not say. A volunteer who says "I do not know" shows that it is allowed. It also builds trust, because the person learns that when you do say something, you mean it.

"Let me find someone." Then do it. Pass the question to the pastor, priest, , teacher or a mature member who has studied it, and offer to introduce them. Do not simply say "you should ask the pastor". Offer to arrange it, and ask when would suit. Pass it on, and stay near: the person has come to you, and the introduction should not feel like being handed away.

Notice what these three sentences do not do. They do not win an argument. A welcome is not a debate. If the person wants to explore the grounds of belief at length, that is for someone prepared, and for a different occasion; the course on evangelism through friendship (LM303E) takes up hard questions in their own right. At the door, the aim is only that the person leaves knowing they were allowed to ask.

6. Knowing when it is beyond you

Some people carry more than hurt or doubt. A person may speak of not wanting to live, or of anger that frightens them or you, or of deep despair. They may describe being unsafe at home. They may be confused or in distress. These are not welcome matters; they are care matters, and a volunteer is neither a counsellor nor a doctor. The next chapter sets out what to do. For now, one rule: if someone is in immediate danger, call the local emergency number first; for anything else that worries you, tell the pastor or priest the same day, quietly, and do not carry it alone. If your worry is about the pastor or priest, or about another leader, go to the person your community names for safeguarding, or to another senior leader. A welcome volunteer's listening is not a substitute for medical or counselling care, and the aim is to help the person reach it. The course on lay (LM205E) teaches the skill of listening itself.

7. What this does for the central claim

A person who has been hurt by a church, or who does not know what they believe, is a person for whom there is already room, because Christ has made room. The welcome does not need to settle the hurt or answer the doubt. It needs to offer a seat and a pace, and a sentence or two that is true. Welcome is not a technique for gaining members. It would be a poor sort of welcome that took in the wounded and the doubting and treated them as a project. They are neither a problem to be fixed nor a conversion in waiting. They are guests of the God who made room for us, and who also, if the psalms are any guide, can bear to be asked "How long?"


Diagram 1. Meeting hurt and doubt

Meeting Hurt and Doubt Four steps, three sentences, and one limit 1. Listen Let the story come 2. Do not defend Do not apologise yet 3. Door open No pressure, no chase 4. Their pace They pick the step Three sentences to keep ready Good question. A question is not a threat. I do not know. Saying so builds trust. Let me find someone. Pass it on. Stay near. Beyond you? Tell the pastor or priest, quietly, the same day. Chapter 5 shows how.

In short

  • A hurt received in a church differs from other hurts because it happened where trust was given. The first need is to be listened to.
  • Do not defend the church, and do not apologise on its behalf before you have listened. You may say you are sorry it happened.
  • The hurt person sets the pace: where to sit, whether to speak, whether to return, what to join.
  • Scripture treats honest doubt with patience: the psalmist, the father in Mark 9, Thomas, and the travellers on the road to Emmaus.
  • Three honest sentences carry a hard conversation: "Good question", "I do not know", and "Let me find someone". Then pass it on and stay near.
  • If you are worried about a person's safety or distress, tell the pastor or priest the same day. Do not carry it alone.
Front Back
Why church hurt is different It happened in a place that was supposed to be safe and spoke for God.
First response to someone hurt Listen. Do not defend the church. Do not apologise for it before listening. Say you are sorry it happened.
Three honest sentences "Good question." "I do not know." "Let me find someone."
When it is beyond you Tell the pastor or priest the same day, quietly. Do not carry it alone.

One sentence to remember A person who has been hurt, or who doubts, needs a seat, a pace of their own, and someone who will say only what is true.

This week's action Practise saying "I do not know, but let me find someone" aloud, and write down the name of the person in your community to whom you would pass a hard question.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why might a hurt received in a church be harder to carry than a hurt received elsewhere?
  • Which pull is stronger in you when you hear a criticism of the church: to defend, or to apologise? What would you say instead?
  • Which of the four passages in this lecture's Scripture section speaks most to a person you have met, and why?
  • How easy is it in your community to say "I do not know"? What would make it easier?
  • Where in your community can a person with a serious question take it? Who would you point them to?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.