Lecture 5-4: Safeguarding, Abuse and Reporting
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Stranger in the Law and the Prophets
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus: Guest, Host and Stranger
- Lecture 1-3: The Early Church Learns to Welcome
- Lecture 1-4: How the Great Traditions Welcome
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Day You Were New
- Lecture 2-1: What a Stranger Sees
- Lecture 2-2: The First Conversation
- Lecture 2-3: Families with Children, and People Who Come Alone
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome in Different Kinds of Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Walk Your Own Entrance
- Lecture 3-1: The First Forty-Eight Hours
- Lecture 3-2: What You Ask For and What You Keep
- Lecture 3-3: Connecting People to People, and to the Church's Path
- Lecture 3-4: When Someone Stops Coming
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Ninety Days with One Person
- Lecture 4-1: Language, Culture and Migration
- Lecture 4-2: People Who Come from Other Churches and Traditions
- Lecture 4-3: People Wounded by the Church, and People with Doubts
- Lecture 4-4: Disability, Age and Access
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Welcoming Someone Unlike You
- Lecture 5-1: What You Hear Is Not Yours
- Lecture 5-2: Practical Help Without Dependency
- Lecture 5-3: Recognising Crisis and Passing It On
- Lecture 5-4: Safeguarding, Abuse and Reporting
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, Your Referral Map
This lecture is the hardest in the course, and it needs to be read slowly. It is about harm done to children and to adults who cannot protect themselves, and about what a welcome volunteer must do when they see a sign of it, or when someone tells them.
It begins with a plain fact. Over recent decades, in many countries, inquiries and investigations have found that children and vulnerable adults were abused in churches of many traditions, as they were in schools, clubs and families. They have also found something worse than the abuse alone: that in many cases, people in authority who knew chose to protect the reputation of the institution, or a colleague, and not the child. People were moved on, files were kept closed, and those who spoke were silenced or doubted. The harm did not end with the act. It continued through every adult who looked away.
That history is why this chapter exists. A community that makes room for strangers must also make sure that the room is safe, and must be ready to hear the person who says it was not.
The lecture asks very little of the volunteer, deliberately. Never investigate. Never promise a child secrecy. Listen. Write down what was said, in the person's own words. Tell the safeguarding lead at once. The rest is the work of the community's written policy and, where it applies, the law.
This lecture does not give legal advice. Laws about reporting, about the position of clergy, and about the protection of volunteers differ by country and sometimes within a country. Ask your leaders for your community's policy and for local guidance.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Explain why safeguarding is part of welcome, and why the history of failure in churches is told honestly.
- Describe in general terms what abuse can look like, without acting as an investigator.
- State what to do, step by step, when a child or an adult at risk tells you something, and what never to do.
- Explain why the written policy and local law decide who reports, and why you should know both before you need them.
- Describe the main elements of safe recruiting and training for those who work with children.
Defend the weak, the poor, and the fatherless. Maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed. Rescue the weak and needy. Deliver them out of the hand of the wicked.”" — Psalm 82:3-4
World English Bible
He took a little child, and set him in their midst. Taking him in his arms, he said to them, “Whoever receives one such little child in my name, receives me, and whoever receives me, doesn’t receive me, but him who sent me.”" — Mark 9:36-37
WEB
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate. Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy.”" — Proverbs 31:8-9
WEB
Psalm 82 is usually read as addressed to those in authority (judges and rulers), and says they will be judged for how they treat the weak. Mark 9 places a child in the centre and says that to receive the child is to receive Christ. Proverbs 31 tells us to speak for those who cannot. None of these gives a procedure. They give the reason a procedure is needed.
1. Why this is part of welcome
A welcome that is only warm is not yet safe. A community that opens its doors to children, to the lonely and to the vulnerable has taken on a duty. Those who come must be able to trust that the people they meet are who they say, that no adult is alone with a child, and that if something is wrong, someone will hear it and act.
It is uncomfortable to put the word "abuse" next to the word "welcome". It would be more uncomfortable still to leave them apart. Communities that did so in the past paid for it, and so did the children.
Honest history helps here and also warns. When the failures were exposed, many were not the acts of one person. They were the acts of a system: leaders who disbelieved, who feared scandal, who moved a person from one place to another, who asked a victim to forgive quickly, or who treated the matter as a private sin to be settled in house. The lesson for a volunteer is not that the church is uniquely wicked. It is that good people, in a community that loves its own name, can fail a child through silence. The cure is plain rules, known by everyone, and a habit of reporting that does not depend on liking or trusting the person involved.
2. Who is protected
Children are people under the age of adulthood set by the law of the place. This varies by country.
Adults at risk (the term also varies: "vulnerable adults", "adults in need of protection") are adults who, because of illness, disability, age, dependence, fear or other circumstances, are less able to protect themselves from harm or exploitation. A person may be at risk at one time of life and not at another.
The two cases are not identical. A child cannot consent to being harmed. An adult has the right to make their own decisions, even risky ones, and a volunteer should not override them. But even in the adult case, a volunteer does not decide alone. The adult's wishes matter greatly, and the policy and local law tell you what the leaders must do. For an adult, the first step is still to listen and tell the safeguarding lead.
3. What abuse can look like, without a checklist
Abuse takes several broad forms: physical harm, sexual harm, emotional harm, neglect, and exploitation (including financial exploitation, which is especially seen in the case of older people). Many cases involve more than one. It may come from a parent, a relative, a partner, a carer, a teacher, a peer, a stranger or a person in the church.
Some signs may be noticed. A child who is suddenly withdrawn, fearful or aggressive. Injuries that are not explained or are explained in a way that does not fit. A child who is hungry, unwashed or dressed unsuitably for the weather, repeatedly. A child who knows things about sex that are unusual for their age. A child or an adult who is anxious around one particular person, or who never goes anywhere without them. An adult who cannot speak for themselves in the presence of a carer, or who seems to have no access to their own money.
Treat that list with care. Every one of these signs has innocent explanations, and none proves anything. A child may be withdrawn because of grief, a move or bullying. A bruise may be from play. This is why a volunteer must not use a list as a tool for investigating. You are not asked to collect evidence, to compare a child's story to a pattern or to decide whether abuse is happening. You are asked to notice that something is wrong, and to tell the person whose role it is to look further.
Some harm is not seen at all. It is told. A child may say it in an offhand way, or in a drawing or a game, or half say it and then take it back. A teenager may say "a friend of mine" when they mean themselves. An adult may mention it only in passing. These moments are brief. How you respond in them matters more than almost anything else in this chapter.
4. If someone tells you
The steps are simple. They are not easy.
- Stay calm and listen. Make your face and voice steady, even if what you hear shocks you. The person is watching your face to see whether it is safe to go on.
- Believe that they are telling you something that matters. You are not their judge, and you are not asked to decide whether it is true. Say: "Thank you for telling me. I am glad you did. It is not your fault."
- Do not ask leading questions. Let them say what they wish in their own words. If you need to, ask open questions such as "Can you tell me more?" Do not suggest answers, do not ask "did he touch you?" and do not press for details. Questioning belongs to people trained to do it, and a volunteer's questions can damage a later investigation and distress the child.
- Never promise to keep it secret. A child who has been told to keep a secret by an abuser will often ask you to keep one too. Say honestly: "I am glad you told me. I cannot keep this a secret, because I want you to be safe. I have to tell someone whose job is to help." Do not say more than you can do. Do not promise that nothing will happen, or that the person will not be angry.
- Do not confront the person accused. Do not question them, warn them, or tell them what you heard. This can put the child in greater danger and can harm any later process.
- Write down what was said, in the person's own words, as soon as possible. Include the date, the time, where you were, who else was present, and what you saw. Do not add your own opinions or interpretations. Sign and date the note. Keep it somewhere private, and give it to the safeguarding lead.
- Tell the safeguarding lead at once. The same day, and as soon as you can. Not at the next meeting. If the child is in immediate danger, call the local emergency number first.
- Stay with the person if you can until the lead takes over, and afterwards be a steady, ordinary, kind presence. Do not treat them differently, and do not ask for updates about what happened next.
(An invented example.) A volunteer in a children's room hears a nine-year-old say, while colouring, that she doesn't like going to her uncle's house because "he does things when mum's out". The volunteer's heart jumps. She keeps her voice level. She says, "Thank you for telling me. You did the right thing." She does not ask what things. When the child says, "Don't tell," the volunteer says, "I can't keep this secret, because I want you safe. I need to tell someone who knows how to help." That afternoon she writes down the child's words exactly, with the time, and hands the note to the safeguarding lead, who follows the community's policy from there.
If the safeguarding lead is the person you are worried about, or does not act, the policy should say who is next. If it does not, tell another senior leader, and where the law or the policy points to an outside authority, follow it. Do not let the matter sink because the person you are supposed to tell is the wrong person.
5. If the concern is about a church worker
Some of the hardest cases concern a person inside the community: a volunteer, a leader, a pastor, a priest. People find it harder to believe, because they know the person and have been helped by them. The same rules apply with greater care.
- Do not investigate, and do not confront the person.
- Do not tell the person that an allegation has been made.
- Do not decide for yourself that it cannot be true.
- Tell the safeguarding lead or the person named in the policy at once. If the concern is about the lead, or about a senior leader, the policy should name an outside route (a regional or national office of your church, or a local authority).
A community that treats the reputation of a leader as more important than the safety of a child has repeated the failure that this chapter is about.
6. The written policy and the law
Two things govern what you do. They are different.
The community's written safeguarding policy says who the safeguarding lead is, how a concern is recorded, who is told, and what the community does. A volunteer should read it before they begin and be able to find it. If your community has none, ask your leaders to write one with advice from a competent source. That is a task for leaders, not volunteers, and it is not optional.
The law differs by country. Some places require certain professions, or everyone, to report suspected abuse of a child to a public authority. Some require it only of certain roles. Some have no general duty. The position of clergy differs: in some places the law exempts a priest or pastor from reporting what they learn in confession or in pastoral confidence, in others it does not, and some require reporting regardless. Some places protect a person who reports in good faith; others offer less. Some require background checks of those who work with children; others do not. A volunteer cannot be expected to know all this, and this course cannot tell you what applies to you.
What the course asks is that you do three things. Ask your leaders for the policy and for local guidance. Know who the safeguarding lead is and how to reach them. And if you do not know whether a matter must go to a public authority, ask the lead the same day. Do not wait to be sure.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Pastoral confidence and the seal of the confessional are held, by some Catholic, Orthodox and other thinkers, as inviolable, because a penitent who cannot trust the seal will not come and will be worse off. Others hold that nothing, including the seal, should stand between a child and protection, and that clergy should be under the same reporting duties as everyone. Some people hold both concerns at once and find them in tension. Laws differ, and the views of a given church differ from the law of the place where it stands. This course requires less than either side. Never promise to keep everything secret; know your community's policy and your local law; protect children first. A lay volunteer has no seal at all (lecture 5-1), and for a volunteer, the answer is always to tell the safeguarding lead.
7. Safe recruiting and training
Much safeguarding is done before anything goes wrong. A community that works with children usually does these things, as its policy and local law allow:
- Recruit openly. Tell people what the role involves. Use an application, references that are really followed up, and a conversation. Do not give a role with children to someone because they are enthusiastic, or because they are a leader, or because nobody else will do it.
- Check where the law provides for it. Some places have official background checks for work with children. Use them where they exist and the policy requires them.
- Train everyone who works with children or vulnerable adults, and refresh the training.
- Keep to the rules of the room. Two unrelated adults present with children; no unsupervised one-to-one time; check-in and check-out; photographs only with consent; no private messaging between an adult volunteer and a child; open doors or windows where possible. Lecture 2-3 introduced these. They protect the children and they protect the adults, because an adult who is never alone with a child cannot be falsely accused.
- Supervise. The volunteer who is never visited, never observed and never asked how it is going is a risk.
- Make it easy to speak. Tell children and parents who they can tell, and in plain words. Put a name and a number where a child can see it.
- Respond to concerns about behaviour early. A "small" breach of the rules (a gift, a private message, favouritism) is where trouble often begins. Gently correct and record it.
None of these requires suspicion of any person. All of them are acts of care, and a good volunteer welcomes them.
8. What this does not ask of you
It does not ask you to be an investigator, a judge, a social worker or a lawyer. It does not ask you to be certain. It does not ask you to know whether the person you are worried about is guilty. It asks you to take seriously what you see and hear, to say what you saw and heard to the person whose job it is, and to leave the rest to them and to the proper authorities. That is the whole of your part, and it is enough to change a life.
If an adult tells you about abuse in their past, the same spirit applies: listen, thank them, do not press for details, and with their agreement put them in touch with the pastor or priest and with a professional support service for survivors. Your listening is a kindness, but it is not a substitute for counselling or medical care.
Diagram 1. What to do when someone tells you
Diagram 2. Say this, and do not say this
| Say | Do not say |
|---|---|
| "Thank you for telling me. I am glad you did." | "Are you sure? That is a serious thing to say." |
| "It is not your fault." | "Why didn't you tell someone sooner?" |
| "I cannot keep this secret, because I want you safe." | "I promise I will not tell anyone." |
| "Can you tell me more?" | "Did he touch you? Where? How many times?" |
| "I need to tell someone whose job is to help." | "I will deal with him myself." |
In short
- Safeguarding is part of welcome. The history of failures in many churches was a failure of systems and silence, and it is why this chapter exists.
- Signs of abuse have innocent explanations. A volunteer notices and reports, and never investigates.
- If someone tells you: listen, ask no leading questions, promise no secrecy, do not confront anyone, and write down their words.
- Tell the safeguarding lead at once. In immediate danger, call the local emergency number first.
- Reporting duties, the position of clergy and the protection of volunteers differ by country. Follow your written policy and local law.
- Safe recruiting, training and the rules of the room protect children and adults alike.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What a volunteer does | Listens, writes down the person's own words, and tells the safeguarding lead at once. |
| What a volunteer never does | Investigates, asks leading questions, promises secrecy, or confronts the person accused. |
| What decides who reports | The community's written policy and local law, which differ by country. Ask your leaders for both. |
| Why safe recruiting matters | Open recruitment, training, two adults and supervision prevent harm and protect the volunteer. |
One sentence to remember Listen, write it down in their words, promise no secrecy, and tell the safeguarding lead at once.
This week's action Ask your leaders for the written safeguarding policy, read it, and write down the lead's name and how to reach them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does the lecture say that the failures in churches were failures of systems and not only of single persons? What would a system that prevented them look like?
- Why must a volunteer not use a list of signs as a tool for investigation? What is the volunteer's task instead?
- Practise saying aloud: "Thank you for telling me. I cannot keep this secret, because I want you safe." What makes it hard to say, and what makes it right?
- Do you know who your community's safeguarding lead is, and where the policy is kept? If not, who could tell you?
- Readers disagree about the seal of confession and about reporting duties. State the two positions fairly. What do both agree a lay volunteer must do?