Lecture 3-3: Privacy, Safety and the Signs of Abuse or Neglect
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Age and Care
- Lecture 1-2: Ageing Across Cultures: Retirement, Loss, Loneliness, Care
- Lecture 1-3: What a Lay Carer Does, and Does Not Do
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbour and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Preparing and Beginning the Visit
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Memory, Repetition and Silence
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer, Scripture and Worship at the Bedside
- Lecture 2-4: Dignity, Choice and the Words We Use
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Planning One Visit
- Lecture 3-1: The Home Visit and the Body's Limits
- Lecture 3-2: Care Homes and Hospitals
- Lecture 3-3: Privacy, Safety and the Signs of Abuse or Neglect
- Lecture 3-4: Money, Gifts and Keeping Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reading Signs and Knowing Whom to Tell
- Lecture 4-1: Dementia: Staying With a Person Whose Memory Changes
- Lecture 4-2: Loneliness, Loss and Feeling a Burden
- Lecture 4-3: The Family Carer
- Lecture 4-4: Faith Questions and Hard Conversations
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Word to the Family
- Lecture 5-1: Serious Illness, Hospice and Palliative Care
- Lecture 5-2: Accompanying the Dying Across the Traditions
- Lecture 5-3: The Moment of Death and the Days After
- Lecture 5-4: What to Say, What to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Words to Offer and Words to Leave
Two commitments sit side by side in this lecture, and they can feel as if they pull against each other. The first is privacy: what you hear and see in a person's home, room or ward belongs to that person. The second is safety: when you see signs that a person may be harmed or neglected, you do not keep it to yourself.
The way through is not to choose one. It is to learn exactly what each asks. Privacy means that you do not pass on what is not yours to pass on, and that you pass on what you must, only to the right person, in the right way. Safety means that you notice, write down what you saw and heard, and tell the responsible person quickly. It does not mean that you investigate, question, confront or rescue.
This lecture is about adults who may be at risk. It gives general signs, not a checklist for proof, and it gives a plain route for telling. It does not give legal advice. The law differs from country to country, and what is required of a lay volunteer differs even within one country. Your community's written policy and your local law decide the detail. This lecture gives the shape that fits any of them.
What these 29 minutes give you
- Explain why what you hear and see in a person's home or room belongs to that person, and describe the circle of knowing.
- Name general signs of possible abuse or neglect, and say why a sign is a reason to tell and not proof.
- Describe the steps to take after noticing a sign: what to write down, whom to tell and in what order.
- State why you never promise to keep everything secret, and what you can promise instead.
- State fairly the disagreement between pastoral confidence and legal duties to report, and what this course requires of a lay carer.
Defend the weak, the poor, and the fatherless. Maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed. Rescue the weak and needy. Deliver them out of the hand of the wicked.”" — Psalm 82:3-4
World English Bible
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate. Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy." — Proverbs 31:8-9
WEB
One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13
WEB
Psalm 82 and Proverbs 31 speak of those who cannot protect themselves, and ask those with any power at all to use it for them. Proverbs 11 speaks of a person who betrays a confidence. The lecture holds both: you may not betray a confidence, and you may not stay silent when someone is in danger.
1. What you hear and see belongs to the person
When you visit, you learn things. You learn how a person lives, what they eat, who calls, what they owe, what they fear, what their body can and cannot do, how they speak of their children, how they speak of God. You may learn a diagnosis, a quarrel in the family, a regret from sixty years ago or a worry about money. Some of this the person tells you. Some you see without being told.
None of it is yours. It belongs to the person. It is not a story to tell at the next meeting, an item for a prayer chain, a reason for a conversation in the car park or an example for a sermon. The person did not give it to the congregation. They allowed you into the room.
Proverbs 11:13 puts it in a sentence: a gossip betrays a confidence, and a trustworthy spirit keeps a secret. This is not only good manners. For an older or housebound person, who may already feel that they have lost control over much of their life, control over their own story is one of the few things left, and it matters a great deal.
Here are the practical rules.
- Health, family and money details belong to the person. Do not pass them to other members of the congregation, to the prayer chain or to a group chat unless the person has said you may. "Please pray for Mrs. A, who has been in hospital" is not yours to say unless Mrs. A has agreed to it, and has agreed to those words. Ask: "Would you like us to pray for this with others? What may we say?" If the answer is no, then it is no, and you pray alone.
- Use the team's private list, not the notice board. Lecture 6-1 describes a list kept by the coordinator: who, how often, what they prefer, never what they suffer from.
- Do not talk about a visit in front of others. In a bus, a shop, a family dinner or a social media post, other people hear.
- Do not take or share photographs or recordings without the person's clear permission, as lecture 3-2 explained.
- Even a "good" story is not yours to tell. "She is so brave, you should hear what she said!" turns a person into an example.
2. The circle of knowing
A helpful way to think about this is a set of circles, with the person at the centre.
- The person. They know everything about their own life.
- People the person has chosen. A family member, a friend, a doctor, a pastor or priest. The person decides whom they tell and how much.
- The responsible person in your community. This is the leader, coordinator or pastor named in your team's policy. A lay visitor tells this person certain things, not as gossip, but because the community has a duty to act on them. Two things go to this person even if the visitor has not asked permission: a sign that someone may be at risk, and a remark of the kind that lecture 4-2 describes.
- People outside the circle. Everyone else. They are told nothing, unless the person has said otherwise.
If you are unsure which circle something belongs in, ask yourself: Did the person tell me this so that I could do something with it? Did they say who may know? If you still do not know, ask the person, or ask the responsible person without naming the person.
This is the model throughout the course. You are not a vault, since some things you must pass to the responsible person. You are not a loudspeaker either, since most things you pass nowhere.
3. Why a sign is not proof
Abuse and neglect of older and housebound adults do happen. They take many forms: physical harm, neglect of basic needs, emotional or verbal harm, being kept from others, being pressured over money or property, harm in a care setting. Harm can be done by a family member, a friend, a paid carer, a member of staff, a neighbour, a stranger or another resident. It can also be done, wittingly or not, by a church volunteer. The wrong may be a sudden act or a long habit.
Care for a person does not always look gentle, and strain in a family does not mean harm. Most families who struggle with the care of an older relative are doing their best, often with too little help. A bruise may be a bruise. A thin person may have a poor appetite for reasons nobody has found. A cold room may mean a broken heater and a relative waiting on a repair.
This is why the course teaches signs, not diagnoses. A sign is a reason to tell the responsible person. It is not a conclusion about anyone. You do not have to know what is happening. You do not have to be right. Your part is to notice, to record and to pass it on to someone whose part it is to look into it.
4. General signs
None of these proves anything. Together or repeated, or when they change, they are worth telling.
- Injuries that are not explained, or an explanation that changes or does not fit the injury, or a person who seems afraid to say how it happened.
- Fear or tension around a particular person, such as a person who goes quiet, flinches, watches the other person's face before answering, or changes the subject when that person enters.
- Being kept from visitors or contacts, such as a telephone that is never answered, a door that is always "not today", a person who is "resting" every time you come, or a person who is not allowed to speak with you alone.
- A carer who will not leave the person alone with you, who answers for the person, or who becomes angry when you ask how the person is.
- Unmet basic needs, such as little food in the house, clothes unchanged for a long time, a cold home in cold weather, no needed aids (glasses, hearing aids, a walking frame), pressure sores or untreated pain, or medicine that is plainly not being given.
- Sudden money trouble, such as unpaid bills in a household that used to pay on time, unexplained withdrawals, a person suddenly short of money, a new "friend" or relative who has taken over money matters, or pressure to sign papers.
- Changes in the person, such as withdrawal, new anxiety, loss of weight, low mood or a person who used to talk and now does not.
- In a care setting, a resident who is left a long time without help, spoken to roughly, handled roughly, or ignored; a place where visitors are discouraged from seeing certain residents.
Some of these signs also have kind explanations. A person who is shy of visitors may simply be unwell. A carer who stays in the room may be tired and anxious. The point is not to suspect. It is that the right person looks, and not you alone.
A note about families. A family may sometimes be the source of harm. This lecture says it once and plainly because a visitor who cannot imagine it may miss what is in front of them. But a visitor who expects it will treat every tired daughter as a suspect. Do neither. Treat each family with the respect due to people who are doing something hard, and keep your eyes open.
5. What you do not do
- You do not investigate. You do not look through papers, open cupboards, question the person closely, talk to neighbours or ask relatives to explain.
- You do not confront anyone. You do not tell a relative or a staff member what you suspect. A confrontation can make things worse for the person after you leave.
- You do not promise to keep it secret. More on this below.
- You do not try to rescue. You do not move the person, remove money, change the locks, take the person to your house or arrange a placement.
- You do not decide that it is nothing. If you are unsure, you tell.
6. What you do
The steps are short and easy to remember.
- Stay calm and stay ordinary. If the person tells you something, thank them for telling you. Do not show shock or anger. Do not question beyond "Can you tell me a little more?" Do not suggest answers.
- Listen to the person's own account. What they say, in their words, is the most important thing you will record. If they do not want to speak about it, do not press.
- Never promise secrecy. If the person says, "Don't tell anyone," say gently: "I can promise that I will only tell the person whose job it is to help, and nobody else. I cannot promise to keep it entirely to myself, because I want you to be safe." This is honest. It is also kinder than a promise you would have to break.
- If anyone is in danger now, call the emergency number. If someone is hurt, threatened or in immediate risk, you do not wait to tell the leader first.
- Write down what you saw and heard, as soon as you can and while it is fresh. Use the person's own words in quotation marks. Write the date, the time, the place and who was present. Write what you saw (a bruise on the left forearm, about the size of a coin) and what you heard ("He says I fell, but I didn't fall"). Do not write what you think it means. Keep the note private and give it to the responsible person.
- Tell the responsible person the same day, the leader, coordinator or pastor your community names, and hand over your note. Say it plainly. Do not add a theory.
- Tell the person what you are doing, if it is safe. "I am going to tell our leader what you told me, so someone can make sure you have the help you need." Be honest. Do not tell the person if telling them might put them at risk, for example if the person who may be causing harm is in the next room. The responsible person can advise.
- Let the responsible person act. They may speak to the person, the family or the home, contact a local reporting body (the service in your area that deals with the protection of adults at risk) or seek advice from their own supervisor. In some places your community must report; in others it may. That is for the responsible person, with your local law and written policy.
- If the responsible person is the problem, or does nothing, go to the next step up. That may be a senior leader, a denominational or diocesan safeguarding contact, or the local reporting body directly. Your community's policy should name this route. If it does not, ask your leader to write it, and in the meantime use the local reporting body.
- Stay present. Keep visiting, kindly and on time. Do not withdraw because you are uncomfortable. The person needs a visitor who does not change.
7. Whom do you tell, in what order?
This depends on your community and your country. In outline:
| Situation | First | Then |
|---|---|---|
| Someone is in immediate danger | The emergency number | Your responsible person, as soon as it is safe |
| You notice signs or hear a worrying account | Your responsible person, the same day | The responsible person decides about a local reporting body, the family or the home |
| The responsible person is involved, or acts too slowly | The next level your policy names | The local reporting body directly |
| You are not sure whether it is a sign | Your responsible person, as a question | Take their advice, and write it down |
8. Pastoral confidence and the duty to report
This is a point where readers will not agree: how pastoral confidence relates to legal duties to report harm.
Some hold that a pastoral conversation is protected in a special way. In the Catholic Church, the seal of confession is absolute for a priest who hears a sacramental confession, and the Orthodox Church holds the confession in the same serious way. Many Protestant and Pentecostal pastors also treat what is said in a pastoral conversation as confidential as a matter of conscience and , and in some places the law recognises a privilege for conversations with clergy. The strongest form of this view is that a person who fears that every word may be passed on will stop speaking, and the people who most need to speak are those whom silence has already harmed. If pastoral confidence can be broken, people will go without help.
Others hold that the protection of an adult who is being harmed, or cannot protect themselves, outweighs confidentiality, and that no one who receives information about serious harm should be able to keep it to themselves. In many places the law requires certain professionals and certain roles to report, and some legal systems also reach volunteers, church officers or clergy. The strongest form of this view is that a promise of secrecy can protect the person who does harm and leave the person who is harmed alone, and that a community which keeps silence for its own reputation has failed.
The difference between a priest hearing a sacramental confession and a lay volunteer on a home visit matters a great deal. A lay visitor is not hearing a confession, and no seal covers what they hear. What a priest may hold as sacred is not what a visiting volunteer can promise, and a lay carer who borrows the language of the seal for a casual conversation gives a promise they cannot keep. Whether a minister's duty to report overrides a seal, and whether the law makes an exception for clergy, differs between countries, and between traditions inside a country. This lecture does not settle it and cannot.
What this course requires is less than either side demands, and enough for a lay carer:
- Never promise to keep everything secret. Promise only what you can keep: that you will tell only the person whose job it is to help.
- Know your community's written policy and your local law, as far as they bear on your role. If you do not know them, ask your leader to give them to you in writing before your next visit.
- Tell the responsible person, and let them decide what goes beyond. You do not have to decide whether the law demands a report. You have to pass it on.
- If a person wants to make a sacramental confession, or to speak to their own pastor or priest in confidence, help them reach that person. Do not stand in for them.
9. A short story
(an invented example) Wiktoria is 79 and lives with her nephew and his wife. Two visitors from her parish come every second Tuesday. For three visits running, the nephew's wife has said that Wiktoria is resting. On the fourth, Wiktoria is in the chair. She looks thinner. She says quietly, while the nephew's wife is in the kitchen, "I am not allowed to have my own money any more." Then she says, "Please don't say anything. They are good to me."
The visitors do not question her. One says: "Thank you for telling me. I will not talk about it with anyone except our coordinator, whose job is to help. I cannot promise to say nothing, because I want you to be well." On the way home they write down, together but separately, what they saw (the thinness, the three visits) and what Wiktoria said, in her own words. They telephone the coordinator that evening. They do not decide whether the nephew and his wife are wrong. There may be a reason. The coordinator asks them to keep visiting, speaks to the pastor and follows the community's policy. The visitors come on the next second Tuesday, as usual.
Notice what the visitors did not do. They did not accuse. They did not search the house. They did not keep the secret. And they did not go away.
10. Liturgical and free-church communities
A parish with five Masses, a cathedral with a safeguarding officer, a diocese with a written protocol: these may give you a named person and a form. A house church of fifteen, an assembly in a rented hall: you may have only your leader and the local reporting body. Either way, the shape is the same. There is a person who is named in advance as the one you tell. If you do not know who that is, find out this week. A route that nobody has written down is a route nobody takes.
Diagram 1. The circle of knowing
Diagram 2. Seen, heard, and what I do not know
| Column | What goes in it | Example of the style |
|---|---|---|
| What I saw | A fact, described plainly | "A bruise on the left forearm, about the size of a coin." |
| What I heard | The person's own words, in quotation marks | "He says I fell, but I didn't fall." |
| What I do not know | Everything else, including causes | "How the bruise happened. Who was there." |
In short
- What you hear and see in a person's home or room belongs to the person. Nothing goes to a prayer chain, a list or a group chat without their permission.
- A sign of possible abuse or neglect is a reason to tell the responsible person. It is not proof, and it is not a verdict on anyone.
- Do not investigate, confront or rescue. Write down what you saw and heard, in the person's own words, and tell the responsible person the same day.
- Never promise to keep everything secret. Promise only that you will tell the person whose job it is to help.
- If anyone is in danger now, call the emergency number. Follow your local law and your community's written policy.
- A lay visitor has no seal. Whatever is true of a priest in confession, a volunteer cannot promise absolute secrecy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What belongs to the person | What you hear and see in their home or room. Nothing goes to a prayer chain or chat without permission. |
| A sign | A reason to tell the responsible person, not proof and not a verdict. |
| After noticing a sign | Stay calm, listen, never promise secrecy, write down what you saw and heard, and tell the responsible person the same day. |
| What you do not do | Investigate, confront, rescue, or decide that it is nothing. |
One sentence to remember Keep the person's story private and the person safe: notice, write it down, tell the one person whose part it is to act.
This week's action Find out who your community's responsible person is for concerns about an adult at risk, and write down their name and how to reach them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time when something you shared was passed on without your permission. What did it feel like? What does that tell you about the visits you make?
- The lecture says that a sign is a reason to tell, not a conclusion about anyone. Why is it important to keep those two apart?
- A person says, "Don't tell anyone." What would you say? Say it aloud in your own words.
- Why does the course ask a lay visitor to write down what was seen and heard, and not what it means?
- Who in your community is the named person to tell? If you do not know, who could you ask this week?