Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
This lecture has two halves that belong together. The first is about dignity: the small, daily habits by which a church shows that a person is a person. The second is about safety: what a congregation does when it sees signs that a member may be harmed, and what it builds into its own habits so that harm is less likely.
They are one lecture because they have one root. A church that speaks to the person, asks before it touches and keeps their private matters private is a church where a person has a voice, and a person who has a voice is safer. A church that talks past people, grabs wheelchairs and discusses diagnoses over coffee has already taught everyone that some members do not have to be asked. Harm grows easily in that soil.
The lecture does not teach church safety policy, insurance or law. Those are taught in another course. It teaches the eye: what dignity looks like, what a worrying sign looks like, and what an ordinary member does next. It also contains one of the places where readers will not agree, which is about who decides when a person needs support to decide.
What these 33 minutes give you
- Describe habits of dignity: speaking to the person, asking before touching, praying with laying on of hands, lifting or photographing, and keeping diagnosis private.
- State fairly the disagreement over who decides for an adult who needs support, and what the course requires of a church worker.
- Name general signs that a person may be harmed, and explain why a sign is a reason to tell and not a proof.
- Describe the steps to take on seeing a sign: write it down, tell the responsible person, use the reporting body and the emergency number, and do not investigate alone.
- State the church's own safeguards: two adults in open spaces, no personal care by general volunteers, no restraint or confinement, and no giving or withholding of medicine.
Defend the weak, the poor, and the fatherless. Maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed. Rescue the weak and needy. Deliver them out of the hand of the wicked." — Psalms 82:3-4
World English Bible
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate. Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy." — Proverbs 31:8-9
WEB
One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13
WEB
Psalm 82 speaks of God's judgement on those who rule without defending the weak. Proverbs 31 tells a king's mother to speak up for people who have no voice before him. Proverbs 11 is about keeping a confidence. These are old texts about power, and they speak first to people who hold power. In this lecture, that includes anyone in a church who has more power than the person beside them. Note that Proverbs 31:8 can be misused: it is not a licence to speak instead of a person who can speak. We will come back to that.
1. Dignity comes first
Safety is easy to teach as a list of rules. Rules matter, and later sections give some. But rules alone produce nervous churches that watch each other and neglect the person. Dignity is the starting point because it says what the rules are for: to protect a person who is a member of the body and made in God's image, and who is therefore never an object to be handled.
Dignity is shown in small things. Here are the habits that matter most.
Speak to the person. Greet them by name. Look at them. Ask them the question. If they use a sign language interpreter, a communication device or a support worker, speak to the person and not to the interpreter or the helper. If speech is slow, wait. If you cannot understand, say so kindly and ask again, or ask a yes-or-no question, or write it down. Never speak about a person in the third person while they sit there ("Does she want some tea?" to the person beside her).
Ask before you touch. Do not pat, push, lift, grab or move a person, a wheelchair, a walker, a cane or a communication device. A wheelchair, for example, is part of how a person moves, and touching it can feel like being touched. A hand on an arm may be a comfort to you and a shock to another. Ask first: "May I?" Then accept the answer. In some cultures, touch is warm and ordinary, and in others it is rare or restricted by gender or age. The rule is the same: ask, and accept a no without argument.
Ask before you pray with the laying on of hands. Some traditions pray with a hand on the head or shoulder, with oil, or with others gathered around. Many people value this. Others find it uncomfortable or frightening, especially if they are asked in front of a crowd, or if the prayer is for their body to change when they have not asked for that. So: ask in private, ask what they would like prayed for, and pray what the person wants. Do not touch if the answer is no. Lecture 1-3 set out where readers differ about healing prayer. The habit is the same whichever view you hold.
Ask before you lift. Lifting a person is personal care, and a general volunteer does not do it (see below). A person who needs to be lifted should be lifted by someone trained to do it, with their agreement, under the community's policy. If a person has fallen and is in danger, the emergency number is called. A volunteer does not improvise.
Ask before you photograph or record. A picture of a person's face or body can follow them to places they never intended. Ask first, say what the picture is for, and let them say no. Lecture 5-4 returns to this.
Keep diagnosis and circumstances private. A diagnosis, a medicine, a benefit, a family difficulty belongs to the person. It does not go on a prayer list, a notice, a group chat or a teachers' handout without their permission. When a volunteer needs to know something to help, they are told what helps, not what the diagnosis is (lecture 5-4).
Accept "no" and "not now." The person does not owe the church a reason. If someone does not want help, a hug, a prayer, a seat change or a photograph, that is their answer.
| Often done, with good intentions | A dignified habit |
|---|---|
| Moving a wheelchair out of the aisle without asking | "May I move this a little, or would you like to?" |
| Announcing "we pray for N, who has [a diagnosis]" | Asking N what words, if any, may be used |
| Taking a photograph of the group "to show we are inclusive" | Asking each person, and not using the photograph if anyone says no |
| Pulling someone's arm to help them stand | Asking "would you like a hand?" and waiting |
| Asking the companion "does he want a drink?" | Asking him |
| Hugging a person who looks sad | "Would you like a hug, or would you rather sit quietly?" |
2. Who decides: the person, the family or a guardian
Dignity raises a hard question. What if a person needs help to decide, or a family and a person want different things? Who decides?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that family members or legal guardians should decide for an adult who cannot decide for themselves. Their strongest case is that a person with a profound intellectual disability, or a person in a severe crisis, may not be able to weigh risk, and that someone who loves them and knows them best must carry that responsibility. A decision left to nobody is also a decision, and it can be harmful. Others hold that the person's own will and preferences should lead, with support, whatever their disability. Their strongest case is that there are many recorded cases of decisions taken "in the best interest" of people who were never asked, who in some places and times were sent away, sterilised, silenced or deprived of friends, and that a right removed is hard to get back. They also point out that the question "can this person decide?" is often really "has anyone given them the support to decide?" Many disabled people's movements have used the slogan "nothing about us without us," and disabled people do not all agree about where the line should be. Laws on guardianship and substitute decisions differ greatly from country to country and change over time, and they are legal matters.
This course requires less than either position. A church worker takes part in no legal decision. A church worker does not sign, advise on, witness or argue about guardianship, consent to treatment, money or where a person lives. What a church worker does is simple: ask the person and listen first; note their wishes; follow local law and ask a qualified adviser.
In practice, "support to decide" is within every church member's reach.
- Give time. Do not rush an answer.
- Use plain words. One idea at a time.
- Offer two choices when open questions are hard.
- Use pictures, objects or writing if they help.
- Let a trusted person sit beside them, if the person wants it.
- Check back. "Did I understand? Is that what you want?"
- Write down what they said, with their permission, with the date, in their words. A note of a person's wishes can matter later, when others are speaking for them.
If a person's wishes and their family's differ on a church matter (whether to be baptised or take part in a service, join a trip, or be in a photograph), do not take sides in public. Speak to the person alone, if they are willing, and note what they say. Then, if they agree, bring the family and the person together with the pastor or responsible person. If the matter touches health, money, housing or law, say plainly, "This is not for the church to decide. Let us help you find someone qualified to advise."
Proverbs 31:8 says, "Open your mouth for the mute." That is a call to those who have a voice to use it so that others are heard. It has sometimes been used the other way, as a reason to speak instead of a person. In this course, we read it as: use your voice to make room for theirs. That step from text to practice is ours.
3. Why safety belongs in a church lecture
Say it carefully, without figures: people who depend on others for care, for transport or for help with intimate matters can be more exposed to harm than others. The reasons are not mysterious. They may need help with the toilet or dressing, which means someone else has access to their body. They may have difficulty telling what has happened, or may not be believed when they do. They may be cut off from friends. They may depend on the person who harms them. They may not know that what is happening is wrong. They may fear that if they speak, the help they need will be withdrawn.
Three further things must be said.
First, harm can happen in any place, including a church. Those who cause harm are often trusted, helpful and generous. A church is not made safe by good feeling. It is made safe by habits that do not depend on trusting everyone.
Second, most carers and families do not harm anyone. A family may sometimes be a source of harm, from strain, from lack of support, from fear or occasionally from intent. We do not know which, and it is not our job to decide. We do not cast families as villains, and we do not assume that a hard-pressed carer is dangerous. Strain explains some things. It does not make a person's safety less important.
Third, nobody in a congregation has to know whether someone is being harmed. That would be an impossible burden, and it would turn members into detectives. A member's job is smaller: to notice, to write down, to tell the right person, and to keep being kind.
4. General signs
Here are general signs that may mean a person is being harmed, neglected or exploited. They are not a checklist for diagnosing a family. Each can have an innocent explanation. A sign is a reason to tell, not a proof, and not a reason to accuse.
- Injuries that are unexplained, repeated, or explained in a way that does not fit.
- Fear or a sudden change in a person around a particular person, place or time.
- Being kept from others: not allowed to speak for themselves, not allowed to come to church, to see friends or to use a phone; always answered for.
- Unmet needs: hunger, clothes unsuited to the weather, poor hygiene, medicine not given, glasses, hearing aids or other equipment missing or withheld.
- Missing money or belongings, pressure to hand over money, gifts or property, or a person who cannot say where their money goes.
- A carer or companion who will not leave the person alone with you, who answers every question, or who becomes angry when the person speaks to you.
- Something the person tells you, in words, in signs, in a drawing or by behaviour. Take it seriously every time.
- A person who seems frightened of being touched, of being left alone, or of a certain person.
Some signs are about the church's own members. A volunteer who insists on being alone with a particular person, who gives gifts, who meets a member in private, or who ignores the church's rules about two adults is a sign for the responsible person to know. This is not an accusation. It is why the rules exist.
5. What to do
The steps are the same wherever you live. The details of law and reporting differ.
- If anyone is in danger now, use the emergency number. Do this first, before anything else, without waiting for permission.
- Stay calm and listen. If a person tells you something, believe enough to act. Do not ask leading questions, and do not ask for details beyond what they offer. Do not promise secrecy: you may have to tell. Say something like, "Thank you for telling me. I am going to make sure the right person knows, so that you can be safe."
- Do not investigate alone. Do not question the family, the carer or the member suspected. Do not confront anyone. Do not try to gather evidence. That is not your task, and it can put the person at greater risk.
- Write down what you saw and heard. The date, the time, the place, what you actually observed, and the person's words as exactly as you can recall them. Leave out guesses and opinions. Keep it private and secure.
- Tell the responsible person the same day. Your community's written policy should name them. In a large parish, this may be a safeguarding officer; in a small assembly, an or leader who has been given the job.
- The responsible person uses the local reporting body. Depending on the country and the person's age, this may be an adult protection service, a child protection service, the police or another body. The category is what matters here. You do not need to know the name. If your community has no written policy or no responsible person, tell the leader of your church that this must be fixed, and tell the local reporting body yourself. If the sign concerns the responsible person or a leader, do not take it to them: go to the next person above them, or straight to the local reporting body. Where the person is an adult who can decide, their own wishes about a report matter, and in some places the rules differ. The responsible person asks the local body what applies. Check locally.
- Stay kind. The member is still a member. Keep greeting them by name. Do not treat them differently, and do not gossip.
Legal duties differ by country and by role. In some places, certain people (teachers, health workers, clergy or church workers) are required by law to report. In others, there is no such duty. Follow local law and your community's written policy.
6. The church's own safeguards
A congregation protects people best by habits it keeps for everyone, always, and not just for people who seem to be at risk.
- No one is alone with a vulnerable person. Two adults, in open spaces: a room with an open door or a window, a shared hall, a visible corner. This rule protects the person. It also protects the volunteer from being falsely accused. It applies to everyone, including the pastor, the priest, the elder and the loved volunteer of thirty years.
- Personal care is not done by general volunteers. Personal care means help with the toilet, with dressing, with giving medicine, with lifting. It is done only by trained people, with the consent of the person (or their lawful representative) and the community's policy. If no such person is available, the answer is not "I will help." It is "we will find a way that is safe."
- No restraint, no confinement. A church worker never holds, pins, shuts in or locks in a person, for any reason. If a person is in distress and cannot be calmed, the church does not use force. It moves other people out of the way, calls the responsible person, calls the person's family or support worker if they are present, and uses the emergency number if anyone is in danger. (Lecture 6-3 returns to hard moments.)
- No giving, and no withholding, of medicine. A volunteer does not give anyone a tablet, a drink to take with a tablet, an inhaler or an injection, and does not tell anyone to skip their medicine. If a person's medicine is a matter for the day, their own helper or family deals with it, and the church worker calls the responsible person, or the emergency number if there is a medical emergency.
- The person's own helper stays. A person's own support worker, family member or friend may be with them. The church does not send them away "to give the person space" without the person's say. If a sign worries you about that helper, do not send them away yourself and do not question them: tell the responsible person.
- Written, known and reviewed. The rules are written down, known by every volunteer, and looked at every year. Church safety policy, insurance and law are taught in another course.
Some congregations meet in homes, in rented rooms or in the open air, with no building and no trained people. The rules still hold. Two adults can be in an open space under a tree. A house church can agree that doors stay open and that nobody takes a member to a bedroom or a bathroom. If you cannot do personal care safely, say so: "We cannot do that here yet. Can we do something else, or arrange it with your helper?"
(an invented example) Anil is a young man with an intellectual disability who sings in the choir of a large parish. Over three Sundays, two choir members noticed that Anil came without a coat in cold weather, flinched when a particular relative came to collect him, and said once, quietly, "I am not allowed to keep my money." They were not sure what any of it meant. One of them, a tenor named Bruno, wrote down on a card what he had seen and what Anil had said, with the dates, and left out his own theories. He gave the card the same day to Beatriz, a social worker who uses a wheelchair and who leads the parish's safeguarding group. Beatriz thanked him, did not ask him to find out more, and took the matter to the local body for such concerns, as the parish's policy required. Bruno never learned the outcome. He continued to greet Anil by name and to stand next to him in the choir. The family may have had an innocent explanation for every sign. The point is that Bruno did not have to know. He only had to tell.
7. A liturgical parish and a free church
In a parish with many Masses or services, the risk of "nobody knows who is responsible" is large. The named person, the written policy and the form for notes should be easy to find. The sacristy, the parish office or the hall noticeboard may be good places. In a small assembly or house church, the risk is the reverse: everyone knows everyone, and the trust can make people reluctant to speak. The named person, the two-adult rule and the written note are just as needed, and probably more.
In both, a disabled member should be among those who help write and review the rules. They know what dignity feels like from the inside, and they know which rules protect them and which only make them feel watched.
8. Where this leaves a congregation
The church that keeps people safe is first the church that treats them with dignity: it speaks to the person, asks before it touches, keeps private things private and supports a person to decide. Its safeguards are plain, ordinary and known to all. When it sees a worrying sign, it does not investigate and it does not look away. It writes down what it saw, tells the responsible person and stays kind. And it remembers the old word, kept in Psalm 82, that to defend the weak and to rescue the needy is part of what it means to be just.
Diagram 1. What do I do when I see a sign?
Diagram 2. The church's own safeguards
| Habit | What it means |
|---|---|
| Two adults, open spaces | No one is alone with a vulnerable person. Applies to everyone, including leaders. |
| Personal care | Only trained people, with consent and under the written policy. Never a general volunteer. |
| No restraint, no confinement | Never hold, pin, shut in or lock in a person. Call the responsible person; call the emergency number if anyone is in danger. |
| Medicine | Never give it, never withhold it. The person's own helper or family deals with it. |
| The person's own helper | Stays unless the person says otherwise. |
| Written, known, reviewed | The rules are on paper, every volunteer knows them, and they are looked at every year. |
In short
- Dignity comes first: speak to the person, ask before touching, praying with laying on of hands, lifting or photographing, and keep diagnosis private.
- Readers disagree on whether family or guardians decide for an adult who needs support, or the person's own wishes lead. A church worker takes part in no legal decision and follows local law.
- People who depend on others for care can be more exposed to harm. A family may sometimes be a source of harm, yet most families are not.
- A sign is a reason to tell, not a proof. Write down what you saw and heard, tell the responsible person the same day, and never investigate alone.
- Two adults in open spaces; no personal care, restraint or medicine by general volunteers; use the emergency number if anyone is in danger.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Habits of dignity | Speak to the person; ask before touching, praying with laying on of hands, lifting or photographing; keep diagnosis private; accept no. |
| Who decides? | Readers differ: family or guardian, or the person's own will with support. A church worker takes part in no legal decision; ask and listen first, follow local law. |
| What to do on seeing a sign | Emergency number if danger; listen; do not investigate; write it down; tell the responsible person the same day; stay kind. |
| The church's safeguards | Two adults in open spaces; no personal care, restraint or medicine by general volunteers. |
One sentence to remember I do not have to know whether harm has happened; I have to notice, write it down, and tell the right person.
This week's action Find out whether your community has a written safety policy and a named responsible person. Write down the role (not the name) and where the policy is kept.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the habits of dignity in this lecture is easiest for you, and which is hardest? Why?
- A friend says, "I would never ask before pushing a wheelchair. I am only trying to help." What would you say to the friend, and what would you ask first?
- What are the strongest reasons you can give for each of the two positions in the "who decides" paragraph? Which reason do you find hardest to answer?
- In the invented example, Bruno did not know whether anyone had done wrong. Why is it important that a volunteer does not have to know?
- Does your community have a written policy and a named responsible person? Does everyone know who that is? If not, who in your community should be asked, and who should be asked to help write it?
- What would help a member with a disability feel that the church's safety rules are for them and not about them?