Lecture 4-1: Dementia: Staying With a Person Whose Memory Changes
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Age and Care
- Lecture 1-2: Ageing Across Cultures: Retirement, Loss, Loneliness, Care
- Lecture 1-3: What a Lay Carer Does, and Does Not Do
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Neighbour and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Preparing and Beginning the Visit
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Memory, Repetition and Silence
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer, Scripture and Worship at the Bedside
- Lecture 2-4: Dignity, Choice and the Words We Use
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Planning One Visit
- Lecture 3-1: The Home Visit and the Body's Limits
- Lecture 3-2: Care Homes and Hospitals
- Lecture 3-3: Privacy, Safety and the Signs of Abuse or Neglect
- Lecture 3-4: Money, Gifts and Keeping Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reading Signs and Knowing Whom to Tell
- Lecture 4-1: Dementia: Staying With a Person Whose Memory Changes
- Lecture 4-2: Loneliness, Loss and Feeling a Burden
- Lecture 4-3: The Family Carer
- Lecture 4-4: Faith Questions and Hard Conversations
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Word to the Family
- Lecture 5-1: Serious Illness, Hospice and Palliative Care
- Lecture 5-2: Accompanying the Dying Across the Traditions
- Lecture 5-3: The Moment of Death and the Days After
- Lecture 5-4: What to Say, What to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Words to Offer and Words to Leave
Some of the people you visit will forget. They may forget your name, the day of the week, or that you came last Tuesday. A few will forget the names of their own children. For a visitor this can feel like the end of the visit, because so much of visiting seems to depend on shared memory.
This lecture says that it is not the end. It says that what a visitor brings to a person whose memory is changing is not information but presence: a calm voice, a familiar face, a plain sentence, and respect. This is the central claim of the course in a very clear form. Care is not fixing, and here there is nothing to fix. There is only staying beside.
This lecture is not medical. Dementia is a word for several conditions in which memory, thinking and everyday ability change over time. Which condition a person has, how far it has gone, and what can be done about it are questions for the person's own doctor and family. A visitor does not diagnose, does not describe stages, and does not speak about medicines. If you are worried about a member of your community, the right step is to tell the family or your leader what you noticed, so that they can decide whether to ask a doctor. It is not to tell the person what you think is wrong.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Explain why a visitor does not diagnose, and say what to do when you are worried about a person's memory.
- Describe how to answer a person whose words do not match the facts, by answering the feeling instead of arguing the fact.
- List practical habits that help a visit go well: using the name, short sentences, one thing at a time, a quiet place, and the same patience for the fifth question as for the first.
- State fairly the disagreement about whether familiar prayers and hymns help, and say what this course requires.
- Speak humbly about the question "Is the person still themselves before God?", using Scripture as a starting point and not as a proof.
and even to old age I am he, and even to gray hairs will I carry you. I have made, and I will bear; yes, I will carry, and will deliver." — Isaiah 46:4
World English Bible
Can a woman forget her nursing child, that she should not have compassion on the son of her womb? Yes, these may forget, yet I will not forget you!" — Isaiah 49:15
WEB
Yahweh, you have searched me, and you know me. You know my sitting down and my rising up. You perceive my thoughts from afar. You search out my path and my lying down, and are acquainted with all my ways. For there is not a word on my tongue, but, behold, Yahweh, you know it altogether." — Psalm 139:1-4
WEB
These three passages are not a doctrine of dementia. They are three voices from different parts of the Bible that say, each in its own way, that a person is known and carried by God. We will use them in the last section of the lecture, and we will be careful about how much they are asked to prove.
1. What a visitor can know, and what a visitor cannot
Memory changes for many reasons. Some are ordinary parts of growing older. Some are caused by illness, by medicines, by grief, by low mood, by poor hearing or sleep, or by a sudden infection, and some of those can be treated. Some are caused by the group of conditions called dementia. A visitor cannot tell these apart, and it is not the visitor's task to try.
What a visitor can do is notice, and then pass on. You might notice that the person you have known for years has begun to repeat questions within a few minutes, to lose the way in a street they know, to leave the stove on, or to speak of a dead husband as if he were in the next room. You write down what you saw in plain words, without a guess about the cause, and you tell the family or the person you answer to in your community. They may already know. They may not. In either case they are the right people to decide what comes next.
Two cautions. First, do not say "I think you have dementia" to the person, or "I think your mother has dementia" to a relative. A name given by a friend at the door is a heavy thing. Second, do not decide that a person "is not there any more" because their memory has changed. That is the mistake this whole lecture is written against.
2. The person is still the person
The British researcher Tom Kitwood, in Dementia Reconsidered: The Person Comes First, argued that a person's sense of who they are is kept up or worn down by the way others treat them. The theologian John Swinton, in Dementia: Living in the Memories of God, argues in broad terms that the Christian community should be a place where people whose memory fails are remembered by God and by their friends. You do not need to agree with every detail of either book to take the practical point. A person whose memory has changed is still an adult, still someone's child or spouse or neighbour, and still a member of the body. What they have lost in one place they may still have in another: a tune, a hand held, the sense of being safe in a room, a gesture of respect that they still recognise.
So the aim of the visit is not to restore memory. It is to make the next half hour a good half hour for the person.
3. Reassure rather than correct
The hardest moment for many visitors is the statement that is not true. A man of eighty-five asks where his wife is, and she died some years ago. A woman asks what time her mother is coming to fetch her, and her mother has long been dead. A person tells you that it is 1962, or that you are their sister.
Our habit is to correct, because truth matters. But think about what correcting does here. If you say "Your wife died some years ago," a man who has asked in good faith may hear the news as new, and he may grieve all over again. Then, ten minutes later, he asks again. To tell him the fact every time is to ask him to lose his wife many times a day.
This does not mean you must lie. It means you do not have to win the argument about the fact. You can answer the feeling under the question. A person who asks for a husband is often saying "I feel alone", "I want to feel safe", or "I miss him." So you say, calmly and gently, "You miss him." Then you ask a question that lets the person talk about the husband: "Tell me about him." Often the person will tell a story that is true and warm, and the feeling will ease without any fact being argued over.
There are honest limits. If a person asks you a direct question that matters ("Am I in hospital?", "Did my husband die?") and is clearly able to take in the answer, say the truth gently and briefly, and stay with them. If they are alarmed by it, do not repeat it. Families and carers differ a great deal here. Some prefer gentle truth every time, some prefer to turn the conversation aside, and many do a mixture depending on the day. Ask the family what they say, and say the same. If you see that the family's way is causing the person real distress, tell your leader and do not argue with the family in the room.
4. Practical habits for a good visit
None of these is difficult. All of them need patience, which is the hard part.
- Say who you are every time. "Good afternoon, Mr Aziz. I am Grace, from the church." Do not ask "Do you remember me?" That is a test, and it can only embarrass. Give the name as a gift.
- Use the person's own name as they like to be addressed, and use it often. Ask the family if you are not sure what name or title the person prefers.
- Come to the person's level. Sit so that your face is near and in good light, and let the person see you before you speak.
- Use short sentences, one idea at a time. "Would you like some tea?" is better than "Would you like tea or coffee, or perhaps some water, and shall I put the window up?" Offer one choice, and then wait.
- Give time. Count slowly in your head after a question. Do not fill the silence.
- Choose a quiet place. Television, a radio, many voices and bright light make it harder for a person to follow. Turn the television down, with permission.
- Answer the fifth question as you answered the first. The person is asking it for the first time. If you notice your voice getting tight, take a breath and say something warm.
- Know the best time of day. Ask the family. Some people are clearer in the morning and tired by late afternoon. A short visit at the right time is better than a long one at the wrong time.
- Be careful with touch. A hand held can be a comfort, but ask first, with a gesture if not with words, and take your hand away if the person stiffens.
- Do not quiz, test or hurry. Do not say "You already told me that."
Hearing and sight matter here as in any visit (lecture 2-2). A person who cannot hear well and whose memory is changing may seem more confused than they are. Check that glasses and hearing aids are in place if the person uses them, but ask first and do not handle them without permission.
(an invented example) Tomas is eighty-one and has lived in the same flat for fifty years. His daughter lives in another city and arranges for a pair of visitors from the congregation to come on Thursday afternoons. Grace, one of the visitors, has learned that Tomas is best after lunch. When she arrives, he often says, "Is Marta home yet?" Marta was his wife, and she died four years ago. At first Grace said, "Tomas, Marta has died," and Tomas wept and then, twenty minutes later, asked again. Now Grace says, "You are thinking about Marta." Tomas nods. "Tell me about her," says Grace. Most weeks he tells her about a dance hall where they met, in a version that changes a little each time. Grace has stopped checking it. When he asks her something direct, such as "Is she dead?", Grace sits close and answers briefly and kindly, and then asks if he would like to look at the photograph on the shelf. She tells his daughter about what he says, as they agreed at the start, and not about anything else.
5. Safety, kept short
Three things only. First, a person whose memory is changing can become frightened, angry or restless, and may try to leave the house. You do not restrain a person, and you do not lift or move them. You stay calm, speak softly, keep your distance if they want space, and call the family or the person you answer to. If the person is in danger, or has left and cannot be found, use the emergency number at once. Second, never agree to be alone in charge of a person who cannot be left, unless the family and your leader have agreed it in advance. Third, do not give medicine, food or drink without the family's say, because a person's swallowing, allergies or diet may be a matter for their doctors. Lecture 3-1 and lecture 3-4 give the wider rules for carers' safety.
6. Dignity does not shrink
It is easy to talk about the person in the third person while they are sitting in the room: "She has been very confused today." Don't. Speak to the person. Speak about the person only where they cannot hear, and only to those who need to know. The visit is a meeting between two adults, even when one of them has lost many words. Lecture 2-4 gave the principles; they apply here with the same force.
7. Familiar prayers and hymns
Many people who visit a person with changing memory want to bring a prayer or a hymn. This is a good instinct, and it can also go wrong.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some carers and families report that a familiar psalm, the Lord's Prayer, the Hail Mary, the Jesus Prayer, a hymn sung in childhood, or a well-known chorus seems to reach a person who has lost most other words. They may join in, remember the tune, or become calm. Some pastors and chaplains, liturgical and free-church, say that familiar words carry something that conversation cannot. Others have different experience. Some people become confused or distressed when prayers are said, perhaps because the setting reminds them of a time they remember in a painful way, or because the voice or the pace is wrong, or because they feel they are being asked to perform. Some family members also say, honestly, that a prayer can be used to make the visitor feel better more than to help the person.
What this course requires is less than either side would ask. Offer, watch the person, ask the family, and stop if distress rises. Do not assume that a hymn will help because it helped someone else. Do not assume it will not. Ask the family what the person has loved, and which words they have used all their life, in which language, in what tradition. A parishioner who has said the Rosary for seventy years may be soothed by it; a Pentecostal member may want a chorus and a clap; an Orthodox member may want the Trisagion or the Jesus Prayer; a Protestant who has loved a psalm may want to hear it read. These are the person's own words, not yours. If the person turns away, goes quiet in a distressed way, or says no, stop at once and sit in silence or change the subject. Prayer is never forced, and a prayer that distresses has stopped being a gift.
Disability access in worship, including the inclusion of people with dementia in a service, is the subject of another course. For the visit, the point is that the person's own faith expression is respected and that you ask, and do not assume.
8. Is the person still themselves before God?
Families sometimes ask a hard question. When the memory of a wife or mother is almost gone, is she still herself? Does she still know God? Does she still belong to the congregation?
We have to be humble here. The Bible does not give a short answer about a particular medical condition, and traditions answer with different emphases. Some stress that the sacraments and prayers of the Church are still given to a person who can no longer speak or follow. Some stress that the community's duty is to keep the person among them. Some will say that only God knows the heart. Do not settle this with a family, and above all do not tell a family what a person's spiritual state is. If they want to talk it through with their own pastor or priest, help them to ask.
What Scripture does offer is a starting point. In Isaiah 46:4 God speaks to people who are old and says "even to gray hairs will I carry you," and in Isaiah 49:15 God says that even if a mother could forget her child, "yet I will not forget you." Psalm 139 says that God knows a person's sitting down and rising up, and every word on the tongue before it is spoken. In all three, the weight is on God's knowing and holding, not on the person's memory. A reasonable reading is that a person is held by God, not by their own memory. That reading is a comfort that you may offer if the family wants it. It is not a proof about any particular person's condition, and it should not be said to settle what readers of different traditions believe about faith and salvation. Say what you hope, say that you do not know more than anyone else, and leave the rest with God and with the person's own pastor or priest.
9. In a parish and in a house church
In a large parish, you may be one of several lay visitors, and the priest or a pastoral associate may already bring the Eucharist or anointing; your part is to be the familiar face and to pass on what you notice. In a small assembly or a house church, you may be the main visitor, and the family may ask you to pray. In either place, the rules are the same: ask, watch, stay short, tell the right person, and keep the person's dignity. Lecture 2-3 explained why a lay visitor does not take on a , and that holds here too.
10. Where this leaves a visitor
A visitor who has learned this lecture can sit beside a woman who does not know her name and be a good guest in her afternoon. That is a real gift to her and also to her family, who watch a visit and see that she is still treated as someone who matters. It is not a cure, and it should not be presented as one. When the visits become too hard, because the person's needs have grown beyond what a lay visitor can give, the care passes to others, and the visitor's task becomes to keep the friendship and to tell the right people. The family carer, who often carries most of this, is the subject of lecture 4-3.
Diagram 1. When the facts are wrong
Diagram 2. Instead of ... try ...
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| "Do you remember me?" | "Hello, Tomas. I am Grace, from the church." |
| "Marta died four years ago." (every time) | "You are thinking about Marta. Tell me about her." |
| "You already told me that." | "That is a good story. What happened next?" |
| "No, it is Thursday, not Sunday." | "It is a quiet afternoon. Shall we have tea?" |
| Talking to the family about the person, in front of the person | Speaking to the person, and keeping the rest for later |
| Starting a long hymn because it is a favourite | "Would you like to hear a psalm? Or shall we just sit?" |
In short
- A visitor does not diagnose or describe stages. A visitor notices, writes it down in plain words, and tells the family or leader.
- A person whose memory changes is still an adult and a member of the body, and the visit aims at a good half hour, not at restoring memory.
- Answer the feeling under the question rather than arguing the fact. Ask the family what they say, and say the same.
- Say who you are each time, use the name, speak in short sentences, give time, and answer the fifth question like the first.
- Familiar prayers and hymns help some people and distress others: offer, watch, ask the family, and stop if distress rises.
- Scripture says that God holds a person; it does not settle questions of faith for any one person, and you may say you do not know.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A visitor and memory loss | Notice, write down in plain words, tell the family or leader. Do not diagnose or describe stages. |
| Reassure rather than correct | Answer the feeling under the words ("You miss him"), then invite a story. Ask the family what they say. |
| Familiar prayers and hymns | They help some and distress others. Offer, watch, ask the family, stop if distress rises. |
| Held by God, not by memory | Isaiah 46:4, Isaiah 49:15 and Psalm 139 stress God's knowing and carrying. A comfort to offer, not a proof. |
One sentence to remember When facts slip away, the feeling remains, so answer the feeling, keep the person's dignity, and stay.
This week's action Pick one phrase you would use to answer a feeling (for example, "You miss him") and say it aloud three times, until it comes without effort.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does a visitor not name or describe an illness, even when the signs seem plain? What is the helpful thing to do with what you notice?
- In the invented example, what changed when Grace stopped correcting Tomas? What did she still do that was honest?
- When a person asks a question to which the truthful answer is painful, what are the possible responses? What does the family's own habit have to do with it?
- Why does a prayer that helps one person confuse another? What would you ask a family before bringing a hymn?
- What does it mean to say that a person is "held by God, not by memory"? What would you not want to say with those words?