Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
Why does a person join a church team that welcomes people with disabilities? Why does a pastor put the subject on the agenda? Why do you read this course? If the honest answer is a mixture, you are in good company. Duty, love, guilt, discomfort, curiosity, a wish to be thought good, and a plain wish to do something useful sit side by side in most of us, and they rarely arrive one at a time.
This lecture does not ask you to purify your motives before you act. It asks you to know what they are, so that the ones you like less do not steer the work while you are not looking. Then it turns from the heart to the door. It follows four invented newcomers through the first five minutes at a church entrance, and asks what is welcome and what is a wall. A person can be greeted warmly and still be told, in a dozen small ways, that the place was not made for them. The lecture ends with what to do about a motive you do not like in yourself.
What these 32 minutes give you
- Name at least five mixed motives people bring to disability inclusion, and say what each can do well and what each can do badly.
- Explain what Matthew 6:1-4 asks of a giver, and what it does not ask.
- Describe the first five minutes at a church door for a newcomer who uses a wheelchair, who is Deaf, who is autistic, or who has a condition others cannot see, and separate what welcomes from what blocks.
- Explain why a person can be welcomed and still feel "not meant to be here".
- Choose a practical response to a motive you do not like in yourself.
Be careful that you don’t do your charitable giving before men, to be seen by them, or else you have no reward from your Father who is in heaven." — Matthew 6:1
World English Bible
But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does," — Matthew 6:3
WEB
Therefore accept one another, even as Christ also accepted you, to the glory of God." — Romans 15:7
WEB
But Martha was distracted with much serving, and she came up to him, and said, “Lord, don’t you care that my sister left me to serve alone? Ask her therefore to help me.”" — Luke 10:40
WEB
Jesus answered her, “Martha, Martha, you are anxious and troubled about many things," — Luke 10:41
WEB
Jesus warns about doing good in order to be seen. Paul gives the one ground of welcome that does not depend on our own state of mind. Jesus tells a busy host what he sees in her. All three texts are about the inside of a person who is doing good.
1. Mixed motives are normal
If you ask a group of church members why they want to welcome people with disabilities better, you will hear a surprisingly honest list.
- Duty. "It is what a church should do." This is a real and respectable motive. It keeps people at the work on the days they do not feel like it.
- Love. "I care about this person, or people like her." This is the motive the church most often claims, and in many people it is genuinely present.
- Guilt. "I have not done enough, and I know it." Guilt can start a good thing. It is a poor driver, because it wants to be relieved, and a thing done to relieve guilt stops when the guilt does.
- Discomfort. "I do not know what to say, and I would like that feeling to go away." This is very common, and almost nobody says it aloud. Discomfort is not a sin. It is a sign that we have had little contact, and contact usually reduces it.
- Curiosity. "I would like to understand." Curiosity is a good beginning if it turns into listening, and a poor one if the person becomes a specimen.
- A wish to be thought good. "I want people to see that I am kind." Few people admit this one, and nearly all of us have it somewhere.
- A personal link. "My child, my parent, my own body." For many members this is the strongest motive of all and the least visible in a church committee, because the link is private.
- Pity. "I feel sorry for people like that." Pity is a feeling many of us have been taught to think of as a virtue. Lecture 1-2 explained why many disabled people do not want it.
The first thing to say about this list is that it is normal. A church that waited for pure motives would wait forever. The second is that the motives are not equally safe. Some of them put the person at the centre. Others put the helper at the centre. The work is to notice which is steering at a given moment, and to act in a way that keeps the person, and not the helper's feelings, at the middle.
2. What Matthew 6:1-4 asks, and what it does not
Jesus says: "Be careful that you don’t do your charitable giving before men, to be seen by them" (Matthew 6:1). He goes on to describe a person who sounds a trumpet when they give, and then he says:
"But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does," — Matthew 6:3 (WEB)
This is one of the most often quoted verses in discussions of motive, and it is easy to misread in two ways.
The first misreading is: do good only if your motive is pure. The text does not say that. It does not tell the giver to stop giving until the heart is clean. It speaks of a particular temptation, giving in order to be seen, and it offers a particular remedy, which is to turn attention away from oneself so completely that "the left hand" does not keep a count. The remedy is a kind of forgetfulness of self in the act, not a test of purity before it.
The second misreading is: so the church should do inclusion quietly, and not talk about it. The verses are about a person's private charity. They do not address what a congregation should say in its notices, what a committee should put in writing, or what a leader should publicly commit to. A church that says nothing about access leaves disabled people guessing whether they are welcome. There is a difference between a person who parades a kindness to be admired and a congregation that publishes a plain statement so that a newcomer knows what to expect. The first is the target of Jesus' warning. The second is ordinary honesty.
What does the passage give us? A question we can ask of ourselves: Is the person in front of me the point of this act, or am I? A congregation that takes a photograph of a disabled member at a special event and posts it on the notice board as a sign of how inclusive it is may fail that test. (A photograph of anyone also needs their permission; we come back to this in Week 5.) A congregation that quietly changes where the chairs go, after asking, passes it.
3. Martha at the table
The story in Luke 10 is about hospitality, and it is also about motive. Martha receives Jesus into her house (10:38). Her sister Mary sits at Jesus' feet and listens. Martha is "distracted with much serving". She comes to Jesus and says:
"But Martha was distracted with much serving, and she came up to him, and said, “Lord, don’t you care that my sister left me to serve alone? Ask her therefore to help me.”" — Luke 10:40 (WEB)
What strikes many readers is that Martha is doing something good and doing it with a motive that has soured. She wants to serve well. She also wants to be seen as doing the work, wants her sister to share it, and wants Jesus to take her side. Jesus does not shame her. He says her name twice, which many readers take as a sign of tenderness, and names what he sees: "you are anxious and troubled about many things" (10:41).
The passage is often read as a contrast between action and prayer, and many commentators say that is too simple: Jesus does not say that serving is bad. What he does say is that even good service can become anxious, a performance for an audience or a grievance against the people who are not helping. A volunteer team that welcomes people with disabilities can slide into the same state. The team works hard. A few people carry everything. They begin to resent the rest of the congregation, and to see the people they serve as the cause of their tiredness. On one reading, the remedy Jesus gives Martha is not to stop. It is to be seen, truly, by someone who knows what is going on in her.
For a congregation the practical lesson is: say aloud when a task has become a burden, share it, and let someone who loves you tell you the truth about how it looks from the outside.
4. The ground that does not depend on us
If motives are mixed, we need a ground for welcome that does not depend on our own state of mind. Paul gives one:
"Therefore accept one another, even as Christ also accepted you, to the glory of God." — Romans 15:7 (WEB)
Three phrases deserve notice. "Accept one another" means mutual acceptance: the church does not divide into acceptors and accepted. "Even as Christ also accepted you" gives the measure and the reason: we have been received, and not because we deserved it. "To the glory of God" names the purpose, which is neither the helper's reputation nor the church's growth.
This does not cancel the need to look at our own hearts. It reframes it. A person who accepts others because Christ accepted them is working from a gift received, and the mixed motives lose some of their grip. Guilt has less to prove. The wish to be thought good has less to prove. The question changes from how am I doing? to who is here, and what would they like?
5. The first five minutes
Now to the door. Four newcomers arrive, on four different Sundays, at an invented church. The door team is led by Hana, a member with low vision, who has chaired it for six years. We will use their situations to see what makes a first impression. Each of them describes themselves in the way shown here; remember the rule that we call people what they call themselves.
(an invented example) Amina uses a wheelchair. She learned of the church from a neighbour. She comes by bus and meets a pavement with a broken edge, a path of gravel and a single step at the door. A man at the door sees her and says, quickly, "Oh, wait, I'll get someone!" He disappears for some minutes. When he returns with two volunteers they offer to lift her chair up the step. She says she would rather not be lifted, and there is an awkward pause. Inside, the only space for a wheelchair is at the very back, beside the cloakroom, and a woman says warmly, "We keep this place for you." Amina is made welcome and also parked.
Joaquim is Deaf and uses sign language; he reads and writes the local language, but it is his second language. He arrives with a friend who is hearing. A greeter at the door speaks to the friend and not to him: "And is he with you?" The greeter hands over a printed order of service that has no words of the sermon and no outline of the prayers. In the service, Joaquim does not know when to stand or when the Gospel is being read until he sees others stand. The friend tries to write notes. By the time the sermon begins he has stopped following. He is warmly shaken by the hand afterwards, and told, "You must be so brave to come."
Kofi is a teenager with autism. (He and his family say "autistic" and "has autism" interchangeably; he prefers to be asked.) He comes with his mother. At the door a cheerful crowd greets everyone; there is a loud bell, a bright light in the entrance, and several people reach to shake his hand at once. He covers his ears. His mother says quietly, "He finds noise difficult." A man says, "Oh, he will be fine, give him a minute." There is a smell of incense in the nave and the music is already loud. After a few minutes Kofi leaves the room with his mother. Nobody tells them there was a quiet room down the corridor.
Lena has a long-term condition that causes severe pain and fatigue, and her condition is not visible. She walks in without help. She is tired from the journey and needs to sit down before the service begins. The only free seats are at the front, in view of everybody. A greeter, seeing her stand for a minute with a hand on a chair, says, "Are you all right? You look fine to me." She says she is fine. She sits in the front and finds that the service lasts longer than she can manage. She cannot leave without being seen. She leaves at the end of the first hymn and does not come back.
The table below sorts what welcomed and what walled.
| Newcomer | What welcomed | What was a wall | A low-cost step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amina, who uses a wheelchair | A person at the door who saw her | A broken path; a step; a man who ran off to find help; being lifted without being asked; a "special place" at the back | A clear path; a person at the door whose first words are "Would you like help, or is there anything that would make coming in easier?"; space for chairs among the seats and not only at the back |
| Joaquim, who is Deaf | A warm handshake | Speaking to his friend instead of to him; no written outline; no way to know when to stand; "so brave" | Face the person and write or gesture if needed; a written order of service with the readings; ask how he would like to take part, and whether an interpreter would help (lecture 3-2) |
| Kofi, who is autistic | His mother's voice, and the invitation to stay | A noisy, bright entrance; many hands at once; incense and loud music with no warning; the quiet room unmentioned | Tell families at the door what to expect and where the quiet room is; one greeter rather than many; no handshake pressure |
| Lena, who has a hidden condition | Someone noticed she needed a seat | "You look fine to me"; only front seats free; no easy way to leave | Keep an aisle seat near the back; say that anyone may stand, sit or leave at any time; do not comment on how a person looks |
Notice that none of these is a story about people who do not care. The man at the door who ran for help wanted to be useful. The woman who said "We keep this place for you" meant it as a kindness. The greeter who said "you look fine" meant to reassure. Each had a motive from the list above. Each thing they did came from a good intention and from not asking.
6. Welcomed, and still not meant to be here
Many disabled people say that the experience described above, being greeted warmly and still feeling that a place was not made for them, is one of the hardest to explain to people who have not met it. Nobody was rude. Nobody refused them. And yet the whole experience said, in a hundred small ways: you are a visitor here, and we are surprised you came.
The pattern, in the accounts people give, tends to include some of the following. A greeter speaks to a companion instead of the person. A "special" seat is offered, apart from everyone else. A person is asked, by someone they have never met, what is wrong with them or what happened to them. A person is prayed over without being asked. A person is thanked for coming, as if it were a favour. A person is invited to a service but never asked to read, to cook, to count the collection or to join a committee. A person is warmly greeted and then no one sits with them, because the greeters do not know what to say.
Each of these is an example of what this course has called welcome without access, or access without welcome. A church needs both. Welcome is how we treat the person. Access is what the place makes possible. A building with a ramp and a cold greeter has the second without the first. A warm parish with a flight of stairs has the first without the second. A newcomer feels the difference within minutes.
Note that this holds in every kind of church. A cathedral parish with five Masses has greeters, ushers, sidespeople, a long procession and a fixed order, and a newcomer may be swallowed in the crowd unless someone takes the trouble to say, "Here is where you may sit, and here is a copy of the readings." A small free-church assembly in a rented hall may have a warm, unscripted welcome and no one who knows how to be sure that a Deaf visitor can follow. A house church may have no steps at all and one person who dominates the talk. The remedy in each case is the same: someone asks, early and simply, what would make this easier.
7. What to do with a motive you do not like in yourself
Sooner or later you will notice a motive in yourself that you would rather not have. You will see that you were pleased at being thanked. You will notice that you stepped back from a person because you were uncomfortable. You will catch yourself saying "God bless her" in a tone you recognise as pity. What then?
Notice it, and do not punish yourself for noticing. A motive you can see is one you can manage. A motive you cannot see manages you. Many people stop at the shame, and then stop the work. Shame is not the aim.
Name it to someone you trust. Not to the person you are working with. Do not ask a disabled member to absolve you or to manage your feelings. Tell a friend, a pastor, a priest, or a fellow volunteer. If the person you tell is a disabled leader, ask first whether they are willing to hear it, because they may be tired of being asked.
Act in a way that checks the motive. If you are afraid you want to be thanked, do the thing without being thanked and see how it feels. If your motive is discomfort, spend a little time in the company of the person on ordinary business, a shared task or a cup of tea, and notice that the discomfort shrinks. If it is guilt, pick one small thing you can finish this month and finish it. If it is pity, ask the person something you would ask anyone: what they enjoy, what they are good at, what they think of the sermon.
Put the person's wishes ahead of your feelings. The test of a motive is what you do when the person says no. If you can accept "no, thank you" without being hurt, or with only a small sting you can carry yourself, your motive is serving them. If you find yourself pressing, or sulking, or explaining how much you wanted to help, it is serving you.
Do not make the person carry your repentance. The work is yours. A disabled member is under no duty to teach you, to forgive you or to be the evidence that you have changed.
A word to a reader who is a person with a disability. You may be reading this as someone who is often on the receiving end of other people's motives. You are not obliged to be everyone's teacher. You may come to a service simply to worship, and your own reasons for coming are your own. If you would like to help the congregation think, that is a gift; it is not a debt.
Diagram 1. The first five minutes
Diagram 2. Mixed motives at a glance
| Motive | What it can do well | How it can go wrong | A check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duty | Keeps the work going on bad days | Becomes cold, a box ticked | Do I also like the people I am serving? |
| Love | Notices the person | Becomes possessive or takes over | Can I take a "no" gladly? |
| Guilt | Starts a change | Stops when the guilt is relieved | Is the thing I am doing finished, or only felt? |
| Discomfort | Tells me where I need contact | Makes me avoid the person | Have I spent ordinary time with members who are disabled? |
| Curiosity | Opens the way to listening | Treats the person as a specimen | Am I asking about the person, or about the condition? |
| Wish to be thought good | Moves me to act | Makes the person an audience prop | Would I do it if no one knew? |
| Pity | Notices need | Looks down from above | Would the person be glad to hear what I am feeling? |
In short
- Mixed motives (duty, love, guilt, discomfort, curiosity, a wish to be thought good, a personal link, pity) are normal; the work is to know which one is steering.
- Matthew 6:1-4 warns against giving in order to be seen; it does not ask for pure motives before acting, and it does not forbid a church from stating plainly what it offers.
- Martha's story shows that even good service can become anxious and resentful; the remedy is to be seen truthfully and to share the work.
- Romans 15:7 gives a ground that does not depend on our state of mind: accept one another as Christ accepted you.
- A person can be warmly greeted and still feel unwelcome; welcome is how we treat people, and access is what the place makes possible, and both are needed.
- With a motive you do not like, notice it, name it to a trusted person who is not the one you serve, act so as to check it, and put the person's wishes ahead of your feelings.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Mixed motives | Duty, love, guilt, discomfort, curiosity, a wish to be thought good, a personal link and pity are normal; know which one is steering. |
| Matthew 6:1-4 | Warns against doing good to be seen; asks that attention be turned from oneself, not that motives be pure first. |
| Welcome and access | Welcome is how we treat the person; access is what the place makes possible; a person needs both. |
| A motive you do not like | Notice it; name it to a trusted person who is not the one you serve; act to check it; put the person's wishes first. |
One sentence to remember Our motives are mixed, and we are received anyway, so the work is to turn our attention from how we look to who is standing at the door.
This week's action Write down the motive you think is steering you most this week, and one small act that would check it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which two or three motives on the list are strongest in you at this moment? Which is the one you would least like to be seen?
- Matthew 6:3 warns against giving to be seen, but a church also needs to say plainly what it offers. Where is the line between the two in your community?
- In the invented examples, no one was rude, and yet each newcomer met a wall. Pick one wall. What would you have to know in order to see it from the inside?
- Why might a person feel "welcomed and still not meant to be here"? Has anyone you know told you something like this?
- What could you do this month to check a motive you do not like in yourself, without asking a disabled person to carry it for you?