Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
Most of the members in the last two lectures can be seen. A wheelchair, a white cane, a sign-language conversation: all of them tell a newcomer something. This lecture is about members whose disability cannot be seen from across the room. A member may live with depression or anxiety, with long-lasting pain or tiredness, with an illness that flares and settles, or with a condition that only appears on some days. They look "fine". They come to church, sit and sing. Often nobody knows what the week has cost them to get there.
Hidden disabilities raise three problems a visible one does not. The first is disbelief: a member who does not look unwell is not believed when they say they are. The second is silence: because the condition is not seen, the member may have decided it is safer to say nothing. The third is a spiritual explanation that replaces care: a congregation may say "pray more", "have faith", "give it to God" or "it is a spiritual attack" when the member needs a doctor, a rest or a friend. This lecture addresses all three.
It also covers the hardest case, in which a member says something that suggests they might harm themselves. This is not a counselling course, and the lecture gives only the first steps a lay person takes and the people to tell. For listening in more depth, the next step is LM205E, Listening Well: Foundations of Lay Pastoral Care.
The lecture does not diagnose, explain causes or recommend any treatment. Those belong to the person and their doctor.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Explain why "but you look fine" is a hurtful thing to say, and name two things a congregation can do instead.
- Describe how good days and bad days affect a member's ability to take part, and give two low-cost options that help.
- State why a church worker never tells a member to stop their medicine, and what to say instead.
- List the first steps to take when a member says something that suggests thoughts of suicide or self-harm.
- Describe how stigma shows up in church language, and say what Psalm 88 and 1 Kings 19 contribute to a church's speech about distress.
Yahweh, the God of my salvation, I have cried day and night before you." — Psalm 88:1
World English Bible
For my soul is full of troubles. My life draws near to Sheol." — Psalm 88:3
WEB
You have put lover and friend far from me, and my friends into darkness." — Psalm 88:18
WEB
Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God! For I shall still praise him for the saving help of his presence." — Psalm 42:5
WEB
But he himself went a day’s journey into the wilderness, and came and sat down under a juniper tree: and he requested for himself that he might die, and said, “It is enough. Now, O Yahweh, take away my life; for I am not better than my fathers.”" — 1 Kings 19:4
WEB
He lay down and slept under a juniper tree; and behold, an angel touched him, and said to him, “Arise and eat!”" — 1 Kings 19:5
WEB
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
Psalm 88 is often described as a lament that does not turn to praise at the end; in this translation its last word is darkness. Psalm 42 argues with itself. Elijah, in 1 Kings 19, asks for his life to end, and the first response is food and sleep. Read them as a Bible that has room for distress and does not hurry it.
1. What cannot be seen
Think of three members of the same congregation. One has long-lasting pain that is worse in cold weather and after standing. One has an illness that causes crushing tiredness, so that some days a morning service is all the energy she has. One lives with anxiety, which makes a crowded entrance feel like a tightening band. None of them uses a wheelchair or a cane. All of them are members, they are tired of explaining and they come, and on some Sundays they do not.
These conditions differ widely. This lecture will not describe them one by one, because that is the work of a doctor and because you will meet them under many names. What they share, for a congregation, is simple. The member's account of their day is the best evidence you have. You cannot check it; you can believe it.
2. "But you look fine"
"But you look so well!" is meant as a compliment, and it lands as a doubt. The member hears: I do not believe you. Other phrases with the same effect include "everyone gets tired", "it is all in the mind", "you were fine last week", "you could do it if you tried", and "maybe you need to get out more". Each asks the member to prove a thing that cannot be proved from outside.
The member may have already heard these phrases many times, from family, from employers and from officials. A congregation can be the one place where they are not said. A better set of words:
- "I am glad you came. How are you today?" and then listening to the answer.
- "Thank you for telling me."
- "What would help most today?"
- "If you need to leave early, please go. We will be glad to see you next week."
Do not ask for a diagnosis. A member who wants to tell you will; a member who does not is entitled to keep it. A diagnosis belongs to the person, as lecture 5-4 will say at more length.
3. Good days and bad days
Many of these conditions are unpredictable. A member may walk across the hall easily on Tuesday and need to sit down at the door on Sunday. She may lead a meeting well in March and be unable to open her post in April. This is not a sign that she is exaggerating on one of those days or hiding something on the other. It is the shape of her condition.
For a congregation, the working rule is to plan for the bad day and welcome the good one. A member who cannot say beforehand whether she will manage a task is not unreliable; she is honest about it. A task can be shared between two people, so that one covers when the other cannot. An invitation to serve can include "and if on the day you cannot, we will manage, and there is no need to explain."
Low-cost options that often help:
- A seat that can be left. An aisle seat near an exit, so the member can step out without crossing a row and without being watched.
- A quiet place. A room, a corner of a hall or a bench outside, open to anyone, with no reason required.
- Going early or arriving late. Some members cope better before the crowd arrives; some come after the opening and go before the end. Neither is rude.
- Having the order of service in advance, so the member can choose which parts to attend.
- A link, a recording or a phone call for the weeks the member cannot come. Online worship is one door for some people and a poor substitute for others; and not every member has a screen or a connection (lecture 3-3), so ask which the member would like.
- A visit, if the member would like one. Ask first. Some members want a visit when they are ill, and some want to be left alone.
These help in a cathedral parish with five Masses (a member can choose the quietest one) and in a house church (a member can sit in the kitchen doorway). They do not cost money.
4. Mental health in the congregation
Many members live with depression, anxiety, low mood that lasts, panic, trauma or other conditions that affect thinking, feeling and energy. Some are on medicine, some in therapy, some neither. Some of them lead the music, sit on the council, and teach children. For many people, such conditions come and go over years.
The course takes three positions.
First, a church does not diagnose. You cannot tell from a face or a sentence what any person is going through, and you are not the person to say what it is called. Do not tell a member what they have, and do not tell them what they do not have.
Second, a church does not explain causes. "It is because of unconfessed sin", "it is a lack of gratitude", "it is a spiritual attack" and "it is your upbringing" are all explanations. Each may be wrong, each may hurt, and none of them is the church's to give. Some Christian communities understand distress partly in spiritual terms, and some members find that prayer and the support of a community help them deeply. That is theirs to say. The line this course draws is between a member who tells you what prayer means for them and a congregation that tells the member that their distress is their own fault.
Third, a church does not offer a cure. It offers company. "Bear one another's burdens" (Galatians 6:2) does not specify the burden. It asks us to share the weight.
5. Medicine and prayer
Some members take medicine for their health, including their mental health. A few have been told, in church, to stop. That is a grave mistake.
Never say "stop your medicine and pray." A church worker does not advise a member to start, stop, reduce or change any medicine, and does not say or imply that taking it shows weak faith. The reasons are practical: stopping some medicines suddenly can be dangerous, and a church worker is not able to judge. They are also pastoral: it tells the member that the thing keeping them well is a sign of failing.
If a member says they are thinking of stopping, say something like: "That sounds like a big decision. Please talk to your doctor first, before you change anything. I will pray for you either way, and I would like to hear how it goes." Prayer and medicine are not rivals. A member can take medicine and pray, and many do.
Lecture 1-3 set out where traditions disagree about healing prayer. It applies here without change: ask before praying aloud over or touching anyone; pray what the person wants; never imply that a lasting condition shows sin or weak faith.
6. When a member speaks of ending their life
This is the most important section of the lecture. Read it twice.
Some members, at some time, think about ending their life. Some say it aloud: "I cannot go on", "everyone would be better off without me", "I wish I were dead", "I do not want to be here". A congregation will hear such remarks, sometimes in the foyer and sometimes at a meeting. Many of the people who say them are not in immediate danger, and some are. You cannot always tell which. So take every remark seriously.
If a member says something like this to you, or you are worried:
- Stay with them. Do not leave the person alone. Do not hurry to another task.
- Listen. Do not argue ("you have so much to live for"), do not hurry to cheer them up, and do not quote a verse to settle the matter. It is enough to say: "I am glad you told me. I am listening."
- Ask plainly, if you are not sure: "Are you thinking of ending your life?" Asking plainly is widely understood not to put the idea into a person's mind, and it often brings relief. Do not ask about methods or details. Never describe, ask about or discuss means of harm. If the person starts to describe them, say gently that you want to find help for them now.
- Do not promise secrecy. You may say: "I care about you, so I cannot keep this to myself. I want to bring in someone who can help." The person may be upset at first; staying close matters more than being thanked.
- Connect them at once to the responsible person in your community (the pastor, the priest or the leader named in your community's policy), and to professional help, such as a doctor or a local crisis line. Offer to stay while the call is made, or to make it with them.
- If life is in danger now, call the emergency number for your country, tell them where you are, and stay on the line.
Do not try to be the person's counsellor. A lay member is not trained for that, and the weight is too much for one person. Your role is to be a calm presence and to bring in people who can do what you cannot. LM205E teaches the listening skills that go with this.
If you are the one having these thoughts: you are not a burden, and you are not alone with it. Tell one person now, a friend, a pastor, a doctor, or a crisis line, and if you are in immediate danger, call the emergency number.
After a crisis, the member needs an ordinary welcome. Do not tell the congregation what happened. Privacy is part of dignity.
7. Stigma in church language
Stigma is the quiet judgement that makes a person ashamed of their own condition. Churches have their own versions.
- "Have more faith."
- "If you were closer to God you would not feel this."
- "A Christian should not be anxious or sad."
- "Just give it to the Lord."
- "Other people have it worse."
- Praying for "the mentally ill" as a class in the intercessions, in a way that lets everyone know whom it is about.
- Jokes about "being crazy" or "going mad".
Some of these use the right words in the wrong place. Giving your worries to God is good counsel for a person who asks for it, and a heavy burden for a person who has been handed it as a task. The harm is not in the text but in the speed: it tells the person to finish quickly something that has no quick finish.
What the Bible does offer is more honest. Psalm 88 is a prayer that ends in darkness. It was kept in the book that the community sang. Psalm 42 speaks to the soul: "Why are you in despair, my soul?" and answers it with hope, but the question is allowed first. When Elijah sits under the juniper tree and asks to die (1 Kings 19:4), the passage does not tell us what he had, and a church should not guess. It records that the first thing the angel does is touch him and give him food and rest, twice, before a word of instruction. The journey was too great for him, and the angel said so. These texts do not diagnose and they are not a method. They show that the Bible's people could say these things aloud, and that God did not turn away.
(an invented example) Elena is a parish councillor in her sixties. She lives with a long-term illness that causes severe tiredness, and she attends the early Mass because that is when she has most energy. After it she goes home to rest. For two years, a few members assumed she was distant. When the council moved its meetings to the evening, she said, in a meeting, that she would not be able to attend them and that she wanted to remain on the council. The chair, a younger man, asked what time of day she could give. They moved the meeting to an afternoon. A year later, the council made an effort to ask other members, too, which time of day suited them.
(an invented example) David leads the music team of a free church, plays three instruments and is on medicine for his mental health, which he takes each day. Two years ago, a visiting preacher said from the pulpit that "real faith needs no pills." David stayed in his seat, shaken. The pastor visited him on Monday and said, "That was wrong, and I am sorry. Please keep taking what your doctor has prescribed." David is still on the team. He has not told the congregation about his medicine and does not intend to, and the pastor has kept to that.
8. Where this advice differs
Some cultures treat mental distress as something to be kept within the family, and members from these backgrounds may say little. Others talk openly. Some communities have rich traditions of prayer for distress, and for many members these are a source of strength. Neither the silence nor the openness is the model. Some churches have a pastor trained in counselling and some have none; some countries have crisis lines and local services and some do not. The principle is the same everywhere: take every remark seriously, stay, bring in the responsible person and professional help, and use the emergency number if life is in danger. Follow local law and your community's written policy where a duty to report applies.
Diagram 1. If a member speaks of ending their life
Diagram 2. Hidden does not mean absent
| What a member may hear | What it says | A better thing to say |
|---|---|---|
| "But you look so well." | I do not believe you. | "I am glad you came. What would help today?" |
| "Have more faith." | Your distress is a failing. | "That sounds heavy. I am here." |
| "Stop the pills and pray." | Care is a lack of trust. | "Please talk to your doctor before you change anything. I will pray either way." |
| "Everyone gets tired." | Your account does not count. | "Thank you for telling me." |
| "You were fine last week." | The condition should be steady. | "Some days are harder. What do you need today?" |
In short
- "But you look fine" voices doubt; believe the member's account of their day and ask what would help.
- Good days and bad days are the shape of many conditions; plan for the bad day with a seat that can be left, a quiet place and shared tasks.
- A church does not diagnose, explain causes or offer a cure for mental distress; it offers company.
- Never say "stop your medicine and pray"; send medicine questions to the person's doctor and pray either way.
- If a member speaks of ending their life: stay, listen, never discuss methods, promise no secrecy, bring in the responsible person and professional help, and call the emergency number if life is in danger.
- Stigma in church speech tells people to finish quickly what has no quick finish; Psalm 88 and 1 Kings 19 make room for distress.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| "But you look fine" | Hears as "I do not believe you." Say instead: "I am glad you came. What would help today?" |
| Medicine and prayer | Never "stop your medicine and pray." Send the question to the person's doctor, and pray either way. |
| If a member speaks of ending their life | Stay, listen, ask plainly, no methods, no secrecy; bring in the responsible person and professional help; emergency number if life is in danger. |
| What Psalm 88 and 1 Kings 19 show | The Bible has room for distress, and the first answer to Elijah was food and rest, not a lesson. |
One sentence to remember What you cannot see is still real, so believe the member, take every word about ending a life seriously, and bring in people who can do what you cannot.
This week's action Find out who the responsible person is in your community for a member in crisis, and write down the local crisis line and emergency number where you can find them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- "You look so well" is meant kindly. How might you respond if you hear it said to a friend, without embarrassing the speaker?
- What in your community's practice already makes a bad day easier (an aisle seat, a quiet place, a recording)? What is one more low-cost step?
- Why is the statement "stop your medicine and pray" a failure of care and not only of knowledge? What might a faithful alternative sound like?
- If a member told you they did not want to be here, which of the six steps do you find hardest to do? Who in your community is the responsible person to tell?
- Psalm 88 ends without hope. Why might a community need such a psalm in its book?