Lecture 6-4: Reading the Year Honestly
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
Most churches keep a calendar and a budget, and many keep a count of how many came on a certain Sunday. Few keep an honest account of who was welcome. A church can build a ramp and not notice that the person it was built for has stopped coming. It can write a good policy and never ask anyone whether the policy has changed their Sunday.
This lecture is about the habit of reading a year honestly. It is not about audits that produce a score, a number to publish or a prize. It is a conversation, once a year, with a few simple questions: Who is here who was not here before? Who left, and do we know why? Whom did we ask? What did disabled members say, and what did we do? What did we keep, and what did we drop?
Along the way the lecture takes up three cautions. A count can mislead and can also take a person's privacy. A person who prefers not to be asked is not a failure. And a small thing kept is better than a large thing dropped. It ends with thanks to those who did the quiet work, and with a question about how to say thank you without turning someone into an advertisement.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Name the questions a church can ask each year about welcome, and say why stories serve better than a count.
- Explain how to gather the year's story with disabled members' advice about the form, and what to do about privacy.
- Explain why a person who does not want to be asked is not a failure of the church.
- Read Luke 15:4-7 as a parable of seeking without treating any person as "lost," and say how it relates to people who left.
- Give a thank-you that is specific, asked-for and not used as publicity, and explain why a small thing kept is better than a large thing dropped.
I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase. So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:6-7
World English Bible
Which of you men, if you had one hundred sheep, and lost one of them, wouldn’t leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness, and go after the one that was lost, until he found it? When he has found it, he carries it on his shoulders, rejoicing. When he comes home, he calls together his friends and his neighbors, saying to them, ‘Rejoice with me, for I have found my sheep which was lost!’ I tell you that even so there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents, than over ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance." — Luke 15:4-7
WEB
But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does, so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly." — Matthew 6:3-4
WEB
Paul says that the work is real and the growth is not ours. Jesus tells of a search and a joy. And he warns against doing good to be seen. The year-end reading has to hold all three.
1. Why read the year at all
A church that does not look back repeats its habits without noticing. Welcome is a practice, and practices drift. A greeter leaves, a notice is copied from last year, a promise made at a meeting is forgotten by the summer. Inclusion needs a place in the calendar, or it will be crowded out by other business.
Reading the year does three things. It lets the church see what has actually changed, and not only what it intended. It gives disabled members a regular occasion to say what they think and be answered. And it lets the church give thanks. The annual reading is not the only way these happen, and good leaders listen all year. But a fixed date means that it will happen.
2. The questions
Here is a set of questions a church can ask once a year. They are not a form that must be filled in. Choose, change and add to them.
Who is here that was not? A new face, a member who returned, someone who has begun to read or serve. Ask what made it possible. Do not count how many have disabilities; ask for stories.
Who left, and do we know why? Some people leave for reasons unconnected to the church: a move, a new job, a different tradition, a change in health. Some leave because something was hard, or because something hurt. Some leave quietly and nobody asks. If the person is willing to say, the church wants to hear. If they are not, the church leaves it there.
Whom did we ask? Not "whom did we help," but whom did we ask: for advice, for a view, to read, to lead, to serve. A year in which the same four people were asked for everything is a year to notice.
What did disabled members say, and what did we do? This is the question that matters most, and the one most often skipped. What was said at the advisory group, at the door, in a note? Which suggestions did the leaders accept, which not, and did they say why?
What did we try that did not work? Include failures. A church that can say "we tried this and it did not help" is a church that is paying attention (lecture 6-3).
What did we keep, and what did we let slip? Some things lasted: the early order of service, the clear path through the chairs. Some were dropped without anyone deciding to drop them.
Who did the quiet work? Name the people, and ask them how they would like to be thanked.
3. Stories, not a count
Why not simply count? Because a count can be accurate and still misleading, and a count of disabled members has real problems.
First, it invites a church to treat people as tallies. Second, it asks the church to decide who "counts" as disabled, and that is not the church's decision. Many members will not tell, and they do not have to. Third, a number can make a church feel good or bad for the wrong reasons. A church with more disabled members on the roll is not necessarily more welcoming than one with fewer; the first may simply have a care home nearby, and the second a hidden door. A count of ramps and large-print sheets tells you what was bought, not whether anyone is glad of it.
A story is harder to summarise and more truthful. "Teodor now chairs the building committee and the meetings are held in a room he can reach." "Two families who had stopped coming sat down at the harvest supper." "The notice sheet now says 'names only with permission,' and an intercessor asked whether she could check hers." Stories can be told without names, and they can be checked with the people in them. Asking "May I tell this?" is part of the habit.
4. Gathering the year's story
Make the gathering easy to join and gentle to join. Some suggestions, all of which cost little:
- Ask the advisory group (lecture 6-2) how they would like the review done: a meeting, a written form, a conversation with one person, a signed or spoken session, an anonymous box. Offer more than one.
- Hold any meeting in a place everyone can reach, with questions sent in advance and in the forms each person uses.
- Say at the start that nobody has to answer, that nothing is marked, and that nobody will be named without permission (the same promises as the labs in this course).
- Write down what is said in a few lines, without names, and send it back to those who spoke. Let them correct it.
- Share a short summary with the whole congregation, true and plain, including what did not go well.
If the community is a house church of a dozen people, this may be one evening with a meal. If it is a large parish, it may be a group of ten people meeting twice, and a page in the parish paper. The method is the same: ask, listen, write down, report back.
5. A person who does not want to be asked
A church that has learned to ask may be surprised when someone says, "I would prefer not to be asked." This is not a failure. A person may be tired of being the one who is asked. They may not want to be seen as the voice of a category. They may want to come to worship and be left alone. They may have found, in the church, one place where they are not an item for discussion.
The respectful response is to honour the request and to leave the door open: "We will not ask you. If you ever want to tell us anything, here is whom to tell." That too is a form of inclusion. Asking has no value if it turns into a duty a person has to carry. And the same is true for the family: not every family wants to be consulted every year.
6. The sheep, and the person who left
Luke 15:4-7 is among the most loved parables, and it is easy to bend. A church reading the year may remember the person who left, and think of the shepherd who goes after the one that was lost. That is a good instinct, but it needs care.
The parable is about God's seeking and God's joy. The shepherd goes after the sheep, finds it, carries it and calls the neighbours to rejoice. Notice two things. First, the sheep did not choose to be lost; it simply wandered. A person who left a church may have chosen to leave, for good reason. The shepherd's search must not become pressure on someone who has decided. Second, Jesus tells the story about those who criticised him for welcoming sinners. It is a story told against the grumbling of people who think they are not lost. It is not a description of disabled people. No disabled member should be thought of as "lost" because they are not in a pew.
So we use the parable with limits. It tells a church to care about the one who is missing, and to be glad if the person comes back. It does not tell the church to chase, or to describe any person as a problem that needs finding. The practical form is the short, honest message from lecture 6-3: "We have thought of you. The door is open. We would like to hear what we could do better, and you do not have to answer." Then the church waits.
7. Small things kept
A church that is energetic in March may be exhausted by September. The year-end reading should therefore be kind to the small things that lasted.
A modest practice that is kept every week is worth more than a large project that is begun and dropped. A person at the door who asks "How would you like us to help you find a seat?" every Sunday for a year has done more than a conference. A printed order sent early every week says that the church has kept its word, every week. When a leader is tempted to add a new project, the question to ask is: What are we already doing that is working, and will adding this endanger it? Saying "not yet" honestly is better than promising what cannot be kept (lecture 4-4).
Write down, as part of the year's reading, what you will keep. Name who is responsible, and leave a short handover page so that the practice survives the person. Keep a note of the things you decided to let go of, and why.
Paul writes, "I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase" (1 Corinthians 3:6-7). He does not say that planting does not matter. He says that it is real, and that the growth belongs to someone else. A church reading its year can say: here is what we did, and here is what we leave to God. This is a relief and not an excuse. It means that we do not have to read the year as a verdict on ourselves. We read it to see what to do next.
8. Thanks to those who did the quiet work
Every church has people who do the small things: who set out the chairs, who check the print size, who send the early order, who remember to ask. Their work is easily overlooked because it is done well.
Thanks should be specific ("thank you for sending the order every Friday for a year"), warm and given in the way the person likes. Some people like to be thanked in front of everyone, and some find it unbearable. Ask. A card, a word after the service, a meal, a note from the leader can all be right.
Jesus warns against doing good to be seen: "don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does" (Matthew 6:3). This does not mean that thanks must be secret. It means that the motive must not be showing off. Here the warning has a particular edge. A church should not turn its inclusion work into publicity: no photograph of a disabled member in the newsletter "to show how we have changed," no "inclusion award" read to the congregation, no story told for the sake of looking good. Nobody should be asked to be the face of the church's goodness. If the church tells a story in public, it asks the person first, and accepts a no.
(An invented example.) A house church of fourteen meets for a supper at the end of its year. The host, Dalia, who is blind and leads the Bible reading rota, asks three questions of the group: "What is one thing that made it easier to come this year? What is one thing that made it harder? What should we keep?" People answer in turn, and one of them writes the answers on a card without names. Someone says the reading sent the evening before made a difference. Someone else says the host's home has steps, and asks that it be moved to a home with level access in the spring. A guest who rarely speaks passes. At the end Dalia thanks Idris, who had sent the reading each week, by name, and Idris says he would have preferred a quiet word. They laugh, and Dalia says she will ask next time.
(An invented example.) In a large parish, the council's small group meets twice in the autumn. Obinna, a who is hard of hearing, chairs the second meeting, and the room has been set so that he can see every face. They go through the seven questions. They note that two members who used to come to the early service have not been seen for months, and that one wrote in the spring to say the stairs had become too much. A member of the group offers to write her a short note, with her permission asked first through a friend. The council decides to keep a weekly bulletin line describing what each service offers, and to let go of a project to rebuild the side entrance for now, since the funds are not there. It writes this down with a date to look again.
Diagram 1. The year's reading: seven questions
Diagram 2. A short, plain year-end report to the congregation
| Heading | What it might say (invented) |
|---|---|
| What we learned | "Sending the order of service the evening before was the change members mentioned most." |
| What did not work | "The helper rota for the side door lapsed in the summer. We have asked members what would make it last." |
| What we are keeping | "The early order of service; the clear path through the chairs; names on the prayer list only with permission." |
| What we are letting go of, for now | "Rebuilding the side entrance. We will look again in a year." |
| Thanks | "To everyone who did small things without being asked, including those who prefer not to be named." |
In short
- A fixed yearly reading keeps welcome in the calendar, shows what changed, gives disabled members a regular occasion to speak and be answered, and lets the church give thanks.
- Stories serve better than a count; a count of disabled members treats people as tallies and asks the church to decide who counts.
- A person who prefers not to be asked is not a failure; honour the request and leave the door open.
- Luke 15:4-7 shows God's seeking and joy; it does not tell a church to chase people, nor to call any disabled member "lost."
- A small thing kept is better than a large thing dropped; thank people specifically and as they wish, and never use inclusion as publicity.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Stories, not a count | A count treats people as tallies and misleads; stories can be checked with the people in them, with permission. |
| A person who prefers not to be asked | Not a failure. Honour it and leave the door open. |
| Luke 15:4-7 and people who left | God seeks and rejoices; the church may send a short, honest, no-pressure message, and then accepts the answer. |
| Thanks | Specific, given as the person likes, never turned into publicity. |
One sentence to remember A church reads its year honestly by asking a few questions, listening for stories, keeping the small things that worked, and thanking people as they would wish.
This week's action Choose one of the seven questions and ask it of one person this month, who has agreed to be asked, in the form they prefer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the seven questions would be hardest for your community to answer honestly? Why?
- Why might a count of disabled members mislead, and what would you use instead?
- The lecture says that a person who does not want to be asked is not a failure. Have you ever preferred not to be asked? What did you need?
- How would you use Luke 15:4-7 in thinking about someone who left, without treating them as a problem to be found?
- How would you thank someone for quiet work, and how would you find out how they would like to be thanked?