Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
- Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
- Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
- Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
- Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
- Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
- Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
- Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
- Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
- Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
- Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
- Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
- Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
- Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
- Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
- Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
Earthquakes happen along lines in the ground that were already weak. A church or a small group has such lines too. They are places where people already differ, and where a small push can cause a break. Most members have seen them without having a name for them.
This lecture gives six fault lines, each with a short invented example. It is a practical map, not a study. We do not claim how often any of them cause trouble. We only say that these are places where trouble often begins, and that a person who knows them can notice sooner. The lecture ends with a short checklist for the first ten minutes after you notice that a conflict has started: what to do, and what to leave alone.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Name six common places where conflict in a church or small group begins.
- Recognise each in a plain example.
- Use a first-ten-minutes checklist when you notice a conflict beginning.
- Explain why you should not carry stories, and name the one exception to confidentiality.
- Notice a danger sign that means a matter should go to someone responsible.
A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1
World English Bible
For lack of wood a fire goes out. Without gossip, a quarrel dies down." — Proverbs 26:20
WEB
Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29
WEB
A wrathful man stirs up contention, but one who is slow to anger appeases strife." — Proverbs 15:18
WEB
1. Six fault lines
1. Time, place and money. These are the most ordinary causes of conflict, and the easiest to underestimate. Who may use the hall? When does the group meet? Who pays for food, for a trip, for a repair? Practical decisions touch people’s routines, their budgets, and their sense of being considered.
(an invented example) A home group has met on Thursday evenings for years. A new couple, who work shifts, ask whether it could move to Saturday. Two older members say they have never been free on Saturdays. The question is not hard in itself. But when the new couple hear "we have always met on Thursday", they hear that they do not belong. The practical question has opened an identity question (lecture 1-2).
Money is especially delicate. People may feel that money questions are "unspiritual", and so say nothing until they are angry. Clear rules agreed in advance (who collects, who spends, who reports) prevent many quarrels.
2. Styles of worship and prayer. Songs, silence, loud prayer, set prayers, standing, kneeling, raised hands, a long sermon or a short one. For many people these are not matters of taste. They are how they have met God since childhood. A change can feel like a loss. A habit that one person finds natural can feel strange or even wrong to another. This was the fault line in the prayer-group case in lecture 1-2.
(an invented example) A small fellowship begins to include a time of spoken prayer in which anyone may speak aloud. One member comes from a tradition where prayers are written and said together. She finds it frightening to pray out loud and does not know how to say so. She starts to arrive after the prayer time, and others take that as dislike of the group.
3. Leadership and roles. Who decides? Who is asked? Who is thanked, and who is overlooked? Volunteers can feel owned by a task, and when someone else takes it over, it can feel like a judgement on them. A leader who does everything may be resented; a leader who delegates may be thought lazy. A new role created without discussion may seem to push someone aside. Often the conflict does not appear as an argument about the role. It appears as small remarks, missed invitations or a quiet withdrawal.
(an invented example) Emeka has made the coffee for the after-service gathering for eleven years. A new volunteer, Mei, is asked to organise "refreshments" and brings tea and cakes. Nobody told Emeka. He says, "I only wanted to know if I was no longer needed." He is not angry about coffee. He is asking whether he still has a place.
4. Age groups. Older members, parents of young children, teenagers, young adults without families, and retired people live in different rhythms. They have different needs and different ways of talking. The same event may be too long for children, too loud for older members, too early for teenagers, too late for parents. Each group can feel the church is run for someone else.
(an invented example) A church changes its main service time from ten o’clock to nine to make room for a second service. Older members who depend on a lift from a neighbour cannot get there. Young families with small children welcome the earlier hour. Each side says, "Nobody thought of us."
5. Old wounds. Many conflicts are not new. A member who was hurt years ago by a remark, a decision or a leader may react strongly to something that looks small now. A church that went through a split or a scandal may carry it for a long time, and every new disagreement may feel like a return of the old one. If a conflict seems far bigger than its cause, an older wound may be under it. This does not mean the person is overreacting. It means the pain is real and has a history.
(an invented example) A woman named Beatriz was once publicly corrected by a church leader in front of the congregation, years ago, at another church. In her new group, a friendly leader says, "Let me make one small suggestion about how you read." She goes pale and leaves. The leader did nothing wrong, and Beatriz is not being unreasonable. The sentence landed on an old hurt.
6. Online messages. Message groups, social media and email can bring conflicts to a head quickly. Tone is lost: a short sentence may be read as cold. Messages can be copied and sent on. A late-night reply may be sent in anger. A person can feel attacked in front of all the others, and the others may take sides at once. We give this a whole lecture in week 5. For now, note that a conflict that began in a message group is not a smaller conflict because it happened on a screen.
(an invented example) In a group chat, a member writes, "Whoever left the hall in that state last Sunday should be ashamed." Four people send a thumbs-up. Two people who both did the cleaning feel accused and say nothing. By the weekend three members have left the chat.
2. Using the map
This map is not a list of "things that cause trouble", and it is not a promise that a conflict has only one cause. A single event often touches more than one line. The use of the map is to help you ask, calmly, "Where might this be coming from?" instead of "Who is to blame?"
It also helps to remember that these lines are not sins. A church that has several age groups, several styles of prayer, and many volunteers will have fault lines for the same reason that a field with a river has a bank. They are part of living together. They need care and attention. They do not need alarm.
3. The first ten minutes: a short checklist
Suppose that you notice a conflict beginning, in a meeting, a corridor or a message. You are not the leader, and you are not a mediator. You are an ordinary member. What do you do in the first ten minutes? Here are seven steps. They are simple on purpose.
1. Stop and breathe. Do not respond at once. "A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger" (Proverbs 15:1). The first reply is often the one that makes it worse. Another proverb says that "one who is slow to anger appeases strife" (Proverbs 15:18).
2. Do not take a side. You may feel that one person is right. Keep it to yourself for now. You do not yet have the whole story, and what you say may be repeated.
3. Do not carry the story. Do not tell A what B said about A. Do not take a message from one to the other as if you were a post office. "Without gossip, a quarrel dies down" (Proverbs 26:20). A quarrel carried by a third person usually grows on the way.
4. Listen briefly and kindly. If someone comes to you upset, let them speak for a few minutes. Say, "That sounds hard." You do not have to agree or disagree. You can say, "I want to hear more, and I also want to hear from the other person."
5. Note the danger signs. Look again at the signs in lecture 1-2: fear, threats, a person with power silencing another, a child at risk. If you see them, stop trying to settle it between the people. Go to step 7.
6. Take care what you say next. Words that "give grace to those who hear" (Ephesians 4:29) are better than words that win. If you must say something in the group, say something about the matter and not about a person: "I think we need to take a break."
7. Decide who needs to know. Most quarrels do not need to go further at this point. But if you see signs of harm, or if you do not know what to do, speak to a pastor or a responsible leader, and speak as briefly and as factually as you can: what you saw, not what you guess. If that person is the one involved, go to someone else who is responsible, or to an outside agency.
Here is the whole checklist in a few words: pause, do not take sides, do not carry stories, listen, look for danger, speak carefully, tell the right person.
4. A word about confidentiality
Someone who comes to you with a hurt may say, "Please do not tell anyone." This is a reasonable request, and in most cases you should keep it. People need to be able to talk without fear. What you hear from one person is not yours to pass on, even to well-meaning friends. This is not only good manners: gossip can do harm, and in a small community it travels fast.
But you cannot promise that you will tell no one in all cases. If you hear that someone is thinking of harming themselves, that someone is going to harm another person, or that a child is being harmed, you may have to tell a responsible person, even if you were asked not to. It is kinder to say so early than to break a promise later. You might say: "I will keep what you tell me private. The one exception is if someone is in danger. Then I would have to tell a person who can help, and I would tell you first if I could."
If self-harm or suicide is mentioned, do not ask for details of method, and do not leave the person alone if the danger is immediate. Contact a pastor or leader you trust, and use your local emergency number. The number differs from country to country, and in some places there is no single number for every service. Find out what applies where you live, before you need it. If a pastor is not available, a local crisis line or emergency service can help.
5. What the first ten minutes are not
They are not a time to find out what really happened, to decide who is at fault, to call a meeting, or to write to the group. They are only a time to avoid making things worse and to find out whether the matter needs more help than you can give. The rest of this course is about what comes after.
Diagram 1. Six fault lines
Diagram 2. The first ten minutes
| Step | Do | Do not |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pause and breathe | Reply at once |
| 2 | Keep your view to yourself for now | Take a side |
| 3 | Keep what you hear | Carry a story from one to the other |
| 4 | Listen a few minutes, kindly | Give a verdict or advice |
| 5 | Look for danger signs | Try to settle a matter involving harm |
| 6 | Speak of the matter | Speak of a person’s character |
| 7 | Tell the right person if needed, briefly and factually | Add what you guess |
In short
- Six common fault lines: time, place and money; worship and prayer; leadership and roles; age groups; old wounds; online messages.
- A small practical question can touch a deeper one, such as belonging or respect.
- The map helps you ask where a conflict may be coming from, not who is to blame.
- In the first ten minutes: pause, take no side, do not carry stories, listen, look for danger signs, speak carefully, tell the right person if needed.
- Keep confidences, but never promise silence where someone is in danger.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Six fault lines | Time, place and money; worship and prayer; leadership and roles; age groups; old wounds; online messages. |
| First ten minutes | Pause, no sides, do not carry stories, listen, look for danger, speak carefully, tell the right person. |
| Why not carry the story? | It grows on the way, and it makes you part of the quarrel. |
| Exception to confidentiality | Someone in danger: self-harm, harm to others, or harm to a child. |
One sentence to remember The first ten minutes are for not making it worse and for finding out whether more help is needed.
This week's action Find out your local emergency number and, in your church or group, who the responsible person is if someone is in danger.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six fault lines have you seen in a church or group you know? Describe it without names.
- In the invented example of Emeka and the coffee, what was Emeka really asking? How could Mei or a leader have noticed?
- Why does the first-ten-minutes list say "do not carry the story"? What might happen if you did, even with good intentions?
- Why is it better to say early, "I will keep this private, except if someone is in danger"?
- What is the local emergency number where you live? Do you know whom you would call in your church if a child or adult was in danger? You may pass if you would rather not say.