FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM406E Reconciling Church and Small-Group Conflict: A Lay Guide to Peacemaking

Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour

Contents 31
LM406E Reconciling Church and Small-Group Conflict: A Lay Guide to Peacemaking
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Standing Beside People in Conflict
  1. Introduction: Standing Beside People in Conflict
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Understanding Conflict
  1. Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
  2. Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
  4. Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Peacemaking Passages Without Misusing Them
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
  2. Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
  3. Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Listening and Conversation
  1. Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
  2. Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
  3. Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
  4. Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Apology, Forgiveness and Restoration
  1. Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
  2. Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
  3. Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
  4. Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Gossip, Taking Sides and the Small Group
  1. Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
  2. Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
  3. Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
  4. Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Beyond Mediation — Safety and Referral
  1. Lecture 6-1: When Reconciliation Is Not the Answer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Who to Pass It To, and How
  3. Lecture 6-3: Caring for the One Beside
  4. Lecture 6-4: What a Church Can Put in Place
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Peacemaking Plan and Referral Map

Jump to the key points ↓

27 min

Most conflicts in a church or small group do not begin with a quarrel. They begin with a sentence said to the wrong person. Someone is unhappy about the new meeting time, and tells a friend in the car park. The friend tells a third person, and by the end of the week five people hold a story about a person who has never heard it. The first disagreement was small. The story has made it large.

This lecture is about words that travel. It looks at what the Bible says about gossip, at how to tell gossip from honest help-seeking, at the forms gossip takes in a church (including the "prayer request"), and at what a lay peacemaker can say when someone brings a story. It also looks at the person the story is about, who is often the one nobody is thinking of.

Two lines must be said at the start, because they hold for this whole chapter. First, harm is not gossip, and it is not a conflict to be talked through. If you hear that someone is being abused, threatened or put in danger, you do not answer with "have you talked to them directly?" Week 6 deals with this, and lecture 5-1 returns to it below. Second, keeping a confidence is not the same as keeping a secret about harm. We will mark the difference clearly.

Everything here is about helping people stand beside each other. It is not about winning, and it is not a way of making sure nobody ever complains. People need to be able to speak about real troubles.

What these 27 minutes give you

  • Explain, from Proverbs and James, why words can make a small conflict large.
  • Tell the difference between gossip and seeking help, using three questions.
  • Recognise three disguised forms of gossip, including the "prayer request".
  • Say two or three sentences you could use when someone brings you a story about a person who is not there.
  • Explain how to care for a person a rumour is about, and when a story must not be "kept confidential".

A perverse man stirs up strife. A whisperer separates close friends." — Proverbs 16:28

World English Bible

The words of a gossip are like dainty morsels: they go down into a person’s innermost parts." — Proverbs 18:8

WEB

One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13

WEB

For lack of wood a fire goes out. Without gossip, a quarrel dies down." — Proverbs 26:20

WEB

So the tongue is also a little member, and boasts great things. See how a small fire can spread to a large forest!" — James 3:5

WEB

Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29

WEB

The proverbs describe what gossip does and why it spreads. James gives a picture of how a few words become a large damage. Paul gives the test for speech in a community: does it build up, and does it give grace to those who hear?

1. What the Bible notices about words

The book of Proverbs is a collection of short wise sayings, and it returns again and again to speech. On gossip it says three things that anyone can check against their own experience.

The first is that gossip damages friendship. "A perverse man stirs up strife. A whisperer separates close friends." A whisperer is a person who passes on talk quietly. The saying does not say the whisperer lies. It says the effect is separation.

The second is that gossip is pleasant to hear. "The words of a gossip are like dainty morsels: they go down into a person’s innermost parts." A "morsel" is a small tasty piece of food. The saying is honest about the listener: gossip would not travel if nobody liked to receive it. In most rumours, the listeners are as important as the tellers.

The third is that gossip feeds a fight. "For lack of wood a fire goes out. Without gossip, a quarrel dies down." If no one passes the story, the fire has no more wood. This is a hopeful saying for a peacemaker: you cannot always stop a quarrel, but you can refuse to add to it.

Proverbs 11:13 adds something that matters later in this lecture: "One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." The proverb joins gossip to the breaking of confidence. It also describes the opposite person as "trustworthy" in spirit, which is a thing a lay peacemaker can aim to be.

James writes about the tongue in the same spirit. "So the tongue is also a little member, and boasts great things. See how a small fire can spread to a large forest!" The picture is of scale. A spark is tiny, and a forest is large. James does not say that every word is a fire. He says that small words can have large results, and that we are slow to see it. Elsewhere in the same chapter he notes that the same mouth can bless and curse (James 3:9-10), which is a plain description of how people actually behave in a church. We say a prayer at the start of a meeting, and we say something sharp about a member after it.

Paul gives the positive test. "Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." Notice that the test is not only "is it true?" It is "does it build up, as the need may be, and does it give grace to those who hear?" A true statement can be unhelpful, and a hard statement can be helpful. The question is what the words do.

2. What gossip is, and a working test

People define gossip in different ways, and the word differs between languages and cultures. For this course we use a working description:

Gossip is telling a story about a person who is not present, to people who cannot help with the matter, in a way that lowers the person or sets others against them.

Each part matters. The person is absent, so they cannot answer. The listeners cannot help, so the telling does not move the problem toward a solution. And the effect is to lower the person or to build a side. Notice that the story does not have to be false. A true story told in this way is still gossip, because what is wrong is the use of the story.

When you are about to say something, or have just heard something, three questions help:

  1. Can this listener help with the matter? A friend who can only worry is not a helper. A leader, the person concerned, or a person with the right skills may be.
  2. How much does the listener need to know? Help needs enough, not everything. A person can say "I am hurt by something in the group and I want advice on how to speak with someone" without telling the whole story or naming names.
  3. Would I say this with the person present? If the answer is no, the telling may be a way of making a verdict without the person ever answering.

A fourth question is sometimes needed: Have I spoken to the person, and if not, why not? There are good reasons not to. The person may be dangerous, or have power over you, or the matter may be one that should go to someone else first. We come back to this at the end. But the question should be asked honestly, and not skipped because speaking to the person would be uncomfortable.

3. Gossip, venting and seeking help

It would be a mistake to think that any talk about a conflict is gossip. People who are hurt need to speak. A person who keeps everything inside may grow bitter or ill. Three kinds of talk are worth separating.

Kind of talk What it does Who is told How much is told
Seeking help Moves toward a solution, safety or understanding Someone who can help: the person concerned, a leader, a counsellor, a trusted guide Only what is needed
Venting Releases feeling; no solution is asked for One trusted person, once, asked beforehand ("May I tell you something that has upset me? I do not want you to do anything with it.") Limited; avoids names where possible
Gossip Builds a side, lowers a person, entertains Anyone willing to listen More than is needed; grows with each telling

The line between venting and gossip is thin. A useful guide is to ask the listener first, to say plainly that you want only to be heard, and to stop if you find yourself telling it for the third or fourth time to a new person. If the feeling does not ease, the next step is not another listener. It is help: speaking to the person, or to someone who can guide.

(an invented example) Rosa leads a Tuesday group. She is upset because Daniel, a member, has twice told the group that her way of choosing Bible passages "is not serious". She tells her sister, who does not attend, "I just needed to say it to someone." That is venting, and it is probably healthy. Then Rosa mentions it to two members of the group "so you understand why I am quiet". Now it is the start of a side. The same hurt, told to different people with a different purpose, has changed its nature.

4. Gossip in disguise

Gossip rarely says its name. In churches it often arrives in a respectable form. Three forms are common.

"I only say this because I care." The speaker is truly concerned, but the person described cannot answer. Care is shown by going to the person, or to someone who can help, not by describing them to others. A test: would the person recognise this as care if they heard it?

The prayer request. "Please pray for Mark and Helen. They are having trouble at home, and I hear he has lost his job again." Prayer is good. But the details here are not the speaker's to give. Mark and Helen may not want them known, and the group now holds private facts. A better form is to ask first ("May I share your situation as a prayer request?") or to pray without details ("Please pray for a family I know who are under strain"). If it is not clear that the details are shared with permission, leave them out. A prayer request does not make private information public, whatever its purpose.

"Between us." A story is offered as a confidence, which makes the listener feel special and makes it harder to say no. But a secret passed from person to person is no longer a secret, and a listener who is drawn in begins to hold a side.

The listener has a part here, as Proverbs 18:8 says. Gossip needs someone who will take the "morsel". A group where nobody feeds the story is a group where the story dies. That does not require you to be harsh. It requires only a habit of not adding to it.

5. Message groups

Much gossip now travels in message groups, social media and email. The same rules hold, and some of the dangers are greater: a message can be saved, copied and sent to people the writer never imagined. Lecture 5-4 gives this its own treatment. For now, one point: do not argue about a person in a group that includes people who can do nothing about it. If you need to raise a concern, raise it with a person who can help.

6. What to say when someone tells you

It is awkward to stop someone who has begun to tell a story. Many people react by listening because they do not know how to stop. Here are some sentences that are honest and not harsh. Use them in your own words.

  • "It may help to talk with them directly. Would you like help to do that?" This is gentle, and it offers something. In some cultures, speaking directly to a person is not the usual way; lecture 3-3 looked at this. The offer can then be changed: "Would it help if someone you both respect spoke with them?"
  • "I would rather not hear this when they are not here. Can we think about who could help?" This is plain without being a rebuke.
  • "I am hearing only one side. I think I am not the right person to judge it." This is true, and it keeps you out of a verdict.
  • "I can listen, but I will not repeat it. And I may suggest you speak with someone." Say this before the story begins, if you can.

(an invented example) Sung-min is asked by Tola after a meeting, "Did you hear what Pedro said about the treasurer?" Sung-min answers, "No, and I think I would rather hear it from Pedro. Is there something you want me to help with?" Tola is a little embarrassed, and says it is nothing. A day later, Tola says she is actually worried about how the money is recorded, and asks whom she should speak to. The first answer did not shut the door. It turned the conversation toward who could help.

Not every listener is able to say this. A teenager or a newcomer may not be able to stop an older member who tells a story. If you are in that position, you do not have to correct anyone. You can say "I need to go", and leave.

7. When it is not gossip and not "talk to them directly"

A caution is needed, because "talk to them directly" can be misused. Suppose someone tells you that a teacher in the youth group has been sending a fifteen-year-old private messages late at night, and that the girl is frightened. This is not gossip. It is not a matter for "have you talked to him?" The person who told you may be doing exactly the right thing: telling someone who might help.

The same is true of stories about violence at home, sexual misconduct, threats, or the misuse of power by a leader. In these cases the answer is not to send the person to confront the one who caused harm, and not to promise to tell no one. Do not question the person closely or try to find out the truth yourself. Listen, say that you will help them find someone, do not promise secrecy you cannot keep, and make sure a responsible person (and where needed, the local agencies) knows. Week 6 explains how. Local law on reporting differs from place to place; check your local law and local agencies. If someone is in danger now, use your local emergency number.

This is the exception to confidentiality. Confidences are to be kept, and they are not to be used as a wall around harm. As earlier lectures said, a safety danger, such as harm to a child or a threat of self-harm or of harm to others, is an exception to confidentiality. Say that to a person early, so they are not surprised: "I will keep what you tell me private, except that if someone is in danger I will have to tell a person who can help."

8. Caring for the person a rumour is about

When a rumour spreads, most attention goes to the tellers. The person it is about may be the last to know. A lay peacemaker has several things to consider.

Do not spread it further, even to correct it. Saying "I heard that Mark lost his job, but it isn't true" repeats the rumour.

Think carefully before telling the person. Some people would want to know. Others would be crushed. Ask yourself: Will it help them? Is it my place? Could I do it privately, kindly and without naming who spoke? If you decide to tell, do not carry the story as a weapon. A good way is to ask: "Would you want me to tell you if I hear something that people are saying about you?" In some cases the right step is to speak to a leader instead, if the rumour is damaging to the community.

Do not ask the person to prove themselves in public. A person does not owe a meeting an answer to every story. If a leader decides that something must be addressed, it is done in private, kindly and with a fair hearing.

Stay close. A person who is the subject of rumour may find that people go quiet when they enter a room. A greeting, an invitation to sit, an ordinary conversation: these are small things, and they make a difference. You do not have to judge the rumour to be kind to the person.

Be careful about what the rumour is. Sometimes the story is about a person who has told someone that they were harmed. A rumour that the person is "making trouble" or "trying to ruin the leader" is a way of silencing a complaint. Do not join it. Do not decide whether the complaint is true. Make sure the complaint reaches someone with the responsibility and the skill to deal with it (Week 6).

9. Where this leaves a lay peacemaker

A lay peacemaker is not a censor of speech. People will talk, and some talk is needed. What a peacemaker can do is small and real: refuse to feed a story, offer a better route, say "I would rather not hear this without them", watch what is said about a person who cannot answer, and make sure danger reaches those who can act. This is standing beside people, which is the work of this course. It is not fixing, and it is not deciding who is right.


Diagram 1. Before you say it, or when you hear it

Gossip or Seeking Help? Four Questions Ask them before you tell, and when you are being told 1. Can this listener help? The person, a leader, a guide 2. How much is needed? Enough to get help, not everything 3. Would I say it if they were here? If not, ask why not 4. Have I spoken to them? Or is there a good reason not to? Mostly yes: seeking help Tell only what is needed, to the one who can help. Ask: "Can you keep this private?" Mostly no: pause Vent once to one trusted person, or stop. Then take the next step toward help. Exception: danger is not gossip Harm to a child, violence, sexual misconduct, threats, abuse of power: do not keep it quiet. Tell a responsible person. Check local law. If danger is now, use your local emergency number.

Diagram 2. What to do when you notice it

If you notice... Then...
Someone starts a story about a person who is absent Offer a sentence: "It may help to talk with them directly. Would you like help?"
A prayer request that names private details Ask whether the person gave permission; pray without details
A rumour about someone Do not repeat it, even to correct it; stay kind to the person; consider whether a leader should know
A story about harm or danger Not gossip; do not promise secrecy; connect to a responsible person (Week 6)

In short

  • Proverbs and James show that small words can make a large harm; gossip separates friends, is pleasant to hear, and feeds a quarrel.
  • Gossip is a story about an absent person, told to people who cannot help, in a way that lowers them or builds a side.
  • Three questions help: can the listener help, how much is needed, and would I say it with the person present?
  • Disguised gossip includes "I only say this because I care", the detailed prayer request, and the "between us" confidence.
  • When someone brings you a story, offer a gentle route to help; do not repeat it, even to correct it.
  • Danger to a child or another person is not gossip and not confidential: connect it to a responsible person.
Front Back
Gossip (working description) A story about an absent person, told to those who cannot help, that lowers the person or builds a side.
Three questions Can this listener help? How much is needed? Would I say it with the person present?
A sentence for a listener "It may help to talk with them directly. Would you like help to do that?"
The exception to confidentiality Danger to a child, threat of self-harm or harm to others, abuse: tell a responsible person; do not promise secrecy.

One sentence to remember A story should travel only as far as help can reach, and no further.

This week's action This week, when you notice yourself about to tell or hear a story about someone absent, ask the three questions and offer one sentence that points to help.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Proverbs 18:8 says gossip is pleasant to hear. What makes a story pleasant to receive? What would it take for you to refuse a "morsel" kindly?
  • The lecture defines gossip by its use, not by whether the story is true. Do you agree? What might be lost if "true stories are never gossip" were the rule?
  • Which of the four sentences for a listener would be easiest for you to say? Which would be hardest in your own culture or setting? You may pass.
  • A prayer request can carry private details. What practices might a group adopt to share needs without exposing people?
  • Why does the lecture say that a safety danger is an exception to confidentiality? What might go wrong if a listener promised "I will tell no one" before hearing the story?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.