FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM406E Reconciling Church and Small-Group Conflict: A Lay Guide to Peacemaking

Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles

Contents 31
LM406E Reconciling Church and Small-Group Conflict: A Lay Guide to Peacemaking
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Standing Beside People in Conflict
  1. Introduction: Standing Beside People in Conflict
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Understanding Conflict
  1. Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
  2. Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
  4. Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Peacemaking Passages Without Misusing Them
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
  2. Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
  3. Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Listening and Conversation
  1. Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
  2. Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
  3. Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
  4. Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Apology, Forgiveness and Restoration
  1. Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
  2. Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
  3. Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
  4. Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Gossip, Taking Sides and the Small Group
  1. Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
  2. Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
  3. Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
  4. Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Beyond Mediation — Safety and Referral
  1. Lecture 6-1: When Reconciliation Is Not the Answer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Who to Pass It To, and How
  3. Lecture 6-3: Caring for the One Beside
  4. Lecture 6-4: What a Church Can Put in Place
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Peacemaking Plan and Referral Map

Jump to the key points ↓

29 min

When two people disagree, a third person is often drawn in. Sometimes the third person is asked to listen. Sometimes the third person is asked to agree. Soon there are two groups, each with its own story, and people who were not part of the first disagreement are now part of a quarrel. This is how a conflict between two people becomes a division in a group.

This lecture looks at how that happens and at what a lay peacemaker can do. It begins with the church in Corinth, where Paul wrote to people who were gathering around leaders. It then describes the pattern many people call a triangle, the usual lines along which sides form in a church, and the signs that a group is becoming divided. It explains how to take a complaint about a leader to a responsible place, and how to stand beside people without joining a side. It ends with the newcomers and young people who are easily drawn in.

The safety line from earlier in the chapter applies here too. A complaint that someone in authority has caused harm is not a "side" in a quarrel. Abuse, threats, sexual misconduct and the misuse of power are matters of protection, not of balance between two views. When the signs of such harm appear, this lecture points to Week 6 and does not try to settle them.

What these 29 minutes give you

  • Describe what Paul says about divisions at Corinth in 1 Corinthians 1:10-13 and 3:3-4, and what the passage does and does not tell us.
  • Explain a triangle (A tells B about C) and say why it eases pressure without solving the problem.
  • Name common lines along which sides form, and three signs that a group is dividing.
  • Distinguish being fair about a dispute from being neutral about harm.
  • Say where a lay person can take a complaint about a leader, and when it must go to Week 6 routes instead.

Now I beg you, brothers, through the name of our Lord, Jesus Christ, that you all speak the same thing and that there be no divisions among you, but that you be perfected together in the same mind and in the same judgment." — 1 Corinthians 1:10

World English Bible

For it has been reported to me concerning you, my brothers, by those who are from Chloe’s household, that there are contentions among you." — 1 Corinthians 1:11

WEB

Now I mean this, that each one of you says, “I follow Paul,” “I follow Apollos,” “I follow Cephas,” and, “I follow Christ.”" — 1 Corinthians 1:12

WEB

Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized into the name of Paul?" — 1 Corinthians 1:13

WEB

for you are still fleshly. For insofar as there is jealousy, strife, and factions among you, aren’t you fleshly, and don’t you walk in the ways of men?" — 1 Corinthians 3:3

WEB

For when one says, “I follow Paul,” and another, “I follow Apollos,” aren’t you fleshly?" — 1 Corinthians 3:4

WEB

Paul writes to a church where people have attached themselves to different leaders. We read it to see what a divided group sounds like, and what question Paul asks about it. We do not read it as a ready answer to every division today.

1. What happened at Corinth

Paul's first letter to the Corinthians is a letter to a church in conflict. A report had reached him. "For it has been reported to me concerning you, my brothers, by those who are from Chloe’s household, that there are contentions among you." The text does not say who Chloe's household were, only that they told him what they had seen. Notice that Paul names the source of the report. He does not hide it, and he does not pretend to have heard it from the air.

What was the conflict? "Now I mean this, that each one of you says, “I follow Paul,” “I follow Apollos,” “I follow Cephas,” and, “I follow Christ.”" People had formed groups around different leaders. We do not know exactly what the groups held. Paul's words do not give us a list of doctrines, and writers on this passage disagree about how far each slogan meant a different teaching and how far it meant loyalty, taste or style. We should avoid saying more than the text says. What the text does say is that people were defining themselves by the person they followed.

Paul's response comes first as a request. "Now I beg you, brothers, through the name of our Lord, Jesus Christ, that you all speak the same thing and that there be no divisions among you, but that you be perfected together in the same mind and in the same judgment." He asks for no divisions, and for being "perfected together". Then he asks three questions. "Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized into the name of Paul?" Each question shows something. "Is Christ divided?" asks whether the one to whom all belong can be split. The other two remind the readers that Paul did not die for them and that they were not baptized into his name. The questions do not tell the Corinthians which side was right. They remove the ground that the sides stood on: the idea that a leader is a banner.

Later in the letter Paul comes back to the matter. "for you are still fleshly. For insofar as there is jealousy, strife, and factions among you, aren’t you fleshly, and don’t you walk in the ways of men?" "For when one says, “I follow Paul,” and another, “I follow Apollos,” aren’t you fleshly?" He uses a strong word, "fleshly", and he ties it to "jealousy, strife, and factions". He does not say that the people are not Christians. He is speaking to the church as a church, and he asks them to look at what their behaviour shows.

Two cautions. First, Paul is writing as an apostle with a relation to this church, and a lay person today does not have the same standing. We should not copy his tone toward a person we do not know well. Second, the passage is about divisions over leaders and loyalties. It is not a rule that no one may ever disagree, and it is not a command to remain silent about wrong. Paul himself deals firmly with other matters in the same letter, such as how the Lord's Supper was being held. The lesson is more limited: when people define themselves by a side, the question to ask is what they all belong to.

2. The triangle

Many people who study groups and families describe a pattern that they call a triangle. It is easy to describe, and a lay peacemaker will see it often.

Two people, A and C, are in tension. A does not speak to C. Instead A speaks to B about C. A feels better, because someone has listened. B now holds a story and perhaps a feeling about C. C may sense that something is wrong but does not know what. The tension between A and C has not changed. A new line has been added: between A and B, and often between B and C.

Two things happen. First, the pressure on A and C eases, so there is less reason for them to meet. The problem stays where it was. Second, B is being asked, openly or not, to take A's side. If B does, B is no longer neutral and may not even know it.

(an invented example) Amira is upset because Leo, who leads the music in her small group, changed the songs without asking her. She says nothing to Leo. At the next meeting she tells Beth, "Leo does whatever he likes." Beth later tells Karim, "I think Amira feels pushed aside." Karim says to Leo, jokingly, "Amira thinks you are a dictator." Leo is hurt and puzzled. Amira, who has never said a word to Leo, has no idea that her comment has travelled. Four people now hold parts of a story, and the two who need to speak have still not done so.

A triangle is not always bad. Sometimes A needs a trusted third person for advice, courage or a companion when speaking to C. That is a use of a triangle that leads out of it. The difference is where the line points. A helpful third person points toward the person concerned or toward the place where help is available. An unhelpful one becomes a place where the tension rests.

If you are B, you have a few choices. You can listen and say "I think you need to talk to Leo, and I can go with you if you want." You can decline to carry messages: "I would rather not tell him that. It will be better if it comes from you." You can ask what the person wants: "What would you like to happen?" Often A has not thought about it. And you can notice when you are being drawn in: if you find yourself feeling anger toward C on behalf of A, stop and ask how much you know.

3. Where sides form

Sides in a church or group rarely form around the original issue only. They gather along lines that already exist. Some common ones are:

  • Age: younger and older members, with different ways of using time, money, music and technology.
  • Role: officers and ordinary members; long-serving volunteers and recent ones; clergy and lay people.
  • Style of worship and prayer: quiet or loud; set words or free words; short or long.
  • Length of time in the group: those who "were here before" and those who came later.
  • Family and friendship: relatives and old friends often side together.
  • Language and background: people from different regions, languages or cultures within one congregation.

These lines are ordinary. People differ in all these ways, and difference is not a division. The danger comes when a disagreement about one thing (for example, the time of the meeting) becomes a statement about who belongs. Then "the evening group" and "the morning group" stop being practical arrangements, and become "us" and "them".

4. Signs that a group is dividing

No single sign proves a division. Taken together, some signs are worth noticing. A peacemaker does not diagnose; a peacemaker notices and asks.

Sign What it can look like
"We" and "they" People speak of "those who..." and use the same group labels repeatedly
Repeated stories The same story about a person is told by several people, with the same words
Seating and avoidance People stop sitting together; some stay away from events when others attend
Decisions as loyalty tests A vote on a small matter is treated as showing who is for or against someone
Leaders as banners "I follow so-and-so" is said or implied, as in Corinth
Labels for persons A person is called by a word, not by name: "the troublemaker", "the proud one"
Messages and side-meetings Groups meet separately to discuss others, or a message group appears that excludes some

If you notice two or three of these, do not announce it. Pay attention. Speak with a few people separately, in a way that does not pass stories. Ask a leader whether they have seen it, if you think they would want to know. Lecture 5-3 shows what a leader of a small group can do in the meeting itself.

5. Fair about the dispute, not neutral about harm

A lay peacemaker is asked to take no side. This phrase needs care, because it can be misunderstood in two directions.

It does not mean that you have no views, or that you never say that something was wrong. It does not mean "I do not want to get involved" when a person is being hurt.

It does mean that, in a dispute between people who both hold reasonable and different views (the time of the meeting, the budget for snacks, the songs, the way a decision was made), you listen to each, you do not carry what one says to the other, and you do not give a verdict. You are on the side of both people, which is a different thing from being on neither side.

Compare this with a situation of harm. If a person tells you they have been threatened, or that someone with authority has pressed them to be silent about abuse, you are not neutral. You do not say "both sides have a point". You make sure the person is believed enough to be connected with someone who can protect and act, and you do not sit them down with the person who caused harm. A short way to hold both: be fair about the dispute, and never neutral about harm.

How do you tell which you are looking at? Lecture 1-2 gave signs: fear, repeated attacks on a person, pressure to be silent, a large difference in power, danger. If you are not sure, treat it as possibly harm until a responsible person has looked, and take your uncertainty to such a person. It is better to ask than to treat a harm as a quarrel.

6. Complaints about leaders

Another common situation is a complaint about a leader: the pastor, the group leader, the treasurer, an , a youth leader. Members sometimes bring such a complaint to a friend, and the friend is unsure what to do. Two things must be kept apart.

Ordinary complaints. The leader chose a topic someone dislikes, runs meetings too long, was careless with a message, or made a decision others disagree with. These are matters to raise respectfully. The best route is usually to the leader, with the person concerned speaking, or with a companion. If the person is afraid to do that, a lay peacemaker can help them think about what to say, or can go along. If the leader is not the right one to hear it, the group or church should have a place to take such matters: a council, a board, a senior pastor, a bishop or other body. Churches are governed in different ways, and some have clear routes while others do not. Ask what the route is in your church or group, without presuming it. Do not make a campaign. Do not recruit people to the complaint before it has been heard.

Complaints of harm or misuse of power. The leader has been physically violent, sexually inappropriate, threatening, manipulative with money, or has silenced those who raised concerns, or is acting in a way that frightens people. These are not matters of taste or style. A lay person does not investigate. The right step is to help the person who raised it to reach someone able to act: a responsible person in the church if that person is not part of the problem, and an outside body (a higher church authority, local agencies, a lawyer) if they are. Local law and your church's rules differ; ask them. Week 6 describes this. If someone is in danger now, use your local emergency number.

In both cases, one thing is the same: do not become the channel for a complaint you cannot help to resolve. If you carry the story from member to member, you have built a side. If you help the person to a responsible place, you have stood beside them.

Signs that a complaint about a leader may be about power and not preference include: people say they are afraid to speak; people who raised concerns earlier were removed or shamed; a leader says that questions show a lack of faith or loyalty; people are asked to sign secrecy promises; a leader insists on handling alone something that others should see. These signs do not prove anything. They tell you that the matter needs a careful look by someone with the right responsibility, and that a lay peacemaker should not be the only one holding it.

7. Standing beside without taking a side

What does it look like to stand beside two people who are in a dispute?

  • You listen to each in turn, separately, and you do not report what one says to the other. If you must report something, you ask permission first.
  • You name your role: "I am not here to decide who is right. I can listen, and I can help you think about what to do."
  • You decline invitations to join a camp: "I want to be a friend to both of you, so I will not take a side."
  • You keep greeting and including both. A person who finds that you are polite to the other person may feel betrayed. Explain, if needed, that you are polite to everyone.
  • You notice your own feelings. If you find that you agree strongly with one person, say so to yourself and consider whether you should step back (lecture 1-3).
  • You do not use the phrase "I'm neutral" as a shield. If harm appears, you act.

In cultures where relationships come first, refusing to join a side may feel like a refusal of friendship, and in cultures where speaking directly is valued, saying "I'll not take a side" may seem cold. These differences are real. The principle holds, and the manner may change: a visit, a meal, a word to say that you value both.

8. Newcomers and young people

New members and young people are often drawn into sides without anyone planning it. A newcomer has no history to place the quarrel in, and may be flattered when a long-serving member confides in them. A teenager may be asked to carry messages between adults, or may hear what adults say about each other at home or in the group.

A few simple practices help. Do not share adult conflicts with children and teenagers, and do not ask them to take messages. If a newcomer is told a story about another member, you can say to the newcomer later, "You may hear different views. You do not have to take any side." Introduce newcomers to several people, not only to one circle. And watch that a young person is not being used by an adult in a way that is not safe: an adult who makes a teenager a private confidant about the adult's troubles, or who asks the teenager to keep secrets, is crossing a line. This is a matter for a responsible person in the church and, where it applies, for your local child-protection rules.

9. What a lay peacemaker brings

The pattern in this lecture is simple. A small conflict becomes a large one when a third party is drawn into a side, and when stories travel. A lay peacemaker can slow this by refusing to be a channel, by pointing toward the person concerned or toward help, by being fair about the dispute, and by making sure that harm is never treated as a side in a quarrel. This is not dramatic. It is repeated, patient, ordinary work. And it is not about winning a position for a person; it is about helping people see each other as people again, inside truth and safety.


Diagram 1. A triangle, and the line that leads out of it

The Triangle: Where the Line Points The tension stays where it was unless someone speaks to the person concerned The triangle that holds tension B A C A and C do not speak A tells B B is drawn in The line that leads out B A C B helps A speak to C B stays beside, takes no side, carries no message If C has caused harm, or holds power over A, do not send A to speak to C alone. Help A reach someone responsible (Week 6). Fair about a dispute; never neutral about harm.

Diagram 2. Fair about the dispute, never neutral about harm

A dispute A harm
Examples Meeting time, budget, songs, how a decision was made Threats, violence, sexual misconduct, child harm, pressure to keep silent about abuse
Stance Listen to both; no verdict; no carried messages Believe enough to connect; do not investigate; do not promise secrecy
Do you bring the two together? Possibly, if both want it and it is safe No. Not by a lay person
Where it goes Peacemaking conversation (Weeks 3 and 5) Responsible person, professionals, agencies (Week 6)

In short

  • At Corinth people defined themselves by the leader they followed; Paul asks "Is Christ divided?" and does not settle who is right.
  • In a triangle, A tells B about C. The pressure eases, the problem stays, and B is pulled toward a side.
  • Sides form along existing lines: age, role, style of worship, time in the group, family and language.
  • Be fair about a dispute; never be neutral about harm. Do not sit a harmed person with the one who harmed them.
  • An ordinary complaint about a leader goes to the leader or a responsible body; signs of harm or misuse of power go to Week 6 routes.
  • Do not make children and teenagers carry adult conflicts, and watch that newcomers are not drawn into sides.
Front Back
The triangle A tells B about C. Tension eases, the problem stays, B is drawn toward A's side.
Paul's question at Corinth "Is Christ divided?" It removes the ground that sides stand on; it does not say which side is right.
Fair, not neutral Be fair about a dispute; never neutral about harm.
A complaint about a leader Ordinary: to the leader or a responsible body. Harm or misuse of power: help the person to someone responsible; outside bodies if needed.

One sentence to remember Stand beside both people, carry nothing between them, and point every line toward the one who can help.

This week's action This week, if someone tells you a story about a third person, say once: "I would like to be a friend to both. Is there someone who could help?"

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In 1 Corinthians 1:12, people say "I follow Paul", "I follow Apollos". Where do you see people in your own setting attach themselves to a person, a style or a group? Think about roles, not names.
  • Paul asks "Is Christ divided?" What does that question do that a ruling on who is right could not do?
  • Describe a triangle you have seen, without naming people. Where could the line have been turned toward the person concerned?
  • What is the difference between being fair about a dispute and being neutral about harm? Why might the second be dangerous?
  • Where in your church or group would a member take a complaint about a leader? If you do not know, how might you find out, without making it a complaint?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.