FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM406E Reconciling Church and Small-Group Conflict: A Lay Guide to Peacemaking

Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group

Contents 31
LM406E Reconciling Church and Small-Group Conflict: A Lay Guide to Peacemaking
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Standing Beside People in Conflict
  1. Introduction: Standing Beside People in Conflict
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Understanding Conflict
  1. Lecture 1-1: Conflict Is Not Strange in the Church
  2. Lecture 1-2: Kinds and Stages of Conflict
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Your Own Reactions
  4. Lecture 1-4: Fault Lines: A Quick Look at Where Conflicts Start
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Conflict Map
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Peacemaking Passages Without Misusing Them
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Matthew 18 in Its Context
  2. Lecture 2-2: Blessed Are the Peacemakers
  3. Lecture 2-3: Forgiveness, Apology, Restoration, Reconciliation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Before You Quote a Verse
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Checking the Verse
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Listening and Conversation
  1. Lecture 3-1: Hearing Both Sides
  2. Lecture 3-2: What a Lay Peacemaker Does and Does Not Do
  3. Lecture 3-3: Opening a Hard Conversation
  4. Lecture 3-4: Words That Calm and Words That Inflame
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Two Sides of One Story
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Apology, Forgiveness and Restoration
  1. Lecture 4-1: Giving and Receiving an Apology
  2. Lecture 4-2: Talking About Forgiveness
  3. Lecture 4-3: After the Conflict: Trust and Community
  4. Lecture 4-4: Why Some Things Take Years
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting an Apology
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Gossip, Taking Sides and the Small Group
  1. Lecture 5-1: Gossip and Rumour
  2. Lecture 5-2: Taking Sides and Triangles
  3. Lecture 5-3: Leading a Conflict Conversation in a Small Group
  4. Lecture 5-4: Online Groups and Messages
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Handling a Moment in the Meeting
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Beyond Mediation — Safety and Referral
  1. Lecture 6-1: When Reconciliation Is Not the Answer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Who to Pass It To, and How
  3. Lecture 6-3: Caring for the One Beside
  4. Lecture 6-4: What a Church Can Put in Place
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Peacemaking Plan and Referral Map

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

It is one thing to understand conflict. It is another to be in a room of eight people when one of them raises her voice. A small group is one of the places where conflict shows most quickly, because the people know each other, sit close, and talk about things that matter: faith, family, money, how the church should act. A leader of a small group, or a member who finds herself or himself leading for a moment, has to decide in seconds what to do.

This lecture is practical. It looks at what can be done before trouble (ground rules), at three common moments when conflict shows in a meeting, at what to do in front of the group and what to do aside, at a short sequence of four steps, at why prayer should not be used to cover a conflict, and at what to do when you, the leader, are part of the problem. It includes a point on which readers will not agree. It does not repeat the general guidance on leading a small group, which belongs to the course LM201E; this lecture adds only what conflict needs.

Two safety lines first. If what happens in the meeting is a threat, an attack on a person for who they are, or a sign that someone is being harmed or afraid, a "conflict conversation" is the wrong tool. Stop the meeting calmly, make sure everyone is safe, and bring in a responsible person afterwards (Week 6). And never ask a hurt person to make peace in front of the group. Reconciliation in public, under pressure, is not reconciliation.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Explain why ground rules are set before trouble and give three examples of them.
  • Describe three common moments of conflict in a meeting and say what to do openly and what to take aside.
  • Use the four-step sequence of pause, acknowledge, promise to talk separately and close.
  • State fairly the disagreement about naming a conflict at once or handling it separately, and the course's requirement.
  • Say what to do if you, the leader, are a party to the conflict, and why prayer is not a way to end a conflict.

So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19

World English Bible

A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1

WEB

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

WEB

These three sentences are not a method. They describe the temper of a good meeting: quick to hear, slow to speak, gentle in answer, and not rushing to a verdict before the facts are in.

1. Ground rules: agree them before there is trouble

A ground rule is a short agreement about how the group will behave. It is better made before a quarrel than during one. When a rule has been agreed in a calm moment, the leader can point to the rule and not to a person: "We agreed we would let each person finish." That is a gentler thing to say than "You keep interrupting".

Ground rules need not be many. A group might agree on five or six. Here are examples, to adapt:

  1. One person speaks at a time. Let each finish before the next begins.
  2. We speak about our own experience. "I think" and "I felt" are welcome; "you always" is not.
  3. What is said here stays here, with one exception. If someone is in danger, the leader may have to tell a person who can help. (Say this plainly at the start.)
  4. We may disagree without leaving. Belonging to the group does not depend on agreeing about everything.
  5. We do not attack a person. We can say we disagree with an idea. We do not call someone proud, foolish or faithless.
  6. Anyone may ask for a pause. The leader will stop the discussion for a minute if asked.
  7. Hard matters can be taken aside. If something is too heavy for the whole group, the leader will arrange to talk separately.

Set the rules when the group begins, and repeat them from time to time, especially when new people join. Invite changes. A rule made by the leader alone may feel like a command, while one that the group helped to make feels like a shared agreement. In some groups, a spoken agreement is best; others like a short written card. Whichever you use, say that the rules are for everybody, the leader included.

Culture matters here. In a group where open disagreement is normal, rule 4 may need little explanation. In a group where open disagreement can feel like an insult to the host or to an , rule 4 may need care, and rule 7 will be especially valuable. Do not assume that your group's way is the right way. Ask the group.

2. Three moments when conflict shows

Conflict in a meeting can look like many things. Three are common enough to describe.

1. Someone dominates. One person speaks more than anyone else, answers every question, or cuts others off. It may not be intended as an attack. The person may be anxious, excited, or used to being the one who speaks. But the others become silent, and some may stop coming. A conflict may be building under the surface.

2. Repeated attacks. One member keeps criticising another: the way she prays, his job, her family, his past. The criticism may be wrapped in humour or in spiritual words. The target stops responding, or responds sharply. Others look away. This is a sign that the matter is not about the topic any more. It has become about the person. It may also be harm, if the pattern is a way of belittling someone or if one person has power over the other. See the safety line above.

3. A disagreement about a political or social issue. A group meets to study Scripture, and a member says something about a public question: an , a law, a war, a group of people. Others respond. Voices rise. In many countries these questions divide people who otherwise agree. The group's agreed rules matter most here. A leader's task is not to settle the political question, and not to say who is right. It is to keep the meeting safe for people who disagree, and to say clearly what the meeting is for.

3. What to do in the open, and what to take aside

Not everything should be done in front of the group. Some things should. A simple distinction:

In the open (with the group) Aside (one to one, later)
Restate the ground rule Talk about a person's behaviour
Slow things down; ask for a pause Ask a person how they are, and listen
Acknowledge that the matter matters Hear the hurt person separately
Offer to come back to a topic at another time Hear the person who spoke sharply separately
Return to the purpose of the meeting Decide what, if anything, to do next

The reason is simple. When a person is corrected in front of others, shame can be added to the original conflict. Shame makes people defend themselves, and defence hardens a conflict. In many cultures public correction is also a very serious matter, and it may be experienced as an attack even when it is gently meant. At the same time, silence is not always kind. If someone has been hurt in front of the group, the group is also watching to see whether the hurt will be noticed. A short, calm word in the meeting ("That was a sharp thing to say; let us pause") tells the hurt person that they are not alone.

4. A short sequence: pause, acknowledge, promise, close

When a conflict shows in the meeting, a leader can use four steps. They are short. The leader does not need to say much.

1. Pause. Say the person's name gently, or raise a hand, or say, "Let us stop for a moment." Silence for a few seconds can help. Do not raise your own voice.

2. Acknowledge. Say that you see that this matters. Do not take a side and do not give a verdict. "I can hear that this is important to both of you." "It sounds as though something has been hard here."

3. Promise to talk separately. Say what will happen. "I would like to speak with each of you after the meeting. I will not decide anything tonight." The promise gives each person a place where they can be heard, and it moves the matter from the room to a calmer setting. Keep the promise.

4. Close the matter for the meeting. Return to the purpose. "Let us go back to the passage." The close is not a way of pretending nothing happened. It says that the meeting will go on and the issue will be handled elsewhere.

(an invented example) In a group of nine, Mehmet says to Anna, who has just said she is troubled about the church's new building plan, "You are always against any change. Perhaps you do not trust anyone." Anna goes quiet. The leader, Grace, says, "Let us pause a moment." She waits. "Mehmet, I think that was sharper than you intended, and Anna, I can see this matters to you. I would like to hear from both of you after tonight, separately. I will not decide anything now. For tonight, let us go back to the question we were reading." Grace does not ask for an apology in front of the group, does not ask Anna to say it is all right, and does not ask the group to vote. After the meeting, she calls each of them.

5. Do not smother conflict with prayer

It is tempting, when a meeting becomes tense, to say, "Let us pray." Prayer is a good thing, and in many traditions it is natural at any moment. The caution is about use. Prayer can become a way of ending a conversation so that nobody has to deal with the hurt. A prayer that says "Lord, help those who are not loving each other" can sound like a rebuke. A prayer used to close the topic says, in effect, "This is finished". The hurt person may then feel that to speak again would be to break the prayer.

A few questions can help. Am I praying because I want to ask for help, or because I want the room to be quiet? Does the prayer name no person and judge no one? Will I still speak to the hurt person afterwards? A short prayer for the group to be given patience, said after the pause and the acknowledgement, is different from a prayer that takes the place of them.

The same caution applies to statements such as "the devil is trying to divide us". Sometimes a conflict is a spiritual matter. But the phrase is often used to silence a person who raised a real problem. It places the problem outside the community, and the person who spoke up becomes the one who "let the devil in". Do not use it to end a conversation. A person who says something is wrong should be heard.

6. Naming it at once, or handling it separately

This is a point where readers will not agree. When a disagreement shows in a meeting, some leaders hold that it should be named at once and aloud. Their reasons are serious. Unnamed tension sits in the room and spoils the meeting. Others will notice and wonder. A leader who pretends nothing is wrong may teach that conflict is shameful and must be hidden. And in cultures that value direct speech, ignoring a sharp exchange can look dishonest or weak.

Other leaders hold that the meeting should go on, and the disagreement be handled separately. Their reasons are also serious. Naming a conflict in front of the group may shame the people involved, and it makes the group into an audience. People under pressure often say things they regret. In cultures where preserving face and the relationship comes first, public naming can cause harm that is difficult to repair. And a group that came to study a passage may not be the right place to work through a hurt.

Many leaders do something in between: a very short, calm acknowledgement ("Something just happened that mattered; I will speak with you both after") and then return to the purpose. What this course requires is less than any one of these ways requires. No one may be shamed, and no harm may be left unattended. If a leader names the conflict, it is done without blame. If a leader keeps the meeting going, the matter is not forgotten: it is picked up afterwards, with each person, and the promise to do so is kept. Where there are signs of harm, none of this is enough, and a responsible person must be told.

7. Meet the hurt person separately

The most important conversation often comes after the meeting. When you meet the person who was hurt, a few things help:

  • Choose a place that is private and comfortable, and one where the person can leave when they wish. If the person is a teenager, or if you are an adult meeting a young person, arrange for it to be in view of others or with another responsible adult. Never be alone with a young person behind a closed door.
  • Listen first. Do not explain, correct or defend the other person. Lecture 3-1 gave the habit of reflecting back.
  • Ask what they need. An apology? Space? To step away from the group for a time? A word with the other person, with you present? Some people need nothing but to be heard.
  • Do not press forgiveness or reconciliation. If they are not ready, say that is all right.
  • Do not promise what you cannot keep. Do not say "this will never happen again" if you cannot be sure. Say what you will do.
  • Notice the signs of harm. If what you hear is fear, a pattern of abuse, a threat, or a power difference that makes the person unable to speak freely, stop trying to resolve it and bring in a responsible person (Week 6).

You also need to speak with the other person, the one who spoke sharply. Do this separately and without judgement. A short question may open the door: "How did that moment seem to you?" The person may be unaware of the effect. They may have a hurt of their own. They may deny what happened. You are not a judge, and your role is not to extract a confession. You can say what you saw, state the group rule, and ask what they can do.

After that, decide whether a conversation between the two is possible and wanted by both. If so, a lay peacemaker can help to arrange it (lecture 3-2 describes the limits). If not, it is acceptable to leave the matter for a while.

8. When the leader is a party

Sometimes the leader is one of the people in the conflict: the sharp remark was about the leader, or by the leader, or the conflict is over the leader's decision. In this case, the leader should not lead the conflict conversation. It is the same principle as for any peacemaker who is a party (lecture 1-3).

What can a leader do? Say so briefly: "This is about me, so I am not the right person to lead this." Hand the conversation to a co-leader, an assistant or a person the group trusts, or ask a pastor or another responsible person to help. If there is no one, go on with the meeting, and arrange to get help afterwards. The leader can also ask a trusted person to sit with the one who was hurt and listen, so that the person has someone who is not a party.

A leader who has been unfair or harsh can say so, plainly: "I spoke sharply last week, and I am sorry. I would like to listen." This is not weakness. It sets a pattern for the group.

9. Where this leaves you

A small group is a place where people can learn to disagree without harm. A leader cannot prevent every sharp word, and does not need to. The aim is much simpler: slow the moment down, show that people matter, keep the promise to speak separately, and notice when what is happening is more serious than a disagreement. If you do those things, you have done what a lay peacemaker is asked to do.


Diagram 1. The four steps in the meeting

When Conflict Shows in the Meeting Pause, acknowledge, promise to talk separately, close 1. Pause "Let us stop for a moment." Calm voice. A few seconds of quiet. 2. Acknowledge "I can hear this matters to you." No side. No verdict. 3. Promise "I will talk with each of you after." Then keep it. 4. Close "Let us go back to our reading." Not pretending. Moving on, with a plan. After the meeting Meet the hurt person separately. Meet the other person separately. Ask what is needed. Press nothing. Threat, fear, abuse of power, harm to someone: stop. Do not bring them together. Tell a responsible person (Week 6). If anyone is in danger now, use your local emergency number.

Diagram 2. Two ways of handling a naming question

Name it at once Keep going, handle it separately
Strength Tension is not left in the room; honest; models that conflict can be spoken about Spares people shame; protects face and relationship; keeps the meeting for its purpose
Risk May shame; turns the group into an audience May leave a hurt unseen; may teach that conflict is hidden
Common ground A short, calm acknowledgement, then the promise to speak separately Same
Required in every case No one shamed; no harm left unattended Same

In short

  • Ground rules agreed before trouble let a leader point to a rule and not to a person.
  • Three common moments are a dominating voice, repeated attacks on a person, and a political or social disagreement.
  • In the meeting: pause, acknowledge, promise to talk separately, close. Then keep the promise and meet each person separately.
  • Prayer should not be used to end a conflict, and "the devil is dividing us" should not silence a person who raised a problem.
  • Some leaders name a disagreement at once; others handle it separately. Either way, no one is shamed and no harm is left.
  • If the leader is a party, someone else leads; if there is threat, fear or abuse of power, stop and tell a responsible person.
Front Back
Ground rule A short agreement about how the group behaves, made before trouble, for everyone including the leader.
The four steps Pause; acknowledge; promise to talk separately; close the matter for the meeting.
The requirement on naming Whether you name it at once or handle it separately, no one is shamed and no harm is left.
When the leader is a party Say so, hand the conversation to someone else, and seek help from a responsible person.

One sentence to remember Slow the moment, acknowledge it, promise to speak separately, and keep the promise.

This week's action Write down two ground rules you would suggest to your group, and one sentence you would say to pause a sharp exchange.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What ground rules would your group find most useful? Which would be hard to agree on, and why? Think about the group's culture and not about particular people.
  • Of the three moments (someone dominates, repeated attacks, a political or social disagreement), which would you find hardest to handle? What would you do in the open and what aside?
  • Why might the sentence "Let us pray" end a conversation that needed to continue? When is a prayer in a tense moment a help and not a shield?
  • Describe the two positions on naming a disagreement as their holders would, in the strongest form you can. What does the course require in either case?
  • If you were the leader and the conflict was about you, whom would you ask to lead it? What would you say?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.