Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Where Teaching Happens
- Lecture 1-2: Starting from the Evidence
- Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
- Lecture 1-4: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Lesson Plan
- Lecture 2-1: The First and the Last Three Minutes
- Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
- Lecture 2-3: Room for Everyone
- Lecture 2-4: Teaching Through a Difficult Moment
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Ten Minutes Taught
- Lecture 3-1: How Do You Know They Learned
- Lecture 3-2: Assessment That Respects the Learner
- Lecture 3-3: Short Checks, Well Made
- Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Check for Your Plan
- Lecture 4-1: Watching a Lesson
- Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher
- Lecture 4-3: Hearing the Learners
- Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Observation Sheet
- Lecture 5-1: Children and Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Adults and Lay Training
- Lecture 5-3: Mixed Ages, Online and Blended
- Lecture 5-4: Lessons in Another Language or Culture
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, One Lesson, Two Rooms
When a lesson ends, the teacher is tired and the next thing is waiting: coffee, a conversation at the door, a family to drive home. In the hour after the lesson, a teacher knows more about it than at any other time. By the next evening much of it has faded. By next week the lesson has become "the one about the Samaritan; I think it went fine."
The check is only half of what the evidence is for. The other half is what the teacher does with it. This lecture teaches a small habit: write a short note soon after the lesson, read it a week later, and choose one change. That is all. The habit is small on purpose. A teacher who tries to fix everything after every lesson soon stops trying to fix anything.
The note is also private. It is the teacher's own place to be honest about a lesson, without having to look good.
What these 16 minutes give you
- Write a short after-lesson note of five lines within a day of teaching.
- Explain why a note should be read again a week later, and what the second reading shows.
- Choose one change from a note, using three questions, and state it so that it can be done.
- Say what must not go into a note, and why a teacher should not try to fix everything at once.
I considered my ways, and turned my steps to your statutes." — Psalm 119:59
World English Bible
Through wisdom a house is built; by understanding it is established; by knowledge the rooms are filled with all rare and beautiful treasure." — Proverbs 24:3-4
WEB
Now therefore this is what Yahweh of Armies says: Consider your ways." — Haggai 1:5
WEB
Each of these verses speaks in its own setting. Here we take from them only a modest point: it is good to stop, look at what you have done, and build on it with care.
1. Why a note, and why soon
Memory is not a good record. The mind keeps the vivid parts of a lesson (the funny remark, the one difficult moment, the praise at the door) and lets the rest go. After a day you may remember the moment someone argued with you and have forgotten that six people could not find the passage. After a week the lesson has been rewritten in your memory as a story, and the story is usually kinder or harsher than what happened.
A written note made soon after, while the lesson is fresh, holds what you saw. It does not need to be long. Five minutes is enough. If you wait until you "have time", you will not write it.
2. The five lines
A note of five lines is enough for most lessons. The first four are the record from lecture 3-3. The fifth is new.
- The goal. Copy it from the plan.
- The evidence. What you saw or heard that shows whether the aim was met. A tally if you used one ("eight slips at level 3, six at level 2, three at level 1").
- Where they stuck. The point at which answers thinned, instructions failed or the room went quiet.
- What came alive. Where people leaned in. It matters as much as the sticking place. It tells you what to keep.
- One thing to change. Only one. (Leave it blank at first if you are too tired. You will fill it in when you read the note again.)
Here is a note in full.
(An invented example.) A teacher led forty minutes with a house group of adults on the road to Emmaus.
Goal: Learners can tell what the two travellers did when they recognised Jesus.
Evidence: Slips: 9 at level 3, 4 at level 2, 2 at level 1. Most said they "went back to Jerusalem" but several did not say why.
Where they stuck: The reading took too long (about 12 minutes), so the pair activity was rushed. Two people did not finish the slip.
What came alive: When pairs retold the evening scene, the room became noisy in a good way.
One thing to change: Shorten the reading by giving the story in two halves, and move the pair activity earlier.
Notice what the note does not contain. It has no names. It does not say who was "difficult". It does not say anything about anyone's faith. It is about the lesson.
3. Read it again a week later
The note has more to say after a week. Three things happen.
First, you see it with some distance. The thing you wrote in anger at the time ("They did not listen!") may now read as "I gave no instruction for the pair activity." The note is the same. You have changed, and now you can see the lesson more fairly.
Second, you can see patterns. If you wrote the same line in two notes in a row ("the reading took too long"), you have found a fault that is not a fluke.
Third, the week gives you a chance to ask. If a point puzzled you, you can ask a learner, or a trusted fellow teacher, what they remember of it.
Do the second reading at a fixed time, such as the day you begin to plan the next lesson. Then the note feeds the plan directly.
4. Choosing one change
A note will usually show several things that could be better. A teacher who tries to change all of them at once cannot tell which change helped, and tends to teach a worse lesson while thinking about five things. Choose one.
Three questions help you choose.
- Which change would most improve the evidence? If the goal is not being met, ask what, in the lesson, stands most between the learner and the goal.
- Which change is small enough to do next time? "Teach more clearly" cannot be done. "Give the instruction for the pair activity before I hand out the slips" can.
- Which change is in my hands? You may not be able to change the room, the time of day or how tired the learners are. You can change the order of the lesson, the wording of an instruction and the length of a reading.
State the change so that you will know whether you did it. A good statement names an action and a place in the lesson: "Read the story in two halves, with the pair activity between them." A poor one names only a wish: "Be more engaging."
Then leave the other things on the list. They are not lost. You wrote them down. Next time, after another lesson, you will choose again. This is slower than fixing everything, and it works better, because a teacher can only hold one new thing in mind while teaching.
5. Keep what worked
One of the five lines is "what came alive." The note is not only a list of faults. A teacher who writes down only faults slowly comes to dislike teaching. The line about what came alive gives you things to keep, and a lesson is improved as much by keeping a good thing on purpose as by mending a bad one. In the example above, the noisy pair retelling is worth keeping and even making a little longer.
6. Keep the note private
The note is for the teacher. It is a place where you may say "I lost the thread" or "I did not know the answer" without anyone reading it. If you thought a colleague, a pastor or a learner would read it, you would soften it, and a softened note teaches you less.
So keep it private. Use a notebook, a folder or a file that only you open. Do not post it where others read, and do not share it in a messaging group by accident.
If you want to share a note with a fellow teacher, or ask for help from someone, show them only what you choose. Lecture 4-2 returns to feedback from others.
Privacy also protects learners. Lecture 3-2 gave the rules for records. In a note, do not write the name of a learner, and do not write anything about a child's family, health or faith. If you must remember that someone needs help, write only "follow up with one learner after the lesson" and carry the name in your own mind, or take it to the responsible person. Follow local law and your community's written rules about records.
7. A hard lesson
Some lessons go badly. The activity collapsed, an argument started, or you did not know the answer to a question. On those days the note is harder to write. Write it anyway, and write it fairly. Put down what happened, and then ask the three questions. Often a bad lesson gives you the clearest change of all.
If a learner left the lesson upset, or something happened that frightens you, a note is not the right place for it. Speak to your pastor, priest or the responsible person for safeguarding. If someone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
8. The teacher is more than one lesson
A single note can read as a verdict on you. It is not. It is a record of what happened in one hour with some people on one day. A teacher grows over years, by many lessons and many small changes. Lecture 6-1 will place the note in the whole cycle of design, teaching, checking, feedback and revision. For now, one note, one change.
Diagram 1. The note, the second reading, and one change
Diagram 2. A good change and a poor one
| Poor (a wish) | Good (an action in a place) |
|---|---|
| "Be more engaging." | "Read the story in two halves, with the pair activity between them." |
| "Make the instructions better." | "Say the instruction once, show it, then ask one pair to say it back." |
| "Have more time." | "Cut the opening talk to three minutes and keep seven for the closing." |
In short
- Write a short note soon after the lesson. Memory keeps the vivid moments and loses the rest.
- Five lines: the goal, the evidence, where they stuck, what came alive, one thing to change.
- Read the note again a week later. Distance shows patterns and corrects what was written in haste.
- Choose one change: the one that most helps the evidence, small enough to do, and in your hands. Say it as an action.
- Keep the note private, with no learner's name and nothing about anyone's faith, family or health.
- Keep what came alive. A note of faults alone wears a teacher down.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The five lines | The goal, the evidence, where they stuck, what came alive, one thing to change. |
| Why read the note again a week later | Distance corrects what was written in haste and shows patterns across notes. |
| Three questions for choosing a change | Which most improves the evidence? Which is small enough to do next time? Which is in my hands? |
| What must not go in a note | A learner's name, or anything about a person's faith, family or health. |
One sentence to remember Write the note soon, read it again, and change one thing.
This week's action After your next lesson, write the five lines within a day. A week later, read them and write one change as an action.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What do you remember best about the last lesson you taught or attended? What might you have forgotten?
- Why might a note you write in a hurry read differently a week later?
- Write the one change you would choose from the note printed in this lecture, using the three questions. Is it small enough to do?
- Why does it help to write down what came alive, not only what went wrong?
- What would you need in order to keep your notes private? What should never be written in them?