Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Where Teaching Happens
- Lecture 1-2: Starting from the Evidence
- Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
- Lecture 1-4: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Lesson Plan
- Lecture 2-1: The First and the Last Three Minutes
- Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
- Lecture 2-3: Room for Everyone
- Lecture 2-4: Teaching Through a Difficult Moment
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Ten Minutes Taught
- Lecture 3-1: How Do You Know They Learned
- Lecture 3-2: Assessment That Respects the Learner
- Lecture 3-3: Short Checks, Well Made
- Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Check for Your Plan
- Lecture 4-1: Watching a Lesson
- Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher
- Lecture 4-3: Hearing the Learners
- Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Observation Sheet
- Lecture 5-1: Children and Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Adults and Lay Training
- Lecture 5-3: Mixed Ages, Online and Blended
- Lecture 5-4: Lessons in Another Language or Culture
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, One Lesson, Two Rooms
A lesson plan with a good goal can still fail for plain reasons. The lesson was planned for sixty minutes and the room was free for forty. The chairs were in rows and the activity needed a circle. Twelve copies of the handout were printed and twenty people came. The projector did not start.
None of this is deep. All of it is common, and all of it can be thought about before the day. This lecture turns the goal and evidence of lecture 1-2 into a plan that can actually be taught: a timetable, a room, materials, and a second plan for when the first one meets trouble.
What these 17 minutes give you
- Divide a 45-minute lesson into parts and leave a margin of time.
- Arrange a room, and choose materials, so that they serve the goal of the lesson.
- Name what to check before copying or showing someone else's material, and say where to look for the rules that apply.
- Write a Plan B for at least four common problems.
- Explain why a plan has to be small enough to be taught.
The plans of the diligent surely lead to profit; and everyone who is hasty surely rushes to poverty." — Proverbs 21:5
World English Bible
Let all things be done decently and in order." — 1 Corinthians 14:40
WEB
For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it?" — Luke 14:28
WEB
Each of these speaks of planning. The first sets the careful plan beside the hasty one. The second asks that things be done "decently and in order." The third is Jesus' picture of a builder who sits down and counts the cost before beginning. A lesson plan is a small case of the same prudence.
1. A plan has to fit a clock
The first thing to know about a lesson is how long it is. Not how long you would like it to be: how long it is. Find out when the room is free, when people arrive, when they leave, and whether something follows that cannot wait. A forty-five-minute lesson is not a sixty-minute lesson that has been squeezed.
Most teachers plan too much. They put an hour of material into forty-five minutes, because the passage is rich and the learners are keen. Then the closing is the part that is lost. Lecture 2-1 will come back to protecting the closing; here the point is that a plan must leave a margin. A margin is time that nothing is scheduled in, so that a question, a late arrival or a slow activity can be absorbed without ruin.
2. A 45-minute timetable
Here is a plan for a 45-minute lesson. Adjust it freely; what matters is the shape.
| Minutes | Part | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 0-5 | Opening | Welcome, say today's one aim, link to last time. |
| 5-15 | Teaching | The passage is read; the teacher explains or tells. About ten minutes. |
| 15-30 | Activity | Learners do something that produces the evidence: pairs, groups, a task. About fifteen minutes. |
| 30-40 | Closing | Learners say it back; one thing to try; the next meeting. About ten minutes. |
| 40-45 | Margin | Nothing scheduled. Absorbs what ran over, or ends early. |
Three remarks about this table.
First, the teaching part is short. For many groups ten minutes of talk by the teacher is about as much as is useful at one stretch. This is a rule of thumb and not a law; some groups will listen longer and some for less, and a teacher learns by watching. The activity part is where learners spend most of their effort.
Second, the closing is ten minutes, not two. It is where the evidence is gathered. A lesson whose closing is "Let's pray, we are out of time" has not had the check it was designed for.
Third, the margin is real. If it is used, fine. If it is not used, the lesson ends gently. A lesson that ends five minutes early causes no harm. A lesson that overruns by ten leaves some people late for the next thing, and some with the feeling that their time did not matter.
For a thirty-minute lesson, keep the shape and shrink each part. For a sixty-minute lesson, give the activity more time and keep the closing and margin. Do not lengthen the teaching part first.
(An invented example.) A volunteer plans a forty-five-minute class on the lost coin in Luke 15:8-10. Her first plan: opening, five minutes; reading and explanation, twenty minutes; a craft, twenty minutes; prayer, five minutes. That adds to fifty, there is no margin, the goal is not checked, and the learners spend nearly half the time listening. She rewrites: opening, five; reading and a short telling, ten; pairs retell the story with two objects, fifteen; closing, in which each child or adult says the story in one sentence and one thing they noticed, ten; margin, five. The plan now fits the clock and makes room for the evidence.
3. The room
The room is part of the lesson. It affects who can see, who can hear and who will speak.
Seating. Rows face the front, and suit a talk. A circle or small tables suit talk among learners. Neither is correct; ask which the goal needs. If you will give a ten-minute explanation and then ask learners to work in pairs, chairs that can be turned are better than chairs fixed in rows.
Space. Can people move without climbing over one another? Is there a clear way to the door? Is there room for a person who uses a wheelchair, a walker or a stroller? Think about this before people arrive and not when someone is standing in the aisle.
Light, sound and temperature. A dim room makes reading hard. A noisy corridor swallows a quiet voice. A room that is too hot or too cold takes attention from the lesson. You may not be able to change these, but you can often move to the better part of a room.
Your own place. Where will you stand or sit so that all can see you and you can see all? Sitting down with a small group changes the feel of a lesson.
Set up early. Arrive before the learners. A teacher who is moving chairs when the learners come in is teaching the first five minutes with divided attention.
4. Materials
Materials are what learners hold, see or hear. Choose them for the goal, and no more than the goal needs.
Print. A handout can carry a passage, a question or a form. Use large enough type that most people can read it without effort. Keep it to one page where you can. Print a few extra.
Screen. A screen can show a text, a picture or a map to a whole room. A screen can also draw eyes away from the people. Put on it only what the lesson needs at that moment. Have the same content on paper as a second plan.
The Bible. Decide whether learners will bring their own, use copies you provide, or read from one text on a sheet. If different translations are in the room, say which one you are reading from, so that those who follow along are not lost. If some learners are not comfortable finding a book in a Bible, point to the page and say the book and chapter slowly.
Small things. Pencils, paper, cards, a timer. Put them where you can reach them. A lesson can stall for lack of one pen.
5. Materials in the owner's terms
Much of what teachers use was made by someone else: a printed curriculum, a song, a picture, a video, a worksheet from a publisher. Someone owns it, and the owner usually sets terms for how it may be copied, shown or shared. The terms are different from place to place, and from publisher to publisher.
This lecture does not give legal advice and does not say what any country's law requires. It says three things. First, find out the terms before you copy or show anything: look at the publisher's notice, ask the person responsible for your community's materials, or ask a qualified person where the matter is unclear. Second, follow local law and your community's written rules. Third, where you are not sure, use what is yours or what is freely given for use: a text in the public domain, your own sheet, or a passage read aloud from a book. A lesson can be taught well without copying anything. Lecture 6-3 comes back to sharing plans and materials honestly.
6. A Plan B
A Plan B is what you will do if the plan cannot be taught as written. Every teacher meets this, and a teacher who has thought of it beforehand meets it calmly. Plan B is not a second full lesson. It is a short list: if this happens, I will do that.
| If | Then (an example) |
|---|---|
| Few people come (three instead of fifteen) | Move into a circle. Skip the group work; do the activity as one conversation. Keep the closing. |
| Many more come (thirty instead of fifteen) | Split into pairs or threes. Ask a helper to take a second group. Print extra, or write the key words on the board. |
| Time is cut (twenty minutes instead of forty-five) | Keep the goal, the opening line and the closing. Do one activity, not two. |
| Equipment fails (no power, no projector) | Use the paper copy. Read the passage aloud. Draw on a sheet or on a board. |
| The room changes (another group is using it) | Move to the hall or outside. Keep the closing, even if only standing in a ring. |
| The key helper is absent | Take the helper's part yourself, in a shortened form, or leave it out and tell the learners what you left out. |
Notice what each answer protects: the goal, and the closing that gathers the evidence. When the plan has to shrink, shrink the middle. Do not shrink the end.
7. A plan small enough to teach
A last principle ties the lecture together. A plan that cannot be taught in the time, in the room and with the people you have is not a plan; it is a hope. Better a modest plan that is taught as written than an ambitious one that falls apart at minute twenty. The plan of a beginner and the plan of an experienced teacher can look much the same on paper; the difference is that the experienced teacher cuts more quickly.
Diagram 1. A 45-minute timetable
Diagram 2. Plan B at a glance
| If | Keep | Shrink |
|---|---|---|
| Few come | The goal and the closing | Group work |
| Many come | The goal and the closing | Teaching by you; use pairs and helpers |
| Time is cut | The goal, the opening line, the closing | Activities: do one, not two |
| Equipment fails | The goal and the closing | Anything that needs power |
In short
- A plan must fit the real length of the lesson, and must leave a margin of unscheduled time.
- A 45-minute shape: opening 5, teaching 10, activity 15, closing 10, margin 5. Do not lengthen the teaching first.
- The room, seating and materials serve the goal; set up before the learners arrive.
- Find out the owner's terms before copying or showing materials, and follow local law and your community's rules.
- When the plan shrinks, keep the goal and the closing, and shrink the middle.
- A plan that cannot be taught as written is a hope, not a plan.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A 45-minute shape | Opening 5, teaching 10, activity 15, closing 10, margin 5. |
| What a margin is | Unscheduled time that absorbs a question, a late arrival or a slow activity. |
| Materials made by someone else | Find out the owner's terms; follow local law and your community's written rules. |
| What a Plan B keeps | The goal and the closing; shrink the middle. |
One sentence to remember A plan is a promise made to the clock, the room and the people who come; plan the promise you can keep.
This week's action Write a timetable for one real or invented lesson, with a margin, and write a Plan B for two things that could go wrong.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a lesson or meeting that ran out of time. Which part was lost? How could a margin have helped?
- In the room where you teach or learn, what would you change about seating, and what could you not change? What would you do about the second?
- What rules about copying and sharing apply where you are? Whom would you ask to find out?
- Write a Plan B for one lesson: what would you do if only a third of the people came, or if the power failed?
- Luke 14:28 asks a builder to count the cost first. What is the "cost" of a lesson that is planned for too much?