FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT707E Teaching Practicum: Designing, Teaching and Assessing a Lesson

Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback

Contents 31
PT707E Teaching Practicum: Designing, Teaching and Assessing a Lesson
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Lesson Is Learned, Not Only Taught
  1. Introduction: A Lesson Is Learned, Not Only Taught
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Designing One Lesson
  1. Lecture 1-1: Where Teaching Happens
  2. Lecture 1-2: Starting from the Evidence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
  4. Lecture 1-4: Who Is in the Room
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Lesson Plan
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Teaching the Lesson
  1. Lecture 2-1: The First and the Last Three Minutes
  2. Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
  3. Lecture 2-3: Room for Everyone
  4. Lecture 2-4: Teaching Through a Difficult Moment
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Ten Minutes Taught
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Checking What Was Learned
  1. Lecture 3-1: How Do You Know They Learned
  2. Lecture 3-2: Assessment That Respects the Learner
  3. Lecture 3-3: Short Checks, Well Made
  4. Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Check for Your Plan
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Watching and Feedback
  1. Lecture 4-1: Watching a Lesson
  2. Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher
  3. Lecture 4-3: Hearing the Learners
  4. Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Observation Sheet
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Different Learners, Different Places
  1. Lecture 5-1: Children and Young People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Adults and Lay Training
  3. Lecture 5-3: Mixed Ages, Online and Blended
  4. Lecture 5-4: Lessons in Another Language or Culture
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, One Lesson, Two Rooms
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Revising and Teaching for the Long Run
  1. Lecture 6-1: Revising the Lesson
  2. Lecture 6-2: Authority, Dignity and Questions
  3. Lecture 6-3: Teaching Together and Sharing Honestly
  4. Lecture 6-4: Teaching Over the Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Three-Month Teaching Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

27 min

Giving feedback is a skill. Receiving it is a harder one, and it is taught less often. A teacher who has prepared a lesson with care, taught it, and then heard that it did not work, has to do something difficult with that news: hear it, sort it, and decide what to do, without being crushed and without shutting it out.

The two failures are easy to name. One is to defend: to explain, excuse, or argue until the person giving feedback gives up. The other is to collapse: to take every comment as proof that one is not fit to teach. Both leave the lesson no better than before. Between them lies a quieter way of working, which this lecture sets out in plain steps.

The lecture also says what to do in a harder case. Sometimes what arrives is not feedback. It is a campaign against a teacher, or a pattern of public humiliation. A teacher should know that this is not part of learning to teach, and that there is a person to go to.

What these 27 minutes give you

  • Describe a way of receiving feedback that neither defends nor collapses.
  • Sort a set of comments into those that help, those that cannot yet be judged, and those not for you, and choose one change.
  • Explain how to receive praise so that it teaches, and why a teacher is more than one lesson.
  • Say what to do when feedback hurts a great deal.
  • Recognise when feedback has become bullying, and name what a teacher may do.

The ear that listens to reproof lives, and will be at home among the wise." — Proverbs 15:31

World English Bible

He who refuses correction despises his own soul, but he who listens to reproof gets understanding." — Proverbs 15:32

WEB

Whoever loves correction loves knowledge, but he who hates reproof is stupid." — Proverbs 12:1

WEB

Yahweh sent Nathan to David. He came to him, and said to him, “There were two men in one city; the one rich, and the other poor. The rich man had very many flocks and herds, but the poor man had nothing, except one little ewe lamb, which he had bought and raised. It grew up together with him, and with his children. It ate of his own food, drank of his own cup, and lay in his bosom, and was to him like a daughter. A traveler came to the rich man, and he spared to take of his own flock and of his own herd, to dress for the wayfaring man who had come to him, but took the poor man’s lamb, and dressed it for the man who had come to him.” David’s anger was greatly kindled against the man, and he said to Nathan, “As Yahweh lives, the man who has done this is worthy to die! He shall restore the lamb fourfold, because he did this thing, and because he had no pity!” Nathan said to David, “You are the man. This is what Yahweh, the God of Israel, says: ‘I anointed you king over Israel, and I delivered you out of the hand of Saul." — 2 Samuel 12:1-7

WEB

The proverbs praise the person who listens to correction. The story of Nathan and David is a hard case: a prophet tells a king, by way of a story, something the king did not want to know. We shall use it with care, because it concerns a grave wrong and a king, and a lesson that ran badly is a far smaller thing.

1. Why it is hard

Imagine that you have taught a class for a year. You have prepared on weekday evenings. You have bought materials with your own money, or stayed late to tidy the room. A colleague sits in and afterwards says, gently and accurately, that the instruction at the start of the group work was unclear and cost five minutes. She is right.

You may feel several things at once. You may feel that she is right. You may feel stung. You may feel that she does not know how much you do. You may feel that you are no good at this. You may feel tired. None of these is a fault, and all of them are common. A teacher's work is bound up with her care for the learners, and a comment on the work can feel like a comment on the care.

The Book of Proverbs speaks of the one who listens to correction as wise, and the one who refuses it as one who "despises his own soul" (Proverbs 15:32). It is a strong saying. Notice what it asks: it asks us to listen. It does not ask us to agree with everything that is said, or to feel nothing. A person can listen to correction, feel the sting, and still make her own decision. The skill of receiving feedback is the skill of listening well while hurting a little.

The strongest case for guarding oneself. There is a view, held by thoughtful teachers, that a teacher who takes in every piece of feedback will be pulled in twenty directions and lose her own judgment. Not all feedback is wise. Some comes from people who have not taught. Some comes from a single bad day. A teacher has the right, and sometimes the duty, to keep her own counsel. This view is right about something real, and the steps below leave room for it.

The strongest case for openness. There is another view, also held by thoughtful teachers, that a teacher who is afraid of correction cannot improve, because she cannot see her own work. Those who "refuse correction" are not protected by their refusal; they lose the one thing that could help them. This too is right about something real.

This lecture asks for both: to listen openly, and to decide carefully.

2. Six steps for receiving feedback

One: listen to the end. Do not interrupt. If the person is making a point you disagree with, let her finish it. You will understand it better, and she will be able to tell that you took it seriously.

Two: say thank you. You do not have to say that you agree. Say, "Thank you for telling me." It is polite, honest and costs nothing. It also keeps the person willing to speak to you again.

Three: ask to understand, not to reply. Questions such as "What did you see?" "Which moment do you mean?" "What would you have wanted to happen?" help you to see the comment more clearly. Avoid questions that are really arguments ("Surely you could see that I had only five minutes?").

Four: write it down. Write the comments in the person's words, as nearly as you can. This helps you to hear them again later, and it slows your first reaction, which is often to defend.

Five: wait. Where you can, wait a day before deciding what a comment means. The first reaction to a comment is often the least reliable. A day often turns "She does not understand" into "She may have a point," or the other way.

Six: sort, and choose one. Go through what you wrote and put each comment in one of three places:

  • Helps. It matches something I noticed, or it shows me something I can see is true.
  • I cannot tell yet. I do not know whether it is right. I will watch for it next time, or ask someone else.
  • Not for me. I have thought about it, and it does not fit my lesson or my learners, or it asks for something I cannot do. I may set it down.

Then choose one thing from the first group and decide what you will try. Not all of them. One. Lecture 3-4 described how a teacher chooses one change after a lesson; the same rule applies here.

Here is how the first of these steps looks in a real exchange, and how it can go wrong.

(An invented example.) A teacher has just heard that her instruction at 10:07 was unclear.

A reply that defends A reply that listens
"Well, I did say it was on the sheet. They should have looked. And the sheets were only printed that morning." "Thank you. Can you say what you saw the learners do after I said it?"
"The class is always like that. It has nothing to do with me." "I did not notice that at the time. I will think about it."
"That's your opinion." "That's useful to know. I will try writing it on the board and see what happens."

The left column feels natural. Each answer protects the teacher for a moment. But each also tells the observer that her words were unwelcome, and that next time she should say less.

3. Praise is feedback too

Some teachers find praise harder to receive than criticism. They wave it away: "Oh, it was nothing." "Anyone could have done it." This is a mistake for a plain reason. Praise that is specific tells you what to keep. If an observer says that your waiting after the question helped six people to write, that is a fact about your lesson that you did not know. If you brush it off, you may stop doing it.

Receive praise the way you receive any comment. Listen, say thank you, write it down. You do not have to feel that you deserve it, and you do not have to feel proud. Treat it as information.

There is a quieter trap on the other side. A teacher can come to depend on praise, and to feel that a lesson was good only when someone says so. That too makes it hard to learn, because the teacher begins to teach for the praise. The best teachers' groups make praise specific and ordinary, so that it informs and does not rule.

4. When two comments disagree

One observer says the pace was too slow. Another says it was too fast. A learner's slip says the reading was long; another says she wanted more of it. This is common, and it is not a sign that someone is wrong.

When comments disagree, go back to the aim. Ask: what was this lesson for, and what did I see that shows whether it was reached? Opinions about pace point in different directions; the evidence of what the learners could do points to a single answer. If you cannot decide, treat the disagreement itself as a finding and try a small change and watch.

5. When feedback is wrong

An observer may be mistaken. She may have misread a silence, or missed something that happened before she came. You are free to say so, once, kindly, and with evidence: "I think that the quiet at 7:22 was thinking. Three people wrote something afterwards." If she accepts that, good. If she does not, you may agree to differ. You do not have to take on a conclusion that you believe is false. You do have to hear it first.

The difference between a defence and a correction is this. A defence is made to protect the teacher, and it turns the conversation toward her. A correction is made to improve the record, and it turns the conversation back to what happened.

6. When it hurts

Sometimes feedback hurts out of proportion to what was said. It lingers for days. A teacher may feel that she has failed, or that she should not teach any more.

Some things may help. First, remember that you are more than one lesson. A lesson is one hour, on one day, with one group. It tells you something about that hour. It does not tell you what you are worth or whether you are called to teach. The record of one lesson is not a record of a person.

Second, separate the comment from the feeling. You may say to yourself, "I feel ashamed. That is what I feel. What was actually said?" Write what was said in the observer's own words. It is often smaller than the feeling.

Third, talk to someone who is on your side: a friend, a fellow teacher, a pastor, a priest. You need not carry it alone. Choose a person who will listen and not add to the hurt.

Fourth, take a rest from it. A teacher does not have to revise the lesson on the night she hears the news.

Teaching is not the only matter in a person's life, and a hard comment on a lesson can fall on someone who is already carrying a great deal. If a teacher finds that she is deeply low, cannot sleep or eat, loses interest in everything, or has thoughts of harming herself, this has gone beyond a teaching matter. She should speak at once to a trusted person, such as a pastor, a priest, a doctor or a counsellor, and, if there is danger now, call the local emergency number or crisis line. This lecture gives no advice about such things beyond that. No one should be left to deal with them alone.

7. The story of Nathan and David

The account in 2 Samuel is useful for one particular reason, and has a limit that must be stated first. It concerns a king who had done a grave wrong, and a prophet sent to tell him of it. It is not an account of a teacher and an observer, and nobody should treat an observer's comment about a lesson as though it carried the weight of a prophet's word. The matter in the lesson is small by comparison.

With that said, the story shows three things about how people receive hard words.

First, Nathan does not begin with an accusation. He tells a story, about a rich man and a poor man's lamb, and lets David hear it. The telling is careful and patient. David is a good listener to a story.

Second, David's first response is to judge someone else. "His anger was greatly kindled against the man," and he declares what the man deserves (2 Samuel 12:5-6). That is how most of us respond to a story about someone else's fault: we see it clearly. Then Nathan says, "You are the man" (12:7). The hearer finds that the story was about him.

Third, the account goes on to show David acknowledging what he had done, without arguing it away. The text does not say it was easy, and we should not say so either. But it shows that the receiving of a hard word can be a turning point and need not be an end.

What can a teacher take from this? Not that every comment is a prophecy. Rather that a person's first reaction to a hard word, whether anger or a judgment of someone else, may not be the last, and that there is a way of hearing that stays long enough to understand. Often the comment we most want to reject has something in it.

8. When feedback becomes bullying

Everything so far assumes good faith. A teacher should also know that not all comments come in good faith, and what to do when they do not.

Feedback has turned into bullying when one or more of these is true:

  • It is about the person, not the lesson: age, voice, accent, appearance, background, standing.
  • It is repeated, over weeks, by the same person or group, long after the point was made.
  • It is public and was not invited, in front of learners or other teachers.
  • It comes with a threat, or with an attempt to push the teacher out, or with exclusion from the group.
  • It is anonymous, spread by rumour, or told to others and not to the teacher.
  • It is used as a weapon in another quarrel, with the lesson as an excuse.

A teacher who meets this has not done anything wrong. She does not have to accept it as feedback, try harder to please, or answer in kind. These are the steps she can take.

Keep a short, dated record. Write down what was said or done, when, and who was present, in plain words, without comment. This helps her to remember, and it helps the responsible person to understand.

Do not retaliate. It is natural to want to answer in kind, but a reply in anger gives the other person a reason to say that she is the difficult one.

Take it to the responsible person. In most communities there is someone who is in charge of teaching, or someone named in the written rules for handling such matters: a coordinator, a pastor, a priest, a senior or a safeguarding person. Go to that person, show the record, and say plainly what you need. If the responsible person is part of the problem, go to the next person named in the rules, or to a trusted pastor, priest or elder outside the situation.

Look after yourself. Tell someone who is on your side. If you are being threatened with harm, or there is danger now, call the local emergency number. If you feel that you cannot go on, talk to a pastor, a doctor or a counsellor, or a crisis line.

None of this is a matter that a church or community should leave to individuals. A group that has agreed rules of the kind in lecture 4-2 is far less likely to see bullying, and more likely to deal with it quickly if it comes. Local law and the community's written rules apply here, and this lecture does not give legal advice.

9. Choosing one change

The end of receiving feedback is a decision. Take the comments you marked as helpful. Choose one. State it as something you will do in the next lesson, in a sentence that could be checked: "I will write the group instruction on the board, and I will ask one learner to say it back." Put it where you will see it when you plan the next lesson. Lecture 6-1 returns to this: the cycle of design, teach, check, feedback and revise turns on a single change at a time.


Diagram 1. From a comment heard to one change

Receiving Feedback Listen, sort, choose one change 1 Listen to the end say thank you ask to understand 2 Write in their words do not argue or explain 3 Wait a day, if you can the first reaction is not the last 4 Sort helps cannot tell yet not for me 5 Choose one change you can check Two ways to go wrong Defend Explain, excuse, argue. The observer learns to say less next time. Collapse Take every comment as proof of unfitness. One lesson is one hour, not a person. Between them Listen openly. Decide carefully. A comment may be right in part. You owe a hearing, not obedience. When it is bullying About the person; repeated; public and uninvited; with a threat; by rumour; used as a weapon What you may do 1. Keep a short, dated record 2. Do not retaliate 3. Take it to the responsible person 4. Tell someone on your side In danger now: the local emergency number. Deeply low: a pastor, a doctor, a crisis line.

Diagram 2. Sorting what you heard

Where it goes What it means What to do
Helps It matches something I noticed, or I can see it is true Choose one of these to try next time
I cannot tell yet I do not know whether it is right Watch for it next time, or ask someone else
Not for me It does not fit my learners, or I cannot do it Think it over, thank the person, and set it down

In short

  • Receive feedback without defending and without collapsing: listen to the end, thank, ask to understand, write it down, wait, sort.
  • Sort comments into helps, cannot tell yet, and not for me, then choose one change you can check.
  • Praise is feedback: specific praise tells you what to keep, and it should be heard and written down.
  • You are more than one lesson. If feedback leaves you deeply low, speak to a trusted person; in danger now, call the emergency number.
  • Nathan's story shows a first reaction that is not the last, but a lesson is a far smaller matter than a king's grave wrong.
  • Feedback about the person, repeated, public, threatening or used as a weapon is bullying: keep a dated record and go to the responsible person.
Front Back
Two ways to go wrong Defending (explaining and arguing until the observer gives up) and collapsing (taking each comment as proof of unfitness).
Three places to sort a comment Helps; I cannot tell yet; not for me. Then choose one change from the first.
You are more than one lesson A lesson is one hour with one group; it does not measure the teacher's worth or calling.
When feedback is bullying Keep a short dated record, do not retaliate, and take it to the responsible person named in the community's rules.

One sentence to remember Listen well, sort what you heard, choose one change, and remember that you are more than one lesson.

This week's action Take a comment you once received and sort it: helps, cannot tell, or not for me. If it helps, write one change you could try.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • When you have been corrected, what was your first reaction? Defend, collapse, or something else? What helped you to hear it?
  • Why does the lecture say that "you are more than one lesson"? What would you say to a teacher who feels the opposite?
  • Two observers give opposite advice about pace. How does the lecture suggest you decide?
  • Nathan began with a story, not with an accusation. Where might a story, or a question, help a hard word be heard? Where would it be a trick?
  • A teacher is told, repeatedly and in public, that her accent is a disgrace. Is this feedback? What may she do?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.