FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting

Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help

Contents 31
PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Church, Mental Health and the Leader's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Noticing
  1. Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
  2. Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
  3. Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Other Kinds of Difficulty
  1. Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
  2. Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Staying Beside and Connecting
  1. Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
  2. Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
  3. Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Carers and the Leader's Own Mind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
  3. Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Congregation Friendlier to Mental Health
  1. Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Small Groups and Gatherings
  3. Lecture 6-3: Access: Space, Time, Cost and Language
  4. Lecture 6-4: Systems and Many Contexts
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Mental Health Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

A pastor has helped a member reach a doctor, and the member has begun to receive care. The pastor wonders what to do now. Should he stop visiting, since the professionals have taken over? Should he ask how it is going, and what the doctor said? Should he be more careful, or more cheerful? An elder hears that a woman in her group has been going to a counsellor for some weeks, and she does not know whether to mention it or say nothing. A volunteer sees a friend in the mission team come back after a long absence, apparently well, and wonders whether the matter is over.

This lecture is about the long middle of care: staying beside a person who is getting professional help. The leader's work does not end when the person is connected. It changes. The professional does one kind of work, and the church does another, and the person needs both. This lecture explains what belongs to whom, why changes in treatment belong only to the treating professional, why a leader does not probe, what ups and downs are to be expected, and what practical and spiritual company looks like.

The central claim to which every week returns is this: a church leader is not a diagnostician but someone who notices, stays beside, and connects. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. The leader has a mind and limits too, and receives help. This lecture is about the middle verb.

This course is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment, and it does not replace professional care. A leader never advises anyone to stop, start, skip or change a medicine or any other treatment. Those decisions belong to the prescriber or treating professional, and nothing in this lecture says otherwise.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Explain what belongs to the treating professional and what belongs to the church, and why they do not compete.
  • Say plainly what a leader does when a person wants to stop or change treatment, or has been told by someone else to do so.
  • Describe why a leader does not probe, and what a leader may ask instead.
  • Describe why a person's progress goes up and down, and how a leader responds to good weeks and bad weeks without judgement.
  • Describe practical and spiritual company that respects the person's dignity and does not take over.

We exhort you, brothers, admonish the disorderly, encourage the faint-hearted, support the weak, be patient toward all." — 1 Thessalonians 5:14

World English Bible

A friend loves at all times; and a brother is born for adversity." — Proverbs 17:17

WEB

Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor." — Ecclesiastes 4:9

WEB

For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow; but woe to him who is alone when he falls, and doesn’t have another to lift him up." — Ecclesiastes 4:10

WEB

He won’t break a bruised reed. He won’t quench a dimly burning wick. He will faithfully bring justice." — Isaiah 42:3

WEB

He heals the broken in heart, and binds up their wounds." — Psalm 147:3

WEB

Let us not be weary in doing good, for we will reap in due season, if we don’t give up." — Galatians 6:9

WEB

Come to me, all you who labor and are heavily burdened, and I will give you rest." — Matthew 11:28

WEB

Paul asks the church to encourage the faint-hearted, support the weak and be patient toward all, which is a description of the long middle of care. A friend loves at all times, and a brother is born for adversity. Two are better than one, and the one who falls is lifted by another. The servant of God will not break a bruised reed or put out a dimly burning wick, which is a picture of a gentle hand with something fragile. God heals the broken in heart and binds up their wounds, and the psalm does not say how, or through whom. The church is asked not to grow weary in doing good, and Jesus invites those who labour and are heavily burdened to come to him for rest. Staying beside is slow work. It is done with patience, without pressure, and with open eyes to the fact that God may work through many hands, including those of doctors and counsellors.

1. After the connection

When a person begins to receive professional help, a leader may feel two opposite things. One is relief: the person is in good hands, and the burden is lighter. The other is a kind of vertigo: the leader's role is no longer clear. Both feelings are normal. This lecture takes up the question of what is left for the church to do.

The answer is, a great deal. A person who is receiving professional care still has a family, a faith, a place in a community, a body that needs feeding and a week that needs a shape. They still have questions that a professional may not be set up to answer: Does God see me? Is this my fault? Will my church still want me? A professional works with the person for an hour or so at a time, in a particular way, for a particular purpose. The church is present for the rest of the week, in ordinary life.

This is why the second mistake of lecture 1-1, leaving out the spiritual, is so costly at this stage. A church that goes silent because "the professionals have it" leaves the person with less than they had. The leader does not take the professional's place, and does not step aside. The leader keeps being the person's friend, pastor and neighbour.

2. What belongs to whom

It helps to see the division of work plainly.

The treating professional (a doctor, a counsellor or another trained person) is responsible for understanding the person's difficulties, deciding about treatment, and changing, continuing or ending it. They have met the person, examined them where needed, and are trained and accountable for what they do.

The church is responsible for what a church gives: company, prayer if the person wants it, the Scriptures, the sacraments or practices of the tradition, belonging, practical help, and a steady presence. These are not second-class contributions. They are what the professionals are not set up to give, and the person needs them too.

The person remains the one who decides what to share, whom to trust and what to do, within their own treatment and their own life.

These three do not compete. A leader who thinks, "If I say too much, I will interfere" can be reassured: interference comes from stepping into the professional's work, not from friendship. A leader who thinks, "They are in treatment, so there is nothing for me to do" can be reassured too: the church's part is just as real.

3. Changes in treatment belong to the treating professional

This is the line that matters most in this lecture, and it is the same line as in lecture 1-3.

A leader never advises anyone to stop, start, skip or change a medicine, a course of treatment or an appointment pattern. Decisions about these belong to the prescriber or treating professional, who knows the person and is accountable for their care.

This line is not abstract. The following moments happen in churches, and the leader should be ready for them.

The person says, "I want to stop." They may feel better, or worse; they may dislike how treatment makes them feel; they may be afraid of what others think; they may feel that to need treatment shows weak faith. A leader should not argue, and should not say "yes, stop" or "no, you must go on". The leader can say: "Thank you for telling me. I can hear that it is hard. I am not able to advise you about your treatment, and I would not want you to change anything without the person who is treating you knowing. Would you like to tell them what you have told me? I would gladly go with you or help you to make the appointment." The leader then keeps listening, and keeps praying if the person wishes.

Someone else says, "You do not need it, you need more faith." This is a harmful thing to say, and it often comes from love, from fear or from a particular view of healing. A leader who hears it should say kindly to the person, not in public, that treatment and trust in God are not opposites (lecture 1-3), and that any change belongs with the person's own doctor or counsellor. A leader should not publicly shame the other speaker. The person can be told that the leader's own view is that seeking help is not a lack of faith.

The person says, "I feel much better now, so I don't need it." This is a hopeful sentence and a delicate one. The leader should rejoice with them, and should say that whether treatment should continue is a question for the person who is treating them. A leader does not say, "Good, you can stop," and does not say, "You must not stop." A leader says, "I am so glad you feel better. Please ask your doctor what they think."

The person says, "I don't think it is working." The leader says, "That is worth telling your doctor or counsellor. They would want to know." Offer help to arrange it. Do not offer a theory about why.

A family member asks the leader to make the person take or stop something. The leader says gently that this is not the leader's decision or the family's alone, and that the treating professional is the right person to speak with, with the person's consent. If there is danger, emergency services apply.

In every case, the pattern is the same: listen, thank, say honestly that you cannot advise, point to the treating professional, offer company. Fix this pattern in your mind. It protects the person, and it protects the leader from carrying a decision that was never theirs.

4. No probing

Many leaders, wanting to help and being curious, are tempted to ask the person what the professional said. "What did the doctor say? What is the diagnosis? What are they giving you? Is the counsellor any good? What did you talk about?" Each of these is a form of probing. A leader does not ask them.

There are three reasons.

  1. They are the person's own information. What passes between a person and their professional belongs to them. They may choose to tell you. It is not yours to ask for.
  2. They put the person in a bind. A person who does not wish to tell you must refuse, and may feel they have been unkind. A person who tells you may regret it later.
  3. They turn a friend into an inspector. The person wants to be met, not checked.

What may a leader ask? Something simple and open: "How are you today?" "Is there anything I can do this week?" "How can I pray for you?" (only if the person wants prayer, and asking the words they would like used). "Would you like company on the way to your next appointment?" If the person chooses to tell you something about their care, listen, and do not offer your own opinion on it. Say, "Thank you for telling me." Do not repeat it to others without the person's permission (lecture 4-4).

5. Ups and downs

Progress is rarely a straight line. A person receiving help may have a good week and then a hard one. They may feel better for some time and then find the heaviness returning. They may feel worse before they feel better, or for reasons that have nothing to do with the care they are receiving. A leader should expect this, and should not be surprised or alarmed by it.

Some things to remember.

A bad week is not a failed treatment, and not a failure of faith. A leader who says, "I thought you were getting help," or "Are you praying enough?" adds weight. A bad week is a good moment for presence, not for questions about cause.

A good week is not the end. A leader who says, "Great, you're fixed," may leave the person alone just as a hard week returns, or may make them feel they must keep up an appearance of being well.

Do not compare. "My cousin was cured in a month" or "I know someone who just prayed and was healed" are not helpful, even when true. They suggest the person is slower, or less faithful. Each person's path is their own.

Do not set a timetable. "You should be over this by now" is a burden, however kindly it is meant.

Stay in the same way. The kind of presence that was right in the first weeks is usually right still: a visit, a call, a place at the table, a prayer if wanted. Constancy matters more than intensity. Paul's phrase is "be patient toward all" (1 Thessalonians 5:14).

If a bad week brings the person to speak of ending their life, or puts them or anyone else in danger now, the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response applies, and emergency services are the first call.

6. Practical company

Practical help is often the most welcome. It is also easy to do badly, by taking over.

Ask, then offer concrete help. "Could I bring a meal on Tuesday, or would you rather I did not?" is better than "Let me know if you need anything." Offer specific things: a lift to an appointment, care for a child for an afternoon, help with shopping, a walk, company on a hard evening.

Keep the person's place. A person receiving help should not lose their roles in the church unless they ask to step back. If they have a duty that has become too much, offer to share it, and ask what would help, rather than removing it. A sudden removal, however kind, can sound like "you are not wanted".

Do not announce. Whether to tell the group or the congregation is the person's decision (lecture 4-4). Do not turn a private matter into a prayer item or a piece of news without the person's clear consent.

Respect refusal. If the person says no to an offer, accept it. They may say yes next time.

Include, without pressing. Invite the person to ordinary events as before. They may come or may not. The invitation itself says: you belong.

7. Spiritual company

A person receiving professional care still has a spiritual life, and the leader's part is to stay beside it.

Pray if the person wishes. Ask in what words. Keep prayers short, warm and free of instruction.

Read and listen according to the person's wish. Some find comfort in a psalm read slowly. Some cannot read at all at present. Some cannot pray, and lecture 3-4 takes that up. Do not push.

Do not use Scripture as a weapon. Do not quote it to correct, to speed recovery or to hint that the person is lacking. Psalm 147:3 says God heals the broken in heart and binds up their wounds; it does not say how, and it is not a verse to be used to dismiss a doctor.

Allow questions and doubts. The person may ask, "Why is God allowing this?" or "Why do I feel nothing when I pray?" You need not answer. Say, "I do not know either. I am here, and I will keep praying." The course on suffering and illness in general takes up the larger question.

If the person tells you something in their care conflicts with what they believe, such as a counsellor who said something that troubles their faith, or a spiritual teaching that seems to clash with a doctor's advice, do not take sides at once. Ask what troubles them. Offer to help them put the question to the professional. If the question concerns a matter of the tradition, you may speak within your tradition and say so, without asking the person to give up their treatment. They should not have to choose between the two.

8. Working with the professional

A leader may sometimes wish to speak with the person's doctor or counsellor. This should happen only with the person's clear consent, only about what the person agrees may be shared, and with the understanding that the professional will probably say very little back, because they have their own duties of confidence (check locally). If a professional contacts a leader, the leader should ask whether the person knows and has agreed, and should say only what is needed. In danger, other principles apply (lecture 4-4).

9. The community around the person

The person's family and their church also need care. A spouse or parent may be worried or weary; lecture 5-1 takes this up. The wider congregation may be curious, and a gentle word from a leader, without detail, can protect the person: "She is receiving care and would like us to treat her as we always have. If you would like to help, a warm greeting is plenty." Do not say more than the person has agreed to.

10. The leader's own limits

Staying beside someone for a long time is tiring. A leader who is the only person staying will wear away, and the person is then left with less. Share the care, with the person's consent, with one or two others who can be trusted to keep it private. Set a limit on what you can give, and say it kindly. Talk to a colleague, a supervisor or a friend about how you are, without giving the person's details. Lecture 5-3 takes up burnout, rest and limits. You also receive help.

11. Two examples

(an invented example) Thornfield Mission Chapel is a small congregation of about twenty-five people. A member, Amara, has begun to receive care from a counsellor and has told only the pastor, Josef. Josef does not ask what the sessions are about. Each Thursday he rings her and asks, "How are you today? Is there anything I can do this week?" Once she says she has had a very hard few days, and that she thought of stopping going. Josef says, "Thank you for telling me. I am glad you did. I cannot advise about your care, and I think this is something to tell your counsellor, because they would want to know. Would you like me to come with you, or to wait with you before you go?" Amara goes, tells the counsellor, and later tells Josef she is glad she did. Josef never learns the content of the sessions, and does not need to.

(an invented example) Wexcombe Cathedral Parish is a large parish with several clergy and a lay care team. A man named Ibrahim, who sings in the choir, has been away for some time and returns after treatment. A well-meaning parishioner says loudly after the service, "You must be better now, praise God!" Ibrahim smiles tightly and goes home early. The care coordinator, Helen, notices, and later writes to him: "I am glad to see you. There is no need to explain anything to anyone. If you would like to sing, there is a place for you. If you would rather sit, there is a place for that too." In a large parish, a single quiet message may do more than the public welcome. Helen also speaks, without naming him, to the choir about not commenting on anyone's health.

In both, the leader neither stepped in nor stepped out. Each stayed beside.

12. What a leader takes from this lecture

  1. Staying beside does not end when the person is connected; it changes.
  2. The professional treats; the church accompanies; they do not compete.
  3. Changes in treatment belong to the treating professional. A leader never advises stopping or changing; listen, thank, say honestly that you cannot advise, point to the professional, offer company.
  4. Do not probe; ask how the person is, not what the professional said.
  5. Expect ups and downs; a bad week is neither failed treatment nor failed faith, and a good week is not the end.
  6. Offer concrete practical help, keep the person's place, and do not announce.
  7. Spiritual company is offered, not imposed; Scripture is never a weapon.
  8. Share the care, and receive help yourself.

Diagram 1. Who does what

Who does what Three parts, no competition The treating professional Understands the difficulty. Decides about treatment, and about changing or ending it. The church Company, prayer if wanted, Scripture, belonging, practical help, a steady presence. The person Decides what to share, whom to trust and what to do in their own life. The line A leader never advises anyone to stop, start, skip or change a medicine or treatment. That belongs to the treating professional.

Diagram 2. When a person says "I want to stop"

When a person says "I want to stop" Five moves, in order 1 Listen Let the person finish. Do not argue, and do not say yes or no. 2 Thank "Thank you for telling me. I can hear that it is hard." 3 Be honest about the limit "I cannot advise about your treatment." 4 Point to the treating professional "Please tell them what you have told me before changing anything." 5 Offer company "I will go with you, or help you make the appointment, and I will go on praying if you wish."

In short

  • Staying beside a person who is getting professional help does not end when they are connected; it changes.
  • The treating professional treats, the church accompanies with company, prayer if wanted, belonging and practical help, and the person decides what to share.
  • A leader never advises anyone to stop, start, skip or change a medicine or treatment; those decisions belong to the treating professional.
  • When a person wants to stop or has been told to stop, the leader listens, thanks, says honestly that they cannot advise, points to the treating professional, and offers company.
  • A leader does not probe: no questions about diagnosis, medicine or what was said in sessions.
  • Progress goes up and down; a bad week is not a failed treatment or failed faith, and a good week is not the end.
  • Practical help is concrete and asked about; spiritual company is offered, not imposed, and Scripture is never a weapon.
  • The leader shares the care and receives help too.
Front Back
Who decides about treatment The treating professional, with the person; a leader never advises stopping or changing.
Reply to "I want to stop" Listen; thank; say honestly "I cannot advise"; point to the treating professional; offer company or help with an appointment.
What to ask "How are you today? Is there anything I can do this week?" Not what the professional said.
Ups and downs A bad week is not failed treatment or faith; a good week is not the end; stay in the same way.

One sentence to remember The professional treats; the church stays beside; and the decisions about treatment belong to the person and the professional.

This week's action Write down the five-part pattern for when a person wants to stop or change treatment (listen, thank, honest limit, point to the treating professional, offer company), and say it aloud once to a colleague so that it is ready.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why might a leader be tempted to step aside once a person is getting professional help? What would the person lose?
  • Why does the course say that a leader never advises stopping or changing treatment, even when the leader feels sure? What does the leader do instead?
  • What is the difference between "How are you today?" and "What did the doctor say?" Why does it matter?
  • How would your community respond to a person who is better one week and worse the next? What sentences would you want to avoid?
  • Thornfield Mission Chapel is small, and Wexcombe Cathedral Parish is large. What would "staying beside" look like in your setting, and who could share the care with you?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.