Lecture 2-3: Children and Others Standing Close
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What We Mean by Addiction
- Lecture 1-2: Substances and Behaviours: One Pattern, Many Faces
- Lecture 1-3: Body, Mind, Relationships, Spirit: Why One Lens Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Stigma and Grace
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Listening to Our Own Words
- Lecture 2-1: The Family as a System
- Lecture 2-2: Codependency, Helping and Enabling
- Lecture 2-3: Children and Others Standing Close
- Lecture 2-4: The Carer Who Is Also Hurt
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: First Words to a Family
- Lecture 3-1: Recovery as a Long Road
- Lecture 3-2: The First Conversation and Readiness
- Lecture 3-3: Relapse: Meeting It Without Despair or Denial
- Lecture 3-4: A Whole Life Rebuilt: Work, Sleep, Friends, Faith
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Day of a Relapse, First Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: How Mutual-Help Groups Are Built
- Lecture 4-2: The Spiritual Side of the Steps and the Church's Own Gospel
- Lecture 4-3: Hosting a Recovery Group: Space, Welcome, Boundaries
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and the Church's Talk
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Hosting Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: Medicine, Treatment and the Church: Who Does What
- Lecture 5-2: Withdrawal and Emergencies: Connecting to Medical Help
- Lecture 5-3: Referring Well and Walking Alongside
- Lecture 5-4: Tangled Troubles: Other Health Needs, Money, Law
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Referral Map
Addiction does not touch only the person who struggles and one spouse. It reaches children who cannot yet understand it, parents who wonder what they did, brothers and sisters, friends who are slowly losing a friend, and colleagues who cover for someone at work. Each stands in a different place and needs something different. A church that sees only "the person" and "the husband or wife" will overlook many who are hurting.
This lecture looks first at children, whose needs are the most urgent and whose voice is the weakest. Then it turns to partners, parents, friends and colleagues. Throughout, it asks what a community can do that is gentle, honest and within its limits.
The central claim of the course applies. Addiction is not explained by moral failure alone or by illness alone. A church does not replace the treating professional, and it does not replace the people who love the person. It is a community that stays beside, connects, and waits, and it also knows its limits.
This course does not replace medical or treatment care. If anyone in the household, adult or child, shows danger signs such as loss of consciousness or severe confusion, medical help is needed at once. If a child may be unsafe, the matter is no longer one for quiet pastoral care alone; see the section on safety below.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe what children in a household with addiction commonly need: safety, truth in a form they can bear, a steady adult and permission to be a child.
- Explain why a child should not be asked to keep an adult's secret or to carry an adult's role.
- Name what partners, parents, siblings, friends and colleagues each commonly face, and one thing a church can offer each.
- Say when concern for a child becomes a safety matter that must be taken to the proper people.
He took a little child, and set him in their midst. Taking him in his arms, he said to them," — Mark 9:36
World English Bible
Whoever receives one such little child in my name, receives me, and whoever receives me, doesn’t receive me, but him who sent me.”" — Mark 9:37
WEB
Whoever receives one such little child in my name receives me," — Matthew 18:5
WEB
When my father and my mother forsake me, then Yahweh will take me up." — Psalm 27:10
WEB
Mark 9:36-37 shows Jesus placing a child in the middle of a room of adults and holding him. Receiving a child is, he says, receiving him. Psalm 27:10 is the prayer of someone whose own parents have failed, and who finds that God has not. Neither text says what to do about a particular family, but together they set the posture: the child is placed at the centre of the community’s attention, held, and not left alone.
1. What a child sees and does not say
Children notice more than adults think. A child may not know the word "addiction", but knows that a parent is different on some evenings. A child learns the signs: the tone of a voice at the door, a closed bedroom, a smell, a sudden quiet at the table, a promise that is not kept. Children also learn what is not to be said. By seven or eight, many have worked out that they must not ask, must not tell, and must watch.
Children respond in different ways. Some become very good: tidy, helpful, always on time. Some become very bad: restless, angry, at war with teachers. Some become invisible. Some turn into small adults, caring for younger children, cooking, holding the mother when she cries. Some become ill with no medical cause, with stomach aches or headaches that come on school mornings. Many feel, without being able to say so, that something about them has caused the trouble, or that if they were better, it would stop. None of these ways is a sign of a defective child. They are what children do when a home is not predictable.
Please do not read this list as a checklist for diagnosing a child. A tired child is not necessarily a hurt child, and many children in homes with addiction grow up well, especially when there is one steady adult who loves them. That last point matters most.
2. What a child needs
Let us put it in four plain needs.
- Safety. A child needs a body that is safe and an adult who is awake to it. This comes before everything else.
- Truth, at the child’s size. Children cope better with a simple, true account than with silence or an invented story. A child can be told, in words fitting their age, that a parent has a sickness that makes it hard to do some things; that it is not the child’s fault; that it is not the child’s job to fix it; and that there are grown-ups taking care of it. A very young child needs only a few sentences. An older child needs room to ask. In every case the account should be given by someone the child trusts, and it should be agreed with the parents where this is possible and safe. What is told should not set the child against a parent, and should not frighten with more than the child can hold.
- One steady adult. It need not be a parent. It can be a grandparent, an aunt, a neighbour, a teacher, a Sunday-school leader. What matters is that someone is reliably present, and will remain so.
- Permission to be a child. A child needs to play, to be late with homework, to be silly, and to have time that is not about the trouble at home. Children should not be asked to be the comforter, the messenger or the keeper of secrets.
A short sentence summarises what a child wants to hear, often without being able to ask: "It is not your fault, you are not alone, and there are people who are looking after this." It is not a promise that everything will be well. It is a promise about the child's place.
3. What a child must not be asked to do
There are things we sometimes ask, thoughtlessly, of children in difficult homes.
- To keep an adult’s secret. "Don't tell anyone Daddy was ill." A child asked to hide the family's trouble carries a weight that is too big, and may learn that adults who care for them are not to be told the truth. A church worker should never ask a child to keep a secret from the parents or the church, and should never promise a child absolute secrecy. If a child begins to tell you something, say that you will listen, and say honestly that if you hear something that means the child is not safe, you will have to tell another adult whose job is to help.
- To act as the go-between. "Tell your mother I'm sorry." "Ask your father if he'll come."
- To take over an adult’s role. Cooking for the family each night for months, tending a parent, managing money or looking after younger children beyond what suits their age.
- To report on a parent. "Is he drinking again?" A child asked to watch an adult carries a role that does not belong to a child.
- To "pray him better". A child may be told to pray every night for a parent to stop. If the parent does not stop, the child may conclude that God did not hear, or that their prayers were not good enough. Children can and do pray, but it is not a child's task to make a parent well.
4. The church and the child
A church that wishes to stand beside a child can do several things within its ordinary life.
- Make its children’s ministry a steady place. Familiar faces, a regular rhythm, a leader who remembers names. For some children, an hour on Sunday is the only predictable hour in the week.
- Train children’s leaders to notice and to listen. Not to investigate, but to notice a change and to be someone a child can approach. Leaders should also know what to do if a child says something that causes concern. The safe church course covers child protection and how to respond; here we say only that each leader should know the church’s policy and whom to tell.
- Guard the child’s dignity. Do not announce a family’s trouble in a class. Do not single a child out. Do not ask a child to say a prayer about a parent in front of others.
- Offer ordinary joys. A camp place, a lift to an activity, a birthday remembered. These are not extras; they are part of what keeps a child connected to life.
- Keep the door open to the family. A child rarely comes alone. If the parents feel welcome, the child comes.
(an invented example) In a small church of about forty people, a Sunday-school leader named Rosa notices that nine-year-old Danilo has stopped talking in class and falls asleep at the end of the hour. She does not ask him about home. She seats him near her, gives him a job handing out paper, and tells him she is glad he is there. She tells the pastor only that she has noticed a change and wants to know whom to ask if she is worried. She keeps coming, week after week, and one day he says, "My dad's in the hospital a lot." She says, "Thank you for telling me. I am sorry that's hard." She does not push him further. She does tell the pastor, who has a plan for what to do if a child reports something unsafe. She stays his steady adult.
(an invented example) In a large congregation with many children, the problem is that no one knows the child. A volunteer coordinator decides that every class will have two regular leaders for a year, not a rotation, so that children are known by name.
5. When it becomes a safety matter
Most children in these homes are loved and mostly safe. But some are not. When a child is hit, left alone for long periods, left without food or care, exposed to danger, or frightened in their own home, the situation is a safety matter, and a church worker must not handle it quietly or alone.
Hold these principles:
- A child’s safety is worth more than a family’s privacy.
- You are not asked to investigate or to decide. You are asked to tell the people whose job it is. In a church, that is usually the person named in the safe church policy. In some places a church worker has a legal duty to report to proper authorities; rules differ by country, region and role, so check locally.
- Do not promise secrecy. You may promise to be careful about who is told.
- Do not confront the adult first if doing so might put the child at greater risk. The safe church course covers what to do and in what order.
- Stay beside the child and the family as far as it is safe to do so.
If you are unsure whether something is a safety matter, ask. Ask the person responsible for safeguarding in your church or agency, or a qualified professional, before you act and before you say nothing.
6. Partners
Partners are the people most often thought of, and they have their own needs. A partner may be married to the person, or living with them, or may be a fiancé or a long-standing companion. They are often the ones who carry the money, the housework, the children and the lies. They may be unsure whether to stay. They may have stayed for many years and may be asked, "Why don't you leave?" Or they may have left and be told, "You have abandoned him."
A church should avoid both of these remarks. The decision to stay or to separate belongs to the partner, with proper advice. Where there is violence or fear, the partner’s safety comes first, and referral is required (see lecture 5-3 and the safe church course). Marriage and family matters belong to the marriage and family course.
What a church can offer a partner: someone who will listen without telling them what to do; time that is not about the person struggling; practical help; and, when they ask, introductions to services and groups for relatives. A partner who is told "God hates divorce" or "you must forgive" before anyone has listened may never come back.
7. Parents, brothers and sisters
When an adult child is struggling, parents may feel failure, shame, anger and grief, often together. They may also feel that they must protect the child, pay the debts or give the room back. They are in the same position as a partner, in a different set of relationships. In some cultures the parent’s shame is great, because a child’s trouble is thought to reflect on the family. A pastor who knows this will take extra care not to add to it.
Parents of younger people have another question: when is it right to step in, and when to let a young adult find their own way? That question is for a counsellor or trained professional, and a church can help find one.
Brothers and sisters are often forgotten. They may be angry about the attention that goes to the one who struggles, or guilty for being the "easy" one, or afraid that they will be next. They may have been the child who was invisible. A sibling may be the only person who knows the whole story. A church that asks a sibling how they are, and does not speak only of the one in trouble, gives something that is not often given.
8. Friends and colleagues
Friends are in a hard spot. They may be the first to see a change and the last to be told. They may lose a friend slowly, as the friendship becomes about the trouble or fades altogether. They may be asked to lend money, lie or keep a secret. Proverbs 17:17 says a friend loves at all times, which has comforted some and wearied others. A friend may be tired, and that is no failure.
A friend can do the following well: stay in touch even when the person does not reply; be honest once, kindly, about a worry, without repeating it every time; keep other kinds of conversation going, about the person's work, their children, their old jokes; and not make the friendship depend on change. A friend also may say, "I can't do this part", and still be a friend.
Colleagues have a different problem, and in many cases it is not the church's to solve. A person at work may see that a coworker is unwell, is missing days, or is making mistakes that affect others. They may feel they must cover for the person or report them. Those decisions belong to the workplace, its rules and its supports, and are not the church’s to settle. A church leader approached by such a colleague can listen, remind them that they are not responsible for fixing another adult, and encourage them to follow the workplace’s own procedures. If safety is at stake in the work, as in driving, caring for others or working with machinery, the safety of others comes first, and the person should tell the person responsible.
9. A word to those who lead
Many leaders find that it is easiest to care for the person who is struggling and hardest to care for the people near them. Those near are many, they have different needs, and they often do not say what they need. A list can help: for any household you know of, ask who lives there, who is nearby, and who has been asked how they are. Then choose one person to ask.
Remember also that the people who stand close are not material. A parent's story, a child's drawing or a partner's tears are not a sermon illustration, a fundraising appeal or a prayer-letter topic. What they trust you with belongs to them.
Diagram 1. What a child needs, and what a child must not be asked
Diagram 2. Who stands close, and what each commonly faces
In short
- Children notice more than adults think; their ways of coping are not signs of a defective child.
- A child needs safety, truth at the child's size, one steady adult, and permission to be a child.
- A child should not be asked to keep an adult's secret, carry messages, take over an adult's role, report on a parent or pray a parent well.
- A child's safety is worth more than a family's privacy: tell the people whose job it is, promise no secrecy, and check locally.
- Partners, parents, siblings, friends and colleagues each stand in a different place and need a listener, not orders.
- What people trust you with belongs to them and is never material for sermons or appeals.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four needs of a child | Safety; truth at the child's size; one steady adult; permission to be a child. |
| What a child is not asked to do | Keep secrets, carry messages, take an adult's role, report on a parent, pray a parent well. |
| A child may be unsafe | A safety matter: tell the people whose job it is; no promise of secrecy; check locally. |
| The overlooked | Siblings, parents, friends and colleagues are often not asked how they are. |
One sentence to remember It is not your fault, you are not alone, and people are looking after this.
This week's action Find out what your community's policy is for a child who tells a leader something worrying, and make sure every children's leader knows whom to tell.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four needs of a child (safety, truth at the child's size, one steady adult, permission to be a child) does your community meet best? Which is hardest?
- What is your church's policy on what a children's leader should do if a child says something that causes concern? Do all leaders know it?
- Why is it harmful to ask a child to keep an adult's secret, and what could you say to a child instead?
- Who in the circle around a person struggling with addiction is most likely to be overlooked in your community: a partner, a parent, a brother or sister, a friend? What would it cost to ask them how they are?
- Where is the line between a colleague's concern and the church's business? How would you respond to a colleague who came to you for advice?