Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and the Church's Talk
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What We Mean by Addiction
- Lecture 1-2: Substances and Behaviours: One Pattern, Many Faces
- Lecture 1-3: Body, Mind, Relationships, Spirit: Why One Lens Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Stigma and Grace
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Listening to Our Own Words
- Lecture 2-1: The Family as a System
- Lecture 2-2: Codependency, Helping and Enabling
- Lecture 2-3: Children and Others Standing Close
- Lecture 2-4: The Carer Who Is Also Hurt
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: First Words to a Family
- Lecture 3-1: Recovery as a Long Road
- Lecture 3-2: The First Conversation and Readiness
- Lecture 3-3: Relapse: Meeting It Without Despair or Denial
- Lecture 3-4: A Whole Life Rebuilt: Work, Sleep, Friends, Faith
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Day of a Relapse, First Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: How Mutual-Help Groups Are Built
- Lecture 4-2: The Spiritual Side of the Steps and the Church's Own Gospel
- Lecture 4-3: Hosting a Recovery Group: Space, Welcome, Boundaries
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and the Church's Talk
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Hosting Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: Medicine, Treatment and the Church: Who Does What
- Lecture 5-2: Withdrawal and Emergencies: Connecting to Medical Help
- Lecture 5-3: Referring Well and Walking Alongside
- Lecture 5-4: Tangled Troubles: Other Health Needs, Money, Law
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Referral Map
A church is a place where people talk. It prays aloud, shares news, asks after one another and notices who is missing. This is part of its strength. In a congregation where people care, a person in trouble is rarely alone for long. But the same habits can do harm. A prayer request passed along in good faith can reach the person's employer. A kind question at the church door can tell a whole row that someone has been away. A person who struggles with addiction often lives with fear of being known, and a church that talks freely may teach that person to stay away.
This lecture asks how a church can keep a person's story safe while still being the community that cares. It looks at prayer requests, the curiosity of a congregation, consent and its range, the limits of confidentiality, and a point on which readers will not agree. The central claim of the course applies: addiction is not explained by moral failure alone or by illness alone; a church does not replace the treating professional; it is a community that stays beside people without stigma. Keeping a story safe is one of the ways it does so.
This lecture is not legal advice. What a pastor, priest, counsellor, volunteer or agency worker must keep private, may share or must report differs by country, region, role and tradition. Check locally and ask a qualified person. It is also not treatment. If a person is in physical danger, medical help comes first and secrecy second.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain why a church's usual habits of talk can harm a person in recovery.
- Describe consent as something asked, with a range, that a person can change.
- Offer a congregation honest and short answers when it asks about someone.
- State the limits of confidentiality as a general principle and say them to a person at the start.
- State fairly three views on open prayer and confidentiality.
One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13
World English Bible
Debate your case with your neighbor, and don’t betray the confidence of another;" — Proverbs 25:9
WEB
Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29
WEB
Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective." — James 5:16
WEB
Proverbs 11:13 and 25:9 name the keeping of a confidence as a mark of a trustworthy person. Ephesians 4:29 asks that speech be "good for building up as the need may be". James 5:16 shows the other side: the early church prayed together for one another's healing and spoke honestly to one another. Notice that the last verse does not say who must hear a person's confession, or how widely. It describes a community in which truth is told and prayer is offered, and it leaves the range to wisdom. This lecture reads the four together: a church that cares speaks truth and prays, and it also keeps what it has been trusted with.
1. Why the church's talk is risky
Imagine three small moments.
(an invented example) At a Wednesday prayer meeting, someone says, "Please pray for Tobias. He's struggling with his drinking again, and his wife is at the end of her rope." Everyone bows their heads. A visitor who knows Tobias's employer is in the room.
On Sunday, a woman at the door says to another, "I heard Kwame's not been to the group at the town hall. I hope he's all right." Neither knew that Kwame attended a group. Now both do.
In the church's chat group, a member writes, "I want to share a testimony: Sunita has been well for some months now, praise God!" Sunita had not told her sister, who is in the chat group, that she had a problem.
In each case the speaker meant well. In each case the person's story left the person's hands without the person's say. Three things follow.
First, the harm is real, even when the intent is kind. Employment, custody, reputation and safety can depend on who knows. Second, the harm teaches. A person who hears their story passed along learns to stop telling it, and then to stop coming. Third, it is easy. Nobody needs to be wicked for this to happen. It takes only warmth, curiosity and a habit of talking.
2. Prayer requests: care that asks first
Prayer is among the church's best gifts, and it should not be given up. The task is to pray in a way that cares for the person and does not expose them.
The first rule is ask before you share. Before bringing a person's struggle to a prayer meeting, a prayer chain or a group message, ask the person: "May I ask others to pray? What would you like me to say? Who may hear it?" If the person says no, the helper prays alone and says nothing.
The second rule is share the person's words, not your own. "Pray for a friend carrying a heavy burden. She says God knows what it is" is the person's wording, if the person has chosen it. "Pray for Sunita's drinking" is not.
The third rule is share only what the prayer needs. Prayer does not require details. God knows them. A request like "Pray for strength and a safe week for a member of our family" carries the care without the story.
The fourth rule is the wider the circle, the less the detail. A prayer between two friends can be specific if the person wishes. A prayer in a meeting of twenty should be general. A written prayer list, a chat group or an email can be forwarded, copied and photographed. Treat anything written as public.
The fifth rule is a family has its own story. A spouse or child of a person who struggles is entitled to seek support and to tell their own side. A church can hold both: it can keep the person's confidence and still care for the family in the family's own right.
Proverbs 11:13 puts the same thing in one line. The trustworthy person keeps a secret.
3. Consent: asked, ranged and changeable
Consent in this setting is not a signature on a form. It is a conversation in which a person decides who may know what.
It is asked. It should not be assumed because a person "did not mind". Ask in plain words: "Who is allowed to know?"
It has a range. Think of rings.
- The innermost ring is the person and the one helper they trust.
- The second ring is a small number of named people who help: perhaps the pastor, the care team, one friend.
- The third ring is a wider group such as a prayer circle or a small group, with general wording only.
- The outer ring is the whole congregation or the public.
A person may say, "Only you." Or "You and the pastor." Or "My small group may know I'm having a hard time, but not what." The helper writes down, for their own memory and without names on any shared paper, what was agreed.
It is free. A yes given quickly, in front of others, or by someone who fears losing help, may not be free. Ask in private, give time to think, and make it easy to say no. A helper who is disappointed by a no has misunderstood the question.
It is changeable. The person may narrow the range or withdraw it at any time. Ask again from time to time: "Is it still all right that the pastor knows? Would you like to change anything?" And if the person asks for something to be forgotten by the circle, the helper does what can be done and says honestly what cannot.
4. The congregation's curiosity
Sooner or later someone will ask, "Where is Marcus? Is he all right?" It is natural to ask, and it is a sign of love. The helper's task is to answer in a way that is true and gives nothing away.
Some short answers:
- "He is well, and we are thinking of him. If he wants you to know more, he will tell you."
- "I do not talk about other people's affairs. Would you like to send him a card?"
- "He is in good hands. Thank you for asking."
Three cautions apply. Do not lie. "He has the flu" when he does not is a false statement and costs trust when it is found out. Do not hint. A raised eyebrow, a sigh or "it's complicated" speaks volumes. Do not leave the asker feeling rebuked. Thank them for caring, and, if it helps, turn the care into something useful: a card, a visit, a quiet prayer.
A church that has agreed beforehand that "rumours stop with the care team" can say so without embarrassment. The agreement is itself a kind of teaching: this is a community that keeps confidences.
5. Records, messages and the digital trail
A helper who keeps notes, sends texts or stores files has created something that can be lost, read or forwarded. Keep as little as is needed. Do not write the nature of a person's struggle in a message that others may see. Do not keep a list of members who are "in recovery" on a shared drive. Do not leave a phone unlocked in a room. If a church or an agency must keep records for a legal or professional reason, check locally what the rules are, who may see them and how long they must be kept. This course gives no rule.
6. The limits of confidentiality
Confidentiality is a strong promise, but it is not an unlimited one. A helper should not promise absolute secrecy, because there are things a helper may not be free to keep.
As a general principle, and subject to local law and the rules of the helper's role, a helper may need to involve others when:
- there is a serious risk that the person or someone else will be badly hurt;
- a child or a vulnerable adult is at risk of harm or is being harmed;
- there is a duty, in law or in the rules of the helper's organisation, to report certain things; or
- the person has asked the helper to tell someone.
What the duty is, and who must carry it, differs by country, by region and by role. Pastors, priests, volunteers, counsellors and agency workers may stand in different places. Some traditions treat a priest's hearing of confession as bound by a seal that is not broken; others do not; the law in some places recognises this and in others does not. This course takes no side and gives no statute. Check locally. The counselling ethics course teaches the principles of confidentiality and referral, and the safe church course covers the protection of children and vulnerable adults.
What matters for a helper is to say the limits at the start. A sentence like this serves: "What you tell me, I will keep private. The one exception is if I fear that you or someone else could be badly hurt, or that a child is at risk. In that case I would have to involve others, and I would tell you first if I could." This is honest. It does not frighten people away. Most people can bear a limit that is named. What they cannot bear is a limit discovered afterwards.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree about how open a church should be with a person's struggle.
Some hold that open prayer is the community's care. They say that the early church bore burdens in the open, that secrecy can turn into shame and isolation, and that a church which hides every struggle in private teaches that struggle is shameful. For these readers, a person who is prayed for by the whole body is held up by the whole body, and the community that says "we are all sinners in need of grace" should be able to say so about this. They would add that in many small communities, everyone knows anyway, and a pretence of secrecy is false.
Others hold that confidentiality comes first. They say that a person's story is the person's, that stigma is real and can cost a person work, family and safety, and that no good comes from exposing someone who did not choose it. They note that the early church's openness was between people who had chosen to confess, and that no one was forced. For these readers, open prayer without the person's say is a violation, however warm the intention.
Others hold that the answer lies within the person's consent. They say that both the first and second views are correct about something: open prayer can be a great gift, and confidentiality is a real duty, and the way to hold both is to ask. If the person wishes to be prayed for before the whole church, then let it be so; if not, then not.
This course does not choose among these. It requires the following. A person's story is not spread without the person's consent. The helper states the range of that consent clearly and keeps to it. And where there is serious danger to the person or to others, the limits of confidentiality apply, and the helper acts as the law and the helper's role require. Check locally. Within these requirements, communities will rightly differ in how open they are.
8. Different places, same care
(an invented example) In a village house church of fourteen, everyone knows everyone and very little is secret. A woman called Lucia asks the group not to speak of her husband's gambling outside the room. They agree, and each says aloud, "I will not tell." In a place where the whole village talks, a spoken promise is a way of making a room safe.
In a large congregation, the pastor has a small care team of four. The team agrees in writing that it will share only with the person's consent, will tell the person who has been told, and will meet once a year to review the practice. The prayer chain is told only: "Please pray for a member who is going through a hard time."
In a parish, the priest hears confession under a seal and also visits families. He keeps the two separate in his own mind and explains the difference to the people he serves.
In an agency, a volunteer co-ordinator tells every new volunteer on the first day what the limits of confidentiality are and who the supervisor is. Volunteers are asked to say the limit to a person at the start of any conversation about a serious matter.
Diagram 1. Rings of consent
Diagram 2. Three ways to ask for prayer
In short
- A church's warm habits of talk, such as prayer chains, door-side questions and chat groups, can spread a person's story without their say and teach them to stay away.
- Ask before you share, use the person's words, share only what the prayer needs, and give less detail the wider the circle.
- Consent is asked, has a range (the person, a few helpers, a small group, the congregation), is free, and can be changed.
- Short honest answers to a curious congregation do not lie, hint or rebuke.
- Confidentiality has limits where there is serious danger or a duty to report; say them at the start and check locally.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ask before you share | Ask the person who may hear, in what words, and for how long; accept a no. |
| Rings of consent | The person and one helper; a few named helpers; a small group; the whole congregation. |
| An honest answer to curiosity | "He is well and we are thinking of him; if he wants you to know more, he will tell you." |
| Limits of confidentiality | Serious risk of harm, a child or vulnerable adult at risk, or a duty to report; say it at the start and check locally. |
One sentence to remember A person's story belongs to the person; ask who may know, keep to the answer, and say the limits aloud.
This week's action Write three short answers you could give if a member of your community asked about someone, and check that none of them lies, hints or rebukes.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time (without names) when a kind remark in a church revealed more than the speaker meant. What would have made it safe?
- Who decides in your community whether a prayer request goes beyond the person who gave it? Do they ask the person first?
- What is your short, honest answer when someone asks, "Where is so-and-so?" Does it lie, hint or rebuke?
- Can you say the limits of confidentiality aloud, in one or two sentences, at the start of a serious conversation? Try it with a partner.
- Which of the three views in the paragraph where readers will not agree is closest to your community's habits? How would a person who held another view feel there?