Lecture 1-4: Stigma and Grace
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What We Mean by Addiction
- Lecture 1-2: Substances and Behaviours: One Pattern, Many Faces
- Lecture 1-3: Body, Mind, Relationships, Spirit: Why One Lens Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Stigma and Grace
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Listening to Our Own Words
- Lecture 2-1: The Family as a System
- Lecture 2-2: Codependency, Helping and Enabling
- Lecture 2-3: Children and Others Standing Close
- Lecture 2-4: The Carer Who Is Also Hurt
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: First Words to a Family
- Lecture 3-1: Recovery as a Long Road
- Lecture 3-2: The First Conversation and Readiness
- Lecture 3-3: Relapse: Meeting It Without Despair or Denial
- Lecture 3-4: A Whole Life Rebuilt: Work, Sleep, Friends, Faith
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Day of a Relapse, First Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: How Mutual-Help Groups Are Built
- Lecture 4-2: The Spiritual Side of the Steps and the Church's Own Gospel
- Lecture 4-3: Hosting a Recovery Group: Space, Welcome, Boundaries
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and the Church's Talk
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Hosting Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: Medicine, Treatment and the Church: Who Does What
- Lecture 5-2: Withdrawal and Emergencies: Connecting to Medical Help
- Lecture 5-3: Referring Well and Walking Alongside
- Lecture 5-4: Tangled Troubles: Other Health Needs, Money, Law
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Referral Map
Most people who struggle with addiction do not first meet the struggle. They first meet the shame. Shame says: you are the kind of person who does this. It says: if anyone knew, they would turn away. It says: you must hide. Shame is rarely spoken aloud, yet it often does more damage than the substance or the behaviour itself, because it shuts the door on the very people who could help.
This lecture asks how stigma works, how it shows itself in church, and what grace offers instead. It reads Romans 7, John 8:36, Galatians 5:1 and Galatians 6:1-2, and it brings to the surface the first of the course's honest disagreements: whether addiction is sin, sickness, or both. The central claim returns: a church does not replace the treating professional; it is a community that stays beside people without stigma, connects, and waits.
This course is not treatment. It does not replace medical or treatment care. Where the body is in danger, medical help is needed at once.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe how stigma and shame work, and how they feed silence and hiding.
- Name ways stigma appears in church life, including in kind and well-meant forms.
- Read Romans 7:15, 24-25, John 8:36, Galatians 5:1 and 6:1-2 with care, without turning any of them into a weapon or a guarantee.
- State fairly the three main positions on whether addiction is sin or sickness, and what this course requires.
- Describe what a welcoming response sounds like in one or two plain sentences.
For I don’t know what I am doing. For I don’t practice what I desire to do; but what I hate, that I do." — Romans 7:15
World English Bible
What a wretched man I am! Who will deliver me out of the body of this death?" — Romans 7:24
WEB
I thank God through Jesus Christ, our Lord! So then with the mind, I myself serve God’s law, but with the flesh, the sin’s law." — Romans 7:25
WEB
If therefore the Son makes you free, you will be free indeed." — John 8:36
WEB
Stand firm therefore in the liberty by which Christ has made us free, and don’t be entangled again with a yoke of bondage." — Galatians 5:1
WEB
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1
WEB
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
Romans 7 is an honest cry. A person who knows what is good and still does what he hates is not a stranger to anyone who has watched a struggle with addiction. Interpreters have long disagreed about exactly who is speaking in this chapter, and this lecture does not settle that; it uses the passage for what it plainly says about a divided heart. John and Galatians speak of freedom as a gift that Christ gives and a place to stand firm in. Galatians 6 describes the community's part: gentleness, humility, and shared burdens. None of these verses promises that a particular person will be free of a particular struggle by a certain time. They describe what God's grace and the community are for.
What stigma is
Stigma is a mark of disgrace placed on a person, usually by a group. It says: this person is lesser, to be avoided, to be talked about and not to. Stigma does not need cruel words. It can come as a silence when a name is mentioned, a joke at the person's expense, a change in how they are greeted, a quiet decision not to ask them to serve or to visit.
Stigma has three effects that matter for a church.
- It teaches hiding. If being found out brings disgrace, hiding is sensible. Everything that makes the struggle worse (secrecy, lies, loneliness) is encouraged.
- It delays help. A person who is ashamed waits longer to speak, longer to see a doctor, longer to tell a family member. The delay can be costly.
- It spreads to the family. The spouse, the children, the parents also feel the mark. Lecture 2-1 returns to this.
Stigma is rarely something we believe we practise. Most people who are cold to a struggling person think they are being principled, or careful, or simply honest. That is why the signs must be named.
How stigma appears in church
Here are some forms, from the blunt to the quiet.
- The verdict. "He is under judgement." "It is a lack of faith." "If she prayed more, she would not have this problem."
- The label. Using words that name the person as the problem.
- The lecture from the front. A sermon on a vice, heard by someone sitting in the third row who is struggling and now feels watched.
- The gossip circle. News of someone's trouble passes through the congregation under the name of "prayer request".
- The removal. A quiet request that the person step back from a role, without any conversation or any path back.
- The shield of perfection. A community where everyone seems fine, so that admitting trouble would mean breaking an unspoken rule.
- The overcorrection. The "kind" community that says "we all have our problems" and never asks the person how they are, because asking might be awkward.
The last two are well-meant, which makes them harder to see. A community can honestly believe it is loving and still be a place where nobody can speak.
What shame does inside the person
Shame is different from guilt. Guilt says, "I did something wrong." Shame says, "I am something wrong." Guilt can lead to confession and change. Shame leads to hiding and to the very behaviour the person wants to escape, as relief from the pain of shame.
This is part of the circle described in lecture 1-2. Craving leads to the pattern; the pattern causes harm; the harm brings shame; shame drives the person back. A church that adds more shame, even with good intentions, feeds the circle. A church that offers grace gives the person something to break it with.
This does not mean guilt is unimportant. A person may have done things that hurt others, and an honest account of that is part of healing. But honest guilt and contempt are not the same. The first looks forward to repair; the second looks down and stays.
Reading Romans 7 with care
Paul writes, "For I don’t know what I am doing. For I don’t practice what I desire to do; but what I hate, that I do." Then: "What a wretched man I am! Who will deliver me out of the body of this death?" And then, almost at once: "I thank God through Jesus Christ, our Lord!"
Three things can be said carefully.
First, the passage describes a divided will in plain words. Many people who struggle with addiction recognise it at once: they want one thing and do another. A church that reads this passage aloud to a person struggling may let them know they are not alone and not unique.
Second, the passage does not end in despair. It turns, within a single verse, to thanks for deliverance through Christ. Yet it does not say when or how deliverance comes for each person, and a helper must not promise it will arrive on a schedule.
Third, interpreters differ about whether Paul speaks here of himself before Christ, of himself as a believer, or of a human being under the law in general. The lecture does not need to decide. It uses the passage as a recognisable human description, not as a ruling on any one person's spiritual state, and it does not suggest that a believer who struggles is somehow less a believer.
Reading John 8:36 and Galatians 5:1 with care
"If therefore the Son makes you free, you will be free indeed" is a great promise, and it is also a verse that can be used badly. A helper may be tempted to say to a struggling person, "You are free, so stop," and so turn the promise into a command. That reverses the gift. The verse says the Son makes free; the freedom is his work, and the person's part is to receive it and to stand in it.
Galatians 5:1 adds that the freed person is told to "stand firm" and not be "entangled again". It speaks to a community that was in danger of going back under a yoke. It does not say that a person who goes back has never been free, nor that the community should leave them. Chapter 6 of the same letter, read next, shows what the community is to do.
Neither verse should be used to predict, promise or demand a result. They are verses about who gives freedom, and about the dignity of the one who is given it.
Reading Galatians 6:1-2 with care
"Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted. Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ."
Look at the verbs. The community is to restore, not expel. It is to act in gentleness, not severity. It is to look to itself, not stand above. And it is to bear burdens, a word that suggests weight carried together over time, not a quick fix.
The phrase "caught in some fault" suggests being trapped, not simply choosing. A person caught in a net is not rebuked for being in it; they are helped out. This does not remove all responsibility, as lecture 1-3 explained, but it sets the tone: the first action of the community is to help.
What a welcoming response sounds like
Grace in practice is often a few quiet sentences. Here are some, with what they do.
| Instead of | Try | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| "How could you let this happen?" | "Thank you for telling me. I am glad you did." | Honours the courage of speaking |
| "You must stop at once." | "What would help you most right now?" | Treats the person as one who can answer |
| "Have you prayed about it?" | "May I pray with you, if you would like that?" | Offers, does not impose |
| "I will tell the pastor." | "Who would you like to know? I will keep this between us unless you say otherwise." | Protects dignity and consent |
| "We will fix this." | "I do not know how this will go, but I will not leave you alone in it." | Promises company, not outcomes |
None of these replaces proper help. They open a door. The next step may be a doctor, a counsellor, a recovery group or a trusted family member, and weeks 3 to 5 address how to take it.
One word on limits: confidentiality has limits, which differ by country, region and role. If someone is in danger or a child is at risk, a helper may have to speak to the proper people. Check locally, and do not promise absolute secrecy. The counselling ethics course covers this.
This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: is addiction sin, or is it sickness?
Some hold that it is a matter of sin and responsibility. In their strongest form, they argue that treating it only as illness takes away the person's agency, that Scripture consistently treats desires that rule a person as something to repent of, and that to call it a disease can deprive someone of the very language of repentance and forgiveness through which God heals. A person who is told they are only ill may never be told that they can change.
Others hold that it is an illness. In their strongest form, they argue that moral language has too often been used as a stick, that it has driven people into hiding and delayed care that might have saved lives, and that a church which cannot say "this is a health condition that needs treatment" will do harm. A person who is told it is only a sin may never see a doctor.
Others hold that it is both, intertwined: a real wrong and a real harm done to the person, a choice and a captivity, a matter for the confessional and for the clinic. They say this is simply what Scripture and human experience show us about many of our troubles. Some of them add that words like "sin" and "sickness" are being asked to do more than they can, and that the debate itself can become a way of avoiding the person.
This course does not ask the reader to choose. It requires three things of everyone, whatever they hold. First, no removal of responsibility: the person remains a person who can act, answer, repent and repair. Second, no reduction of a person to a diagnosis or to a sin: they are neither only a patient nor only an offender. Third, company without stigma, and a link to medical care: whatever the church believes about the cause, it stays beside the person, never uses its view as a reason to withhold kindness, and helps them reach proper treatment when they need it.
Small and large communities
(an invented example) In a congregation of about twenty gathered in a hired room, a man called Pavel quietly tells the leader he has been gambling away his wages. The group is so small that anything he says could reach everyone by evening. The leader says: "I am glad you told me. I will tell no one. Can we meet again on Thursday?" The group's smallness is a danger to privacy, but it is also a gift: a leader can show by example how a secret is kept.
(an invented example) In a big city church with several pastors and a care team, a woman called Lucía wonders whether to say anything at all. Nobody knows her. If she speaks, the information goes to a form, a database and a meeting. The team can be skilled, but what Lucía needs to hear first is not a process; it is a single warm human voice saying, "You are not in trouble here." The church's size is a gift of resources and a danger of anonymity.
In both places the first act of grace is the same: someone listens without recoiling.
The limits of this lecture
Grace is not a technique, and nothing here promises that a gentle response will bring a person to recovery. It brings a person into company. Recovery is a long road, and the next weeks walk it. And the helper too has limits: the one who listens needs support, rest and honest boundaries, a theme of week 6.
1-1. How stigma feeds the circle
1-2. Sin or sickness: three positions, three requirements
In short
- Stigma teaches hiding, delays help and spreads shame to the whole family.
- Stigma in church can be quiet: the verdict, the label, gossip as prayer request, removal with no road back.
- Shame says "I am something wrong"; guilt says "I did something wrong". Guilt can lead to repair; shame leads to hiding.
- Romans 7, John 8:36, Galatians 5:1 and 6:1-2 describe a divided will, freedom as Christ's gift, and the community's gentleness; none is a promise of a result.
- Readers differ on sin, sickness or both; the course requires responsibility kept, no reduction to a label, and company with a link to care.
- Grace in practice is a few plain sentences: thanks, an offer, and a promise of company, not of outcome.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Stigma | A mark of disgrace; it teaches hiding, delays help and spreads shame to the family. |
| Shame and guilt | Shame says "I am something wrong", guilt says "I did something wrong"; guilt can lead to repair. |
| Galatians 6:1-2 | Restore in gentleness, look to yourself, and bear one another’s burdens. |
| Sin or sickness | Three positions; the course requires responsibility kept, no label for the whole person, and company with a link to care. |
One sentence to remember Grace opens the door that shame has closed, and promises company, not a result.
This week's action Choose one sentence from the table of welcoming responses, say it aloud to yourself, and decide what you would add or change so that it sounds like you.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a word or phrase your community uses about people with addiction. Does it open or close a door? What would you say instead?
- The lecture distinguishes shame from guilt. Where have you seen shame mistaken for repentance?
- Which of the quiet forms of stigma (the lecture from the front, the gossip circle, the removal, the shield of perfection) is most likely in your community? Why?
- Romans 7 is an honest cry. What would it mean for a leader to read it aloud to someone without turning it into a promise or a rebuke?
- State each of the three positions on sin and sickness in the strongest form you can, as its holders would. Which requirement of the course is hardest for you to keep?