FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT721E Addiction and Recovery Ministry: Understanding, Companionship, Referral

Lecture 3-3: Relapse: Meeting It Without Despair or Denial

Contents 31
PT721E Addiction and Recovery Ministry: Understanding, Companionship, Referral
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Beside, Not Above
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside, Not Above
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Understanding Addiction
  1. Lecture 1-1: What We Mean by Addiction
  2. Lecture 1-2: Substances and Behaviours: One Pattern, Many Faces
  3. Lecture 1-3: Body, Mind, Relationships, Spirit: Why One Lens Is Not Enough
  4. Lecture 1-4: Stigma and Grace
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Listening to Our Own Words
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Families and Those Standing Close
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Family as a System
  2. Lecture 2-2: Codependency, Helping and Enabling
  3. Lecture 2-3: Children and Others Standing Close
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Carer Who Is Also Hurt
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: First Words to a Family
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The Road of Recovery, and Relapse
  1. Lecture 3-1: Recovery as a Long Road
  2. Lecture 3-2: The First Conversation and Readiness
  3. Lecture 3-3: Relapse: Meeting It Without Despair or Denial
  4. Lecture 3-4: A Whole Life Rebuilt: Work, Sleep, Friends, Faith
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Day of a Relapse, First Conversation
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Recovery Groups and the Church
  1. Lecture 4-1: How Mutual-Help Groups Are Built
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Spiritual Side of the Steps and the Church's Own Gospel
  3. Lecture 4-3: Hosting a Recovery Group: Space, Welcome, Boundaries
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and the Church's Talk
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Hosting Agreement
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Working with Medicine and Treatment, and Referral
  1. Lecture 5-1: Medicine, Treatment and the Church: Who Does What
  2. Lecture 5-2: Withdrawal and Emergencies: Connecting to Medical Help
  3. Lecture 5-3: Referring Well and Walking Alongside
  4. Lecture 5-4: Tangled Troubles: Other Health Needs, Money, Law
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Referral Map
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Recovering People and the Community
  1. Lecture 6-1: Recovering People in Ministry: Welcome and Boundaries
  2. Lecture 6-2: When the Helper Is Worn Out
  3. Lecture 6-3: A Community That Does Not Feed the Problem
  4. Lecture 6-4: Learning Together and Keeping Faith over Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Recovery Ministry Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

Many communities hope for a clean story: a person struggles, a person turns, a person is well. Real recovery rarely runs so straight. For many people, the road includes a return to the old pattern, once or several times, before things settle. This is what people mean by relapse.

This lecture asks how a church can meet a relapse without despair (giving up on the person, or on itself) and without denial (pretending it did not happen, or that it does not matter). It looks at signs, safety, grace and responsibility held together, and the work of reconnecting a person to care. It also faces a question on which readers do not agree: what the goal and pace of recovery should be. The central claim of the course applies: addiction is not explained by moral failure alone or by illness alone, recovery is a long road lived in grace, and the helper has limits too.

This course is not treatment. It teaches no medicines, methods or ways of managing stopping. A return to use can carry physical danger. Any danger sign (loss of consciousness, severe illness, confusion, use in pregnancy) means medical help at once.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • Describe relapse as part of many roads of recovery, without treating it as inevitable or as trivial.
  • Name early signs that a person may be slipping, and respond without accusation.
  • Hold grace and responsibility together when a relapse has happened.
  • Help a person reconnect to care, and know what is safe to say in the first conversation after a relapse.
  • State fairly the different views of what the goal and pace of recovery should be.

Don’t rejoice against me, my enemy. When I fall, I will arise. When I sit in darkness, Yahweh will be a light to me." — Micah 7:8

World English Bible

Yahweh is merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and abundant in loving kindness." — Psalms 103:8

WEB

For he knows how we are made. He remembers that we are dust." — Psalms 103:14

WEB

Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1

WEB

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2

WEB

Micah 7:8 gives words for a person who has fallen: not to be rejoiced over, and a hope of rising. Psalm 103:8 and 103:14 describe a God who is slow to anger and who remembers that we are dust. Galatians 6:1-2 speaks to the helper: restore in gentleness, look to yourself, carry burdens together. None of these says that falling is good, and none says that it does not matter. They describe how God, and God's people, are asked to meet those who have fallen. These verses are a pattern of care and not a promise that a person will not fall again.

1. What relapse is, and is not

In this course, relapse means a return to the old pattern of use or behaviour after a period of stopping or reduction. It can be a single occasion or a slide back over weeks. It can be small or large. It can happen early on the road or after many years.

Three things should be said at once.

First, relapse is common in many roads of recovery. This course gives no figures, because it has none it can stand behind, and because figures can be used to excuse (everyone does it) or to frighten (almost everyone fails). Both uses harm. The honest statement is simply that many people travel a road with setbacks in it, and that a setback is not the end of the road.

Second, this does not make relapse unimportant. It can be dangerous. It can hurt the person's family again. It can bring back shame like a flood. It can destroy trust that took a long time to build. A church that says "It's fine, these things happen" has not met the person's pain.

Third, a relapse is not proof that the earlier recovery was false. A season of stopping was real. The work done in it was real. The relationships mended in it were real. A relapse does not cancel them.

2. Despair and denial: two ways of getting it wrong

Churches tend to fall into one of two ditches.

Despair says: "We knew it wouldn't last." It may be spoken as a sigh, a withdrawal of attention, a quiet decision that the person is "not serious". It may take the form of anger: "After everything we did." Underneath, it often hides the helper's own grief or tiredness. The person feels it at once and does not need to be told.

Denial says: "It's nothing." It may be spoken as encouragement ("Don't worry about it!") or as silence, a determination not to mention what everyone knows. Denial protects the helper from an uncomfortable conversation. It leaves the person alone with something that needs to be spoken.

Between these is a narrow path: to say the truth gently, without drama, and to stay.

3. Signs that a person may be slipping

Helpers are not detectives and should not behave like them. But it is natural to notice change, and noticing is a form of love. Here are some general signs. None of them is proof, and any of them can have other causes.

  • Withdrawal from the group, missed meetings, unanswered messages.
  • A return to old company or old places.
  • Sudden secrecy, or stories that do not fit together.
  • A change in mood: unusual irritability, flatness, or a brightness that seems forced.
  • Neglect of work, sleep or food.
  • Money problems, or hints of them.
  • A return of the old language of excuse ("just this once", "I deserve it").
  • Family members saying that things "feel like before".

If you notice some of these, do not confront. Make contact. "I've missed you. How are you really doing?" is better than "I think you've been using again". If the person tells you, listen. If they do not, you have still left a door open.

4. Safety first

When a relapse is known, the first concern is safety, not blame. Ask, gently and calmly, whether the person is safe now. Safety includes the following.

  • Physical safety. Is the person ill, confused or in danger? If so, call for medical help at once and stay.
  • Safety of others. Are children or vulnerable people in the person's care? If there is any risk to a child, the safe church course and the proper authorities come first, and the helper does not decide this alone.
  • Safety from the person's own despair. A relapse can bring heavy shame. If you hear talk of ending life, take it seriously; the crisis course teaches what to do, and the matter should not be handled by a helper alone.

Only when these are settled does the longer work begin.

5. Grace and responsibility together

Many helpers feel that they must choose: be gracious, or be honest about responsibility. The choice is false. Grace without responsibility is indulgence. Responsibility without grace is a verdict. The Christian teaching is both: forgiveness is real, and so is the person's work in what follows.

What does this look like in a conversation after a relapse?

(an invented example) Adaeze has told her care-team friend, Grace, that she drank again last weekend after many months. Grace could say:

"Thank you for telling me. I'm glad you did. I'm not going anywhere. Are you safe right now? ... I'm sorry it was a hard weekend. What do you think happened? ... What do you think would help this week? ... Would you like me to help you get in touch with your doctor or your counsellor? ... Shall I call on Thursday?"

Notice what is present. Thanks for honesty. Presence. A safety question. A real question about what happened, asked to understand and not to build a case. A forward look. An offer to reconnect to care. A next step.

Notice what is absent. No sermon. No "how could you?". No suggestion that the relapse shows the person is not serious. No promise that it will never happen again. No advice about medicines.

Responsibility is not shown by a scolding. It is shown by treating the person as a capable adult who can take the next step.

6. Reconnecting to care

After a relapse, the person's contact with professionals and with mutual-help groups may have broken. Shame often keeps them away. A helper can say: "People who've been through this often go back to their doctor, counsellor or group after a setback. Would you like me to come with you?" A church should not take the place of these, and it should not be offended if the person goes to others for what the church cannot give. Week 5 returns to referral.

If the person is in a treatment programme and has a relapse, the helper's role is to support the person to be honest with their team, not to hide it from them to save embarrassment.

7. Staying beside the family

A relapse hits the family hard. A spouse may feel the old fear return. Children may feel it without words. The church should not forget these people. They need to be told that they are not at fault and that they, too, are cared for (lectures 2-3 and 2-4). Do not ask them to carry the secret on the church's behalf, and do not ask them to be the monitor of the person's recovery.

8. The goal and the pace of recovery

This is a point where readers will not agree about the goal and the pace of recovery.

Some hold that the only faithful goal is complete abstinence, now and for good. They say that anything less misleads the person, that a partial goal is a door through which the old pattern returns, and that Scripture's language of being set free points to a clean break. For these readers, to speak of reduced use as a possible goal is to weaken the call to freedom, and a church should hold a clear line.

Others hold that a staged reduction of harm also counts as a real gain. They say that a person who is using less, harming fewer people and keeping their work and family is better off than a person who has been pushed out of every circle, and that insisting on all or nothing can drive people away from the very help they need. For these readers, to insist on a single goal for everyone is to confuse the ideal with the first step.

Still others hold that the right goal depends on the person and the situation: on the kind of problem, on how long it has run, on the person's health and on what their treating professionals advise. They say that no church can know this from outside.

This course does not choose among these. It requires the following. Medicines and treatment methods are not discussed here, and are not for the church to decide. The goal is set by the person together with their professionals, not by the church alone. The church's part is honest conversation and steady company. Safety comes first, and where there is physical danger, the person is connected to medical care. And whatever the goal, the church does not remove its welcome from a person who falls short of it, and does not call a person's honest account of their progress a failure of faith.

9. Relapse in communities of different sizes

(an invented example) In a house church of nine, Tomasz tells the group he has gambled again. Nobody has training. They sit quietly. An older member says, "Thank you for saying." Another asks if he is safe and whether money for the rent is at risk. They agree that two of them will help him find a counsellor in the town, and that nothing leaves the room without his say.

In a large congregation, a volunteer notices that a man in the choir has been missing and the rumour is that he has "gone back to it". The care team has agreed beforehand that rumours stop with them. One team member visits and says nothing about the rumour. She says only that she has missed him.

In a parish, the priest, who has known a woman in recovery for years, hears from her son that she has relapsed. The priest does not call her out of the blue with a sermon. He says to the son, "Thank you. Please tell her I'm thinking of her, and I'd be glad to see her whenever she likes."


Diagram 1. Between despair and denial

Meeting a relapse Two ditches and a narrow path between them Despair "We knew it wouldn't last." Withdrawal of attention Anger, "after all we did" The person feels it at once The narrow path Thank them for telling Ask: are you safe now? Ask what happened, to understand Offer a way back to care Fix one small next step Denial "It's nothing." Silence about what all know Cheerful dismissal The person is left alone Safety first: body, others, the person's own despair Danger signs mean medical help at once. A child at risk goes to proper authorities.

Diagram 2. Grace and responsibility

Grace and responsibility together Neither alone is enough Grace alone becomes indulgence: "nothing matters" Both together welcome stays; the person is trusted to take the next step Responsibility alone becomes a verdict: "you are a failure" Responsibility is shown by trusting a capable adult with a next step, not by a scolding.

In short

  • Relapse is part of many roads of recovery; it is neither inevitable nor unimportant, and it does not cancel what came before.
  • Despair withdraws from the person and denial leaves the person alone; the narrow path says the truth gently and stays.
  • Safety comes first: physical safety, safety of others, and the person's own despair; danger signs mean medical help at once.
  • Grace and responsibility are held together by trusting a capable adult with a next step.
  • Readers differ about the goal and pace of recovery; the goal is set by the person with professionals, and the church offers company and honest conversation.
Front Back
Relapse A return to the old pattern after a period of stopping or reduction; common on many roads and never to be shrugged off.
Two ditches Despair (withdrawing) and denial (pretending nothing happened).
First questions after a relapse Thank you for telling me. Are you safe now? What do you think happened? What would help?
Goal and pace Set by the person with professionals; the church offers honest conversation and steady company.

One sentence to remember Meet a relapse with the truth and the open door together.

This week's action Write down, without names, the first three sentences you would hope to say to someone who tells you they have slipped.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which ditch is your community more likely to fall into, despair or denial? What in its habits makes that so?
  • Why does "It's fine, these things happen" fail the person who has relapsed? Why does "I knew it wouldn't last" fail?
  • Look at Grace's words to Adaeze. Which sentence would be hardest for you to say, and why?
  • In the paragraph where readers do not agree, which position do you find yourself drawn to? How could you still keep faith with a person who held a different one?
  • Who, in your community, looks after the family when a relapse happens?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.