Lecture 5-4: After the Crisis, and Loss at a Distance
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Sent, Not Spent
- Lecture 1-2: Who Sends? Structures and the Gaps in Them
- Lecture 1-3: Discernment, Readiness and Saying "Not Yet"
- Lecture 1-4: The Care Agreement: Roles, Support and Authority
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Mapping Who Is Responsible
- Lecture 2-1: The Body: Health and Safety as Stewardship
- Lecture 2-2: The Soul: Worship, Loneliness and Being Fed
- Lecture 2-3: Pressure That Piles Up
- Lecture 2-4: Teams, Power and Mistreatment
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Care Check-In
- Lecture 3-1: Marriage and Family Under Strain
- Lecture 3-2: Raising Children Abroad: Choices With No Single Answer
- Lecture 3-3: Belonging, Loss and Growing Up Between Places
- Lecture 3-4: Keeping Children Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Questions a Family Asks Together
- Lecture 4-1: Calling and Collapse
- Lecture 4-2: Rhythms of Rest: Sabbath, Leave and Home Assignment
- Lecture 4-3: Who Looks After the Worker? Check-Ins, Counselling and Confidentiality
- Lecture 4-4: Leaving Early, Leaving Well
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Limit and a Rest Plan
- Lecture 5-1: Honest Reporting
- Lecture 5-2: Money, Donors and the Dignity of the People We Describe
- Lecture 5-3: Preparing for Crisis
- Lecture 5-4: After the Crisis, and Loss at a Distance
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Crisis Plan
When a crisis has passed, the people in it often hear a sentence that sounds kind: "It is over now." For the people who lived through it, it is not over. Their bodies are tired, their minds replay what happened, their family has been changed, and their questions have not been asked. The community around them, relieved, wants to return to ordinary life. The one who has just come through a hard time may feel they are not allowed to still be shaken.
This lecture is about what a community owes a person after a crisis, and about a kind of loss that is common among people who serve far from home: the death of a colleague, a local friend or a family member, grieved at a distance, sometimes without the chance to attend a funeral or to be among one's own people. It also takes up two hard subjects that must be handled with care: the risk that some callings carry, and the way a community speaks of those who die in service.
The argument is short. After a crisis or a loss, the community does not hurry the meaning, and it does not leave the person to carry it alone. It stays, it listens, and it lets mourning be mourning.
This lecture belongs to the course's central claim. A missionary is a person called by God and sent by a community, not a spare part and not a hero. A community that moves on quickly after a loss treats a worker as a part that has been repaired. A community that turns a loss into a legend treats a worker as a hero. In both, the person and the grieving family are left behind.
This lecture describes no violent event and gives no account of any death. It offers no counselling, diagnosis or treatment. How to care for the bereaved in general belongs to the pastoral-care courses; this lecture teaches what is different when the grief is far from home and what the sending side owes. This is not medical or mental-health advice. Where distress is deep, speak with a trusted person, the organisation's care contact, a health professional and, where there is danger now, the local emergency service.
What these 30 minutes give you
- Describe what a community owes a person after a crisis: debriefing, accompaniment and time.
- Explain why meaning is not rushed after a loss, and what a community can say and not say.
- Name what is different about grief far from home, including being unable to attend a funeral.
- Distinguish a calling that accepts risk from pretending there is none, without glorifying danger.
- State fairly the disagreement over how to honour those who die in service, and the requirement this course sets whatever view is held.
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
World English Bible
Jesus wept." — John 11:35
WEB
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18
WEB
a time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;" — Ecclesiastes 3:4
WEB
Paul's instruction is brief and does not offer a method: weep with those who weep. In John 11, Jesus is shown weeping at a friend's grave, though he knows what he is about to do. The verse is not used here to say that grief is only a prelude to joy. It says that weeping is something Jesus did. Psalm 34 speaks of nearness to those who are brokenhearted. Ecclesiastes says that mourning has its time. None of these passages tells a mourner to be quicker. We read them to say that a community does not need to hurry past grief and may sit with it.
1. After a crisis: what is owed
A crisis ends when the event is over. Its effects do not. After illness, an accident, an evacuation, a threat or a disaster, a person and a family may be tired in ways that do not show. They may sleep badly, startle easily, feel numb, feel angry, weep without warning or find they cannot make small decisions. Or they may seem entirely well and show nothing for months. These are things others may notice, and none is a diagnosis. They are common human reactions to a hard time, and the same person may show some, all or none. Where they continue or deepen, a health professional is the right person to ask.
A sending community owes three things after a crisis.
1. Debriefing. A debrief is a conversation, soon after, in which the people involved tell what happened in their own words, and are heard by someone who does not need to fix it. It is not an inquiry and not a report for the files. Where a decision or a mistake needs to be reviewed, that is a different conversation, held later and held separately, so that a person who needs to talk is not also a person on trial. A good debrief is led by someone trained for it where possible, who is not the person's direct supervisor, and who understands the setting. Where no such person is near, a trusted listener by telephone or video is better than none. Where it is possible, plan in advance who this person will be. (Lecture 4-3 spoke of the value of a listener who does not report to the supervisor.)
2. Accompaniment. To accompany is to stay with someone over time. It means a call a week later, and another a month later, to ask, "How are you now?" It means noticing the day that the event happened a year ago. It means not assuming that a person who said "I am fine" in the first week is fine in the sixth. A sending body that is present in the first hour and absent in the first month has left the hardest part to the family. Accompaniment also means practical help: a rest, a change of duties, travel for a family to see their own people, or a visit.
3. Time. The community lets the person take time before deciding whether to stay, whether to return, whether to continue the work. Big decisions made in the weeks after a crisis are often made in shock. Unless safety requires an urgent answer, they can wait. A community that presses "So, will you go back?" in the first week has treated the worker as a part to be refitted.
Notice that none of the three is a strategy for getting a worker back to work. They are owed because the person was called and sent and has been through something hard. Whether the person returns to the same work, a different work or none at all is a separate matter, decided later, with care and without shame.
A word for those who were near the crisis but not in it: the local colleagues who helped, the neighbours who sheltered a family, the team members who stayed behind. They also carry what happened. They are often thanked least and asked least. A sending community that remembers them has shown that care does not stop at a passport.
2. No rush to meaning
When something terrible has happened, people want it to mean something. It is a natural wish. It is also a risk. A community, a team or a worker may reach too quickly for a sentence that makes sense of the loss: "God must have a purpose", "It was meant to be", "Their sacrifice will bear fruit". Said too soon, such sentences close a door. They tell a grieving person that the right response is acceptance, not sorrow, and that anger or doubt are not welcome.
There is a wisdom in not rushing. The friends of Job are praised in Job's story for their first seven days, when they sat with him and said nothing, and criticised for what they said when they began to explain. Whatever meaning there is, it is rarely found by someone else telling it to the sufferer. It is found, if at all, by the sufferer, slowly, in the company of people who stay.
This does not mean that faith has nothing to say. It means that faith's first words, in front of a person in grief, are more often "I am here", "I am so sorry" and "Tell me about them" than "Here is why." A person of faith may, when asked, speak of hope; the question is who asks and when. Take care not to quote a verse as a stick. A verse that tells a mourner not to grieve, or to endure more, or to be thankful, is used badly.
Say it also from the side of the grieving. A grieving person may not yet want comfort, or may want it from a particular person, or may need to be angry with God and say so. A community that can bear a person's anger is a community that has learned something.
3. Loss on the field
Loss is a part of every life, and loss on the field has its own shape. Consider three.
The death of a colleague. A team member, a fellow worker or a leader dies, perhaps of illness or in an accident. The team grieves together, but its members also have jobs, families and a place to run. The sending body is far away. A memorial may have to be held without most of those who loved the person, and the colleague's own family may be in another country. What helps: a plan for who tells the family and in what order; a time for the team to be together; rest from duties; and the presence of someone from the sending side who is not in the team, so that those in it are not left to hold each other up alone.
The death of a local believer or friend. A local friend, a church member or a neighbour dies. The foreign worker may be an outsider at the funeral, uncertain what is expected and unsure whether to grieve openly. It is a good moment to ask, as in lecture 3-1, "What would be right for me to do?" and to be guided by local people. Often the most important thing is to be present, to follow the local custom of mourning, and to see the family through the following weeks, not only on the day. A foreign worker's grief for a local friend is real, and local people can honour it by letting it show.
Seen from the local side: a local community that loses someone may also be asked to comfort the foreign worker who is grieving, and may be unsure whether that is wanted. They may be uncertain whether to say aloud what the person meant to them. A word of welcome, "You are part of our mourning", can open the door.
The death of a family member far away. A parent, a sibling, a friend or a child dies in the worker's home country. The news arrives by telephone or message. The worker is alone, or alone with a family, far from the people who share the loss. The funeral may be in days, and travel may take longer than that, or be too costly, or be blocked by a closed border or a sick child. The worker may not be able to go.
4. When one cannot go home
Being unable to attend a funeral is a particular wound. It is rarely spoken of. A funeral is where a community says goodbye together, and where a mourner is held up by others. Without it, the loss can feel unfinished. A person who stays behind may feel guilty for not being there, and may feel that they chose the work over the family. Others at home may feel angry or let down, whether or not they say so.
The sending community can do three things.
Decide in advance who will pay and who will decide. If a worker's family at home is bereaved, the question "Can I go?" should not be a negotiation in the week of the death. The agreement (lecture 1-4) names what the sending body will do and what it will not, and the worker knows it. Where a worker can go, the community helps them go. Where they cannot, the community says plainly that it is sorry and does not suggest that a different choice would have been braver.
Make a place for mourning where the worker is. A memorial service, a quiet evening with the team, a meal, a candle, a reading, a time to speak of the person: these let the worker mourn with others. A local congregation may do this very well if told, and may be honoured to be asked. A sending church at home may also hold a service and send a recording, a letter or a photograph.
Keep in touch with the family at home. A call, a letter or a message from the sending congregation to the bereaved relatives says that the worker is not forgotten and that the loss is shared. A pastor or a member who can visit the grieving relatives and tell the worker how they are is doing a hard and useful thing.
Later, a worker may want to visit a grave, or to mark an anniversary. A rhythm of leave or home assignment (lecture 4-2) can allow for this, and it is worth asking, not assuming, whether the worker wants it.
(An invented example.) Hana, sent by the Wicklow Road Fellowship to the town of Dunmere, learns by telephone that her father has died. It is a night's flight and then a day's drive to her home town, and the funeral is in three days. Her husband has a fever and the family has a young child. Hana decides she cannot go. The Fellowship's care contact, Mr Prior, calls the same day and says, without being asked, "We are so sorry. We will help you decide what is right, and whatever you decide, we will not think less of you." He asks her what she would like. She says she would like the funeral to be held without her feeling forgotten. The Fellowship arranges for a member to sit beside her mother and to send a recording of the service; the team in Dunmere sits with Hana for an evening and each tells a memory of their own fathers; and the local church sends a woman, Mrs Elam, who sits quietly with her for an hour. Two months later Mr Prior calls again, and asks if Hana would like to plan a visit home. She does not feel that her loss was solved. She does feel that it was not carried alone.
5. A calling that accepts risk, and pretending that there is none
Some callings carry real risk: of illness, of accident, of unrest, and sometimes of danger from those who oppose the faith. Some workers and some churches know this and accept it, with open eyes, after prayer and counsel. This is not to be mocked or made small. A person who knowingly accepts risk for the sake of others deserves respect, and the same is true of the family who supports them.
Two different things need to be kept apart.
A that accepts risk says: "This work may be dangerous. We have thought about it. We have counted the cost (Luke 14:28). We have a plan. The family has been heard. We accept the risk together, and we will not leave the person alone." It is open, shared and prepared.
Pretending there is no risk says: "Nothing will happen to us," or, "God will protect us, so no plan is needed." It does not count the cost. It leaves the family to meet the danger unready.
And there is a third thing that must also be named: a glorifying of danger. Here risk is not merely accepted but admired. Those who go to dangerous places are spoken of as the truly serious ones, and those who choose safer places, or who leave, are felt to be lesser. This pressure can lead people to take risks that others have not agreed to, or to stay too long, or to hide their fear. It also makes those who stay in ordinary places feel small. This course does not say that suffering is without meaning. It does say that a community that praises danger has stopped caring for the people who face it.
The difference between these shows in what the community does. A community that accepts risk plans (lecture 5-3), accompanies, and does not rush meaning. A community that glorifies danger tells stories of courage and does little for the family.
6. How a community stands by
The community's work after a loss is, in the end, simple, and its pattern is in Scripture's few words: weep with those who weep; Jesus wept; the Lord is near to the brokenhearted. In practice, this means the following.
- Be present, and say little. "I am sorry" and "I am here" are nearly always enough. Ask before you advise. Do not tell a mourner how they should feel.
- Say the name. People often avoid speaking of the dead to avoid causing pain. Most mourners are glad to hear the name spoken.
- Do the small, practical things. A meal, a lift, the school run, a phone call to a relative. These are not small.
- Stay for the long time. Grief is slow and returns. Remember the day, the month and the year.
- Respect the family's wishes about what is said, to whom and when, and about what is shared outside the family.
- Do not turn the loss into a means. A death is not an occasion for an appeal, nor a tool to move a congregation. Care for the bereaved comes before the story.
- Point to others when it is beyond care. Where grief seems to be deepening or a person is in danger now, a trusted pastor or priest, the care contact, a health professional and the local emergency service are the right people.
How to care for the bereaved in general, in a congregation, belongs to the pastoral-care courses. What is added here is the distance: the call that must carry the weight a visit would carry, and the community that must decide in advance to stay.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is how to honour those who die in service.
One position, found in many traditions, holds that memorials and honour are right and good. The church has always remembered its dead. To name them, to hold a service, to keep an anniversary, to write the name in a book or on a wall, and in some traditions to speak of martyrs and saints, is to tell the truth that the community owes them, and to teach the young what faithfulness has cost. A community that does not remember is ungrateful.
A second position distrusts any language that lifts one death above others. It points out that the many ordinary workers who die of illness, accident or age in service, and the local believers who die unremembered, are no less loved by God. It notes that a language of honour for the dramatic death can make the quiet one feel less. It warns that stories of heroes can pressure others to seek danger, or shame those who leave. On this view, the safest thing is to honour all who have served, in the same plain words, and to speak with great care of any one.
Each position protects something real: gratitude and memory on one side, equality and a refusal to glorify on the other. Each can fail. The first can slide into legend, and into pressure on the living. The second can slide into silence, so that no one is remembered at all.
This course requires less than either position asks. Whichever view is held, honour without glorifying danger, and care for the bereaved before the story. Remember the dead truthfully, in plain words, with the family's consent about what is said and shown. Do not use a death to raise money or to shame others into service. Do not tell a story of a death in a way that makes a reader feel small for being safe. And before any memorial, ask what the family and the local people want.
Diagram 1. After a crisis and in loss: what a community owes
In short
- After a crisis a community owes debriefing, accompaniment and time. These are owed to the person, not as a means of returning them to work.
- Meaning is not rushed. First words are "I am here" and "I am sorry", and a verse is never used as a stick.
- Loss at a distance needs a plan: who decides about travel, a place for mourning where the worker is, and contact with the family at home.
- A calling may accept risk when it is counted, shared and planned. Pretending there is none, and glorifying danger, both leave people alone.
- Readers differ on how to honour those who die in service; the course requires honour without glorifying danger, and care for the bereaved before the story.
- Where grief is deep, the right people are a trusted person, the care contact, a health professional and, if danger is present, the local emergency service.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What a community owes after a crisis | Debriefing, accompaniment and time. It is owed to the person, not as a way to return them to work. |
| Why not rush meaning | Quick explanations tell a mourner to stop grieving. First words are "I am here"; wait to be asked for more. |
| Loss at a distance | Decide in advance about travel, make a place for mourning where the worker is, and keep in touch with family at home. |
| Honouring those who die | Honour without glorifying danger, with the family's consent, and care for the bereaved before the story. |
One sentence to remember A community that stays, says little and does not hurry grief has done most of what care asks.
This week's action Think of someone who has had a loss or a hard time. Contact them this week and say their name or the name of the one they have lost.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time when someone said "It is over now" and it was not. What would have helped more?
- Why is it a kindness to separate the debrief, where a person tells what happened, from the review, where decisions are examined?
- Which sentences that try to give meaning to a loss have you heard? When might they help, and when might they hurt?
- Hana could not attend her father's funeral. What did the people around her do well? What else might a community do?
- Say, from the side of a local church, what you might wish a grieving foreign colleague to know, and what you might find it hard to say.
- Which of the two positions on honouring those who die in service is closer to your own tradition? State the strongest point of the other.