Lecture 6-3: Care Across the Line Between Foreign and Local
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Sent, Not Spent
- Lecture 1-2: Who Sends? Structures and the Gaps in Them
- Lecture 1-3: Discernment, Readiness and Saying "Not Yet"
- Lecture 1-4: The Care Agreement: Roles, Support and Authority
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Mapping Who Is Responsible
- Lecture 2-1: The Body: Health and Safety as Stewardship
- Lecture 2-2: The Soul: Worship, Loneliness and Being Fed
- Lecture 2-3: Pressure That Piles Up
- Lecture 2-4: Teams, Power and Mistreatment
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Care Check-In
- Lecture 3-1: Marriage and Family Under Strain
- Lecture 3-2: Raising Children Abroad: Choices With No Single Answer
- Lecture 3-3: Belonging, Loss and Growing Up Between Places
- Lecture 3-4: Keeping Children Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Questions a Family Asks Together
- Lecture 4-1: Calling and Collapse
- Lecture 4-2: Rhythms of Rest: Sabbath, Leave and Home Assignment
- Lecture 4-3: Who Looks After the Worker? Check-Ins, Counselling and Confidentiality
- Lecture 4-4: Leaving Early, Leaving Well
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Limit and a Rest Plan
- Lecture 5-1: Honest Reporting
- Lecture 5-2: Money, Donors and the Dignity of the People We Describe
- Lecture 5-3: Preparing for Crisis
- Lecture 5-4: After the Crisis, and Loss at a Distance
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Crisis Plan
In many places where foreign workers serve, there are two kinds of colleague who do almost the same work, who eat at the same table at lunch, and whose lives are looked after in very different ways. One has a written agreement, a named contact, a plan for illness and a route home if things go badly. The other has a family, a church and the goodwill of friends. The first is often the foreign worker. The second is often the local colleague. Neither chose the difference. It came with the way each was sent, or not sent.
This lecture asks what a community owes across that line. Its argument is: care should not be divided by passport. A colleague who works beside a sent person is a person whom God called, whether or not any community sent them, and the people who work together are, in the plainest sense, one body. This follows from the central claim of the course. If care is owed to a called person and not earned by usefulness or by nationality, then a local worker is not outside it. This is a question of justice, because a gap in care falls on those who can least afford it. It is also a question of partnership, because a gap between colleagues spoils the work they share.
The lecture also warns that this is not a simple matter of "give more." Money from outside can create dependence, can distort a local church and can put the local worker under the foreign funder's thumb. Careful people disagree about how far to go. The lecture lays out the disagreement and asks what holds true whichever way a reader decides.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Describe how care may differ between foreign and local workers in the same work, and say why this is a question of justice and of partnership.
- Name the main areas of care (pay, safety, rest, family, counselling, security, later life) and ask who carries each for a local colleague.
- Explain the dangers of dependence, and the opposite danger of calling neglect "independence".
- State fairly the main positions on the level of support for local workers, and the requirements this course sets whichever one is held.
- Name blind spots that foreign workers, senders and local colleagues may each have, and say what a person can do about their own.
that you receive her in the Lord, in a way worthy of the saints, and that you assist her in whatever matter she may need from you, for she herself also has been a helper of many, and of my own self." — Romans 16:2
World English Bible
Receive him therefore in the Lord with all joy, and hold such in honor," — Philippians 2:29
WEB
Beloved, you do a faithful work in whatever you accomplish for those who are brothers and strangers." — 3 John 5
WEB
They have testified about your love before the assembly. You will do well to send them forward on their journey in a way worthy of God," — 3 John 6
WEB
We therefore ought to receive such, that we may be fellow workers for the truth." — 3 John 8
WEB
When one member suffers, all the members suffer with it. Or when one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it." — 1 Corinthians 12:26
WEB
These passages are about care passing between people who work together. Paul asks a church to "receive" and "assist" Phoebe and says she has helped many. In Philippians, a church that sent Epaphroditus to serve is told to receive him and to honour him when he comes back, after an illness that frightened them. In 3 John, the writer praises a host who looks after travelling workers, who are strangers to him, and says that those who receive them become "fellow workers". The direction of care runs more than one way. It runs from a community to the person it sent, from a local host to a stranger, and from a worker to a church that has often been the helped one.
Paul's picture of the body in 1 Corinthians 12 is the broadest of these. We read it plainly: if one member suffers, the others suffer with it. It does not say "unless the member is from another country."
1. Two colleagues, one clinic
(An invented example.) In the town of Dovrin there is a small health clinic run by a local church. Two people work in it every day. Chidi is a nurse from a city far away, sent by a partnership of congregations in his own country. Ilir is a nurse from Dovrin, employed by the clinic, who has worked there for nine years.
In the spring Chidi fell ill. He was seen the same day. The partnership's contact person was telephoned, the family was told, and within the week a plan that had been written before he left was followed: someone to look after his work, a place to rest, and travel to better care. He was away for a month and then came back to light duties for another month. He was grateful and a little embarrassed by the fuss.
Three months later Ilir became ill with something similar. He worked two more days, then stayed at home. His wife asked the church for help. The church took up a collection, which was kind and not enough. Ilir went back to work after nine days, still weak, because the clinic could not easily pay a nurse who was not there. Chidi noticed that Ilir was thin and quiet, and did not ask why. He assumed that Ilir had family around him, which was true. He did not know about the collection, the nine days, or the pay.
Nobody in this story is a villain. The partnership did exactly what it had promised. The clinic's board was poor and doing its best. Chidi had never been asked to think about what happened to Ilir when he was ill, because no one had told him it was a question. And Ilir never raised it. He said later, "I did not want to be one more request. The clinic exists because of the foreigners' help. How can I ask for more?"
Look at the same facts from each side.
The sender's side. The partnership's agreement covered "members of the sending congregations." It was written for the people the congregations sent. It did not say anything about the people those workers worked with, because nobody had asked. A congregation can be entirely faithful to its own people and still leave a gap beside them.
The foreign worker's side. Chidi's care was real, and he had not chosen it over Ilir. But he had also never been asked what he would want for his colleague. Few foreign workers are told that this is part of their responsibility. When they are not, it is easy to see only what is in front of oneself.
The local colleague's side. Ilir had been loyal for nine years and was valued. But he was in a position of quiet dependence on the clinic, on the foreign funders behind it, and on the foreign colleague who spoke well of him to them. Asking for help would have felt like complaining about people who had been generous. A person in that position may say nothing. Saying nothing is not the same as needing nothing.
2. What care includes, and who carries it
The care owed to a worker is wider than a salary. Think of the areas this course has covered and ask each as a question about a local colleague:
- Pay. Is it fair, regular and agreed in writing? What happens during illness?
- Safety. Does the worker face danger because of the work, because of association with foreigners, or because of the work's visibility? Who knows, and who would act?
- Rest. Does the worker have rest and leave that the work will protect?
- Family. Who looks after the worker's spouse and children when the work takes the parent away, or when the worker is sick or hurt?
- Counselling and listening. Does the worker have a trusted person to talk to who is not their supervisor, in their own language and from their own tradition?
- Security of place. If a project ends or a foreign partner leaves, what happens to the worker's job, house and standing?
- Later life. What is there for a local worker who has given thirty years and has no plan for old age?
Foreign workers often have an answer to most of these, written or unwritten. Local workers often have an answer to a few, through their family and church, and a gap in the rest. This is a general observation, not a rule: the gap varies from place to place and from person to person. Some local workers belong to a large, well-run church network with better care than any foreign colleague has. Some foreign workers, sent by a small congregation with few resources, have almost nothing. The line that matters is not nationality, it is who has someone responsible for them and who does not. But where there is a pattern, it is a pattern worth seeing.
This course does not give medical, legal, financial or security advice, and it names no sums. Where these matters arise, the people to ask are the organisation's written rules, local law, a qualified adviser and the local church's own leaders. The rule is the same as before: find out, put it in writing and keep it where it can be reached.
3. Why this is a justice question
When one colleague has a safety net and another does not, the one who falls through is usually the one with less power, fewer options and less voice. That is the shape of an injustice even where nobody intended it. Nothing in the passages quoted above makes a worker's care depend on citizenship.
It is also a justice question in a second way. A local worker's pay or care is often decided by someone elsewhere: a foreign funder, a board in another country, a visiting leader. The one whose life is affected has little say in the decision. A justice that only hands out goods and does not ask the person is half a justice.
4. Why this is a partnership question
A team is damaged when its members live under different rules. If one colleague can take a day to recover and another cannot, or if one is evacuated in danger and the other must stay, resentment may grow quietly on both sides. The foreign worker may feel guilty and not know what to do. The local worker may feel that he is less valued, or may feel that he must not say so. When a foreign worker leaves, the local worker may be the one who stays to answer for what was started. This hurts trust, and trust is the thing the work depends on.
A partnership also means that the local colleague is not an assistant. A local worker brings a language, a knowledge of the place, a place in the community and often a deeper commitment to it than a foreigner who will leave. The help to be given is not charity to a lesser partner. It is the care that colleagues owe each other.
5. The danger of dependence, and the danger of calling neglect independence
Care from outside has a cost, and it is honest to say so. Where foreign money pays for a local worker's security, several things can happen.
- The local church may stop expecting to look after its own, because someone else will.
- The local worker may come to answer to the funder more than to the church he serves.
- The arrangement may end when the funder's interest or money ends, leaving the worker worse placed than before.
- Others in the community may see the funded worker as set apart, and relationships may suffer.
- The arrangement may set a standard that no local church can keep up.
These are real. The course on cross-cultural communication and adjustment looks at help that creates dependence and help that builds dignity; the same questions apply here: Who named the need? Who decides? Does the community give something? Who will keep it going?
But there is an opposite danger, and it is easier to miss. A foreign worker or a sending body may say, "We do not want to create dependence," and in saying so leave a colleague without care in a crisis. Independence is a good end. It is not a reason to look away while a colleague goes without. A principle meant to protect people from being controlled can be turned into an excuse for not noticing them.
6. This is a point where readers will not agree
Careful Christians disagree about how much support local workers should receive, and who should give it.
Some hold that local workers should be supported at the level of their foreign colleagues, or at least at a level that does not leave them visibly worse off. Their reasons are justice and unity: it is wrong that two people sharing the same work, the same risks and the same table should live in different worlds, and wrong that the colour of a passport should set the price of a person's health. They add that workers paid at a much lower level often leave for better-paid work, and that a church that cannot see its pastor cared for has not been taught what care is.
Some hold that support should follow local conditions: what a local family of similar position lives on, what the local church could keep up if outside help stopped, and what will not set the worker apart from the community he serves. Their reasons are the dangers named above: dependence, jealousy, and a standard that no local church can carry. They point out that a level of support that makes a local pastor a different class from his members may harm his ministry.
Some hold that the local church should carry its own workers, with foreign partners helping only in emergencies, in training or in special projects. Their reason is that a church that is not asked to carry its own leaders never becomes a church that can. They hold that the long-term health of the local body matters more than the short-term comfort of one worker.
Each position protects something real: fairness, sustainability, or the local church's own growth. Each also has a risk: the first can create dependence and divide a church; the second can quietly accept inequality as "local conditions"; the third can leave a person to suffer for a principle. This course does not choose one.
What the course does require, whichever view a reader holds, is this. No worker is left outside care because of nationality. Some form of care is always present for each worker: someone responsible, a plan for illness and danger, and a person to talk to. The arrangement is agreed openly with the local church, not worked out over its head. It is written down, so that it can be reviewed and does not depend on one person's goodwill. And no foreign colleague or sending body decides alone what a local colleague needs.
7. Who carries the local worker's needs
The place to begin is the local church. It is the community the local worker belongs to and serves, and in the ordinary way it carries the first responsibility. This is not a loophole. The foreign partner who sees a gap and says, "That is for the local church," and goes home, has not understood the question. The honest question is: what can the local church carry, what can it not carry yet, and what can partners carry without taking over?
Some guides:
- Ask the local church and the worker, and listen. Do not guess what the need is, or assume it is greater or smaller than it is.
- Agree openly. Who gives, for how long, for what, and what happens when it ends. Do not make private arrangements that others learn about by chance.
- Keep the same standards of honesty about money for everyone: written, accountable and open to the local church's leaders (lecture 5-2).
- Protect the local worker's safety and privacy. Do not publish a local worker's name, photograph or place without consent, because it can put them in danger. When a foreign worker leaves, ask who is left more exposed, and what has been done about it.
- Include local workers in the community's care. A community that holds a day of rest, a retreat, a conversation or a funeral for its foreign workers can invite the local ones, if they wish to come.
- Do not make a distinction between those who are "ours" and those who are not. If the care covers one worker in a team, ask why it does not cover the others.
8. Naming one's own blind spots
Every person here has a blind spot, and it is more useful to name one's own than to hunt for another's.
A sender may ask: Whom do we count as ours? What does our agreement say about the people our worker works with? Have we ever asked a local colleague, not through our worker, what they need?
A foreign worker may ask: Do I know what would happen to my colleague if he were ill for a month? Have I spoken of my own care in front of people who have none? Do I speak for local colleagues in meetings where they could speak for themselves?
A local colleague may ask: Do I assume that the foreigner has more resources than he has, or that those who send him have none of their own limits? Am I willing to say what I need, even when it is awkward? And, where I hold authority myself, do the people under me have the care I wish for?
None of these questions is a charge. They are a way of seeing what a person's own position hides.
9. A last word on both directions
3 John praises a local host for looking after strangers. Romans 16 asks a church to receive a visitor who has been "a helper of many". Philippians asks a church to honour a man who had risked his health for them. In each case care passes in more than one direction, and the community is stronger for it. Foreign workers are often cared for by the local people among whom they live: with meals, with warnings, with friendship in illness and with a bed in a crisis. A partnership that sees itself only as giver misses what it has been given.
Diagram 1. Care for two colleagues: where the gaps fall
In short
- Care should not be divided by passport: a colleague beside a sent person is also a called person, and the team is one body.
- Ask each area of care (pay, safety, rest, family, listening, security, later life) about the local colleague as well as the foreign one.
- Outside help can create dependence. Calling neglect "independence" is the opposite error and is just as easy to make.
- Readers disagree on the level of support; the course requires that none be left outside care, and that the arrangement be open and written.
- The local church carries the first responsibility, with partners; protect local workers' safety, privacy and say in their own care.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why a justice question and a partnership question | The gap falls on those with least power; and a team living under different rules loses trust. |
| Dependence and its opposite | Outside money can make a church stop carrying its own. Calling neglect "independence" leaves a colleague without care. |
| What the course requires on level of support | No worker outside care by nationality; the arrangement agreed openly with the local church; written down; no one decides alone for another. |
| Who carries a local worker's needs | The local church first, with partners who help without taking over and who protect the worker's safety and privacy. |
One sentence to remember Those who work together are one body, and care owed to a called person is not divided by the colour of a passport.
This week's action Take one team or partnership you know, real or imagined, and ask the seven questions about the colleague who is least likely to have been asked.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the story of the clinic, who could have noticed the gap, and what would each of them have needed to know to see it?
- Why might Ilir not have asked for help, even though he needed it? Say it in his own words.
- Care can be divided by something other than passport: by rank, by sex, by tribe, by whether a person was sent by a large body or a small one. Where might that happen in a place you know?
- Name one danger of dependence and one danger of calling neglect "independence". Which one is easier for you to overlook?
- State fairly each of the three positions on the level of support for local workers. Which of them protects something the others miss?
- What would it look like to include local workers in a care that has so far been only for foreign ones? Who would need to be asked first?