FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT735E Mercy and Justice: The Church and Its Neighbours

Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour

Contents 31
PT735E Mercy and Justice: The Church and Its Neighbours
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Neighbours, Not Cases
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Neighbours, Not Cases, and What This Course Does Not Teach
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Mercy and Justice in Scripture and in the Church's Memory
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
  2. Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
  3. Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
  4. Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Helping Without Harming
  1. Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
  2. Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
  3. Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
  4. Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Knowing the Neighbourhood and Working with Others
  1. Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
  2. Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
  3. Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
  4. Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Many Neighbours, Many Needs
  1. Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
  2. Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
  3. Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
  4. Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The People Who Serve, Witness, and the Church's Voice
  1. Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
  2. Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
  3. Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
  4. Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Disaster, Endurance and Humility
  1. Lecture 6-1: When Disaster Comes
  2. Lecture 6-2: Compassion Fatigue and the Tired Helper
  3. Lecture 6-3: Staying the Course and Measuring With Humility
  4. Lecture 6-4: Endings and Handing On
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Our Covenant With Our Neighbours

Jump to the key points ↓

28 min

When a person comes to a church for help, something happens in the mind of the person who meets her, usually before a word is said. A reason arrives. She must have spent it. He lost his job. They have no one. It is the system. It is bad luck. The reason may be kind or hard, and it may even be right. But it arrives fast, and it decides a great deal: what we ask, what we offer, how we speak, how long we stay, and whether the person feels met or measured.

This lecture is about those reasons. It makes one argument. People are poor for many reasons, often several at once, and Scripture itself holds more than one of them together. So a church should not reduce poverty to a single cause. It should ask what is true of this person and this place, and it should remember that behind every explanation stands one neighbour.

This is the fourth step in the central claim. If mercy is a relationship between neighbours, then we cannot love a person well while we hold a story about her that she would not recognise. And if justice is the shared responsibility of a whole community, then it matters whether the cause lies in a person, a law, a loss or a loneliness, because the community's part is different in each. The lecture touches laws and public help only as categories. It is not legal, tax or welfare advice.

What these 28 minutes give you

  • Name five kinds of explanation for poverty (choice and character, structures and laws, broken relationships and isolation, spiritual and emotional factors, and chance) and state each in its strongest honest form.
  • Show from Proverbs, Job, Ruth and James that Scripture speaks of idleness, of oppression and of loss, and does not reduce poverty to one of them.
  • State fairly the disagreement over the causes of poverty and what the course requires of every reader.
  • Notice how a first explanation shows in a sentence, and rewrite a sentence so that it names a person and not a category.
  • Explain why people who are poor have strengths, choices and gifts, and why a person need not tell a story in order to be helped.

He becomes poor who works with a lazy hand, but the hand of the diligent brings wealth." — Proverbs 10:4

World English Bible

An abundance of food is in poor people’s fields, but injustice sweeps it away." — Proverbs 13:23

WEB

He who oppresses the poor shows contempt for his Maker, but he who is kind to the needy honors him." — Proverbs 14:31

WEB

The first verse says that a lazy hand makes a man poor and a diligent one brings wealth. The second says that there is plenty of food in poor people's fields, and that injustice sweeps it away. They stand in the same book, a few chapters apart. Neither cancels the other. The third reminds us what lies under both: a poor person is not a problem but a human being whose Maker takes note of how he is treated.

1. The question behind the question

"Why is she poor?" sounds like a request for information, but it is often a request for permission. If the cause is her own doing, then perhaps we owe her less. If the cause is the system, perhaps it is nobody's fault in this room. If it is chance, perhaps we may help and feel good about it. The explanations we hold are rarely neutral. They are tied up with our need to feel safe, fair, or blameless.

That is why this lecture is placed in the first week. Whatever practice we learn in later weeks, it will be shaped by the explanation we carry in. A church that quietly believes that poverty is always the person's fault will build a very different supper table from one that believes it is always the system's fault, and both will miss many of the people who sit at the table.

2. Five kinds of explanation

People have given at least five kinds of answer to the question. Each is held by thoughtful people, and each captures something true. Here they are in their strongest form, with what each tends to leave out.

1. Choice and character. Some explain poverty chiefly by what people do: how they work, spend, save, plan, and treat their families. In its strongest form this view respects people as agents who make decisions that matter, and it refuses to treat them as helpless. It also notices that some patterns of habit really do make a hard life harder. What it can leave out is the question of which choices were truly open, and what it can do, in the mouth of a hasty person, is turn a neighbour into a verdict.

2. Structures and laws. Others stress the arrangements around the person: how wages are set, who holds land, how courts treat people, what things cost, which neighbourhoods have schools and clinics, who is shut out by language or by rules. In its strongest form this view says that a person can do everything right and still be held back by something she did not make. It reminds us that some harms are repeated across a whole community, and so are the community's to address. What it can leave out is the person's own agency, so that she becomes only a victim.

3. Broken relationships and isolation. Others notice that poverty is often a matter of who is missing: a family that has broken, a friend who has moved away, no one to lend a sum or to watch the children, no one to ask. In its strongest form this view says that hardship and loneliness feed each other, and that the first thing a church may be able to give is company. What it can leave out is that some people have warm families and still lack food and rent.

4. Spiritual and emotional factors. Others point to grief, fear, shame, despair, addiction, and the spiritual struggles that can come with them, and some speak of spiritual forces that bind and harm. In its strongest form this view takes the inner life seriously and does not treat a person as only a body to feed. What it can leave out is that a material problem, such as no work or an unpaid rent, can be wrongly turned into a spiritual one. In this course we meet such matters only by noticing, referring and staying beside a person. We do not diagnose or treat.

5. Chance. Others point to what nobody chose: an illness, an accident, a death in the family, a flood, a war, a failed harvest. In its strongest form this view says that many people are poor because something fell on them, and that the line between a secure household and a struggling one is thinner than the secure like to think. What it can leave out is what communities can do to be ready for such falls, which is part of the structural question.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some stress personal choice and character; some stress structures and laws; some stress broken relationships and isolation; some stress spiritual forces; some stress chance. Within each group there are careful thinkers and also careless ones, and the groups cut across traditions: a Catholic, an Orthodox, a Pentecostal and a Baptist may each hold any of them. Writers also disagree about how the weight of each cause varies from place to place, and the numbers that are offered are disputed, so this lecture offers none. What the course requires is the following. Do not reduce poverty to one cause. Ask what is true of this person and of this place, and expect that the answer will be mixed. Where a cause lies in a person's choices, treat her as an agent, not a verdict. Where it lies in a structure, treat the neighbours as responsible together, not as villains. Where it lies in loss or loneliness, offer company. Where it lies in chance, offer help without blame.

3. What Scripture itself says

The Bible does not give us one explanation. Look at what Proverbs says. On one side:

"How long will you sleep, sluggard? When will you arise out of your sleep?" — Proverbs 6:9 (WEB)

"A little sleep, a little slumber, a little folding of the hands to sleep: so your poverty will come as a robber, and your scarcity as an armed man." — Proverbs 6:10-11 (WEB)

The sayings against idleness are real, and a church should not pretend they are not there. But the same book says:

"An abundance of food is in poor people’s fields, but injustice sweeps it away." — Proverbs 13:23 (WEB)

Injustice sweeps away what the poor have grown. And there is a sharper warning to those with power:

"Don’t exploit the poor, because he is poor; and don’t crush the needy in court; for Yahweh will plead their case, and plunder the life of those who plunder them." — Proverbs 22:22-23 (WEB)

Elsewhere the same collection notes how power runs along the line of debt:

"The rich rule over the poor. The borrower is servant to the lender." — Proverbs 22:7 (WEB)

and says of the one who oppresses the poor and the one who is kind to them that each treats the Maker accordingly (Proverbs 14:31). Proverbs gives wise sayings that are true in most settings, and it is not trying to fit every case into a single rule. A reader who picks only the verses about laziness reads half of the book. A reader who picks only the verses about oppression reads the other half. The book wants us to hold both and to ask which one is before us.

Other books add other causes. The book of Ruth opens with a famine, a family that has to leave its land, and then a husband and two sons who die (Ruth 1:1-5). Naomi and Ruth are poor because of hunger and bereavement, which no one chose. The letter of James speaks, in the New Testament, of a cause that lies in someone else's act:

"Behold, the wages of the laborers who mowed your fields, which you have kept back by fraud, cry out, and the cries of those who reaped have entered into the ears of the Lord of Armies." — James 5:4 (WEB)

Here wages were held back by fraud. The poverty of the labourers is not their own doing but the work of the people who hired them. And Job shows the opposite temptation. His friends insist that his loss must come from some fault of his own, and the book ends by rejecting that explanation (Job 42:7). Job himself, when he describes the way he once lived, gives a picture of careful justice:

"Because I delivered the poor who cried, and the fatherless also, who had no one to help him, the blessing of him who was ready to perish came on me, and I caused the widow’s heart to sing for joy." — Job 29:12-13 (WEB)

"I was a father to the needy. The cause of him who I didn’t know, I searched out." — Job 29:16 (WEB)

Notice the last line: "The cause of him who I didn't know, I searched out." Job did not decide a stranger's case from a distance. He went and looked into it. That is the habit this lecture is asking for.

4. One situation, four tellings

Here is one situation, told four ways.

(An invented example.) In the town of Lowmarsh, Tamsin Odhiambo, a mother of two, cleaned offices in the evenings. Last spring the firm that employed her lost its contract and she was given fewer hours. In the same month her mother, who looked after the children while Tamsin worked, fell ill and went to live with a sister in another town. Tamsin fell behind with the rent. She came to the church's food table twice, and she did not say much.

Telling A: choice. "She took a flat she could not afford and has not learned to budget. She should have saved something."

Telling B: structures. "The firm cut her hours with little warning. Rent in this part of town has risen faster than wages. There is no children's care near her work."

Telling C: relationships. "With her mother gone, she has nobody to ask. She did not tell anyone at church for months because she was ashamed."

Telling D: chance and the inner life. "Her mother's illness came without warning. She is exhausted and frightened at night, and has stopped sleeping well."

Each telling has a true part. Each also has a gap. A is right that Tamsin made decisions, and silent about what was available. B is right about the firm and the rent, and silent about Tamsin as a person who acts. C is right that she is alone and ashamed, and may be silent about the practical need for money this month. D is right about her state, and may not say that tiredness is not the cause of the unpaid rent.

Notice also what each telling would lead a church to do. Telling A leads to a talk about budgeting. Telling B leads to asking whether the church can speak with the landlord, or help her find the services that exist in her place. Telling C leads to a friend at the table, and a seat beside her. Telling D leads to an offer to sit with her, and, if the strain is heavy, to help her reach a health professional. Perhaps none of these would be wrong. But a church that held only one would give only one kind of help.

What would a good first step be? Not choosing among the four, but asking Tamsin: "What would help most this month?" and then listening. The aim is not to get her to tell a story. It is to find out what is true. A person need not explain how she came to need food in order to receive it. If she wants to tell, listen gladly. If she does not, the food is still hers. And if she tells you that she is afraid for herself or for her children, or that someone is hurting her, the conversation changes at once: you stay with her, you bring in a trusted pastor or safeguarding person, and if there is danger now, you call the local emergency number.

5. Checking our words

What we think shows in how we speak. A few phrases are warning signs because they put a category where a person should be.

Said badly: "The poor are always looking for a handout." Said well: "A man who has lost his work asked us whether we could help with food this week." The first is a claim about a whole group that nobody can prove. The second is about a person who exists.

Said badly: "They've made their bed." Said well: "I don't yet know how she came to this. I would like to hear it, if she wants to tell me."

Said badly: "It's all the system's fault." Said well: "Some of what she faces was done to her, and some she can change. Which part should we help with first?"

Four questions help us to check a sentence before we say it.

  • Is it about a person or about a category?
  • Is it a guess about a cause that I am stating as a fact?
  • Would I say it to her face?
  • Would she recognise herself in it?

The same check applies to the stereotype of the comfortable. "The rich do not care" is as much a verdict as "the poor are lazy". Job was a comfortable man who searched out the cause of a stranger. And the Bible does not treat poor people as saints either:

"A needy man who oppresses the poor is like a driving rain which leaves no crops." — Proverbs 28:3 (WEB)

A person in need can do wrong to another person in need, as any person can. A stock saint is as false as a stock villain, and neither helps us to see the person at the table.

6. The strengths and choices of people who are poor

One more thing needs saying, because it is so easily forgotten. People who are poor are not defined by their lack. In many places they manage on very little with great skill: they stretch a meal, find a cheaper road, lend and borrow among neighbours, hold a household together through years that would break others. They have views about their own neighbourhood that outsiders lack. They make choices, some wise and some not, like everyone. And they give: they cook, mind each other's children, sit with the dying, and carry each other's burdens. Ruth, who had nothing, supported Naomi, and Naomi advised Ruth.

A church that sees this will not speak of "the poor" as one group. It will see Tamsin, a woman who cleans offices and has a mother and a rent. And it will see that she may also be a person who could sit on the supper team a year from now, or teach someone else to find the services in her town, if she is asked and if she wants to.

7. From the other sides

How does this look from other places? The person who is helped may feel that every question about the cause is a test she has to pass, and so may give the answer she thinks will be accepted. The volunteer may need a reason in order to feel that the help is safe and fair, and may not notice that this is her need and not the neighbour's. The pastor or priest, who stands at the door, may carry the guilt of the comfortable, or the weariness of the one who has been told too many stories, and may speak from that. And the neighbour who is neither giver nor receiver may hear the whole conversation as a judgement on her own street.

Each of these people is listening for a cause. If we say aloud, "We do not need your story to help you, and we are glad to hear it if you want to tell it," we remove some of the fear from every one of them.

8. Where this leaves us

The point of the lecture is not to find the right cause. It is to hold the question open long enough to meet the person. Scripture gives the church the habit of its own mixed account: some are poor through idleness, many through oppression, some through loss, some through loneliness, and all of them are neighbours. The next lecture turns the argument into a practice. It asks you to notice your own first reaction.


Diagram 1. Five explanations, and the neighbour in the middle

Five Explanations, One Neighbour Each holds something true; each leaves something out Choice Habits, work, decisions made Risk: a verdict Structures Wages, laws, rent, courts, access Risk: only a victim Relationships No family or friends nearby Risk: skips need Inner life Grief, fear, shame Notice and refer Risk: spiritualise Chance Illness, disaster, death, lost work Risk: no readiness The neighbour in the middle Ask what is true of this person and of this place. Expect a mix of causes, and say so in your words. A person need not tell a story in order to be helped. Do not reduce poverty to one cause Proverbs speaks of idleness and of oppression; Ruth of famine and loss; James of withheld wages; Job rejects blaming a sufferer.

In short

  • People are poor for many reasons, often several at once; do not reduce poverty to one cause.
  • Five kinds of explanation are held: choice and character, structures and laws, broken relationships and isolation, spiritual and emotional factors, and chance. Each has a true part and a gap.
  • Scripture itself speaks of idleness, oppression, bereavement and fraud. Job searched out the cause of a stranger instead of deciding it from afar.
  • The explanation we carry decides what we ask, what we offer and how we speak; check a sentence for a person and not a category.
  • A person need not tell a story to receive help. If she wants to tell it, listen gladly.
  • People who are poor have strengths, make choices and give; the comfortable are not stock villains either.
Front Back
Five explanations Choice and character; structures and laws; broken relationships and isolation; spiritual and emotional factors; chance.
Scripture's mix Proverbs speaks of idleness and of oppression, Ruth of famine and loss, James of withheld wages, and Job rejects blaming a sufferer.
The course's requirement Do not reduce poverty to one cause. Ask what is true of this person and this place.
Checking a sentence Is it a person or a category? A guess stated as a fact? Would I say it to her face? Would she recognise herself?

One sentence to remember Many causes lie behind poverty, and one neighbour stands in front of us, so we ask before we explain.

This week's action Notice one explanation you voice about someone in need this week, and replace it with one honest question you could ask the person.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the five explanations do you reach for first? Which do you reach for last? Where did you learn them?
  • Proverbs speaks both of the lazy hand and of the injustice that sweeps away the poor man's harvest. How might a church hold both without choosing?
  • In the four tellings of Tamsin's situation, what is true in each, and what is left out? Which would be easiest for your church to believe?
  • "The cause of him who I didn't know, I searched out." What would searching out a cause look like, without making a person tell her story?
  • Take a sentence you have heard in your church about "the poor" or "the rich" and rewrite it so that it names a person and not a category.
  • Name a gift or skill that a person who is poor has given you or someone you know.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.