Lecture 6-1: When Disaster Comes
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
- Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
- Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
- Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
- Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
- Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
- Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
- Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
- Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
- Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
- Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
- Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
- Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
- Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
- Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
- Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
- Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
- Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
- Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
A flood, a fire, an earthquake, a storm, a sudden closing of the only factory in a town: some events fall on a whole neighbourhood at once and overwhelm ordinary life. In the first hours nobody is sure what is needed. People are afraid, many want to help, and almost everyone is tired.
This lecture asks what a local church can usefully do when that happens. It makes three claims. First, the church's greatest gift in a disaster is usually presence, and presence needs no special training. Second, help that is not tied to what is actually needed can add to the trouble. Third, the hardest and longest part comes after the cameras leave. The central claim of the course is at work here. Mercy is a relationship between neighbours, and in a disaster the neighbours are hurt together. Some of the helpers lost their own homes. Justice here means the shared responsibility of the whole community, including its official services, for the people who have lost most.
This lecture does not teach rescue, first aid, medical care or legal work. Those belong to trained people. It teaches how a church stands beside such people and beside its neighbours. It is not legal, tax or welfare advice. The rules for gifts, for registering a relief fund and for dealing with the authorities differ from place to place, so find out for your own place and follow local law and a qualified person.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Describe three things a church can usefully offer in an emergency, and three things it should leave to trained responders.
- Explain why a church should ask what is needed before it sends or collects goods, and show how to ask.
- State how gifts and money received for a disaster can be held openly, with two people involved.
- List the safety rules for volunteers at the scene of a disaster.
- Describe the long recovery after the emergency ends, and what a church can do in it.
Now when Job’s three friends heard of all this evil that had come on him, they each came from his own place: Eliphaz the Temanite, Bildad the Shuhite, and Zophar the Naamathite, and they made an appointment together to come to sympathize with him and to comfort him." — Job 2:11
World English Bible
So they sat down with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and no one spoke a word to him, for they saw that his grief was very great." — Job 2:13
WEB
As any of the disciples had plenty, each determined to send relief to the brothers who lived in Judea;" — Acts 11:29
WEB
which they also did, sending it to the elders by the hands of Barnabas and Saul." — Acts 11:30
WEB
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
WEB
You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone." — Exodus 18:18
WEB
Job's friends came, sat down and said nothing for a week. Later in the book they speak, and much of what they say is wrong; but the first week is the part we read here. In Acts, a church that is told of a coming famine decides to send help, and it sends it by two named people to named leaders. Paul tells the Romans to weep with those who weep. Jethro tells Moses that no one can carry a whole people's trouble alone.
1. What a church is in a disaster
A church is not an emergency service. It does not usually have boats, doctors, engineers or radios. But it has things that a disaster needs and that official services often cannot supply quickly.
- It is already there. Its members live on the streets that were hit. They know who is old, who lives alone, who has a baby, who speaks little of the local language.
- It has trust, built over years. People who would not open a door to a stranger in a uniform may open it to a neighbour they have greeted for ten years.
- It has a building. A hall may serve as a place to gather, to be warm, to charge a telephone, to sit with a cup of tea, if the building is safe and the authorities agree.
- It has people with time and hands, and a habit of meeting.
- It can stay. Official services move on to the next emergency. A congregation lives here.
A church also has limits, and a disaster finds them fast. It does not know the whole situation. Its volunteers are not trained for the scene. Its members are hurt too. A church that is honest about both lists is much more useful than one that pretends to have only the first.
(An invented example.) On a night of heavy rain, the river Wend rose over its banks in the town of Odenmoor. By morning, about forty homes along Mill Lane were under water. Ravenhill Church stands on higher ground. Its pastor, Nuala Brandt, did not know what to do, and she said so to the church's small team when they met in the hall at seven o'clock. "We are not the rescue service," she said. "So who is?" Within an hour one of the deacons had found the telephone number of the town's emergency office, which the church had written on a card two years before, and had learned where the official shelter was. The church's first act was not to organise anything. It was to find out.
2. Presence first
Job's three friends did something right before they did anything wrong. They came. They made an appointment together, so none of them arrived alone. When they saw his state, they wept, and they sat with him on the ground for seven days and nights without a word. The writer says why: "they saw that his grief was very great." The rest of the book shows that when they began to explain his suffering to him, they said much that was false and unkind. We do not read Job 2 as a model for what to say. We read it for the first week: go, sit down, be together, say little.
Paul gives the same direction in one short line: weep with those who weep. In a disaster this may be the most ordinary and the most needed thing a church member can do. Sit in a kitchen with a woman who has lost her furniture. Walk beside a man to the shelter. Stand in the queue with an old neighbour so that he is not alone. You do not need to fix anything or explain why it happened.
A few examples of what presence sounds like, said badly and said well:
| Said badly | Said well |
|---|---|
| "Everything happens for a reason." | "I am so sorry. I am here. What would help you this hour?" |
| "At least nobody died." | "This is a heavy loss. Would you like to tell me about it, or just sit?" |
| "God must be teaching you something." | "I do not know why this has happened. I will stay with you." |
| "You should be grateful." | "You have been through a great deal." |
The right-hand column is not a formula. It shows a way of speaking that does not explain, does not hurry and does not make the sufferer comfort the helper.
3. Link to the official responders
In most places there is some authority that coordinates a disaster: a civil protection office, a local government, a fire or rescue service, a relief agency, a large charity, a community council. In some places that authority is strong. In some it is weak, slow or absent, and neighbours do most of the work in the first days. In some, the church is a minority and its offers may be treated with suspicion. The principle holds in all of them: do not work in parallel with the official response if you can work with it, and do not pretend that it does not exist.
Before any disaster, a church should find out, for its own place, and write down:
- who coordinates an emergency, and how to reach them;
- where shelters are set up, and who runs them;
- what the church may and may not do in a shelter or at the scene (rules differ widely);
- the local emergency number, written where every team member can find it.
Then, when a disaster comes, the first call is simple: "We are a church on such a street. We have such a hall and such a number of volunteers. How can we help, and what should we not do?" Take the answer. If the authority says it needs nothing from a church, accept that, and ask whether neighbours need visiting or whether you may help in some other way, later.
4. Ask before you send
Almost every disaster brings a second trouble: goods and offers that nobody asked for. Trucks of used clothes arrive in a warm place. Cases of tinned food arrive where there is no way to open them or no one to sort them. Volunteers arrive who need food and a bed themselves. Piles of well-meant things block roads, fill halls and must be sorted, stored and thrown away by the very people who are in shock. Some people who work in disaster relief have called this a second disaster, and the church should not add to it.
The remedy is a question: "What is needed, by whom, and who will receive it?" Ask the official responders and ask the neighbours themselves. Then compare two messages:
Said badly: "Our congregation has a lorry full of clothes and bedding. We are bringing it to Odenmoor tomorrow. Where should we unload?"
Said well: "We are a church two hours from Odenmoor and we want to help. What are people short of right now? Is anything arriving that you cannot use? Is money more useful than goods? Whom should we send it to?"
Often the honest answer is money, to a recognised local body, or nothing yet. Giving money to those who know what is needed feels less personal than a lorry. It is often more useful, because the people on the ground can buy what is short, in the local market, and the market itself recovers. But this is not always so, and it depends on the place and the moment. Ask.
The same holds for the church's own neighbours. Before you carry a bag of food to a house, ask the person at the door what they would like. A person who has lost everything has not lost the right to choose.
5. Gifts and money held openly
When a disaster stirs a congregation, gifts of money flow in, and the church becomes the keeper of other people's trust. The rules of the early church in Acts 11 are modest and clear. The disciples decided each according to what they had. They sent it to the elders of the churches in Judea, the people who would know who needed it. And they sent it by the hands of two named men, Barnabas and Saul, not by one.
Three principles follow, and they hold anywhere:
- Say what the money is for, and use it for that. If the gifts were for the flood, do not quietly spend them on the church roof.
- Two people, not one. Two people count the money, two sign the record, two know where it is kept. This protects the neighbour and it protects the person holding the money from suspicion.
- Say what was received and what was spent, in a simple note, to those who gave. A church that says nothing teaches its members not to give next time.
Find out in advance what your own place requires of a church that collects money for others: whether it must register, report or keep certain records, whether gifts may be received for people outside the congregation, and what happens to money left over. This lecture gives no figures and no legal rules. If the sums are large or the situation is unclear, ask a qualified person, and tell the donors what you are doing. Lecture 2-3 explains the same habits in ordinary times.
6. Safety at the scene
The most common harm done by well-meaning helpers is to themselves. A volunteer who walks into a damaged house, wades into floodwater, lifts a fallen beam or goes into a smoke-filled building can become the next person who needs rescuing. A church team has no business in these places.
- Follow the official instructions and cordons, even when you cannot see why.
- Do not enter a damaged building unless the authorities say it is safe.
- Do not try rescue or medical care you are not trained for. Call the local emergency number and stay with the person until help comes, if it is safe to do so.
- Never work alone, and tell someone where you are going and when you will return.
- Watch the weather, the light and the hour. Tired volunteers make mistakes.
- Keep a list of who is on the team today, so that nobody is lost in the confusion.
- Eat, drink and rest. Lecture 6-2 returns to this.
If a neighbour is in danger now, or says they may hurt themselves, the team stops everything else and calls the local emergency number. Distress after a disaster is common and is usually not a sign of illness. But anyone who is deeply distressed, who cannot sleep for days, or who talks of ending their life, needs a health professional, a trusted pastor or priest, and the emergency service if the danger is present. Your part is to notice, to stay beside them, and to help them reach the right person.
7. Sharing the load
Moses stood from morning to evening judging the people, and his father-in-law told him plainly that the thing was not good. Jethro's counsel was to choose able, honest people and to divide the work into large and small matters, so that the load could be shared. A congregation that responds to a disaster by gathering around one strong person will wear that person away, and the helpers will wait on one telephone.
A small team structure works in most places:
- One coordinator, who talks to the official responders and keeps the list.
- One person for goods and money, always with a second beside them.
- Visiting groups of two or three, each with a short list of streets.
- One person for the volunteers: rest, food, who is on today.
- One person for stories and photographs, who protects the dignity of the affected (see lecture 2-4).
None of these needs training in disaster. All of them need a plan agreed before the water rises. A single sheet is enough.
8. From the other side: the person whose home was hit
It helps to ask what a disaster looks like from the doorstep. (An invented example.) Tomas Veyra, a retired bus driver on Mill Lane, stood in his front room in the second week and said to a visitor from Ravenhill, "The first day, forty people came. Now it is quiet. That is when I have to decide what to throw away." He was not ungrateful. He had been given coats he did not need and a hot meal he did. What he needed now was a person who would stand beside him while he sorted the wet boxes, and who would not take a photograph.
Seen from the side of the one who suffers, a disaster has two parts. In the first hours it is chaos, and help is welcome in almost any form. In the second part, which lasts months, it is ordinary life with a missing floor, a missing job or a missing person. The attention drains away. The neighbour is left with forms, repairs, a child who will not sleep and a hollow in the street.
And a person like Tomas is not only a receiver. He knew which houses had been empty, where the old well ran, and who among the neighbours could not climb a stair. When the church asked him, he made a list on the back of an envelope that was more useful than anything the visitors had thought of. Neighbours in a disaster are helpers as well as the helped.
9. After the cameras leave
The long recovery is the part a church is best placed for, and the part it most often forgets. Some things a church can do, in months and years:
- Keep visiting, at a rhythm that fits: after a week, a month, three months, the first anniversary. A short visit, without an agenda, is enough.
- Help with the tedious tasks: forms, appointments, phone calls, sorting through belongings, moving furniture. Walk beside the neighbour; do not do it for them unless they ask.
- Link people to the services that exist, and go with them if they wish (see lecture 3-2).
- Notice who is slipping: the one who stops coming out, the one who drinks more, the child who changes. Notice, ask gently, and refer (see lecture 3-4).
- Mark the day, if the neighbours wish it, with a simple gathering or an act of remembrance, led by them.
- Be honest about what you can keep doing, and say when you cannot (lecture 6-4).
The long recovery is also where a church's own interest can mislead it. A disaster brings new faces, gifts and good feelings. When the attention fades, a church may be tempted to count the event as a success and move on. Lecture 6-3 asks how to measure this humbly.
10. Photographs, stories and appeals
Disaster pictures spread quickly, and they can be taken at the worst moment of a person's life. The rule of lecture 2-4 holds with extra force: a neighbour's face, name and story belong to the neighbour. Consent is given freely and can be withdrawn. In the first days people cannot be asked in any calm way, so the safe course is to take no photographs of people who are hurt, grieving or in distress, to publish no names and no addresses, and to wait until the person is able to say yes or no. Help is never made conditional on it. Do not use a neighbour's loss as bait for a fund. A truthful appeal can be written without anyone's tears.
Diagram 1. A disaster in four stages: what a church can offer
In short
- In a disaster the church's first gift is presence: go, sit down, weep with those who weep, and say little.
- Find out in advance who coordinates an emergency, and work with them. A church is not a rescue service.
- Ask what is needed before sending or collecting goods. Unrequested help can become a second disaster.
- Gifts are held openly: a stated purpose, two people involved, and a note to the givers. Find out local rules.
- Volunteers keep out of damaged places, do no rescue or medical work, and never work alone.
- The long recovery begins when the cameras leave, and a neighbour's story and face belong to the neighbour.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Job 2:11-13 | The friends came together, wept, and sat seven days without speaking. Presence is the first work. |
| Before sending goods | Ask what is needed, by whom, and who will receive it. Often the answer is money or waiting. |
| Acts 11:29-30 | Relief decided according to means, sent to the elders by two named people. Gifts are held openly. |
| Safety at the scene | Follow official instructions, enter no damaged place, do no rescue or medicine, never work alone. |
One sentence to remember In a disaster a church goes first to be present, works beside the official responders, asks before it gives, and stays when the cameras leave.
This week's action Write one page for your own church: who coordinates an emergency here, how to reach them, and the local emergency number. Keep it where the team can find it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- If a disaster struck your own town tonight, who would coordinate the response, and how would your church reach them? If you do not know, how could you find out this week?
- Why might sitting in silence for a week be a better first act than a good explanation? When would a neighbour need something more practical at once?
- Describe a time when a gift arrived that nobody wanted. What did it cost the people who received it? Say it from their side.
- Why do two named people carry the relief in Acts 11? What would you put in place in your own church so that no one person holds gifts alone?
- Tomas Veyra said that the hard time was after the forty visitors went away. What would a church need to arrange, now, so that visits continue in the second month?
- What would a church do if it were itself a small minority, watched or distrusted, in a disaster? What would it still be able to offer?