FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT735E Mercy and Justice: The Church and Its Neighbours

Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent

Contents 31
PT735E Mercy and Justice: The Church and Its Neighbours
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Neighbours, Not Cases
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Neighbours, Not Cases, and What This Course Does Not Teach
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Mercy and Justice in Scripture and in the Church's Memory
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
  2. Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
  3. Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
  4. Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Helping Without Harming
  1. Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
  2. Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
  3. Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
  4. Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Knowing the Neighbourhood and Working with Others
  1. Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
  2. Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
  3. Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
  4. Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Many Neighbours, Many Needs
  1. Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
  2. Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
  3. Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
  4. Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The People Who Serve, Witness, and the Church's Voice
  1. Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
  2. Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
  3. Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
  4. Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Disaster, Endurance and Humility
  1. Lecture 6-1: When Disaster Comes
  2. Lecture 6-2: Compassion Fatigue and the Tired Helper
  3. Lecture 6-3: Staying the Course and Measuring With Humility
  4. Lecture 6-4: Endings and Handing On
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Our Covenant With Our Neighbours

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

Sooner or later a church that serves its neighbours wants to tell people about it. It wants to thank the donors, encourage the volunteers, report to the congregation, raise money for next year, or simply show that something good is happening on the street. So someone takes a photograph. Someone writes a paragraph for the newsletter. Someone posts a few lines online.

This is natural, and it is not wrong. But at this point a quiet change takes place. Until now the neighbour was a person in a relationship. Now the neighbour may become a picture, a quotation, an example, a reason for people to give. The neighbour's name, face, trouble and history are used in the church's story, often before anyone has asked whether the neighbour wants that.

This lecture is about the telling. It argues that a neighbour's story, picture, name and situation belong to the neighbour. They are not the church's property, because the church happened to be present. They may be shared with the neighbour's free agreement, which can be withdrawn, and which is never made a condition of help. It looks at photographs, names, newsletters, appeals and social media, and at the temptation to use hardship as bait. It also asks a harder question: how a church can speak for people who are not heard, without speaking in their place.

This belongs to the central claim of the course. If mercy is a relationship between neighbours, then a neighbour's story is told as one neighbour would tell another's: with permission, with care, and with the other's good in mind. If it is told for the giver's benefit alone, the neighbour has become, once more, a scene in the giver's story.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Explain why a neighbour's story, picture and name belong to the neighbour.
  • Describe consent that is free, informed and withdrawable, and say why it can never be tied to help.
  • Name what to check before using a photograph, a name or a story, including where a person may be at risk.
  • Spot the signs of an appeal that uses hardship as bait, and rewrite one so that it keeps the neighbour's dignity.
  • Say how a church can speak on behalf of those who are not heard, while making room for them to speak for themselves.

Therefore whatever you desire for men to do to you, you shall also do to them; for this is the law and the prophets." — Matthew 7:12

World English Bible

Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate." — Proverbs 31:8

WEB

Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy.”" — Proverbs 31:9

WEB

Love is patient and is kind; love doesn’t envy. Love doesn’t brag, is not proud," — 1 Corinthians 13:4

WEB

doesn’t behave itself inappropriately, doesn’t seek its own way, is not provoked, takes no account of evil;" — 1 Corinthians 13:5

WEB

doesn’t rejoice in unrighteousness, but rejoices with the truth;" — 1 Corinthians 13:6

WEB

bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things." — 1 Corinthians 13:7

WEB

The first verse is a test that every photograph and every paragraph can pass or fail: how would I want to be shown? Proverbs 31 gives a reason to tell the story at all, since the voiceless need someone to speak. And Paul's description of love supplies the manner: no bragging, no seeking one's own way, rejoicing with the truth. Read honestly, that list is a good checklist for a newsletter.

1. Whose story is it?

When a neighbour comes to the church with a trouble, the church learns something about that neighbour's life. It learns a name, a face, a house, a history, a relation. It may learn more than the neighbour's closest friends know. It is easy, then, to slip into thinking that the church now owns this knowledge. The church was there. The church helped. Surely the church may tell what it saw.

The answer of this course is no. What the church learned, it learned in trust. The neighbour's name, photograph, story and situation belong to the neighbour. The church holds them on loan. It may use them only as the neighbour agrees, and only for as long as the neighbour agrees.

Why so firm? Several reasons come together.

  • A story is a piece of a person's life. To tell it is to hold a person up for others to see, in the worst season they may have known. The person may want that, and the choice is theirs.
  • Words and pictures last. A photograph posted online can be copied, found years later by an employer, a landlord, a former partner or a child's classmates, and cannot truly be taken back. A newsletter can be kept in a drawer for decades.
  • The person may be at risk. Some neighbours are hiding from a violent person. Some are afraid of an official or of their own community. Some are in a legal difficulty that they do not want known. A picture and a place name can lead someone to them. The church often cannot know which neighbours these are.
  • Others are drawn in. A story about a mother also tells about her children, her partner and her family, who did not agree to anything.
  • It is the Golden Rule. Jesus says that the law and the prophets are summed up in this: whatever you desire for people to do to you, do to them. Ask honestly: if I were struggling to feed my family, would I want a camera pointed at me? Would I want my story read out so that strangers might feel generous?

Consent is the neighbour's agreement to be shown or named. For a church that cares about dignity, consent has three marks.

Free. The neighbour can say no, and nothing is lost. This means, above all, that help is never made conditional on consent. A person who needs food must never feel that the bag depends on a photograph, a testimony or a signed form. Consent asked at the desk, by the person who controls the help, in the moment of need, is hardly free at all, for the neighbour is thinking of the bag and not of the form. It is better to ask at a quiet moment, separate from the giving, and to make clear that the answer changes nothing.

Informed. The neighbour knows what is proposed: which photograph or which words, where they will appear (a wall, a newsletter, a website, a social-media page, a report to donors), for whom, for how long, and with what name or without. "May we use your story?" is not enough. "May we print what you told me about the job centre in our church newsletter, which goes to members and is kept on our website, without your name?" is nearer to it.

Able to be withdrawn. The neighbour may change their mind later, for any reason or none. The church says in advance how it will respond: what it can remove from its own pages and files, and what it cannot recall, such as a newsletter already sent. It is honest about this limit. It does not promise what it cannot do.

A few more notes.

  • Children. A child's photograph or story calls for the consent of a parent or guardian, which is more than the child's wish, and the law on children's images and personal data in your place may require more. In many cases the best course is to show no identifiable child at all. Where a child may be at risk, no consent is enough. Child protection belongs to the course on church safety and compliance; the point to keep here is to find out the local rules and follow them.
  • Adults who cannot give full consent. A person who is very distressed, ill, confused or frightened may not be able to weigh what they are agreeing to. Wait, or leave it out.
  • Consent in a group. A picture of a room of people needs the agreement of each person in it who can be recognised. A notice at the door saying "we take pictures" is not agreement.
  • Written or spoken. A simple written agreement, in plain words and in a language the person reads, is usually better than a spoken yes that nobody recorded. But a form must not be a trap: short, clear, with the right to say no printed on it.

A sample of wording, which is only an illustration and should be adapted to the place and checked with someone who knows the local law:

May we use your photograph or your story? You do not have to say yes. Whatever you decide, you will be helped in just the same way. If you say yes, you can tell us what we may use, where it may appear, and whether to use your name. You can change your mind at any time by telling us. We will take it down from our own pages. We cannot take back something that has already been printed or sent.

3. Pictures and dignity

Even with consent, there is the question of how a person is shown. A photograph is made by someone with a point of view, and it can honour or diminish.

Ask of any picture:

  • Is the person shown as a person? Looking at the camera or at a friend, with a name if they wish, doing something, with a face that is not twisted in distress? Or as a type: a child with outstretched hands, a woman in tears, an old man alone in a bare room?
  • Would the person be glad to be seen like this, in a year? A moment of exhaustion or shame is not a thing most people want to keep on show.
  • Who is acting in the picture? A common pattern is the giver standing tall and the receiver reaching up. A picture of a neighbour setting out chairs, serving tea, mending a fence or teaching a skill tells the truth about mutual giving (lecture 2-1).
  • Is a person made into a prop? A photograph of a hand holding a bag of food, taken with the volunteer's face in clear view and the receiver's face cropped, tells its own story about who matters.
  • Is it true? A picture staged, a scene arranged, a pose set up for the camera, a quotation tidied or invented: these are lies, however good the cause.

The simplest rule is this: show people at their best, with their agreement, and as they would wish to be seen.

4. Using hardship as bait

A fundraising appeal wants a response. The writer knows that a picture of a suffering child will bring more gifts than a picture of a well-run kitchen. The temptation, felt by honest people, is to choose the most painful image and the starkest words, because the cause is good and the need is real.

Several things go wrong when hardship is used as bait.

  • The neighbour becomes a means. The person in the picture is there to move the donor. That is the opposite of the relationship the course describes.
  • The picture misleads. A single moment is shown as if it were the whole person. A community with skills, history and pride is reduced to need.
  • It teaches donors a false lesson. Donors learn to give to pity and not to people, and they learn to expect that those who are helped will remain objects of pity.
  • It can exaggerate. A claim that "your gift will change a life" or "every family will be saved" cannot always be kept. This course does not offer any figures on what gifts achieve, because no one can promise them in advance and they vary by place and programme. Appeals should say only what the church can truthfully say.
  • It makes giving about the giver's feeling. If an appeal succeeds by making the donor feel good or guilty, it is a close relative of the trumpet in Matthew 6.

Paul's description of love is a quiet test. Love "doesn’t brag", it "doesn’t seek its own way", it "rejoices with the truth". An appeal can ask: Are we bragging about what we did? Are we seeking our own way, our growth, our funding, at the neighbour's cost? Do we rejoice with the truth, so that every claim can be checked?

An honest appeal can still be moving. It does not need to hide that people are hungry or that a family is in trouble. It needs to say it with respect, give the neighbour's own voice where consent allows, and describe what the church truly does.

5. A worked example: an appeal rewritten

(An invented example.) Here is a draft appeal from an invented congregation, the Brightwater Fellowship.

Draft. Look into the eyes of little Sami. He has not eaten since yesterday. His mother, who has been abandoned by her husband and is too weak to work, cries every night. Without YOUR gift this winter, Sami will go to bed hungry again and again. Don't turn away. Give now and save a child's life! (A photograph of a small boy, crying, with a bowl.)

What is wrong here? The child is named and pictured at his lowest, with no sign that his mother agreed. The mother is described by her weakness and her husband's act, in a way she might never have chosen. A claim is made about the child's life that no donor can check. The words "Don't turn away" press the reader with guilt. And no one is shown doing anything except waiting for a gift.

Now an honest revision, with all details invented.

Revised. Every Wednesday in the winter months, about thirty neighbours come to the Brightwater Fellowship hall for a meal and a bag of food. Some are families who have run short after a job ended. Some are older people who live alone and come mainly for the company. They also help: one man mends our chairs, and two women run the tea table. "I did not want to ask," says one of them, who has agreed that we may quote her without her name. "Here, nobody made me feel small." We want to keep the hall open through the winter. If you would like to give, or to join the volunteers, you will find the details below. Gifts are used for the food service only, and we report to our members each year on how they were spent. (A photograph of the tea table with cups and chairs, no faces, taken with the volunteers' agreement.)

Notice what changed. No child is named or shown. The neighbours are described by what they do as well as by what they lack. The quotation is used with consent and without a name. The claim is only what the church can truthfully say. The donor is invited, not pressed. The purpose and the report are plain. It is also, perhaps, less likely to produce a rush of gifts in one week. A church should be willing to accept that cost, and should say honestly to its supporters that this is how it tells the story.

(This lecture does not give advice on fundraising law, tax receipts or data protection. These differ widely. Find out what applies in your own place and ask someone qualified.)

6. Social media and fast sharing

A phone makes everyone a publisher. A volunteer takes a photograph at the door and posts it before they have thought. A church member shares a story in a group chat with the words "isn't this sad?". A leader writes about a family on a personal page.

Short rules that a team can agree on:

  • No photographs of neighbours on personal phones or personal accounts. If pictures are taken for the church, they are taken by a person the team has agreed, with a church device where possible, and kept in one place.
  • Nothing posted without the agreement described above. Not a name, not a face, not the place, not a "someone we helped today".
  • No details that could identify a person even without a name: a street, a workplace, a description of a family.
  • Check the background. A photograph of a hall can show a face in a corner or a letter on a table.
  • Speak to those who share. The team agrees on these rules before a mistake happens, and tells volunteers in plain words why they matter.
  • If a mistake happens, act quickly: take the post down, tell the person involved, say sorry plainly, and ask whether there is anything else they would like done.

7. When we speak for others

Proverbs 31:8-9 tells the reader to open the mouth for the mute and for those left desolate, and to judge righteously. This is a good verse for churches. There are people whom nobody hears: the new arrival, the person who is afraid, the person with no vote, the child. A church has a voice, a hall and the ear of some who might act. Using that voice for others is a way of love.

But there is a danger, and the verse itself gives a hint of it. The verse speaks of those who cannot speak for themselves, and that is a different thing from those whom nobody has asked. In many places, people described as voiceless are voiceless chiefly because nobody has sat down to listen. A church that speaks quickly for a group may leave the group no place to speak for itself, and may get things wrong.

A few questions before speaking for someone:

  • Have we asked them? What do they want said, and what do they not want said?
  • Can they speak for themselves, and would they prefer to? Could we make room, by inviting a neighbour to speak at a meeting, or by passing on a letter in their own words?
  • Whose purpose does the story serve? The neighbour's, or the church's cause, or an argument somebody wishes to win?
  • Would they recognise themselves in what we say? If the neighbour read it, would they say, "Yes, that is true, and I am glad you said it"?

When the answer is yes, to speak on behalf of the voiceless is a service. When the answer is no, it is the beginning of a quiet theft. This question returns in lecture 5-3, which asks when and how a church should speak about injustice.

8. A story that belongs to the neighbour

What should a church do with a story that a neighbour has given freely? Some practical points:

  • Check the words with the person before they are published. Show them what will be printed, and let them change it.
  • Thank them, and tell them where it appeared. Give them a copy if they would like one.
  • Respect a no without asking why.
  • Do not store stories longer than needed, and do not reuse them in a new setting without asking again.
  • Do not combine stories into a false "typical" case and present it as true. If a composite is useful, say that it is one. (This course's own examples are marked as invented for that reason.)
  • Do not pay for stories in help. If a neighbour is given something in thanks, it is given as a gift, not as a price, and never promised in advance as a reason to agree.

9. The same matter from other sides

From the neighbour. A person whose face has been used without being asked may feel exposed. A person whose story was told well, with permission, may feel honoured. Many neighbours say yes happily when asked properly. The asking is a sign of respect.

From the volunteer. A volunteer who loves the work may want to share it, and may not realise the harm. Give volunteers a clear, simple rule and a reason.

From the donor. A donor wants to know that the money is used well. A donor who is shown dignity and honest accounts tends to trust more than one who is shown pity. A donor is also entitled to ask how a church tells the story, and to be told.

From the leader. A leader feels the pressure of the budget. The temptation to choose the story that raises the most is real. A leader's courage is to choose the version that can stand being read by the neighbour.

From the neighbour who is neither. A neighbour who sees a church use photographs of local people on a poster may draw conclusions about how the church sees the street. A church that tells its story with care may lend the whole neighbourhood a little dignity.


Diagram 1. Before we tell a neighbour's story

Telling the Story: A Path of Questions The story belongs to the neighbour. Any "no" ends the path. 1. Is it needed? Could we tell it without a person? Often we can 2. Is there risk? A child, or a person who may be in danger? If yes: leave it out 3. Ask freely Apart from the help, what, where, how long "No" costs nothing 4. Show it to them Let them read it or see the picture first They may change it Check the picture or text A person, or a type? Would they be glad of it in a year? Is anyone shown giving, not only receiving? Is every word true and checkable? Afterwards Thank them; tell them where it appeared Remove it from our own pages if asked Say plainly what we cannot take back Ask again before using it somewhere new Hardship is not bait Signs of bait: a face at its lowest, a name with no consent, "your gift will save a life", guilt in the last line, a staged scene, a claim nobody can check. Help is never made to depend on a photograph, a testimony or a signature.

In short

  • A neighbour's name, picture, story and situation belong to the neighbour. The church holds them on loan and may use them only as the neighbour agrees.
  • Consent must be free, informed and withdrawable, and help is never made to depend on it. Ask apart from the giving.
  • Children, and people who may be in danger, are left out unless local rules and a safe plan allow otherwise.
  • Show people as people, at their best, as they would wish to be seen. Do not use hardship as bait or claim what cannot be checked.
  • Before speaking for others, ask whether they have been asked, whether they could speak themselves, and whom the story serves.
Front Back
Whose story is it? The neighbour's. The church holds it on loan and uses it only as the neighbour agrees.
Three marks of consent Free (help never depends on it), informed (what, where, how long), and able to be withdrawn.
Hardship as bait A face at its lowest, no consent, a claim nobody can check, or guilt in the last line.
Before speaking for others Have we asked them? Could they speak? Whom does it serve? Would they recognise themselves?

One sentence to remember Tell a neighbour's story as you would want yours told: with permission, with care, and for their good.

This week's action Look at one photograph, post or paragraph your church or team has used. Check it against the questions in this lecture and write one thing you would change.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why might a church feel that it owns the story of a person it has helped? Say it from the church's side, and then from the neighbour's.
  • Why is consent asked at the desk, by the person who controls the help, hardly free? Where and when could it be asked instead?
  • Take a photograph you know of people being helped. Using the questions in the lecture, how does it show the person? What would you change?
  • In the Brightwater appeal, which changes were the most important? What would a church lose by using the revised one, and what might it gain?
  • A volunteer posts a photograph from the door and the person later asks that it be removed. Write what you would say to the person, and what you would do.
  • Proverbs 31:8-9 asks us to open the mouth for the voiceless. What are two questions a church should ask before it speaks for a group of neighbours?
  • Choose one line of 1 Corinthians 13:4-7 and apply it to a church newsletter.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.