Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
- Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
- Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
- Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
- Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
- Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
- Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
- Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
- Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
- Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
- Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
- Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
- Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
- Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
- Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
- Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
- Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
- Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
- Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
A church that begins to serve soon meets other helpers. There is a clinic, a school, an office that handles housing or income, a charity that runs a shelter, a mosque that gives food in the month of fasting, a women's group that lends money to its members, a family network that has quietly looked after its own for generations. Some of these are run by governments, some by other organisations, some by neighbours. Together they are the systems around us.
What these systems look like depends very much on where you live. In some places public help is wide, and a church mostly fills gaps and helps people find their way. In others there is little or none, and the church, the family and the local community are the first and last resort. In others help exists on paper but is hard to reach, or people fear it. Some readers live where churches are small minorities or are watched, and where a public office may not welcome a church's help. This lecture teaches what holds across these settings, and it says so where a point depends on the setting.
The argument is this: a church that knows what else exists, and how to reach it, serves its neighbours better than a church that tries to be everything. Knowing the systems is a form of love. It is also a form of humility: it admits that the church alone cannot meet every need, and that neighbours have a right to what they are entitled to.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Name the main categories of help that exist, or may exist, in any place, and say why a church should learn which of them are available where it lives.
- Describe how to make and keep up to date a short list of local services, and what to put in it.
- Explain why people who need a service often do not reach it, and what accompanying someone does and does not mean.
- State fairly the main views on how public help and church or community help relate, and say what this course requires whichever view is held.
- Explain why the church should neither ignore the public system nor assume it meets every need.
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate." — Proverbs 31:8
World English Bible
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God." — Romans 13:1
WEB
Give therefore to everyone what you owe: taxes to whom taxes are due; customs to whom customs; respect to whom respect; honor to whom honor." — Romans 13:7
WEB
When they had tied him up with thongs, Paul asked the centurion who stood by, “Is it lawful for you to scourge a man who is a Roman, and not found guilty?”" — Acts 22:25
WEB
So then, as we have opportunity, let’s do what is good toward all men, and especially toward those who are of the household of the faith." — Galatians 6:10
WEB
These passages need care. Romans 13 was written to Christians in a city under imperial rule, and it speaks of the purpose of authority. It is not a ruling on whether any particular government is just, and it is not a ban on speaking or asking. Read beside Acts 22, it shows the same apostle using the legal rights he had when they were ignored: Paul asks a plain question about what is lawful (a similar appeal is in Acts 25:10-11). Proverbs 31 speaks to those with some voice and standing, telling them to use it for those who have none. In practice, these passages do not decide whether a church should trust or distrust a public office. They tell us that authority has a purpose, that rights may be asked for, and that someone with a voice should lend it. Galatians 6:10 reminds us that doing good is for everyone, which includes the people a church does not know.
1. Why a church should know what exists
(An invented example.) Wanjiru, a member of a small church in the town of Pellam, noticed that an older man who came to the Tuesday meal looked unwell and was losing weight. She asked kindly if he was seeing a doctor. He said that he had been told he needed a form, that the form needed a stamp, and that he had not understood where to go. She did not know either. She took him a second helping of the soup. He came back the next Tuesday looking the same.
Wanjiru did nothing wrong. But the church had a gap: it had no list of what was around it and no one who had learned how the local system worked. A cup of soup is good. An older man who is entitled to some help and cannot find the door is also a matter of justice, because he is a member of the community and the community owes him a way in.
Learning the systems does not make a church less spiritual. It is part of what it means to love a neighbour in practice.
2. The categories, not the details
This lecture does not tell you what help your country offers, because it cannot. It gives you the categories to ask about. In any place, find out what exists for each of these:
- Health: clinics, hospitals, mental-health support, help with medicines, services for people who use drugs or alcohol.
- Housing: emergency shelter, rented homes, help when a landlord acts unfairly, help when someone cannot pay.
- Food: public programmes, food banks, community kitchens, school meals.
- Income: work programmes, payments for people who cannot work, advice on debt.
- Legal help: advice on papers, rights, contracts, disputes, family matters; courts and those who help people use them.
- Children and school: schools, childcare, services for children who need extra help, services for children at risk.
- Disability: access, aids, assessments, carers' support.
- Older people: care at home, day centres, help with pensions and papers.
- Emergency: police, fire, ambulance, disaster services, crisis lines.
For each category, learn three things: what exists, who runs it (a public office, another charity, a faith group, a community), and how a person actually reaches it. Do not assume that because something exists on paper it is easy to reach, and do not assume that because you have never heard of it, it is not there. In some places there is free help that most people do not know about.
Also learn what is not there. A gap in the list is useful knowledge: it tells the church where its neighbours have nowhere to go.
This lecture is not legal, tax or welfare advice. Eligibility, rules, charity registration and similar matters differ widely and change. Find out for your own place, from the office or advisor who is responsible, and follow local law. A church volunteer should never tell a neighbour what he is or is not entitled to; the person should be sent to someone who knows.
3. Making a list and keeping it alive
The most useful tool a church can make for this work costs almost nothing: a short, shared list of services. A good list has one line for each service:
| Service | What it does | Who runs it | Who can use it | How to reach it | Language, cost, hours | Checked on |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (example) Pellam Health Post | Basic care and referrals | The public clinic | Anyone in the district | Walk in, mornings; bring any papers you have | Local language; no fee, to be confirmed | (date) |
Some rules keep a list honest.
- Name an owner. One person, with a deputy, is responsible. A list nobody owns goes out of date within months.
- Put a date on every line. "Checked on" is the most important column. A list with old information sends people to closed doors.
- Phone or visit before you add. Do not copy from a website you have not checked.
- List organisations, not people. Do not record the personal details of a neighbour on this list. The list is about services.
- Check the language and the fear. A service that is open to all may be unusable to someone who does not speak the language, who fears an official office, or who does not trust anyone who asks questions. Note that on the list.
- Review twice a year. Put it in the calendar.
- Keep it where volunteers can reach it, in a form that does not need an internet connection if that is not reliable where you live.
Add services run by other churches, other faiths and community groups. A neighbour does not mind who runs the service so long as it helps.
4. Why people do not reach services
A church may find that many of its neighbours are entitled to some help and are not receiving it. This is not usually because they are lazy or ignorant. Common reasons include:
- Language. Forms and offices use words the person does not know.
- Paperwork. Documents are lost, or never existed, or need a stamp from an office in another town.
- Distance and cost. The office is far, the fare is more than the help is worth, the hours clash with work.
- Fear. A previous visit ended badly; the person fears being judged, or fears what an official might do with the information.
- Shame. To ask for help may feel like a confession of failure.
- Not knowing. Nobody told them.
- A bad past experience. Someone was sent away without being heard, and does not try again.
Notice that this list describes systems and feelings, not character flaws. A church that sees this will not say "why don't they just apply?" It will ask what stands between this neighbour and the door.
5. Accompanying someone to a service
One of the most useful things a church can do costs nothing but time: go with someone. Accompanying a neighbour to an office, clinic or hearing is an old form of mercy. Done well, it looks like this.
- Offer, do not insist. "Would it help if I came with you?" The person may prefer to go alone, or with a family member.
- Ask what the person wants you to do. Some want you to sit in the waiting room. Some want you to speak. Some want only a face they know.
- Do not speak for the person unless asked. Let the neighbour tell their own story as far as they can. Lend your voice where they ask you to, and give it back.
- Do not hold the person's papers longer than needed, and give them back at once.
- Treat the official as a person too. Officials are neighbours also: they work inside rules they did not write and often with too little time. Being courteous costs nothing and tends to make the visit go better. It is also right.
- Know your limit. You are a companion, not a lawyer, a doctor or a caseworker. If the visit turns to a matter of law, health or safety, the person needs someone qualified; help them find that person.
- Follow up a week later: "How did it go? Is there anything else that is stuck?"
A sample of the difference.
Said badly: "Give me your papers; I'll sort it out. You won't understand it anyway."
Said well: "I can come with you on Thursday if you like. You tell them what has happened, and if you would like me to add anything, I will wait for you to nod. The papers stay with you."
6. Looking from the other side
From the side of the person who struggles to reach help. To a person who has been sent from desk to desk, a church volunteer who simply sits beside them for an hour may be the first person who has treated their problem as worth that time. It also matters that the volunteer does not take over. A person who is made to feel that others can do it better learns not to try.
From the side of the person at the public office. A clerk with a long queue may be glad when a church helper has a clear list of what the person needs, and may be unhappy if a church arrives with demands. A good relationship with the local offices, built over time and by courtesy, helps neighbours who come after.
From the side of the church leader. A leader may be tempted to start a new programme when an existing one just needs a bridge. Before building, ask whether the need is that nothing exists, or that something exists and cannot be reached.
7. Public help and church help
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that public systems are the proper first line of help: that a community owes certain things to all its members as a matter of justice, that it does so through shared institutions, and that the church's role is to help people reach these institutions and to cover the gaps they leave. They point to the care that Scripture lays on the whole community for the weak, and they fear that when churches do the work quietly, public bodies are let off. Other Christians distrust public systems, or live where they do not exist, and hold that church, family and local community help is primary. They point to the early churches that cared for their own and for outsiders without a state to help, and they fear that large systems can be impersonal and can weaken the bonds between neighbours. Others distrust both, having seen help misused by public offices and by religious bodies, and they look to small, accountable groups close to the people helped. Each view has serious Christians behind it and each protects something real: justice for all, closeness, and honesty about failure.
This course requires less than any one of these views requires. A church should neither replace the public system as if it were nothing, nor assume the public system meets every need. In practice that means: learn what exists; help people reach it; speak up for neighbours who are turned away unfairly, asking the questions of lecture 5-3 first; cover real gaps with care; and do not promise what the church cannot sustain. How a church should speak about injustice in public systems, and the theology of the state itself, belong to later work and to the course on public theology.
8. The honest limits of both
It is easy to speak as if one of these, church or public help, were the hero and the other the villain. Neither is. Public offices can be slow, rule-bound, understaffed and sometimes unjust, and they can also be fair, quick and kind, and many of the people who work in them are doing their best. Churches can be warm, flexible and close, and they can also be inconsistent, closed to those who are different, short of money and led by volunteers who tire. Both are made of people.
So the church can say two things at the same moment. "We are glad this service exists and we will help you reach it." And: "We are sorry this service is not enough, and we will not pretend it is." A church that says only the first may lose sight of what is wrong. A church that says only the second may lose sight of the good that is there.
9. A word on other charities and groups
Many places have other organisations that do the same kind of work as the church: other churches, faith groups, secular charities, mutual-aid groups, unions, clubs. Learn who they are and what they do. A few cautions:
- Do not assume they are rivals. Most are glad to know a church exists and what it offers. Lecture 3-3 teaches how to work with them.
- Do not send people to a service you have not checked. A referral to a place that is closed or unkind is a harm.
- Do not duplicate by accident. If three groups run a food table on the same day in one street and nobody covers the next, the gap is the church's to see.
- Ask what they need. Another group may be short of volunteers or space, and a church can give without starting anything.
Diagram 1. The list of services: what to ask, and what to keep
In short
- Systems differ greatly by place. Learn the categories of help, then find out which exist in your own place and how a person reaches them.
- Keep a short, dated list of services with one owner, and check it twice a year. List organisations, not people.
- People often miss help because of language, paperwork, distance, fear or shame, not because of a flaw in character.
- Accompany only if asked; do not speak for the person; give papers back; send legal, health or safety questions to someone qualified.
- A church neither replaces the public system as if it were nothing, nor assumes it meets every need.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Categories of help | Health, housing, food, income, legal help, children and school, disability, older people, emergency. |
| A good service list | One line per service, dated, with an owner, checked twice a year. Organisations, not people. |
| Accompanying a neighbour | Offer, ask what they want, do not speak for them, give papers back, know your limit, follow up. |
| Public and church help | The church neither ignores the public system nor assumes it meets every need. |
One sentence to remember Knowing what else exists, and how to reach it, is one of the plainest ways a church loves its neighbours.
This week's action Choose one category of help and find out, by a visit or a call, one service in your place that offers it and how a person reaches it. Write it on the first line of a list.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the place where you live, which of the nine categories of help is easiest to find, and which is hardest? How do you know?
- Why might a person entitled to help not use it? Pick one reason and describe it from that person's side.
- What would you put on the first line of a service list for your church? Who would be its owner?
- When a church volunteer goes with a neighbour to an office, what is the volunteer's job, and what is not?
- State the view that public help should come first, and then the view that church and community help should come first, each as its own supporters would put it. What does each protect?
- Why does the lecture warn against treating either the church or a public office as the hero? Where have you seen that mistake?