Lecture 6-3: Staying the Course and Measuring With Humility
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
- Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
- Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
- Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
- Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
- Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
- Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
- Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
- Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
- Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
- Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
- Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
- Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
- Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
- Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
- Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
- Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
- Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
- Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
Much of the work of mercy is not a dramatic rescue. It is a long, plain walking beside people: a visit every month for years, a meal every Wednesday, a friendship with a family through three bad winters and one good one. This kind of work is hard to see. It is also hard to judge. After a year, a church may ask: is this doing any good? Is it the right work? Should we go on?
This lecture asks how a church can answer that question honestly. It makes two claims. First, staying with people over a long time is itself a form of mercy, and it costs more than any single gift. Second, a church should look at what its service does, and it should do so with humility: it should count what can be counted without pretending that counting shows everything, it should ask the people it serves, and it should never turn a neighbour into a number. The course's central claim applies: mercy is a relationship between neighbours, so the neighbour is a witness to the work, not only the subject of it.
The lecture touches records and reports. It is not legal, tax or welfare advice. The rules for keeping information about people, for reports to donors and for registered charities differ by place, so find out locally and follow local law and a qualified person.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain what long accompaniment costs and why it is worth it, using Scripture.
- Name three kinds of evidence a church can use to look at its service: what we did, what the neighbours say, and what we learned.
- State fairly the positions on how far to measure results, and the requirement the course makes.
- Describe three ways to ask a neighbour for an honest view, and one risk in asking.
- Describe a review without blame and say what it should and should not record.
Let us not be weary in doing good, for we will reap in due season, if we don’t give up." — Galatians 6:9
World English Bible
I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:6
WEB
So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:7
WEB
Even so you also, when you have done all the things that are commanded you, say, ‘We are unworthy servants. We have done our duty.’" — Luke 17:10
WEB
Know well the state of your flocks, and pay attention to your herds:" — Proverbs 27:23
WEB
Jesus asked him, ‘What do you want me to do for you?’ The blind man said to him, ‘Rabboni, that I may see again.’" — Mark 10:51
WEB
Paul speaks of work that takes time, and of the harvest that is not in the worker's hands. He also tells the Corinthians that planter and waterer share one work and both are nothing beside the God who gives the increase. Luke 17:10 is not a licence to be careless; it speaks against the helper who thinks he has earned a reward. Proverbs says a shepherd must know the state of his flock, which is a call to look carefully. And Jesus asks the blind man what he wants before he does anything. That question is the heart of an honest review.
1. The long walking-with
There is a kind of service that a short trip or a single campaign cannot do. It is to stay. A church that visits the same housebound woman every month for six years has given her something that no parcel could: a person who comes back. A team that sits with a family through the unemployment of a father, the illness of a child and a long wait for a decision has given more than any sum of money.
This kind of work has a cost, and the lecture should say so plainly.
- It is slow. Nothing seems to change. People take two steps forward and one back, or the other way round.
- It is repetitive. The same visit, the same meal, the same form.
- It is uncertain. You will not know whether it helped. Sometimes the person moves away, or stops answering, and you never hear.
- It tests the helper's motive. A person who serves to feel useful will tire when the results fade.
- It tests the church's patience. Congregations like projects that start and finish. A friendship does not finish.
And it has a worth that is easy to lose sight of. A neighbour who is accompanied for years learns that they are not forgotten. They gain a person to ask, a witness to their life, and a link to others. A church that stays also learns. It sees what actually helps, what does not, and what the neighbourhood is like in the second and third year, which a quick visitor never sees.
Paul writes to the Galatians: "Let us not be weary in doing good, for we will reap in due season, if we don’t give up." Read in its setting, the verse is a word to a community, not to a lone hero, and it promises a harvest in its season, not on our timetable. It does not promise that every effort will succeed. The words "if we don’t give up" are a call to endure together, and lecture 6-2 has already said that endurance needs rest.
2. What we can and cannot know
A church that serves for years will want to know whether its work is good. There are three honest reasons for looking.
- . The church has been trusted with time, gifts and people's confidence. It should know whether it is using them well.
- Learning. If something is not working, it can change.
- Honesty. Those who give, and those who are served, deserve a truthful account.
But there are limits, and a church should be as honest about them as about the results. Here are the kinds of things that can and cannot be known.
What can be counted fairly easily: how often the service ran; how many people came, roughly; how many volunteers were on the rota; how long the team has been serving; what was spent. These numbers tell us something. They tell us whether we did what we said.
What is much harder to count: whether a person's life is better; whether they feel less alone; whether they have more hope; whether a friendship formed. Such things change slowly, differ from one person to another, and often show only years later. A visit that looks pointless in March may be the reason a person holds on in November.
What cannot be counted at all: whether a neighbour was honoured; whether a church was faithful; whether the Spirit was at work. We can look at signs. We cannot measure them.
And there are two quiet dangers in numbers. A figure that is easy to count may take the place of the thing that matters: a church may begin to serve more people and listen to each of them less. And a figure that looks good may hide harm. A programme that reaches many may reach them badly.
3. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree about how far a church should measure the results of its mercy. One position holds that careful measurement is part of honest stewardship: those who give money, time and trust to a church are owed an account of what has been done with them, and a church that never looks closely at its work may continue for years a service that does harm or does no good. Many who hold this view add that love requires it, since it would be unloving to keep doing something that does not help. A second position holds that the numbers miss what matters: that a friendship, a restored hope or a kept faith cannot be put in a table, that the pressure to produce figures bends a church towards what is easy to count, and that Scripture speaks of faithfulness, not of results. A third position holds that any evaluation must include the voice of those served: that the people who receive help are the first witnesses of whether it helps, and that a review made without them is incomplete however careful it is. Each of these positions protects something real. They are not always opposed; many people hold two of them at once.
This course requires less than any one of them demands, and more than none. Hold results with humility. Include the neighbour's voice. Do not turn people into data. A church may count what it can count and say plainly what the counts cannot show. It asks the people it serves what they think, in a way that lets them answer honestly. And it keeps in mind that the final measure of its work is not in its own hands: "neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase."
4. Asking the neighbour
Jesus asked the blind man, "What do you want me to do for you?" It is a question that a church can put to the neighbours it serves, not only at the start of a service but throughout. A neighbour is the best witness to whether the help helped, and also the one least often asked.
But asking honestly is not simple. People who receive help often find it hard to say that it was not good enough. They do not wish to seem ungrateful. They fear that help might be taken away. They may tell the helper what the helper wants to hear. This is the power gap that lecture 2-1 described, and it does not vanish because the helper asks nicely.
Some ways of asking that work better:
- Ask someone else to ask. A trusted neighbour, a person from another church or a volunteer who is not part of the service can talk to people with less awkwardness than the person who gives them the food.
- Ask in small groups, over tea, not on a form. A conversation of six people, with the leader out of the room, often gives more than a questionnaire.
- Ask simple, open questions. "What is working? What is not? What would you change? What do we not understand?" Avoid "Are you satisfied?", which invites a polite yes.
- Put a neighbour on the review group, as a member and not a guest, with the same voice as the pastor.
- Say that nothing will be taken away for an honest answer, and mean it. Any answer may be given anonymously, and nobody is asked to give a name.
- Act on what you hear, or explain why not. A neighbour who is asked and then sees no change will not answer next time.
And remember that the opinion of those who come is not the opinion of everyone. Who does not come? The person who was treated badly once and never came back, the one who could not get past the door, the family that never heard. Their silence is also a reply. Ask someone who knows the neighbourhood who is missing (lecture 3-1).
5. Not turning people into data
Records and numbers are useful, and they carry a risk. A church that collects stories, names, ages and cases for a report may slide from helping a person to producing evidence about them. The principles are these.
- Keep only what you need, and know why you keep it (lecture 2-3). If you cannot say what a piece of information is for, do not collect it.
- Count tasks and events, not people's worth. "The meal ran forty times this year" is an honest count. "We rescued eighty families" makes the neighbour the object of the church's deed.
- Do not put a person's story in a report without their free consent, which may be withdrawn, and which is never tied to help (lecture 2-4).
- Do not claim more than you know. A church that tells its donors "this changed lives" should be able to say whose life, in what way, and how it knows. Where it cannot, it should say "we believe" or "we hope", and say what it does not know.
- Do not invent figures, and do not inflate them. Writers disagree about how to measure the effects of programmes, and the answer differs from place to place. A church should be wary of any claim that sounds too neat.
- Find out the local rules on keeping information about people, and follow them.
6. Learning from failure
Every service fails sometimes. A church that cannot say so is in more danger than one that can. A review without blame is a short meeting after something has gone wrong, or after a season, in which the team asks what happened, what we learned, and what we will change. It is not a trial.
(An invented example.) The Thursday homework club at Ravenhill Church ran for two years. In its third year attendance fell to a few children, and two volunteers dropped out. The team held a review. They asked the families who had stopped coming, through a parent who was not on the team. The answer was plain. The club met at five o'clock, when most parents were still at work and the older children had to mind younger ones. Nobody had asked. The team had counted how many came and had not asked who could not. They moved the club to a Saturday morning, and they asked two parents to help decide what the club should do. The numbers rose, but what the pastor, Nuala Brandt, wrote in the minutes was this: "We were counting the ones who came and it the club."
A review sheet of that kind can be short.
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| What did we say we would do, and did we do it? | Honesty about our own promises |
| What did the neighbours tell us, and who did we not hear from? | The neighbour's voice and the missing |
| What went wrong, without blaming anyone? | Learning, not shame |
| What will we change, stop or keep? | Action, with a date |
| What do we not know? | Humility |
Keep the minutes plain, keep names out of them where names are not needed, and share what you learned with the people who were asked.
7. From another side
A neighbour who has been accompanied for years sees the work differently from the church. A woman who has been visited for six years may not say "the programme helped me." She may say, "She came on Tuesdays." What mattered to her was the shape of the week, and no review form has a box for it.
The volunteer sees another thing. A volunteer who has done the same task for three years may no longer ask whether it works, because it has become what he does. A fresh pair of eyes, perhaps from another congregation, can ask the simplest questions, and often the most useful.
And a donor or a leader sees another: a need to know that gifts were not wasted. That need is fair. It should be answered with a true account, not a pleasing one.
Diagram 1. Looking at our work with humility
In short
- Staying with people over years is a form of mercy. It is slow, repetitive and uncertain, and it is worth the cost.
- A church may look at its work for stewardship, learning and honesty, and it should say what counts cannot show.
- Readers disagree about measuring. The course requires humility, the neighbour's voice, and no people turned into data.
- Ask neighbours simple, open questions, through someone they can speak to freely, and act on what you hear.
- Keep only the information you need, make no claim you cannot support, and find out local rules on records.
- A review without blame asks what we did, who we heard, what went wrong, what to change and what we do not know.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Galatians 6:9 | Do not grow weary in doing good; a harvest comes in due season. It is a word to a community that endures together. |
| Three limits of numbers | Some things can be counted, some are hard to count, and some, such as faithfulness, cannot be counted at all. |
| Asking the neighbour | Use open questions, ask through a trusted other person, put a neighbour on the group, and act on the answer. |
| Not turning people into data | Count events, keep only what you need, use no story without free consent, and claim no more than you know. |
One sentence to remember A church stays with its neighbours for the long haul, looks honestly at what it does, asks the neighbour first, and leaves the harvest to God.
This week's action Pick one service your church runs. Write down one thing you can count, one thing a neighbour could tell you that no count can, and one person you could ask.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a service you know that has lasted for many years. What has it cost the people who run it, and what has it given the people it serves?
- Why might a donor and a neighbour want different things from an evaluation? How could both be answered honestly?
- State the three positions on measuring results in your own words, in the form their holders would accept. Which parts of each would you keep?
- Why might a neighbour hesitate to tell a church that its help is not good enough? What could the church do to make an honest answer easier?
- In the invented homework club, the team counted those who came. Who did they not count? Whom could you ask, in a service you know, to find who is missing?
- What is the difference between "we rescued eighty families" and "the meal ran forty times this year"? Which is more honest, and why?